Home Artists Posts Import Register

Content

Good evening, my Ranma fans. Apologies for getting this out a few days after I wanted, but I had several days of time I could use on my fanfics, and I was hugely on a roll! I finished like 10,000 words a day, woo. King of Champions6is now done and off to the editor, although judging by the answers people gave to my HP questions, part of the chapter might annoy its readers LOL. Similarly, Semblance of Hope will be finished and sent off by tomorrow night. It’s an episode sized, but that will let me time to concentrate on the small story winner. After that will be the patron only winner.

Anyway, as mentioned for those of you who didn’t immediately turn away from seeing the (HP Only) tag, This is this month’s Ranma-centric questions. Amusingly though, I honestly only have questions about Stallion of the Line. I had a handful of others, but most deal with events too far in the future for a few of the fics, and others deal with fics that aren’t in the story rotation yet. Putting them in would feel too much like teasing you all, the same kind of thinking that kept me from putting Heroes of the High Seas into the present rotation.

So…

1. I have already determined that the Marines will be bringing in more officers and admirals than were involved in the canon War of the Best. I have looked at the marine with the strange robot arm from the movies, Zoro’s friend and the marines from the Fifth movie (I think it’s the fifth? The one with the demon sword).  But I am wondering what the meteor user – the blind swordsman- and his fellow newbie were doing at this point?

2. There are two characters whose reaction to events in the war I am having trouble with: Mihawk and Doffy.

a. Would Mihawk fight to the last for the marines even if he can see that they are losing or if their plans go awry before the first shot is even fired? Or would he cut his loses and retreat, and if so, when?

b. Similarly I have to wonder about Doffy. If the battle doesn’t go down at Marineford like planned, would he simply leave? If the Marines demanded it, would he bend and bring along his crew to add their firepower? And if the battle does turn, when would he try to take advantage, near the end of the battle or the instant he senses the marines might lose? Would he just leave, or join in on beating the marines?

3. Are there any other pirates that could theoretically be lifted to Shichibukai status that you would like to see involved in this war? You all can include pirates not introduced at this point in canon, pirates allied with one of the Yonko or from the movies. I’ve shown previously I am not going to turn my nose up at movie-only characters.

4. While I know that he truly joined the crew in canon, I am debating on letting Jinbei and his crew become the third allied group of Raffy’s forces. This way I can bring him in occasionally, he remains an ally, and yet isn’t a main character, letting me concentrate further on the main characters. Thoughts?

5. Usopp. Should he join the crew? Or, better, become part of Jinbei’s crew and thus an ally? I… REALLLY do not like his character in some ways before the timeskip. After, he is much better, but even then, I don’t know if he would fit in with the crew as is. And I think he would have as many issues with Raffy as Nami has had in the past occasionally.

Comments

Hiryo

1.) Was already answered by others here better than I could. 2.) A) Mihawk. For him having a challenge, ie is still fighting a fight he enjoys would be more important. He needed challenges. And what interests him in fighting/testing out strong opponents may weight more. However if those are satisfied, he would flee then. B) Doflamingo: As long as he can get benefits/stays on top/sees a way to win he would stay. 3.) No Opinion on that one. 4.) Jinbei being ‘only an allied force would be too weak a message and danger for the future. Him joining him should be still done, however he can be ordered to handle the other forces due his great capabilities! 5.) As is, and how the crew came to be and your writing style is. I think him already joining Buggy and aligning him with him would be poor a heart that he stops suddenly wanting to be with the crew. As said I’m against him joining.

Novus

1. I don't know enough about the movies and such to really suggest anyone. 2a. I never got the impression Mihawk had any real loyalty to the Marines. It always seemed to me that he basically just thought of his title as a way to prevent the Marines from annoying him constantly. More...I'm honestly shocked if he's even present at all. Assuming he was around for Garp going ape-shit, I can't imagine his reaction having been anything but either: NOPE! I'm OUT! or SWEET, I GET TO FIGHT HIM! With little room in between. Meaning he's either dead, nursing serious injuries, or has fucked off from the area entirely. That, of course, is assuming he was present. If he wasn't, then it's a bit of a toss up. The Marines have done several colossally stupid things in rapid succession, weakening themselves to the point that I'm not sure he'd bother supporting them. They aren't going to be in any shape to protest his ignoring them for a long long time, after all. Even if they somehow still come out on top at Marineford. b. Doffy doesn't give a shit about anyone but himself. I think he'd most likely just not show at all. The marines have lost too much firepower to be capable of compelling him. 3. Honestly? No. Not a single one I can think of. Or, more to the point, anyone with the power to promoted to that status wouldn't agree to be in the first place. In order to be powerful enough to receive that offer...they have to already BE powerful. And powerful pirates aren't exactly known to be willing to swing around to following the marines. Most of the warlords in canon were either compelled by a need to defend some place (Hancock and Jinbei) or were basically using it as a cover so they wouldn't be bothered while they ran their take-over-the-world scheme (Doffy, Croc, Moria, Kuma). Literally the only exception in the starting warlord set was Mihawk. Who, as I already pointed out, seemed to always just regard the position as a way not to be constantly bothered. 4. I honestly think you're on the right track with that idea. Trying to make too many main characters slows pacing down (as happened with A Third Path to the Future a lot of the time). And, in-story, if Raffy is going to be taken seriously as a new Yonko, gathering another powerful captain/crew under him is far more valuable than a single additional crewman. 5. Literally any option that keeps him away from being a main character is a great option. Always hated Usopp, even if he did get a bit better post timeskip. If you go with Jinbei being a supporting Captain of his own crew, adding him to that crew makes a LOT of sense. It would actually give Usopp what he was always looking for, even more so than canon really, while keeping him from becoming a major character -_-.