Home Artists Posts Import Register

Content

Hey everyone :D Thanks most of all to your amazing help the decision process has been fairly swift and I've arrived at what I think I can call a preliminary list for the Commander Collection! You'll see some things have questions attached still - if you could help me figure those out it'd be amazing!

Without further ado:

  • Clue
  • 2/2 Drake
  • */* Hydra
  • Exile Marker (how many do you think would be good?)
  • Commander Death Counter (how many of these would you usually need?)
  • 4/4 Kaldra
  • Experience Counters (I guess one that you can put a d6 on?)
  • 4/4 Beast
  • 1/1 Soldier
  • */* Avatar
  • 20/20 Marit Lage
  • 1/1 Assassin
  • 0/1 Plant
  • 0/1 Reef Worm
  • 3/3 Fish
  • 6/6 Whale
  • 9/9 Kraken
  • 1/1 Sand
  • 1/1 Kor Soldier
  • 3/3 Ape
  • 1/1 Sand Warrior
  • 3/3 Frog
  • 1/1 Saproling
  • 3/3 Elephant
  • 1/1 Kor Ally
  • 1/1 Soldier Ally
  • 2/2 Knight Ally
  • 1/1 Rat
  • 4/4 Angel
  • 1/1 Hippo
  • 0/1 Spawn
  • 1/1 Scion
  • 2/2 Wolf
  • 0/1 Kobolds (x2?)
  • 1/1 Cat Soldier Vigilance
  • 2/2 Satyr
  • 1/1 Myr
  • */* Horror
  • */* Pack Rat
  • 2/2 Pincher
  • 1/1 Cleric
  • 1/1 Pentavite
  • 1/1 Snake
  • 3/3 Wurm Deathtouch
  • 3/3 Wurm Lifelink
  • 1/1 Sliver
  • 1/1 Thopter
  • 2/2 Zombie
  • 1/1 Spirit
  • 1/1 Goblin

What do you think? Is anything important missing? Do I have stuff in there that doesn't belong? Should I quit entirely? Let me know! :)


Again thank you so much for your invaluable help - it means so much to me.


All the best

Hannes

Comments

Anonymous

Commander death token could use a d6 too. Elf warrior perhaps :) and elf Druid...that's my only token in edh right now, but I have previous prints.

Apiris

I'm not really a fan of the reef worm chain. I've never actually seen those played in EDH. I'd really, really like a serf token for Sengir Autocrat.

Anonymous

A 5/5 demon with flying would be nice. Is there any chance you might do the commander emblems too?

Anonymous

Commander Death Counter: One per player, and you put a coloured dice for counting damage from each commander. I believe 4 or 6 are the best options

Anonymous

A counter with each of the mana symbols on it so you can track how much floating mana you have of each type you have would be super useful.

Anonymous

An Elemental set would be great to see (5/5 Elemental, 3/1 Elemental, 1/1 Elemental)

Anonymous

Can we get some dragon tokens?

Anonymous

Trostani's Summoner is pretty popular in token and flicker decks, so a 2/2 knight, 3/3 centaur, and 4/4 rhino would likely be quite appreciated! Also the 1/1 elf druids from Freyalise would be nice as well. 5/5 dragons and 5/5 demons are pretty common too.

Anonymous

An idea I had would be be tokens that are specific to commander from the all the sets that have been released by WOTC... otherwise the options can be as far reaching as the entirety of MTG.

Anonymous

Voice of Resurgence is pretty common, and it needs a */* Elemental equal to the number of creatures. The Trostani's Summoner trio of 2/2 Knight, 3/3 Centaur, and 4/4 Rhino would be awesome too.

Anonymous

Exile markers? What are those? There is no "commander death counter" those are age counters.

Anonymous

Don't quit :-) The List looks pretty impressive... :-)

Anonymous

Many of these have more than one card producing them or never have had a token printed for them yet see a lot of play. Hope this helps. Absolute Essentials Missing: 1/1 Insect token (Ant Queen) 3/3 Beast token (Garruk Wildspeaker) 2/2 Cat token (Kemba, Kha Regent) 4/4 Dragon token (Descent of the Dragons) Very Nice to Have: 2/2 Spawn token (Spawning Pit) 1/1 Thrull token (Endrek Sahr, Master Breeder) 0/1 Serf token (Sengir Autocrat) 1/1 Dragon token with Devour 2 (Dragon Broodmother) 3/1 Graveborn token (Sek'kuar, Deathkeeper) 1/1 Vampire token with Lifelink (Sorin, Lord of Innistrad) 2/2 Vampire token with Flying (Sorin, Solemn Visitor) 1/1 Rat token with Deathtouch (Ogre Slumlord) 1/1 Kithkin Soldier token (Cloudgoat Ranger) 1/1 Human token (Increasing Devotion) 1/1 Faerie Rogue token (Bitterblossom) *edited* 5/5 Dragon token (Dragonmaster Outcast)

Apiris

This person made a list that I'd be happy to buy. However, Bitterblossom makes Faerie Rogues. A 0/1 goat from springjack posture would also be nice. The one from Modern Essentials had the wrong power. A 1/1 death touch snake would also be helpful.

Anonymous

This list looks quite nice. The only one I commonly use that is absent from that list is the 1/1 Elf Warrior that Rhys the Redeemed can put out.

Anonymous

Sounds great, I can't wait

Ceri

I would suggest making the Pentavite into a generic 1/1 Flying " 'vite ", so it works for Tetravites and Triskelavites too, since I see those more often than the basic Pentavite

Anonymous

*/* Spirit for Daxos the Returned

Anonymous

Is this a list with intention of cutting down or is it meant to be bigger than the Modern Essentials pack? If it serves a general essentials to carry, it could probably use a 2/2 vampire token, a 1/1 elf warrior and/or elf druid, and a 2/2 cat. Will this also be funded through Kickstarter?

Anonymous

Looks awesome, the only ones I'd suggest are a 3/3 frog-lizzard and a 2/2 legendary wolf. How do we get ahold of these?

johannesvoss

Yes it'll be a neat and tidy Kickstarter campaign, implementing everything I've learned last time :)

johannesvoss

You guys are the best! :D Thank you so much, this collection will be amazing! :D

Anonymous

3/3 Angel 1/1 Elf Warrior 1/1 Rat token with Deathtouch (Ogre Slumlord) 1/1 Faerie Rogue token (Bitterblossom) 5/5 Dragon token (Dragonmaster Outcast)

Anonymous

I think the 6/6 dragon token for Utvara Hellkite would be really helpful

Anonymous

I know I'm Super super super late to the party. but is there talk of any 8/12 Genju of the Realm token?