Marked (Make A Choice) (Patreon)

(Timeskip 10 Minutes)

((Y/N)'s POV)

Jess-GIVE HIM BACK!!!

Benny-Make me.~

Jess-Gladly!

Jess jumped at Benny and I to tackle her and when I fell out of her arms for them to fight I tried to get up, but I was so tired of trying to run already. They were fighting since the moment Slenda left the room, but just then I was grabbed and ran with while most of the others either watched Jess and Benny fight or... actually they were just watching and not trying to break it up, instead making sure they don't get caught in it. Whoever this was running really fast and covered my eyes until I heard a door open and close before I was put down. My eyes were uncovered and I saw I was in a room that looked like it belonged to a goth teen girl or something. There was even some knives on the wall and when I turned to see who it was... It was Jane.

<figure></figure>

Jane-That psychotic bitch didn't hurt you, did she?~

She bent closer to me, but because she had black eyes, she just looked so scary to be around. I tried backing away from her, but all it did was make her walk closer to me until I hit her bed and she grabbed me to put me on her bed before she looked at my knees and when I did too I saw one was bruised and it started to feel sore.

Jane-*Gasp* That bitch!

(Y/N)-Um... Y-You shouldn't say that.

Jane-Wait here.

She went into her bathroom then came back out with a jar of some kind of cream and scooped some out with her finger to put it on my knee. It quickly stopped hurting, but the bruise was still there and slowly going away now.

Jane-Alright, let's check for more.

(Y/N)-I-It's just my knee. I'm-.

She only lifted my shirt before letting it go then rolled up my shorts a little before she left to put the jar away and I tried to leave, but the second I grabbed the door knob.

Jane-HEY!!!

I froze in place before I was grabbed and thrown across the room and back on the bed and even when the landing was soft I saw Jane run to me and hop on her bed to pin me down.

Jane-Were you just going to leave me after I helped you?!

(Y/N)-I-I-I... B-But I-.

Jane just covered my mouth before she just laid next to me and held me tight before she turned on her T.V. in here to put on a movie. I just tried to shift a little to get comfy, but that made her a little angry and hold me tighter. This was also a really scary movie, so with all of this going on too... I started crying and that finally made her hold me a little less tight.

Jane-Awwww, no, no, no. Don't cry. You're alright... ish.

She started rubbing my back to comfort me before her door suddenly swung open and we both looked to see it was my school nurse and this look on her made her super scary.

<figure></figure>

Nurse Ann-There you are!

She just marched up to us and Jane was about to grab a knife, but Nurse Ann pinned her wrist down just inches away from it.

Nurse Ann-Remember what Slenda said... Now give him.

She took me from Jane and tried to get me to stop crying, but that was not gonna happen as she was walking out of the room and I saw Jane giving us a mean look. I tried to wiggle out of Nurse Ann's arms, but she only held me tight before we made it to a room that looked like a hospital room with 9 hospital beds, and one normal looking bed. She strapped me down to one of the hospital beds in this big room then started petting my head.

Nurse Ann-Awwww, you must be so scared. I know how scary it can be.~

She walked away from me and to a cabinet to grab some things and when I saw her coming back... She had a needle and I already hate needles. I screamed and cried louder then all she did was rub my cheek before she tied a rubber strap around my arm then poked me with the needle.

Nurse Ann-I know you hate needles, I know, you're gonna calm down now.~

(Nurse Ann's POV)

What I just gave him was a small dose of a little special medicine I made that is going to slow his heart rate, so the adrenaline doesn't pump through as much as well as weakening his motor skills for a while. In other words, he will be forced to calm down and be unable to move, but he will still feel everything. I had this before for my "patients" I captured and I experimented this at multiple hospitals and school districts until I stayed at the elementary school to keep an eye on (Y/N). I did plan to let him end up like the others at first, but the poor thing was being tormented at school and I first saw him in the nurses office crying. I just waited for my medicine to kick in before I took him out of his bed and put him in mine with me to cuddle.

Nurse Ann-I know you can't talk right now, but how about a little show. I know you like (F/C).

He really couldn't react much right now, but I went ahead and rolled out my big T.V. on its stand and put on his show before I went back to cuddling him. This is for sure gonna persuade him into picking me tonight, but during his show, a horror movie suddenly turned on and I felt a jolt come from him. I looked to see the remote was in the stand, so I did not sit on it and that could only leave...

Nurse Ann's mind-Benny!

I just didn't chance it and through a few scalpels at my T.V. to make sure she couldn't get through or use my T.V. anymore. I just pulled (Y/N) closer when my lights started to flicker then she jumped out from one of my heart monitors in here.

<figure></figure>

Benny-Hey "little man" did you miss me?~

Nurse Ann-You put on a scary movie for him?! You're lucky he's drugged!

Benny-Oh, so you can drug kids, but me putting on a horror movie is crossing a line?

Nurse Ann-Get out!

Benny-Now you remember what Slenda said, right? No hogging him on the first night and we all get a turn... Oh and one more thing. Next time you wanna make sure that the screen is completely destroyed or else I can do something like this.

She snapped her fingers dramatically to turn on my broken T.V. then cords came out of it to grab him and if my drugs still weren't in effect he would be screaming as he was yanked into the T.V. and I was furious at Benny who only gave me a smug smile.

Benny-Bitch at me at dinner later.~

She jumped into the T.V. while I threw another scapple at her, but I missed by not even a split second.

((Y/N)'s POV)

I kept my eyes closed from the few seconds of bright lights until they were gone I landed on something soft and bouncy. I opened my eyes to see I was on big bed and from what I could see, there was game posters on the walls and a few stacks of video games, some even reached the ceiling. Just then the T.V. turned on to some kind of static before Benny jumped out and for some reason I still wasn't scared at all.

<figure></figure>

She jumped on her bed next to me before she moved me to a more comfortable position to cuddle me and I have no idea why I was ok with this when I couldn't even move. Next she gave me a weird smile before she took my hand and stuffed it in her boobs and I felt my face heat up because I never touched a girl there before.

Benny-*Gasp* You naughty boy. Do you even have anything to say for yourself?!~

I couldn't talk or at least pull my hand out, but I was stuck until she lifted me above her and she was actually kinda strong. She even tossed me in the air a bit above her to catch me with her hands and feet until she let me fall face first into her chest.

Benny-*Tsk* *tsk* *tsk* You really love these, do you? If it makes it better, on that "sick day" off of school... I snuck in with our little artist... Huh, I guess you never got her name... Olivia was pretty much thinking about her favorite model.

I was confused and I could move my face a little more before she sat me up on the bed before she got a poster from under her bed then showed it to me. It was a painting of us in a mostly red painting that was actually good, but really embarrassing when I noticed she was really close to me naked while I was asleep.

Benny-Oh relax, your mom was home and this took hours, so she did me first then added you later on. I just snuck in to take the picture and she tagged along.

I just closed my eyes and I heard her giggling at me before she put it away and held me in her arms before she took me to a couch in her room and had me lay on her while she played video games. She was playing some scary games that I was forced to watch and listen too and I felt a little scared. Maybe whatever Nurse Ann gave me was going away now and maybe if I wait for the right moment, I can make a run for it and... leave... my parents... here.

(Y/N)'s mind-There's gotta be a way to get them out of that game. After a while I could move a little more and when she felt this she got with me while carrying me out of her room.

Benny-You know, if you pick me tonight, I could help you out in the morning.

(Y/N)-... Wh-What's... in the morning?

Benny-I wouldn't want to spoil the surprise, but let me put it like this. We were eager for months to have you here, so you bet we would want to be the first to give you something.

Just then she knocked on a door before she laid me on the ground in front of it.

Benny-I'll give you some time to think it over... See you at dinner.~

The lights flickered a couple of times before she just vanished out of nowhere then the door opened and I saw who it was and she looked so happy to see me.

<figure></figure>

Jill-*Gasp* Well look who came to play. Why are you laying there, silly cutie pie?~

She picked me up and took me in her room and saw someone else was in here and she was painting then she turned to show herself as Olivia.

<figure></figure>

Jill-Start a new one! I want one of me holding him!

Olivia-I can't. I'm low on blood.

Jill-I thought you had a pile of cans worth?

Olivia-That was before you all made me blow it all on fixed portraits of you with (Y/N) and I used the rest to make my personal gallery of him.

Jill-Can I see?!

Olivia-Take a peek and you'll be filling those cans yourself.

Jill didn't look too happy about that and just took me to a ball pit in her room with me while Olivia went back to painting. I could move some more, but still felt a little weak and the fear feeling was starting to come back and I tried get out of the ball pit, but I was picked up and held in front of Jill.

Jill-And where are you going? We didn't play any games yet.~

She stepped out and took me a table and pulled out 3 cups and a piece of candy.

Jill-Tell you what, if you win, you can go with no strings attached... If you lose however, you're going to do a little something at dinner.

(Y/N)-Wh-What if I say no?

She froze for a second before she gave me a creepy smile and tapped her finger slowly on the table. I was creeped out and when she put me on the other end of the table she put the cups down, but a piece of candy was under one.

Jill-Best 2 out of 3. When i'm done, you pick one. Simple.

She only switched the cups one time and I picked the middle and the candy was under that cup, so I got the first round. I just need one more, so I paid attention and then... she went really fast and even lifted the cups to put it under a new cup without stopping and I lost track right before she stopped.

Jill-Pick one.

(Y/N)-Um... middle again.

She lifted it to show it wasn't there and showed me it was under the cup on the left then she went again even faster this time until she stopped after 2 minutes and Olivia came over to pick me up and sit on my chair with me on her lap.

Olivia-I know where it is, but if I tell you, you'll be doing me a favor in the morning.~

(Y/N)-...

Jill-Go ahead... Pick one.~

(Y/N)-U-Um...

(Timeskip To Dinner)

(Jackie's POV)

We were all called to dinner and I was bringing my kidney box with me to eat while the others had their food I hated. I didn't get my turn with (Y/N) yet, so I was gonna get it at dinner most likely since Slenda wanted us to have a turn with him before bed. When I made it to the dinning room I was greeted by (Y/N) doing a little dance with Jill and he did a little twirl next to her and he looked so cute and funny as others were watching too.

<figure></figure>

Tami-I-I-I wanna d-d-dance wi-with him!

Jess-Fuck off, I didn't get a turn, yet!

Tami-Me neither!

Angel-Get in line!

Natelie-Same here!

Lulu-I would my turn.

Slenda-Now girls, all of those that didn't have a turn as of yet will get to hold and feed him as well as doing small things. Just keep it polite at the table.

She sounded so fancy and when the girls took their seats Slenda gave my to Tami first and she gave me a strong hug while bouncing me on her lap. When the food came out it looked delicious, but my eyes ripped away from it when I saw who or what was bringing it out.

<figure></figure>

There was 5 of them in the room and I held on to Tami tighter since they were scarier and this made her happy and the other girls were looking at us like I was a puppy or something.

???-*Hiss* *groan*... *growl*.

It was getting closer to us while looking at me before Tami grabbed her axe, but a tentacle snatched the monster up and even left a little blood behind before Slenda bring it to her and now I saw angry eyes forming under the skin on her head.

Slenda-That is "not" how you will behave around my son.

She threw it to the ground and used 3 other tentacles to stab it and before it could scream she covered its mouth before throwing it back through the door it came in.

Slenda-I guess you all get extra food tonight. Let this be a lesson though.

I tentacle came over to gently tickle under my chin and a bit of laughter slipped up before i tucked my chin in.

Slenda-You will not look at my baby in that way... Ever.

We all soon started eating and Tami didn't let me feed myself and mostly just played with me until Angel took me from her.

Tami-H-Hey!

Angel-If you won't let him eat then i'll feed him and you can play with him another time!

Tami-*Hmph*.

Angel made train noises and stuff like that and Lulu leaned over her chair to feed me some of her food and I would try to say no, but I don't think it was a good idea to risk getting them mad. Dinner tasted really good even if I didn't look at the food much since I couldn't look away from what made the girls creepy or the monsters that were still in here, but left and came back with dessert. This time I did see what they brought and it did look very good as Slenda took me and gave me to Jess.

<figure></figure>

Jess-Open and say ahhh for your favorite big sister.~

Natelie-Um, the fuck did you just say? He hasn't even gotten to know us much.

Jess-Yeah, because I have to take this from a walking clock copying my smile.

Natelie-At least I still have color and not burned.

Jess got angry until she fed me a bit of her pudding since I didn't have my own, but Natelie leaned over and gave me a piece of chocolate with whipped cream on it. That almost made it a battle to feed me the best. I tried to look away from them and saw the others were looking at us, but Jackie didn't have a pudding cup for some reason. She just got up, but Slenda noticed this.

Slenda-Jackie, didn't you get a turn with him, yet?

Jackie-I'll take my turn at breakfast in the morning. I just went through my last kidney and need to go find more... I'll be out late.

Slenda-Very well.

I wonder what Jackie meant by that before she left then Slenda clapped her hands.

Slenda-Now that you all had a fair shot to make a brief moment of bonding with him, he'll now choose who he shall sleep with. If he doesn't choose in the next minute, he'll just sleep with me... Who shall it be, sweetie?

All of the girls left in here looked at me and if I don't pick, i'll just go with Slenda either way...

(Y/N)'s mind-Who should I pick?