Home Artists Posts Import Register
Join the new SimpleX Chat Group!

Files

The Drydock - Episode 179

00:00:00 - Intro 00:00:40 - Storage precautions for gunpowder in the age of sail? 00:06:28 - What was the idea behind the Atlanta class? 00:12:53 - IJN cruiser hit in the Feb 1942 raids? 00:14:56 - Naval engagements where being old turned out to be an advantage? 00:18:58 - Contra-rotating propellors on ships? 00:24:30 - Battle of the Chesapeake, what happened? 00:32:52 - What benefits to civilian life do we enjoy thanks to naval technology? 00:39:55 - In your opinion, were there any noteworthy naval actions by the various warlords during the Chinese Civil War (1912-1949)? 00:41:40 - Steam locomotives have cylinder drain cocks to allow any condensated water out of the cylinders when starting. How was it generally handled on ships and how did it change between reciprocating engines and turbines? 00:44:23 - Roles for Akron etc in WW2? 00:46:35 - How valuable was ultimate top speed vs cruising speed/range? 00:52:17 - Would the Jeune École have been a viable option for either the U.S. navy or the navy of the confederacy during the American Civil War? 00:56:36 - What if HMS Erebus and HMS Terror had chosen to risk the unknown passage east around King William Island? 01:00:19 - Any examples of an enlisted man figuring significantly in a navy's history, excluding being known or important just for his valorous actions in combat? 01:02:38 - Was just it a coincidence that HMS Berwick came off worse in both of her cruiser engagements, or would any of the other Counties have done better? 01:04:46 - Had Tone NO. 4 launched on time how likely is it to have missed the US Carriers due to their different positions earlier in the day? 01:07:24 - How much of an effect would Force Z have been if it had not been sunk? 01:11:54 - What would Drach do in place of Admiral Callaghan? 01:23:22 - Why did the RN abandon transom sterns for the Nelsons, and especially the KGVs? 01:26:53 - How would damage control aboard differ aboard a starship vs an ocean ship? How would it be similar? 01:31:05 - Was jamming actually used at Jutland? Would not the presence of enemy jamming be something of a 'trouble over here' sign as surely as hearing gunfire when it comes to indicators of hostilities elsewhere in the fleet? 01:34:43 - Would World War Two naval aviators have benefited from having an angled flight deck to land on? 01:39:42 - Was Shoho the greatest use of overkill in WW2? 01:41:36 - What kind of added difficulties would the Grand Fleet and the Harwich Force commanders have had if the codes of the Kaiserliche Marine had not been captured so early in the war? 01:46:49 - When the US Navy was bombarding the Japanese held islands, did they use only HE shells or did they also employ AP shells to penetrate the bunkers and tunnel systems? 01:49:10 - Was a literally all big gun ship, i.e. no secondaries at all, ever a viable strategy? 01:53:22 - HMS Nelson AA main guns? 01:56:12 - Guided main gun rounds for battleships? 02:00:50 - Why were there such recurrent problems in making a turret for anything more than two guns? 02:08:33 - Was it common for the Royal navy to invest in ports and just later abandon them? In what other cases has this occurred? 02:11:34 - Rear Admiral Sir Home Riggs Popham appears to have truly been "a damned cunning fellow" with a colorful career, and many significant contributions to the Royal Navy and the British Empire. Was or is he a particularly notable officer of the Royal Navy, or did the Royal Navy produce many with similar accomplishments during their careers in the Age of Sail? 02:15:52 - What is your favourite WW 2 Maritime warcraft aircraft and why? 02:17:39 - Why did it take so long for ship to ship missiles to become effective weapons? 02:22:02 - Did the Japanese have any real equivalent to the Condor in the Pacific Theater, and how effective was it? Conversely, what were the most effective Allied counters to it? 02:24:55 - Can you please explain whyconverting Leonardo da Vinci and the Italia class ironclad into aircraft carriers is a terrible idea? 02:28:50 - What would be commonly accepted values for acceptable dispersion? How much is too much, and how much is too little, and why those values? 02:40:40 - How useful were the active pre-standard U.S. battleships (Arkansas, New York, and Texas) in WWII and how does that utility compare to the QE and R-class battleships of the Royal Navy? 02:44:55 - What would a Washington Naval Treaty look like if the British had lost their fleet in WW1 (and the High Seas fleet also sank, so they can't use the German Ships) and would that give the RN a leg up in WW2 by having the most modern fleet? 02:53:09 - Was it imprudent to value ultra-long range in gunnery? 03:00:03 - How did SMS Derflinger get the name Iron Dog and is it the best warship nickname of all time?

Comments

Anonymous

I walked into a local (Richmond, VA) grocery store to pick up a few Irn Brus for this. There was a Scottish clerk who noticed and asked, "How do you know about Irn Bru" in a very deep brogue. Thanks, Drach. Now I have to explain what a naval historiography youtube channel is.

Anonymous

@Bryan Roper: You live in Richmond? I'm only about an hour away -- in Farmville! (Also, where can I find Irn Bru in Richmond?)

Andrew Dederer

Don't be too hard on Miyazaki, he's quite capable of drawing photo-accurate aircraft, when he wants to. His SteamPunkish "Battleship" looks like he took an earlier drawing of the Chinese Ting Yuen class "battleships" (he did a series of 4-5 page comic vignettes for an airline magazine "Iron Dragons" was about the Yalu Battleships) Some of these were collected in the "Daydream Notes" art book. http://halcyonrealms.com/illustration/hayao-miyazakis-daydream-note-artbook/ and caricatured it even more The Ting Yuen's had a triangle of turrets forward, making them very distinct. "High oh" isn't quite how to pronounce his name, but it'll do in a pinch.

Anonymous

Publix. International Aisle. British section. Usually bottom shelf

Anonymous

In the answer of the Battle of the Chesapeake, during the American Revolution, the statement was made that this was the pre-revolution French Navy which had a better firing rate. Was this reference to the pre-French Revolution French Navy?

Anonymous

In Master and Commander (which is a classic) there is a scene where they are being stalked by the French privateer. They put a raft out at night with oil lamps. They then shut the lamps off the Surprise. The question is: why did they need to put out a raft??? Why didn't they just turn off any lights? How could the privateer track them in the night? I do not believe they had radar in 1803.

Anonymous

Drach, do you have many 1/350 scale or 1/700 scale model ships? Your marathon drydocks are great listening while I attempt to construct them.

Anonymous

The USS New Jersey has a video on firing the 16" guns that talks about the primer man.

Andrew Waite

I have heard the UK's new 70,000 ton carriers HMS Queen Elizabeth and HMS Prince of Wales called Big Lizzie and Big Charlie as a nod to Prince Charles the current Prince of Wales. HMS Queen Elizabeth is named for the Tudor monarch Queen Elizabeth the First, not the current Queen. Nicknames for Type-42 destroyers, HMS Newcastle was the Geordie Gunboat, HMS Liverpool the Crazy Red Chicken and HMS Southampton (a Portsmouth based ship) was the Scummer.

Anonymous

Wondering If it were possible to put the Indiana Class (BBs 1, 2, 3) PreDreadnoughts on the list to be explored. They were routinely referred to as the worst ships ever designed yet the did an awful lot of traipsing about for ships intended for Coastal defense. I figure they must not have been very good, but were they (In Drach's studied opinion) as bad as all that when compared to other Navy's first design attempts?...

John Hargreaves

The new Agamemnon (Astute class submarine) will have the nickname from Nelsons ship which was HMS Eggs and Bacon (its tradition).

John Hargreaves

Metric and Imperial I like most use both in my engineering life but what really matters is how you estimate and perceive a size - I always estimate in Imperial because I have an experiential feel for an inch or a foot as I tend to relate to how these measurements came into existence i.e. lengths of body parts (careful don't be rude). I then tend to relate my estimate and then convert to metric.

Anonymous

WRT the Nelson/Rodney turret layout, the Japanese tried both ways. Initially, they had the second turret superfiring. See Atago and her predecessors. But then they made the third turret superfiring in the Mogami class.

Anonymous

Oh yeah? Huh, I went to school in Farmville, howabout that. And yeah, I 2nd Bryan's Publix suggestion; I usually find at least 4-5 bottles when I look there.

Anonymous

The idea is, the French privateer follows the raft and, all going well, does not discover the deception until sunrise. Meanwhile, Surprise has sailed off in another direction, and by sunrise, is far away.

Mike Zitter

Interesting reasoning behind your imperial estimation. I'm tought to think in metric by our schooling system, but my dear dad tought me how to estimate a meter by using your body (backing your careful addition here :-) ). FYI a meter is by estimation equal to a stretched arm, measured from the fingertip to the opposit shoulder.