Backfire, Part 1 (Patreon)
Content
Now, not so much. Brendan's pecs still bulged and his arms were still round and firm, but not nearly as defined. His trim waist was still flat, but the once-visible abs were gone. His ass wasn't as prominent as it used to be, and a desk job left him with skinnier legs. All of the flaws he used to worry about were magnified. He obsessed over his short, squat cock and lack of any significant body hair. He had a dusting on his chest, arms and legs, but that was it. Every wrinkle on his face felt like a canyon cutting into his skin and he was convinced his thick, chocolate hair was thinning. Just about all of this was in his head. By any objective standard he was still the picture of fitness, with looks and a body that most guys would kill for. His smooth, high cheeks and button nose left him with the same boyish looks he always had, and the wrinkles around his eyes were immediately overshadowed by their bright blue color. And while he'd lost some definition, his ample muscle hadn't gone anywhere. If anything he looked more built with the extra padding. His package WAS on the small side at just under a wide six inches, but he knew exactly how to use every one of those inches. In reality he had nothing to feel inferior about.
But then there was Tyler. At 28 his friend still had the body he’d had at 21. He had the same full head of raven hair and the same constant stubble on his cheeks. His olive complexion still sported its constant tan and the shredded muscles underneath hadn't changed a bit. Every time Tyler moved, his body bulged and flexed. He didn't have an ounce of fat on him. His huge, hairy pecs sat between his bowling ball shoulders above a tapering washboard waist. His arms were segmented groups of furry, meaty muscle that constantly threatened to rip his sleeves every time he moved them. His rigid 8-pack was boxed in on either side by prominent obliques and was divided down the middle by a trail of fur that disappeared into his stuffed pants. Unlike Brendan, Tyler had a long hose that constantly looked like someone had shoved a banana in his underwear. Hard, he topped out over seven inches. It stood out even more because whatever he had on was always stretched tight across the large, gravity defying globes of his hairy ass and round, sturdy thighs.
Brendan's blood boiled every time he thought about it. Tyler didn't even have to work any harder at the gym. Over the years Brendan had to constantly up his game, but Tyler breezed through his workouts like always. And when they went out, instead of dividing and conquering the ladies, they all flocked to Tyler and Brendan would get the leftovers. Even at work, Tyler was able to charm his way up the ladder while Brendan had to bust his ass for a meager middle-management position. They both had degrees in business. They’d both managed to land decent positions at area firms right out of school, but Tyler had shot ahead. In their group of friends, instead of them both being Top Dog, Tyler was clearly the alpha. When the guys came over to watch a game, they deferred to Tyler even though it was Brendan’s apartment too. Brendan was sick of it.
His increasing desire for revenge had taken him to some dark corners of the internet. He started to visit websites in search of something that would level the playing field. He honestly didn’t know what he was looking for; he just hoped he’d know it when he found it. Hour after hour was spent stewing in his resentment, scouring websites in every known language seeking an outlet for his anger. It was becoming an obsession. He’d smile and laugh with his friend like always. They’d still go to the gym together before hitting the bars, but while whatever random girl Brendan had met snoozed next to him, he’d stay up listening to the sounds of Tyler’s grunting and pounding, hating his friend more and more.
Then, one morning, Brendan woke up to an email. It was from a man in the Ukraine who said he could help with what Brendan was seeking. Brendan’s first instinct was to ignore it. The english was spotty at best and he hadn’t sent anyone a message, so he figured it was a fishing scam. Then the man emailed again mentioning Tyler by name. That gave Brendan pause. He’d never used Tyler’s name in any searches. Still, he didn’t respond until the third day. He woke up to yet another email, this time outlining every dark thought he’d ever had about his friend. Everything he felt and wanted was laid bare in broken english.
That was enough. He responded and the man said he could make whatever Brendan wanted a reality. Brendan didn’t hesitate. He’d been plotting his perfect revenge for some time. For starters, he wanted Tyler to be irresistible to men, straight or gay, and repulsive to women. His friend wasn’t a homophobe, but he got incredibly uncomfortable any time a guy hit on him. So suddenly finding himself a guy magnet while women wouldn’t pay him the slightest attention would be perfect. And he wanted Tyler to play it up. His friend always talked shit about guys who he viewed as too feminine, so Brendan wanted his friend to gay it up in a big way. Loose inhibitions, revealing clothes, flaky, ditzy attitude, and feminine speech and mannerisms. On top of that he’d be constantly horny and cock hungry. Which brought up the physical changes. The only physical change that Brendan wanted was for Tyler’s huge hose to shrink down a few inches. He thought about taking more than that, but the mental image of his hairy, sculpted, hyper masculine friend swishing around was too good to pass up. The only remaining question was whether or not Tyler should be aware of what was happening. Brendan had to think about this. On the one hand, his friend’s panic could be satisfying, but on the other, deep down, he still cared about his friend in a twisted way. Ultimately he decided to make Tyler oblivious to the changes. He’d know what was happening to his friend, and that would be enough.
For his part, Brendan wanted the perfect body back. He wanted the charm again. He wanted to turn heads when he walked in a room the way he used to. He didn’t want to have to worry about things anymore. He told the man he wanted all the things that Tyler had, and the man said he could deliver. For a price. It had cost Brendan almost everything he had, but three months later a box arrived with a small, luminescent vial.
He poured it in and carefully replaced the lid on Tyler's shake. Now all he could do was wait.
********
The next day at work was excruciating. Brendan was a ball of nervous energy at his desk, unable to think about anything else. Did Tyler drink it? Did he notice something off? The liquid was supposed to be tasteless and odorless, but what if? And Brendan had no idea what the timeline was for any of this. Should he feel different? He felt the same as always. And he didn't look any different so far. He kept checking his reflection and prodding himself, but couldn't find any differences. He resisted the urge to text Tyler. They didn’t usually text unless there was a specific reason and he didn’t want to give the other man any indication that something was up. All he could do was watch the minutes tick by.
He breezed through his post-work visit to the gym, but he attributed this more to his anxiety than any magic potion. There was a creeping thought in the back of his mind that all he'd done was waste a huge chunk of money. His nerves turned to a feeling of utter foolishness as he headed home.
"How could I have been so fucking stupid," he cursed to himself in the shower. "Magic? What the hell was I thinking?" Dejected, he toweled off and threw on a pair of boxer briefs and a baggy muscle shirt. Just as he left his bedroom he heard the door opening. "Hey man," he said, trying his best to sound normal as Tyler came in. His friend was still clad in his own sweaty gym clothes, the damp tshirt outlining the shelf of muscle across his chest. "I thought you were going out tonight?"
Tyler kicked off his shoes and shook his head. When he looked up his expression was confused. "I was, but it's been a weird day," he said with an embarrassed smile.
Brendan had to fight to suppress a grin as his doubts started to give way. "Weird how," he asked casually.
Tyler shrugged. "I dunno...I've just felt..off..all day. People have been weird towards me, too. Do like have something on my face or something?"
"Uh...nope, looks fine to me."
"The guys at the gym were all just...staring at me. Like, STARING, staring. Checking me out, staring. When I changed out of my work clothes most of the dudes in the locker room looked real thirsty."
Brendan played it off. "Whatever, stud. You shy all of a sudden?"
Tyler gave a laugh. "No, but I'm not a piece of meat. Especially not for a bunch of guys." He scratched his head, his hairy bicep flexing. “And remember Gina, the new girl I’ve been chatting up? She’s the one I was supposed to go out with, but she wouldn’t so much as look at me. She bailed and refused to tell me why. After that I just didn't feel like going out."
"Eh, I wouldn't worry about it," Brendan said, clapping Tyler on a broad shoulder. "I was just gonna watch the game tonight if you wanna dude-time it up."
Neither of them noticed that Brendan still had his hand on Tyler's shoulder. The confused man grinned and nodded. "Yeah, sounds like a plan. Lemme get cleaned up."
Brendan held it together until he heard the shower crank back on. Then he lost it. He wanted to shout victoriously but had to settle for a few silent fist pumps. Something was clearly happening to his friend. As soon as he'd touched Tyler's bare shoulder, he watched his friend's expression change completely. He wanted to see how far he could take it without pushing too hard too soon. He hurried into his bedroom and swapped out his baggy muscle shirt for a cut-off one he worked out in. This let Tyler see more of his exposed lower half.
"A night in's probably a good thing anyway," Tyler said as he came back out, his buff, dripping frame covered only in a towel that hung low and precarious on his trim waist. He looked at Brendan, but if he noticed the different shirt he didn't say anything. Instead he disappeared quickly into his bedroom and reemerged wearing nothing but a pair of small blue briefs. His long, thick cock and meaty balls filled the pouch near to bursting.
Brendan looked Tyler up and down. This was definitely new. Tyler would hang out shirtless all the time, and he wasn't shy about being in his underwear briefly around Brendan, but he'd never just hung out in it. "I can see why the guys stared, handsome," he joked.
"Fuck man, don't you start on me," Tyler laughed. Even as he laughed, Brendan caught his friend obviously checking him out.
"Just sayin', that lower body routine looks like it's working."
"Yeah?" Tyler turned and flexed his barely-covered ass.
Brendan felt his cock twitch. He blushed and quickly turned away. “What the fuck?” he thought to himself. Then it hit him. He hadn’t thought this through entirely. He’d wanted Tyler to be irresistible to guys, which apparently included him. “Okay…okay…this isn’t so bad. I can still make this work,” he said to himself. It wasn’t in the original plans, but in some ways it was even better. He wouldn’t just watch Tyler get dominated by other guys, he could take part in it. Brendan paused again. Why would he want to take part in something like that? He wasn’t gay either. His hesitation left when he turned and saw Tyler sprawled in a chair, his stuffed bulge on display between his meaty, hairy thighs. He couldn’t take his eyes off the other man as he took up a spot on the couch.
They tried to watch the game, but it quickly became clear that they were more interested in watching each other. They’d both been caught staring multiple times. Each time they’d laugh it off awkwardly until Tyler finally broke the silence.
“Is that for me,” he asked, his eyes focused on Brendan’s crotch.
Brendan looked down and felt his face turn red. His boxer briefs were obviously tented, and since he’d put the cut off shirt on he couldn’t do anything to hide it. “Uh, shit! Sorry man,” he stammered.
“I’m feelin’ it myself,” Tyler said, squirming. His long cock had snaked off to the side and was outlined under the straining fabric.
Brendan returned the question. “So is that for me?”
Tyler started to speak, his eyes going wide and his face turning crimson. He leaned his head back on the chair and stared at the ceiling. “Dude…what is with this day?!” He ran his strong fingers through his hair and the sight of his huge biceps flexing practically made Brendan’s mouth water.
Brendan pressed. “So is that a yes or a no?”
“It’s a ‘I’m gonna go put some pants on,” Tyler sighed, standing.
Brendan wanted to see how far he could go. “Oh, come on,” he said casually. “What’s the big deal?”
“Certainly not that,” Tyler laughed, nodding towards Brendan’s smaller tent.
“Never had any complaints,” Brendan said smugly.
“Just people asking where it is?”
Brendan was trying not to get angry. He was supposed to be pushing Tyler, not the other way around. “If you’re so proud of yours why are you so uncomfortable right now?”
Tyler laughed, but it was clear he WAS uncomfortable. “What? I’m not…I just didn’t think you wanted to stare at my boner all night.” He fixed Brendan with a piercing look. “Do you?”
“Maybe I do,” Brendan said flatly. He wasn’t sure if he was just egging Tyler on or if he actually wanted to. “Come on then, big man. Lose the panties and let’s see it.”
Tyler blushed and grinned bashfully. “Oh, you think I won’t? Fine.” He pulled his briefs down and kicked them free, wagging his solid log inches from Brendan’s face. “There ya go, dude! Take a nice close look.” Brendan felt his heart start to race as he leaned in. He was so turned on he couldn’t stand it, but he knew this wasn’t how things were supposed to go. Tyler had done what he told him to, but this wasn’t what he pictured. "This is what you wanted, right?" Brendan was too transfixed by Tyler's bobbing cock to respond. He felt his stomach flutter and his hands start to tremble. Tyler just looked down at him with an arrogant grin and bounced the warm organ against his cheek.
"He...hey!" Brendan laughed nervously and moved his head away.
Tyler did it again. "What? This isn't weird, right? You’re the one who said this was okay.”
"No it...this isn't what I wanted," Brendan stammered unconvincingly.
Tyler pointed at the damp spot on Brendan's tented briefs. "It sure looks like you want it," he said, watching his friend's eyes follow his cock like a hypnotist's watch. Brendan just licked his lips. "Go ahead," was all Tyler needed to say. Brendan leaned forward and swallowed as much of Tyler as he could, his hands reaching up and clamping on to his friend's firm, hairy cheeks.
"What the fuck am I doing?!" Brendan screamed at himself. It was supposed to be Tyler getting him off, not the other way around. He shouldn't even be doing this, let alone enjoying it so much. He should have been revolted. He was choking on another man's huge dick and loving every second of it. But then Tyler wasn't just another man. His friend was beautiful.
He knew on a logical level that it was because of the potion mishap. He wasn't entirely in control of his actions. He could have stopped if he wanted to, but spell or not, the other man was suddenly magnetic. The longer Brendan was around him the more he wanted to do whatever Tyler asked. Tyler's fingers in his hair and quiet moans drove him wild. The feeling of the solid cheeks flexing under his death grip while Tyler pumped his hips was intoxicating. He didn't want it to end. The wide, slick pole sliding against his tongue sent wave after wave of pleasure through him.
Brendan was surprised at how quickly he took to it. He'd never done anything remotely like this, but after only a few minutes he was swallowing Tyler almost to his base. And when the other man finally exploded in his mouth he guzzled it down like he was taking a shot of whiskey.
"Whoa….whoa….” Brendan panted while he rested his face against Tyler's firm abs, drinking in the other man's musky scent. His friend’s fingers still danced through his hair while his own hands were gently rubbing the backs of Tyler's powerful thighs.
"Shit man," Tyler finally sighed. "You should'a told me you were so good at that a long time ago." Brendan beamed at the compliment, finally letting Tyler step away. He looked up at the other man's wry, cocky smile and melted all over again. "You been gay this whole time?"
"What? No!" Brendan blushed. "I'm not...just because I did...are you?"
"Of course not!" Tyler flexed unconsciously, each of his ample muscle groups inflating. Despite his denial, he was looking at Brendan with equally hungry eyes. "It's just us, so whatever,” he said, trying to convinced himself. “We're both super horny and it’s been a weird day. That's all."
"Right, right," Brendan agreed quickly, clearing his throat. There was a long pause while they stared at each other until Brendan finally asked, “So, uh, do I get a turn?" He watched the conflicting emotions play across Tyler's face. This was the real test. His friend's smile faded and his eyes darkened. Regular Tyler would want to punch him for even suggesting it, but before Brendan had to try and cover his tracks the smile came back.
Tyler blushed and shook his head. He scratched his scalp nervously and took a deep breath, shifting his weight from foot to foot. Seeing the sculpted, confident stud suddenly bashful was a turn on in itself for Brendan. "Fuck, man, this is so weird, but..." With that he dropped to his knees. His hands shook as he reached up and pulled Brendan's now-soaked underwear down.
Brendan held his breath while Tyler stared at his squat, aching cock. His friend's hands were unconsciously kneading his meaty thighs while Tyler hesitated. Brendan finally gave him an encouraging smile and gently reached out and guided Tyler's head forward. Tyler didn't resist and Brendan let out a louder groan than he'd anticipated when Tyler's soft, full lips wrapped around him. Tyler's scratchy stubble on his thighs contrasted with the warm, wet mouth bobbing up and down on his pole was overwhelming. All Brendan could do was stroke Tyler's short black hair with one hand while the other clutched at the couch cushions. Watching the other man's broad, rippling shoulders flex rhythmically while his head bobbed deeper and faster nearly made Brendan cum by itself. "OOOOHHHHHH.....!" He didn't last long. After getting so worked up by the job he’d done on Tyler it felt like his friend had just started when he was spraying down his throat.
Tyler sucked it down just as eagerly as he had, grinning and blushing as it dribbled down his chin when he pulled his head away. "Eager little squirt isn't it," he laughed, wiping his chin.
"That usually...doesn't happen...so fast," Brendan panted. "You must be a natural. Sure you haven't done that before?"
"Fuck you, man," Tyler stood and gave Brendan a playful shove before falling on top of him on the couch. They wrestled, each one loving the sensation of the other against their naked body. Tyler couldn't get enough of Brendan's softer, beefy frame, and Brendan loved the prickly hairs coating Tyler's granite body. "Okay...okay...you win, you win," Tyler conceded when Brendan had him pinned. Their faces hovered inches apart. "Uh, are we gonna make out now? 'Cause that might be too gay."
"Oh would it?" Brendan shifted off Tyler and wormed behind him so that they were spooning on the couch. He threw a heavy arm over Tyler's hairy chest, holding him in place. "What about cuddling?"
"Dude! Come on!" Tyler half heartedly put up a fight but quickly conceded, relaxing against Brendan's broad chest.
"We can still catch the end of the game," Brendan said as they settled. In his head he was trying to piece together what was happening. None of this was what he'd pictured. Nowhere in his revenge fantasy did he see himself spooning naked with Tyler after they'd blown each other. He did his best to focus, to try and think back to what could have been screwed up, but all he could focus on was the buff, gorgeous man in his arms. Every time he thought of Tyler that way he told himself it was the spell, but that didn't stop it from happening. Instead of thinking about how to fix this he was loving the way it felt to stroke Tyler's furry chest, or how nice the other man's shampoo smelled.
And Tyler seemed just as content. He'd tensed at first, but after a few minutes Brendan had felt him relax entirely. Even when Brendan’s cock hardened against his back, Tyler just wiggled his ass against it. And when Brendan’s stroking fingers drifted south to wrap around Tyler’s lengthy pole, the hairy man just moaned and let his friend stroke. Brendan would only stroke for a few minutes at a time, working Tyler up without getting him off.
“Duuuude….you are killin’ me here,” Tyler groaned when Brendan pulled his hand away again.
Brendan just rubbed Tyler’s scruffy abs. “What’s your hurry,” he asked, feeling the other man shiver when he nibbled his ear.
“Oh that’s not fair,” Tyler said, rolling over so they could face each other. They shifted so that he was on top this time and his mouth fell to Brendan’s burly chest, his tongue flitting against one of his friend’s prominent nipples.
“MMMMmmm….” Brendan just settled on the couch and folded his hands behind his head while Tyler worked his chest before sliding steadily down until his mouth had explored every inch of Brendan except for his throbbing cock.
“Little squirt looks eager again,” Tyler said, his tongue flicking the underside of Brendan’s short, wide pole.
“Your’s isn’t much better.” Brendan nodded towards the small puddle on his thigh left by Tyler’s oozing member.
Tyler slid off Brendan and pulled the other man upright so they were sitting next to each other. He left his hand on Brendan’s thigh, his fingers dancing against his friend’s tight balls. “Alright, a race. Whoever blows first loses.”
Brendan grinned. “And what does the winner get?”
Tyler didn’t have to think about it. “Loser has to do whatever the other one says for the rest of the night.”
Brendan couldn’t help but appreciate the irony of that statement given what was going on. “Deal.”
They seized each other’s cocks and went to work. Neither spoke. They just grunted or moaned while they did their best to hold it in. Brendan used the ample fluid slowly oozing out of Tyler’s cock to his advantage, lubing the other man up so he could easily glide along the pulsing organ. After his quick performance earlier, Brendan was determined not to lose. He was gritting his teeth so hard he thought they would break when he felt Tyler tense.
“Fu…fuuuuuck….” Tyler hissed, spurting like a geyser. Brendan held on until the deluge stopped, the warm fluid splattering against his fist. Tyler sighed and leaned his head on the back of the couch. “Goddamn it. I thought I had you.”
“Almost,” Brendan grinned mischievously at his friend.
Tyler shrugged. “A deal’s a deal. So…?”
Brendan nodded towards his unfinished handjob. “We can start with that. But,” he stopped Tyler when the other man went to continue, “I want you to kiss me while you do it.”
Tyler turned bright red, his bashful grin coming back. “Wh…what?”
“You heard me,” Brendan said flatly.
“Come on, man, that’s…that’s too…” The word Tyler was looking for was intimate. Getting each other off was one thing. They were two horny dudes helping each other out, nothing more. But kissing? That was a different story.
“Hey, these were your rules. But if you wanna back out of the deal…” Brendan was cut off when Tyler leaned over and gave him a quick peck on the mouth. “Cute, but no way. Like you mean it.”
“Can’t I just blow you again?” The fact that those words even left straight-guy Tyler’s mouth almost made whatever was happening to himself worth it for Brendan.
Brendan shook his head. “Nope. Come on, it’s just making out. How is that worse than anything else?”
“I dunno, man, it’s just…” Tyler trailed off with a nervous laugh. “You really wanna do that?” His face was practically purple with embarrassment. “Fuck, dude….how’d we get here? Wasn’t I just bitching about those thirsty dudes at the gym? Now I’m about to fuckin’ make out with another guy like I’m some chick?”
“You’re certainly acting like a pussy right now.” Brendan egged him on, hoping he hadn’t pushed too far. It was the right move. Tyler gave a short laugh and then leaned in, kissing Brendan roughly. He worked his tongue into Brendan’s mouth like they were wrestling again. It wasn’t until their tongues were entwined that Brendan even stopped to consider why he’d made that request in the first place. His desire for Tyler kept him from thinking about how wrong this all was, but he tried to at least make a mental note of it for later. Like before, Tyler was tense at first. His motions were mechanical and felt forced. But after a few minutes he relaxed and got into it. Gone was the nervous man who didn’t want to do it, replaced by the confident hunk that had no problem landing woman after woman. Their hands were all over each other while their faces pressed together and all Brendan could think about was why hadn’t they done this years before? Things were only intensified when Tyler resumed working on Brendan’s stubby cock. Brendan felt like he was melting. He was putty in Tyler’s strong hands. He came while his tongue was exploring the inside of his friend’s mouth. The strange sensations of another man’s solid, hairy body against his when there was usually someone soft and smooth pushed his brain into overdrive.
“You’re not a bad kisser, little squirt,” Tyler said when he finally pulled his mouth away.
“See? That wasn’t so bad.”
“I’m willing to admit that I could have been wrong. But you’re totally the girlfriend in this set up,” Tyler said with mock seriousness.
“I do have better tits,” Brendan said, flexing his thick pecs. They clambered off the couch and stretched, smiling silently as they were still unable to look away from each other. Neither one knew what to say. They were both experiencing the sensation of seeing the other for the first time despite their decade of friendship.
“Weird fuckin’ night,” Tyler yawned. “I think I’m ready for bed.”
“Same here,” Brendan said as he shut off the lights and followed Tyler towards his bedroom.
“Uh…” Tyler gave him a confused look.
Brendan just grinned. “The deal, remember? You’re sleeping with me tonight and your bed is nicer.”