Home Artists Posts Import Register
The Offical Matrix Groupchat is online! >>CLICK HERE<<

Content

NOTE: I'm endlessly grateful to every Patron who gives for any reason, but for what it's worth THIS series in particular is the one that takes the most amount of work and gets blocked from monetization by YouTube most often. So more than anything else, this series exists thanks to you - so if you know anyone who you think might enjoy it and/or may also want to become a Patron; by all means please share the links far and wide ;)

Anyway..

TRANSFORMERS: THE MOVIE debuted in 1986 to scathing reviews and a less-than-transformative box office performance - after all, it was essentially a 90 minute toy commercial whose target audience was already getting its fix on TV for free. But home-video and regular TV play, combined with the enduring popularity of the TRANSFORMERS brand and the shocking (however marketing-driven) decision to kill off many of the most popular original characters made it a pop-culture staple for a whole generation of fans; many of whom today regard it as a cult classic... but is it?  

Where some merely see a cynical feature-length commercial highlighted by oddball voice-casting, inconsistent animation and some of the cheesiest 80s heavy metal ever recorded; many devout fans insist it all (somehow) adds up to something more - and its enduring popularity suggests they might have a point: There's a thousand things "wrong" with TRANSFORMERS: THE MOVIE; but if a whole generation still claims to be sincerely captivated by its strangely-hypnotic bizarre visual aesthetic, caught up in its surreally-serious sci-fi melodramatics and moved to tears by the death of Optimus Prime... are they wrong? 

Is it just nostalgia talking? Where does authorial intent (in this case: to make a toy commercial) give way to audience-perception in determining which creative works get to "matter?"  

Is TRANSFORMERS: THE MOVIE... Really That Good? 

Files

Really That Good - TRANSFORMERS: THE MOVIE (1986)

REALLY THAT GOOD is an independent MovieBob Production. If you enjoy it and want to see more like it, please consider supporting The MovieBob Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/moviebob1 Welcome to a NEW kind of film-criticism series, built around the radical premise that just because "everyone knows" a movie is a classic doesn't mean it stops being worth a deeper look. TRANSFORMERS: THE MOVIE debuted in 1986 to scathing reviews and a less-than-transformative box office performance - after all, it was essentially a 90 minute toy commercial whose target audience was already getting its fix on TV for free. But home-video and regular TV play, combined with the enduring popularity of the TRANSFORMERS brand and the shocking (however marketing-driven) decision to kill off many of the most popular original characters made it a pop-culture staple for a whole generation of fans; many of whom today regard it as a cult classic... but is it? Where some merely see a cynical feature-length commercial highlighted by oddball voice-casting, inconsistent animation and some of the cheesiest 80s heavy metal ever recorded; many devout fans insist it all (somehow) adds up to something more - and its enduring popularity suggests they might have a point: There's a thousand things "wrong" with TRANSFORMERS: THE MOVIE; but if a whole generation still claims to be sincerely captivated by its strangely-hypnotic bizarre visual aesthetic, caught up in its surreally-serious sci-fi melodramatics and moved to tears by the death of Optimus Prime... are they wrong? Where does authorial intent (in this case: to make a toy commercial) give way to audience-perception in determining which creative works get to "matter?" Is TRANSFORMERS: THE MOVIE... Really That Good? "Black Vortex", "Disco Lounge", "Marty Gots a Plan", "Oppressive Gloom", "The Curtain Rises", "Ultralounge", "Wizardtorium," "Inspire" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/b... "Transformers" is a property of Hasbro Inc. REALLY THAT GOOD is a work of film/media criticism created for education and journalism purposes and makes no claims on any media that is discussed in any individual episode.

Comments

Anonymous

I'm not sure I've seen this since I first saw it in a movie theatre as a child. Excellent episode.

Dave

That intro was absolutely grand and incredibly informative and tied in amazingly well with the theme. As to the review, that was similarly fantastic, great insights all around!

Jason Youngberg

I loved this episode! I put a comment under the name "Alverant" on the YouTube channel so I won't repeat it here. But really, thanks for making this.

Anonymous

I'm not here to put you under any pressure, take all the time you need/want on making it as good as you can: When roughly will the BVS review be? Sometime before or after Christmas?

Kenneth Chisholm

Superb as always. Could you consider the next films to examine like A Boy Named Charlie Brown or the original Karate Kid? For that matter, would you consider doing the same kind of examination for TV series like Robotech or Babylon 5?

Anonymous

Your long videos are always your best work. I know longer videos are exponentially harder to produce than your Overthinker Lists while also being less friendly to YouTube's algorithms, so I'm really glad you still make these. You are one of the few creators on YouTube I will actually watch an entire hour long video from, so you must have some kind of talent for creating them.

Anonymous

I have mixed feelings about the film itself (having been a girl in '80s Transformers fandom will do that to you), but the intro on this is possibly the best I've seen from you yet. Bravo!

Anonymous

One of your best, Bob. This is the kind of stuff that makes me glad to be a patron.