Home Artists Posts Import Register

Content

A test of an Ecoegg alternative to laundry detergent, that I bought from ASDA in the UK.

I was surprised to find something like this being sold in a major supermarket, as the eBay ones that have been around for a while are very much a placebo device.

I decided to give it a test.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PWbPDF3-LTA

Files

Testing an Ecoegg from ASDA

Not my usual style of video, but when I saw this on sale in ASDA (UK chain formerly owned by Walmart), I was wondering whether the bold claims had any substance. The only way to find out was to test it. This is basically a plastic shell filled with various beads, that claims to be an alternative to normal detergents, with a life of 50 or 70 washes. (70-wash as supplied and then smaller 50-wash refills.) The white pellets are supposedly a concentrated surfactant (molecule that bonds with both water and oil), and the dark tourmaline pellets are supposed to ionise the water and make it more alkaline. If the ball does liberate surfactants then keep in mind that it will also do so during the rinse cycles that are normally used to wash residual dirt and detergent out of your clothing. The laundry industry is full of theatre with optical whiteners (ultraviolet fluorescing dye) that gives the impression of white clothing being brighter, and really pungent aromas that have been marketed to the point that people think that "fresh linen" is actually what fabric is supposed to smell like. Then there are the "softeners" that basically coat your clothing (and laundry equipment) in fragranced wax to give it a softer feel in the same way that oil and grease soaked overalls feel "soft" too. You can wash most clothing in just plain water with no detergent, and it will rise out the natural bodily salts and dust, but it can leave a slight stale aroma after a while as plain water will not remove natural oils well. That's where it's useful to use a SMALL amount of detergent to help wash the oils out. I tend to use standard dish washing liquid, but be aware that some machines will foam excessively with dish soap and that can result in water spraying out the detergent drawer when the machine fills for a rinse. A small quantity of fabric conditioner washed down into the drum will get rid of foam virtually instantly. While the laundry detergent manufacturers want you to pour huge quantities of their detergent into your machine, it only takes a small amount to clean normal clothing. Try using half the amount you normally use. The same goes for conditioner. If you want to use it to mask aromas then try using much less than normal. The Ecoegg did impart a faint and fairly pleasant aroma onto clothing. And for non manual workers it may be enough to get satisfactory results. But for those of us who have physically active jobs a more traditional detergent may be a better option. This may actually work for you if you alternate between conventional detergent and the use of the laundry ball (as a placebo) to help cut down on chemical use. If you enjoy these videos you can help support the channel with a dollar for coffee, cookies and random gadgets for disassembly at:- https://www.bigclive.com/coffee.htm This also keeps the channel independent of YouTube's algorithm quirks, allowing it to be a bit more dangerous and naughty. #ElectronicsCreators

Comments

09Klr650

You can make a 5 gallon bucket worth of laundry detergent with a Fels naptha bar some borax, and washing soda.

Jonas

One washing machine of ours broke down because of too much soap in the machine.. it came out from some emergency valve or similar inside the machine at the top of the water container and spread inside the electronics of the machine and it just stopped working completely. I mean soap came out of the detergent compartment as well, but yeah.

John Harrison

Clive we add a small amount of Dettol or equivalent into the softener siphon compartment and no conditioner (some will turn to jelly if you mix them) Our wash is normally 30'c. Before we did this we would get black spots that must have been forming on the drum like mould; worse in Summer our kitchen gets full sun most of the day. We started doing this when our shower towels started to smell like damp hay when we hung them to dry on the landing. We use a dehumidifier when washing will not dry on the line, we do not have room for a tumble dryer. I worked for Thorn EMI in the 1980s we made tumble dryers 28 different models - they were all the same - just different names and colours, the Bendix was the only one with a moulded plug, the Hotpoint had orange switches, I thought it was daft thing to do. We had a punch tape robot to paint inside the drum, a skilled operator moved the gun and it recorded it on punch tape. Later the drums were not painted we used Zintec plated steel; Best not to leave wet clothes in the drum. Another daft thing they did was make the same tumble drier that was heated by GAS: Crazy thing to do for the domestic market.

bigclive

During the pandemic Sainsbury's sold bottles of "fabric conditioner" that were mainly 2.45g per 100ml of Benzalkonium Chloride, plus aroma. That's basically the same ingredients as generic supermarket disinfectant. It's a very common broad spectrum biocide. The same stuff used at a very low concentration in alcohol-free foaming hand sanitiser, as it is also a surfactant that produces a dense foam.