Prompt: Helping a Friend Ch. 9 (Fairy Tail) (Patreon)

Summary: Cana, Gray, and Lucy continue their threesome as Gray comes up with an idea for him, Natsu, and Lucy to all be winners. Includes: Threesome, cheating

---

Gray’s legs were trembling as he leaned against the kitchen counter. Lucy had her arms around him, kissing him passionately, pressing her tongue against his as Cana sucked at his cock.

The brunette was on her knees, tits wrapped around his shaft as her lips gently suckled on his tip. Her tongue slid around the head, coating it in saliva as the woman moaned. The wet slurping sounds she made was the perfect music for Lucy and Gray’s make out session. 

The blond pressed her large breasts against Gray. Her hard nipples rubbed his body, before she broke the kiss and smiled at him. A thread of saliva fell between their lips, breaking as their eyes both turned. 

Their smiles faded for a moment as they both looked at the clock hanging on the wall.

“So, what time is Natsu getting back?” Gray asked, Cana’s lips almost not affecting him as he looked at Lucy.

“He’ll be back in the afternoon,” she replied. He nodded in understanding.

There was a moment of silence, before Gray looked into Lucy’s eyes and smiled. “So we’ve got time?” He pulled Lucy close, pressing his lips against hers once more as they kissed. His tongue tasted her lips, begging for entry, and she submitted, opening her mouth as she wrapped her arms around his body, kissing back with almost as much passion as he gave her.

Their arms clung to one another as Gray moaned. His voice was muffled by Lucy’s lips and tongue, but he still moaned loudly as Cana made him cum. Sperm filled the brunette’s mouth, coating the walls of her mouth as more sprayed down her throat, pooling into stomach.

Cana gagged and choked for a moment, tears pooling in the corners of her eyes. She gave out some muffled coughs, quivering as she struggled to breathe through her nose.

The brunette gasped for air as she unimpaled her head from Gray’s dick. Thick lines of semen spilled from her mouth and onto the ground as she moved her hair from her eyes and slowly caught her breath. What fell out either fell onto the ground or was slurped back into Cana’s mouth as she looked up at the two.

“Lucy. Bend over onto the table.”

“Heh. You got it, Gray.”

The blond obeyed the order without hesitation, pulling away from the black-haired man and leaning forward until her breasts were against the smooth surface of the table. She wiggled her butt from side to side as Gray followed her. He placed her hands on her ass, admiring the shape and size of her tender rear, before he began to gently rub his cock against her pussy.

Lucy moaned at the teasing touch, biting her lower lip, until suddenly gasping and crying out as the cock was pushed into her pussy. 

It slid in easily, having gotten used to the size and shape after all the times Gray had fucked her. Lucy shuddered as it entered her, feeling it split her apart and brush against her inner walls. She was panting as her fingers grabbed the edges of the table, desperate to hold onto something as Gray slowly pushed his hips forward. More and more of the thick member was pushed into her, spreading her apart as she shuddered and gasped.

Cana watched the two with a jealous pout, wanting nothing more to join in, but how? Her perverted mind soon found an answer, and she walked forward, on all fours, towards the two with a smirk on her plump lips. 

Neither noticed the brunette as she crawled towards them. Gray was too busy admiring the tight walls of Lucy’s cunt, feeling the way they stroked every inch of his dick, moaning as his tip kissed the entrance to Lucy’s womb. His fingers dug into her ass, squeezing it as he closed his eyes and just enjoyed the sensation of being squeezed.

Meanwhile, Lucy was loving the feeling of being filled and stretched. Every thrust sent shivers down her spine and threw her into another pool of pleasure. She was shaking, quivering with every thrust as her toes were lifted off of the ground. She arched her back, pushing her large breasts against the table as she fought to keep her moans down.

A task that was next to impossible when Cana suddenly started rubbing her fingers against Lucy’s pussy, and her other hand against Gray’s balls. Both moaned at the soft touch, opening their eyes and looking down to find Cana on her knees below them. She flashed a smile, before she leaned towards Gray and opened her mouth. 

Cana licked his balls, dragging her tongue along the skin, before pressing her nose against the pair of cum factories. She took in their scent, before gently sucking on them. She dragged her tongue along the balls, and then to Gray’s dick, tasting Lucy’s wet pussy on the shaft.

She shuddered, moaning at the taste, before moving towards Lucy. She kissed the blond’s pussy, watching the cock thrust in and out of it as she stole a kiss whenever she could. Her tongue licked a circle around Lucy’s pussy as Cana moved back and forth, before watching as Gray came inside of the blond, filling her with cum.

Said cum trickled out of the blond’s womanhood, giving Cana the chance to lick it up as her perverted mind thought of what else she could for fun with the two. In a matter of seconds, she came up with her next idea as Gray and Lucy struggled to catch their breath. 

Cana stood up as Lucy and Gray watched her. With a quick spell, Cana materialized the strap-on she had used with Lucy during their threesome with Elfman. Lucy’s eyes widened and her cheeks became a faint crimson as memories flooded into her mind.

“Judging by that look in your eyes, I’m guessing you remember this?” Cana licked the tip, before grinning. “Because I remember the look you gave me when I used it on you. We should show Gray, don’t you think?”

Staring at the plastic rod gave Gray an idea, and he grinned as he slowly pulled his cock out of Lucy. “We should take this to the bedroom,” he suggested, and both of the lovely ladies agreed with smiles on their faces.

The three left for the bedroom, and Cana followed Gray’s next command of laying on the bed. She strapped on the sex toy and laid down on her back, letting the plastic toy aim towards the ceiling. Gray patted Lucy on the ass, and the blond smiled as she crawled onto the bed and sat down on the member.

Lucy let it fill her body, moaning as it stretched out her tight pussy. She was shaking as the rod rubbed her soft, moist walls. She shuddered as she bounced up and down, riding the thick rod as Gray got onto the bed and leaned close to Lucy’s ear. 

“Having fun?” She nodded her head as Gray placed his hands on her jiggly breasts, giving them both a squeeze as she continued to moan and gasp. 

Without any warning, he aimed his cock against her ass and pushed forward, slowly splitting her ass in two with his veiny dick. Lucy’s moans grew into screams and cries as the cock spread her asscheeks apart. 

Gray and Cana fucked Lucy right there. When the man swung his hips back and forth, it lifted Lucy up slightly, before he pushed her down onto Cana’s dildo. Then the woman would lift up her hips, just enough to make Lucy bounce. She’d place her hands on Lucy’s body, gently pushing her against Gray.

The two worked together, all for Lucy, all to make the woman go mad with lust and pleasure. The buxom woman’s tongue hung over her lower lips as she stared at the roof, moaning out her lovers’ names. 

It was at this moment that Gray made his move. He leaned forward, and he whispered into Lucy’s ear a single sentence, but it was more than enough to make her freeze. “Imagine Natsu having an affair.” 

The sentence sent Lucy into a fantasy. She imagined her boyfriend cheating on her, making love to another woman. 

She saw him fucking Evergreen, holding her down as he pounded her pussy on her bed. She moaned and cried out, just like how Lucy would when she was being fucked.

Then she imagined Natsu doing the same to Levy. Holding her in his arms as he fucked her like a beast. The small, petite beauty screamed and cried out as she was ravaged, yet the smile on her face told Lucy everything.

She loved it. Natsu was an amazing lover. Mercilessly pounding her and making her cum again and again, and she adored it. She screamed Natsu’s name as she came, cumming to the feeling of his semen filling her pussy and coating her walls.

Lucy imagined herself just watching Juvia blowing Natsu, cleaning his cock after he had just fucked both Evergreen and Levy. They stared into each other’s eyes as Natsu stroked Juvia’s blue locks.

Jealousy bubbled in Lucy’s stomach, but so did lust and desire. Arousal. It all mixed together as Gray whispered, “I mean, fair’s fair, right? He gets to have affairs, so do you… Then you two can reunite and still be the happy couple madly in love.”

That brought Lucy over the edge. Her eyes widened as she gasped, feeling her body burning like a sun, before she went supernova. She bit her lower lip until it was nearly bleeding as she came. 

The orgasm was one of the greatest of her life, and soon, she was mewling and crying out with a wide smile on her. Her eyes rolled into her skull as her body quivered like a leaf in the wind.

Her pussy and ass tightened around both Gray’s cock and Cana’s strap on. The young man squeezed her hips, trembling as a flood of semen filled her tight butt. His hands dug into her supple, soft flesh as he kissed her neck and shoulders, moaning as her ass milked his cock for cum. 

Cana gasped, feeling the vibrations of Lucy’s bouncing. The blond bimbo was such a good fuck. Even the brunette could tell with just a strap on. She ended up digging her fingers into the bed’s sheets, opening her mouth and letting out a loud moan as she soon came as well.

Lucy fell off of Cana and laid on the ground, panting as Cana pulled her closer and kissed her. Lucy let out an exhausted groan, but kissed back, pressing her tongue against Cana’s as Gray watched with approval. 

Gray wanted the beautiful blond to be happy. Truly he did, but honestly, he wanted to be happy to, and he’d be at his happiest if he could keep fucking Lucy, even after he started dating Juvia.

Hopefully he could convince the young woman to keep cheating on Natsu. Hell, maybe he could convince the pink-haired man to sleep around behind Lucy’s back. Everyone wins…

---

In two hours, Natsu was going to come home. 

Lucy and Gray waited with hushed, quiet breaths. Cana left over an hour ago to do some drinking, but the two were still at Natsu and Lucy’s home. Right now they were showering together, washing each other’s bodies as the moments ticked by. 

Lucy could see she wasn’t the only one clearly getting impatient, so she acted to try and get Gray’s mind off her boyfriend. 

It started with a kiss, like it did most times, before Lucy was soon riding Gray’s cock, bouncing on his lap as he laid his head back and rested in the warm bath. It wasn’t easy, due to the size of the tub, but they made it work as Lucy moaned and shuddered from the cock inside of her.

Gray’s was easily one of her favorites. Next to Natu’s, of course….

Lucy moaned again as her pussy wrapped tightly around Gray’s shaft. The warm water only made her skin more sensitive as electric ecstasy went through her flesh. Her moans were suddenly muffled as Gray kissed her. Her eyes widened, before she wrapped her arms around him and pushed her tongue into his mouth.

He sucked on it as her hard nipples dragged along his chest. His cock throbbed inside Lucy, before pushing against her G-spot. The sweet spot made her cry out, breaking the kiss as the two stared into each other’s eyes.

“G-Gray!”

“Hm?”

“Just… just stop for a moment so I can breathe,” she begged, her voice almost laughing at how out of breath and exhausted she was. She took a long, deep breath, before exhaling. “I-I think I have a plan to convince Natsu to keep letting us fuck, but it means we’ll only be able to meet once a month.”

“Fine by me,” he replied.

“A-alright. Now-Mmmph!” Lucy’s eyes widened as Gray pulled her back into the kiss, and try as she might, Lucy just couldn’t bring herself to break free from his powerful lips and delicious tongue. She held him tightly, kissing him as he hoped her plan would work.