BTC: Chapter 11 (Posting Version) (Patreon)

-- CHAPTER 11: Naimh --

****

"Hey, Matty?" Belle called. "Can you get the fancy plates out?"

Glancing over my shoulder, I nodded to Belle, set down the romaine lettuce I’d been shredding for the salad, and went to the sink to wash my hands. Heading out to the dining room, I opened the china cabinet and pulled out the “fancy plates” as Belle put it, along with the matching serving platters, gravy boat, and crystal stemware. It was customary for us to use these only for special occasions, like tonight’s Thanksgiving Dinner.

I brought everything back into the kitchen for a quick rinse. Belle and I shared the space on autopilot, working in silence. Midway through rinsing, she bumped my hip with her elbow, and I automatically slid out of the way so she could clean her hands.

Mr. K poked his head into the kitchen and asked, “Anything I can do to help?”

“Nope,” I replied immediately without looking up while I hand-dried the china.

“We got it, Dad,” Belle added without looking up as she went back to the turkey. “Almost ready.”

Mr. K chuckled and returned to the living room. On his way, I heard him comment, “They’re so cute together.”

“Of course,” Mother replied. "They're a properly domesticated couple."

I tuned out the rest of the conversation and busied myself with everything else I needed to do for dinner. Mother was right: Belle and I were properly domesticated, and this was our third year handling Thanksgiving Dinner without parental support. Well, to be fair this was our third year handling it without Belle's dad's support. Mother had never really been involved, and she was the type that if you told her just once that you didn’t need her assistance, that was good enough for her.

Ten minutes later, I plopped the finished turkey onto the big serving platter, Belle went and told our parents to please have a seat at the table, and the two of us started ferrying out all the food.

Taking holiday meals together had become something of a tradition for our two families ever since Belle’s mom died. Mr. K and Mother were comfortable around each other, although it was clear there was no trace of chemistry between them. Tonight’s meal was much like any other: unhurried, unpretentious, and utterly mundane. Mother and Mr. K did most of the talking, as they were the ones who hadn’t seen much of each other for the past several months. And at the end of the evening, Mother and I walked back home.

As soon as we walked back inside our house, Mother turned to me with a gleam in her eye. “He has NO idea what you’re doing with his little girl, does he?”

I blinked in surprise, pausing halfway through the process of hanging my jacket on the coat rack. “Um, what?”

Mother just gave me a look. She knew I’d heard her.

“Uh… well…” I stammered before admitting, “I had been wondering if he’d started to suspect.”

Mother snorted and shook her head. “He doesn’t have a clue.”

“You can tell that?”

Mother rolled her eyes at me and put away her coat. With her back to me, she continued, postulating, “Perhaps he has a blind spot for you. You’re the son he never had, after all. You’re the golden child who can do no wrong in his eyes. And he still believes his daughter is the same innocent, adoring virgin she’s always been.” Mother glanced back at me. “For now.”

“For now?”

Mother turned to face me, took a deep breath, and gave me a look with genuine concern in her eyes. “Be careful, Matthew. Belle isn’t just any ordinary girl you can sleep with and abandon.”

I frowned. “I have no intention of--”

“I didn’t suggest you did,” Mother interrupted. “Just keep in mind that you don’t have the luxury of breaking up with her and never seeing her again. Belle’s father will find out eventually, one way or another. Once that happens, the dynamic of these little holiday dinners is going to change. Whether it changes for the better or worse depends on you.”

I blinked again. “That’s… kinda heavy…”

Mother’s smile was thin. “You’re an adult now. Get used to shouldering the weight.”

And then she headed upstairs.

****

Except for Belle, I didn’t see any of the BTC girls until Saturday. Thanksgiving was a family holiday, of course, and Black Friday had always been the busiest shopping day of the year.

To me, a Friday off from school suggested sleeping in until noon, not waking up before dawn in order to get in line at the nearest big box store to get doorbuster deals on the latest cameras, computers, and other electronic gadgets. Nor did it suggest heading straight to the mall to buy overpriced clothing at a huge discount to bring them down to only “kinda” overpriced clothing. But that’s me.

The girls on the other hand, were going to the mall in pairs. At least they never tried to drag me with them for Black Fridays, saying I’d just slow them down. And even after Wednesday’s little catastrophic drive back from San Francisco, nothing was going to get in the way of their shopping day.

Belle came over a little after 4pm after her shopping trip with Mari, wearing some of her new purchases. I was thankful she hadn’t arrived holding three or four shopping bags, expecting me to sit through a fashion show. I WAS happy to see her new lingerie, on the other hand. I was even happier to slowly peel her out of the brand-new lingerie, shove my head between her legs, and express my admiration by slithering my tongue up her slit. I ate her to two orgasms before crawling up her body, notching myself in her folds, and slowly pressing inside. Her soreness was pretty much gone by now, and I slow-dicked her to another blissful orgasm before pulling out and letting her swallow my load.

The second time, she let me fuck her from behind, and my little Annabelle waddled home with my cum squishing inside her cunt.

It had been the calm before the storm.

Saturday morning, the girls arrived.

****

We weren’t supposed to meet up on Saturday, at least not as a group of seven. The girls all had families and friends and people who expected them to spend quality time together on weekends, especially holiday weekends. But every single one of them showed up promptly by 10am, as had been agreed upon by the end of that fateful Wednesday afternoon drive.

We were supposed to have driven back to my house after visiting the city Wednesday afternoon. We were supposed to have changed into swimsuits, collected in the hot tub, and gotten a little frisky. At one point in Chinatown, Sam whispered into my ear about how she was going to get all the girls to take off their bikinis in the hot tub and start grinding on me until my balls were the size of grapefruits so I would have an extra big load when I finally gave Belle a facial.

But Wednesday didn’t turn out like that.

Belle came over early. Neither of us was horny, but it was nice to hold each other all the same. Mari and Alice arrived soon after, and then Naimh. And at 10:00am on the dot, Sam and Zofi rang the doorbell.

We gathered in front of the TV, as always. I sat in the corner for once, with Belle on the middle cushion and Mari next to her. Sam and Zofi were on the loveseat. Alice was in the armchair. And Naimh paced nervously back and forth behind her.

None of us knew quite how to start. Sam was the alpha, the one who always got the discussion going. But she stared down at her lap, holding Zofi’s hand between both of hers for reassurance. Belle was pretty quiet, too. She wasn’t on trial the way Sam was, since we still hadn’t told anybody we’d been having sex. But in the course of Wednesday afternoon’s little furball in the van, it had come out that Sam, Belle, and I had engaged in a threesome of sorts, which meant that Belle had prior knowledge of said de-virginization before Sam’s admission in the car. And of course, as party to the crime, I’d obviously had prior knowledge as well.

Naimh, unsurprisingly, broke the awkward tension. But the manner in which she spoke surprised us all. “I forgive you, Sam,” were the first words out of her mouth.

“What?” Sam asked in surprise.

Everyone else looked at each other in shock, and then at Naimh as she walked around the armchair and stood in front of the TV. “I know I was angrier than anyone on Wednesday. Gingers are known for their tempers, after all, and Irish gingers are even worse. But that was three days ago and I’ve had a lot of time to think since then.”

Naimh took a deep breath, closed her eyes, and gave Sam a sincere look. “You were my first friend when I came to the States. You welcomed me into this special club with the unfortunate name. You introduced me to my best friends, and you introduced me to him.” The redhead turned to look at me with a warm smile.

“I’ve asked myself several times what I would have done in your situation,” Naimh continued. “All dressed up with hair and makeup, feeling like a princess… Matty in a nice suit and dashing like a prince… Big empty house and no other girls to distract him…”

“You already said what you’d do,” Alice challenged. “In the van, you said the group meant more to you than sex.”

“I know I did. It’s really easy to promise that in a van coming home from a group trip,” Naimh told Alice before turning her attention to Sam. “I imagine it must’ve been a lot more difficult alone in a bedroom when the clothes are off and his face is in your crotch.”

Sam looked down and squeezed Zofi’s hand between hers. “You’re being very generous, Neevie.”

Naimh sighed. “I’m not happy about what happened, but I do forgive you. At the end of the day, I think ostracizing you over this would do more to break up the BTC than you having sex with him would. The club means more to me than having sex with Matty, and it certainly means a lot more to me than holding a grudge against Sam.”

“She betrayed the BTC,” Alice yelled angrily. “She’s the one who came up with The Rule in the first place, and SHE’S the one who violated it!”

Naimh shrugged and said, “I would be a hypocrite if I didn’t admit I was main one pointing out The Rule says we can’t ‘date’ him and says nothing about fucking him.”

“That’s not what The Rule means anymore, and you know it!” Alice seethed.

“I knew The Rule,” Sam spoke up. “And I know I violated it. I didn’t mean to. It was an emotional night and everything just sort of happened.”

Sam looked at me, and all of a sudden everyone else was looking at me, too. The details of that night hadn’t really been discussed on Wednesday, just the fact that she’d mounted herself on me before I’d realized what was going on. In this, Sam had taken full responsibility and the girls held me blameless, even when I pointed out I knew exactly what I was doing when Sam and I had a repeat on Monday with Belle watching. “I genuinely believe she didn’t mean for it to happen,” I stated sincerely. “I mean, she didn’t like… oops… accidentally fall and land on my dick. But… yeah… it was an emotional night.”

Everyone collectively pondered that.

“Can I say something?” Mari asked quietly. She’d been very quiet on Wednesday, not saying much if anything when all hell broke loose aside from some surprised squawking, and it was a little surprising to hear her speak up now. Everyone looked around for a second and gave her their full attention. “I forgive her, too. To be perfectly honest, I’d always assumed one of you would sleep with him eventually. How could it NOT happen? There are still, what, nine months until we go to college? No way was everyone going to limit themselves to blowjobs and eating pussy until then. You guys are all such vibrant and sexy young women. We could all see how much things were escalating. And Sam… well… you’ve always been our leader. It sorta even makes sense that you’d be his first. I kinda get the impression you’d have been really mad if someone else had him before you, like that thing with Holly. You’re… uh… competitive… that way.”

Sam turned pink in embarrassment, but she didn’t disagree.

“And even for me, once I realized it was going to happen eventually, I… uh… well…” Mari blushed and stared nervously into her own lap as her voice trailed off. Belle reached out to hold her best friend’s hand. And we all waited patiently for her to find her voice.

Mari shot an embarrassed look at me and went back to intensely scrutinizing her own lap. She paused, took a deep breath, and added, “Honestly… I… I mean I was hoping…” She stopped, took another deep breath, and finally looked over at me. “Will you take my virginity someday, Matty?”

The room went silent. Everyone suddenly stared at me.

“I… uh…” I took a deep breath of my own to collect myself before finishing rather formally, “I’d be honored.”

“Someday, not today,” Mari added quickly, before exhaling in a loud rush of released tension. “I mean, I’m totally not ready yet.”

I exhaled in relief too. “Uh, yeah. That’s… uh, no problem.”

Mari started crying then - not sad tears nor happy tears, really - more like tears released along with her tension. It was immediately obvious how much that admission had taken emotionally for Mari, and Belle slid over to hug her best friend. Even Alice, who was still upset, got out of the armchair to hug Mari from the other side. Naimh came over as well, and finally Sam and Zofi got up and reached in to rub a shoulder or arm or whatever they could reach. Lastly, I put my long arms around the group.

Eventually, though, the group hug disengaged. First I and then the girls backed off one at a time, like peeling layers of an onion, until only Belle and Mari remained. Mari was crying softly, and Belle was crying with her, and that’s when Belle admitted through her own tears, “I’ve been having sex with Matty all week.”

You could actually hear the air get sucked out of the room it happened so fast. Naimh was the first to regain her voice, squawking, “Wait, WHAT?”

Sam shot me a look right away, and I shrugged helplessly. She and Zofi were still kneeling on the floor just in front of Mari, and Zofi’s mouth gaped open in shock while she covered it with both hands, her eyes wide as saucers. Alice had returned to the armchair and now planted both forearms on her spread knees, hanging her head down and shaking it slowly. And Naimh stood up and frowned, furrowing her eyebrows while lost in thought.

Belle started unspooling the story, still crying but obviously needing to get this off her chest. She explained about me visiting on Sunday afternoon to tell her about my post-wedding encounter with Sam, getting so angry with me at first and then following me back to my house still yelling while her dad just smirked at us, and then ultimately seducing me. She then explained how painful losing her virginity felt the first time because she was in too much of a hurry and we didn’t prep her enough, but how the second time was so much better. And when she started explaining that she became so sore afterwards she could barely walk for a few days, Mari interrupted to exclaim, “I THOUGHT you were walking funny!”

The girls actually started laughing, even Alice, and for the first time I started to think everything just might turn out alright. And that’s when Naimh walked over, tapped my shoulder, and muttered brusquely, “Come on.”

I’d been smiling at Belle and Mari laughing together while wiping their tears, but now looked up at Naimh in surprise. “Huh?”

The gorgeous redhead looked at me patiently, giving me a few seconds to figure it out before she repeated, “Come on. It’s time.”

I blinked in surprise. “What, now?”

Naimh laughed lightly before giving me a deadly serious look. “I’ve already been waiting for months, and I’m not waiting a minute longer than I have to. COME ON.” Suiting action to her words, she grabbed my hand and physically pulled until I stood up.

I glanced back behind me while Naimh dragged me toward the stairs. I saw first Sam staring after us, and then my eyes met Belle’s a second later. Sam was grinning, but Belle actually looked a little jealous. Then again, I figured Belle merely wished she could come watch.

Feeling my hesitance, Naimh glanced over and found me gazing back at the others. She stopped tugging my hand, which made me look at her. And after pursing her lips, Naimh’s jaw set as she came to a decision and abruptly started dragging me back into the family room.

“Uh, are we not doing this?” I asked dumbfoundedly.

The gorgeous redhead shook her head, stating, “Changed my mind.”

I misunderstood her. I thought she meant she’d changed her mind about having sex with me, but she was in a different head-space than me. Naimh actually meant she’d changed her mind about the location, something I didn’t realize until she parked me back on the couch, knelt before me, and started tugging my pants off.

“Whoa, what?” I squawked in surprise once my pants and underwear hit the back of my knees. I wasn’t remotely hard, but Naimh was determined. “I thought you just said…”

She seemed to realize my confusion, flashed me a grin, and explained, “Oh, we’re still DOING this. We’re just doing it right here.”

Sam gawked at us, chirping, “After all that bitching about getting your own one-on-one?”

“I told you,” Naimh said while tugging down her own jeans, which took a little effort since they were tight enough to seem spray-painted onto her. I watched the way the redhead’s big tits wobbled in her t-shirt as she did so. “The BTC means more to me than sex. Being with my best friends means more to me than fucking him, which is why I’ve waited this long as it is.”

I’d been waiting a long time, too, and watching the most gorgeous thing I’d ever seen stripping herself down before me with the full knowledge of her intent to finally fuck me, I started getting hard despite myself. The sight of her neatly trimmed red beaver, proving the carpet matched the drapes, had me salivating, and Naimh giggled when she saw the direction my gaze.

“See something you like?”

I grinned and looked up at her pretty face. “Yeah… I still love your eyes.”

Naimh laughed and reached for the hem of her t-shirt. But she paused before removing it, instead reaching up behind her back and unclasping her bra. “I know you love my eyes, but I think there are two other things you’re dying to see right now.” With that, she wriggled and slipped her hands inside her sleeves to pull the strap off one shoulder and then the entire bra out through the opposite armhole. When she was done, she was still wearing the tight t-shirt, but now her erect nipples were making prominent dents in the cotton fabric.

I blinked and stared at those headlights, nodding, “You have my full attention.”

Now I’ve said before that Naimh was the most gorgeous thing I’d ever seen, but I don’t think I’ve spent nearly enough time waxing poetic about her incredible body. Zofi had the slender model’s build, and both Sam and Mari had more outrageous curves that simply screamed, ‘FUCK ME’! Naimh was somewhere in the middle, not quite as tall as Zofi and not quite as curvaceous as Sam or Mari. Instead, it seemed like she possessed the best features of all of them. Still tall and slender but packed with Double-D curves and a tight ass, Naimh was a copper-haired comic book heroine brought to life. Her emerald-green eyes were large and luminous. Her face was high-cheekboned perfection. Her fiery hair flowed in silky waves around her face. On a scale of 1 to 10, she was an 11, and I’d wanted to fuck the shit out of her from the moment I saw her.

I had that same look in my eyes today, and Naimh recognized it immediately. With a grin, the busty redhead pulled the hem of the t-shirt up to the lower edge of her tits, paused, and then slowly inched the fabric upward to reveal the curvature of her underboob. She stopped again just before revealing her nipples, wiggled her torso a bit to make those puppies dance, and laughed when I groaned in anticipation. I’d seen her tits before, obviously. I’d freaking hosed down her tits with my cum a few times by now. But no matter how many times I’d already seen her naked breasts in the past few weeks, a slow reveal like this had me enraptured like it was the very first time.

Naimh flashed her nipples for a split-second before covering them up again. I groaned in disappointment, and she stood there for a second smirking at me. “You first. Take off your shirt. I wanna see those pecs.”

I ripped my shirt off my head in a hurry, not wanting to delay Naimh’s titty drop any longer than I had to. She grinned, tucked her thumbs beneath the bunched-up fabric, and finally lifted the cotton away to let her juicy freckled Double-D melons plop down against her own chest and wobble like jello for a second. She raised the shirt up to her chin and jiggled her shoulders to set “the girls” in motion. It was a dance she’d done for me before. The difference back then was that the titty drop was itself the end goal, a tease in and of itself. Okay maybe that’s not true, because ever since Mari first let me suck on her boobs, Naimh was more than happy to let me do the same. But the point is: today I knew we would not be stopping at just the titty drop, or even stopping at me sucking on her nipples.

Today… this was merely foreplay on the way to actual sex, and she had my heart thudding inside my chest with anticipation.

Laughing, Naimh covered up her tits, making me frown and start audibly whining. Her laughter got louder and more musical, and she quickly did another titty drop and dance. This time, she finally ripped the t-shirt over her head, leaving her completely naked. And at long last, my arms were full of busty redhead as she straddled my lap and shoved her tongue into my mouth.

Naimh and I sucked each other’s faces while she wrapped her arms around my neck and grinded herself against my bare erection trapped between our two bellies. I didn’t even think about hesitating to grab her ass, reveling in the joy of implicit permission to do whatever the hell I wanted to her. Compressing her butt-flesh in my hands, I kneaded and squeezed and used the redhead’s ass to pull her crotch against my boner with even more pressure.

My butt-crack felt wet with moisture, and I realized Naimh was getting so aroused she was leaking pussy juice all over my shaft. She was as desperate to get me inside her as I was to get inside, and that realization hit me like a ton of bricks.

Here we were at the precipice… FINALLY… and I still couldn’t quite believe it. I’ve said before that I was absolutely smitten the first time I laid eyes on the Irish redhead, and I already waxed poetic about her a minute ago. But in plain simple fact, she was the most gorgeous thing I’d ever seen. Her large, emerald-green eyes were perfection. Her porcelain skin was dotted with adorable freckles that had instantly made me wonder just how far they went down. Her cheek structure, her pouty lips, that flaming red hair, her amazing rack, her tight waist, her boner-inducing hips, her drum-tight ass, her long lithe legs, I mean, I could go on for hours and hours about her physical attributes. She was a horny sexpot who never failed to get my engine running, instantly becoming my number one masturbation fantasy. And on top of all that, she was a really FUN person to be around, and yet as much fun as it was to hang out with her all the time, I often found myself regretting her membership in the BTC because it automatically made her off-limits as a potential girlfriend.

But none of that mattered right now. The lines had been crossed, the arguments for why Naimh and I shouldn’t do this wiped away. There were no longer any barriers keeping us apart, and all of a sudden I couldn’t wait to get inside her. So tearing my face away from hers, I gasped, “I need to fuck you NOW.”

Naimh’s emerald eyes glowed, her agreement obvious. She elevated herself on her knees, reached down between us, guided my cockhead into position, and paused to look around the room for the first time since she’d started taking off her bra. All eyes were on us, Belle and Mari on the couch to my right, Sam and Zofi on the loveseat to my left, and Alice standing behind Naimh. I bet from that angle, Alice would have a great view of my upright cock and balls between Naimh’s legs, a vertical column about to disappear.

Nobody said a word. Everyone stared with rapt attention. Naimh reached out with her left hand to Belle, who was the closest on that side. She also reached out to Sam, who was closest on her right. And thus holding hands with two of her friends, only then did Naimh let gravity take over as she sank ever so slowly around my cock, swallowing me whole in a single, steady descent.

I shivered and let my head loll over the backrest, my lower jaw quivering as the pleasure of FINALLY being inside Naimh radiated out from my very core. She let go of the others and collapsed against my chest, holding me close, and for about a minute, neither of us moved. We each savored this moment of utter and complete unification, our two bodies melded together as one for the first time ever. From then on it was only her and me, one-on-one the way she’d always wanted it.

She leaned in to kiss my neck, sucking hard enough to give me a hickey while I wrapped both arms around her body to hold her close. Those glorious tits were crushed into my chest, and suddenly seized with a desire to feel her nipples in my mouth, I sat up to make that wish a reality. I mashed her melons around my cheeks and suckled away like a starving infant, but only for a little while. Tilting my chin, I captured Naimh’s lips instead, and as our tongues came out to play, she started rising and falling in my lap.

She was a quiet lover at first, something I hadn’t expected. Naimh had always been the most brash and vocal flirt of the club, constantly pushing sexual boundaries and stretching the definition of The Rule to its limits. But she simply whimpered and moaned for several minutes as she rode me, adjusting her arms to hold me close, bracing her hands on the couch’s backrest for leverage to hump me harder, or cradling my head against her chest while I feasted on her tits.

We writhed together and moaned together, me using the springiness of the couch cushions to undulate my turgid tool in and out of her tight twat, she flexing her legs to hump herself up, down, and around to carve my cock against every corner of her cunt.

Naimh came without warning. She didn’t speed up or whimper that she was getting close. One moment she was humping me, the next her breath caught as she froze at full depth, her fingernails digging into the skin of my upper arms and her snatch spastically squeezing my surrounded shaft. She spoke for the first time, a breathless, “Oh, Matty!” And I cuddled her close all through her climax.

When she came down from that peak, she collapsed against my chest and gasped for air. I stroked her spine and gave her time to recover, my dick still hard and throbbing deep within her core. Eventually, she pulled back and stared at me with a look of deep-seated unconditional love, and I was a little bit shocked to see the intensity of her emotions. She had always been the flirty one, the overtly physical one. That she’d wanted to bang me forever was no secret, but I’d never suspected she harbored anything… emotional… for me. And yet there it was, plain as day on her face, the flirtatious façade masking her feelings no more.

Maybe it was just the head-rush of her orgasm, exquisite pleasure making nascent feelings momentarily stronger than really were.

Maybe they were real.

I didn’t know, but I found myself suddenly quite interested in finding out.

“That was amazing,” Mari breathed quietly, her voice suddenly breaking the spell. For the last ten minutes or so, the world around Naimh and me had ceased to exist. But with a sudden pop, the bubble burst and we both became only too aware of our audience.

I glanced first to my right and saw Mari clamping her hands over her mouth, wide-eyed and looking contrite for speaking aloud. Belle was silent, but her mouth was open in a soft pant, and I could see her hand still inside her skirt where she’d obviously been masturbating while watching us fuck only a few feet away.

It occurred to me then that this was more than likely the first time any of the BTC, save Belle, had ever seen two other people have sex with their own eyes. Alice now sat on the armrest just behind Mari, her eyes glazed over and her chest heaving in obvious arousal. I turned to look the other way and saw that Sam and Zofi were still in the loveseat, only Zofi was now more or less seated in Sam’s lap and was panting hard as well. Their hands at the moment were in innocent enough positions, but I got the distinct impression they’d been pawing at each other while witnessing their friends engage in a live sex act before their very eyes.

But despite the interruption, I was determined to focus on the lover in my lap. I willed myself to ignore the presence of the others and tilted Naimh’s chin so I could express my adoration for her with my lips. She moaned happily into my kiss and wrapped both arms around my neck. And after we broke for air, she whispered softly. “That was nice, but I want you to FUCK me now, hmm?”

Her emerald eyes sparkled, and with a grin I suddenly rolled us over to the right. Belle squealed and backed up as we invaded her space, but I hooked my arm behind Naimh’s lower back and physically hauled her back towards me and parked her butt right at the front edge of the couch cushion. My cock became disengaged from her cunt in the process, but after draping her legs over each of my forearms, I swiftly notched myself at her splayed-open pink heaven’s gate and slammed my way back inside.

The first time, Naimh and I had rather intimately made love.

This time, I did exactly what she’d asked: I FUCKED her. And we both got a lot more vocal in the process.

“Ohhh! Myyyy! Gawwwwwd!” became a familiar refrain.

“Fuckme! Fuckme! Fuckme!” was pretty common, if obvious.

“I love this! I love you!!!” took me a little by surprise.

After a few minutes, Naimh raised her legs higher and hooked them over my shoulders, a position that let me drive myself even deeper down to her core with heaving, full-length lunges. A little later, she crossed them around my waist and clutched me close, forcing me to press my pelvis against her clit and sort of grind away at her. The Irish redhead kept screaming, and it seemed to me that the longer we went, the thicker her Irish brogue became. By the end of it, I couldn’t understand a word she was saying, but the way her fingernails clawed at my back and her heels drummed against my ass told me all I really need to know anyway.

Well, not everything.

Naimh clenched up and came once more, but afterward I started to feel the telltale tingle in my balls announcing my own imminent eruption. Mother’s voice asking, ‘Are you using protection?’ rang off inside my head. And grunting from the strain, I leaned down and asked, “Are you on the pill?”

Naimh’s eyes glittered as she realized I was close to cumming deep inside her. She nodded and replied, her voice thick with emotion, “I nev’ra stop’d tak’n ‘em. I’knew yu’n’I were gon’ do this one day, and I dinna wan’ be cau’ unp’pared.”

Gasping with relief, I put the rest of my energy into pounding the hell out of her. Naimh went silent then, having become quite coolly observational instead of delirious with pleasure. I mean, she still whimpered and moaned from the sensations my pistoning prick sent throughout her nervous system, but she studied my face intensely, watching my expressions as I got closer and closer to climax. She stroked my cheek, cooed at me encouragingly, and when my neck muscles started to tense, she kissed my nose and urged, “Cum in me. Fill me up with your seed. I’ve been dreaming about feeling your warm sperm flowing into my willing body. I’ve wanted it deep inside me from the moment I met you. Cum in me, Matty. Cum in meeeeeee!!!”

Naimh’s last word stretched out into a scream as I slammed in one last time and held myself there, my cock belching out great globs of cream into her welcoming honeypot. She tightened her ankles behind my butt, clutching me with all four limbs while I gasped her name, “Neeeeeevvviiiiieeee!” And I shuddered in her warm embrace all throughout the rest of my ejaculation, until finally I could fire away no more.

The room was silent save for the panting breath of seven people in the aftermath of one of the most erotic experiences of their lives. I pressed the crown of my head against the backrest just over Naimh’s left shoulder. She still cuddled me close, murmuring endearments into my ear like, “Fuckin’ incredible, Matty. I’ve never felt like that before. You fulfilled all my dreams and expectations. I mean, I knew we’d be great together, but that was even better than I’d hoped for.”

You know, things that made me feel REALLY good and proud of myself.

Of the others, Mari was the first to speak again, “That was even more amazing.”

Sam was out of breath too, but she asked, “Hey Belle… is THAT what it looked like when Matty was fucking me?”

Belle giggled and replied, “Yeah, pretty much.”

“Just… wowww…” Sam breathed.

The sound of Sam’s and Belle’s voices discussing Monday evening’s tryst stirred me from my stupor, and fully aware of the lake of Matty-cum that must be swimming inside Naimh’s pussy at this moment, I was seized by a sudden impulse. Picking my head up, I gave Naimh a quick peck on the lips, grinned, and told her, “Don’t go anywhere.”

The redhead frowned at me. “Huh? Where would I go?”

I kissed her again and slowly drew my hips back, my cock still hard enough that Naimh’s pussy lips clung to it as if they didn’t want to let go. But eventually I managed to pull completely out and squat down two feet away from the couch, staring back at Naimh’s red-worn pussy still spread open obscenely wide.

I looked over, got Belle’s attention, and head nodded toward the redhead. “Are you thinking what I’m thinking?”

At first, Belle frowned and looked confused, but a moment later the first dollop of cream oozed out of Naimh’s slit, and before I even blinked Belle dove headfirst between the Irish girl’s spread thighs.

“Belle! What are--? OhmiGAWD!” Naimh squealed in shock as the petite strawberry-blonde started slurping scraps of semen from her sodden snatch.

Mari squealed even louder, and Alice flat out SHRIEKED.

Alice’s ear-splitting exclamation is what actually got Belle to pull her head out and gawk wide-eyed at her friends, panic setting in as she realized what she’d just gotten caught doing. But a second later, Naimh grabbed the back of Belle’s head and shoved it right back into her crotch, yelping, “Don’t STOP!”

So Belle went back to eating, Naimh started creaming, and by the time the redhead drummed her heels against Belle’s back during a screaming orgasm, I was rock hard and ready to go again.

So I sidled up behind Belle’s waving butt, raised her skirt, and pulled the crotch of her panties aside. She only flinched once in surprise at the unexpected touch. But once the horny pixie realized what was going on, she put her face back down into Naimh’s pussy, raised one knee, and planted her foot to really spread herself open wide while I put my cockhead into position, waggling her tushie invitingly.

And then everyone got to see their SECOND live sex act of the morning.

****

“Penny for your thoughts?” Belle asked softly into my ear.

“Hmm?” I asked distractedly, my gaze across the circular hot tub at the several pairs of naked breasts bobbing up and down like corks on the surface of the bubbling water. None of the girls had brought swimsuits, you see. They’d arrived expecting a heavy discussion, not a trip to the hot tub. But after this morning’s activities, everyone was in a rather… unique… mood. And when Naimh suggested we all just skinny dip, she’d been met with a chorus of agreement.

“Nevermind,” Belle laughed. “I don’t need to ask to know what you’re thinking.”

I shrugged and went back to ogling. Because well… tits. The knowledge that this was the first time in my life I’d ever sat in a tub with six COMPLETELY NAKED girls fully occupied my mind, and I intended to enjoy every second of it before somebody woke me up from this amazing dream.

“So…” Belle leaned in close to my left, grinning lasciviously, and whispered so softly that no one else could hear, “Which one are you gonna tap next?”

I smirked at her and whispered right back. “Planning which pussy you’re gonna suck my cream out of next?”

Belle giggled. “Something like that.”

“Something like what?” Mari asked from the other side of Belle.

Feeling in a jovial mood, I went ahead and asked Mari, “Did you ever realize your best friend was inclined to eat out other girls?”

Mari’s eyes flew open WIDE, and she actually retracted from Belle a bit. “Uh… well…”

“Please, don’t freak out,” Belle implored, suddenly looking quite scared of losing her best friend. “That was only the second time I did it. I… uh… I mean, I never thought of myself as gay before, and it wasn’t planned. So I don’t want you thinking I’ve been secretly lusting after you for years or anything like that.”

Mari blushed and held up her hand. “Relax, B. I wasn’t… I mean, okay, maybe I was a little freaked out. But not in a bad way. I was just surprised, that’s all.”

Naimh was on the right side of me and had heard that part of the conversation. “Second time?” she put two and two together and shot a look over at the remaining girls. “Sam! Did Belle go down on you?”

To her credit, Sam didn’t look embarrassed in the least as she grinned and replied, “Yes she did. Went after Matty’s creampie. Surprised me with her enthusiasm, too.” The blonde fixed me with an amused look. “Your little Annabelle is quite the cumslut, slurping it out of other girl’s pussies.”

“I’m only a slut for Matty’s cum,” Belle said defensively. “Let’s make that absolutely clear. Besides, I’m betting I’m not the ONLY one in this group who’s been eating pussy.”

“Guilty!” I announced, raising my hand.

“NOT who I was talking about,” Belle admonished, fixing Sam with a look.

With a smirk, the blonde stared pointedly up and to the left, putting on airs as she stated in a sing-song voice, “I’m sure I don’t know what you’re talking about.”

“Guilty!” Zofi announced, grabbing Sam’s wrist and raising her best friend’s hand, along with her own.

“We figured,” Alice drawled.

Zofi and Sam giggled.

Zofi leaned forward. “If you’re interested in refining your technique, Belle, I’d be happy to give you some pointers.”

Belle turned crimson and sank down a little beneath the bubbles. “I’ll, uh, keep that in mind.”

“Don’t tease her,” Mari challenged. “You two may be perfectly comfortable messing around with other girls, but Belle’s still figuring that part of herself out, okay?”

Sam and Zofi looked at each other for a second, and Zofi gave Belle an apologetic look. “I’m sorry, but I wasn’t teasing,” she said sincerely. “We’re friends, all of the BTC, and while I’ll admit to being eager to get your panties off, I don’t ever mean to pressure you. If you’re interested, I’d be happy to teach you. If not, no big deal.”

“Zofi’s good,” Naimh added helpfully. “Really good.”

Alice slapped Naimh’s upper arm. “You never told me you were messing around with them!”

Naimh winced. “You didn’t seem interested in girl-on-girl stuff. I didn’t want to scare you.”

Alice rolled her eyes. “Explains a lot, though. I was wondering why you didn’t freak out when Belle started going down on you.”

“Holy crap!” I sat up straight and looked at Belle. “I just realized. THAT was our first proper threesome!”

Belle mused on that and chuckled.

“Wait,” Sam frowned. “I thought -I- was your first threesome.”

Belle shrugged. “Matty’s splitting hairs. He said that he fucked you, and then I went down on you, but at no point were the three of us physically connected.”

Zofi frowned at me. “What about that time when I sat on your face while Neevie gave you her first blowjob? Or any of the other dozens of times you were messing around with one girl while another was messing around with your dick?”

Belle explained again, “He said he wasn’t actually fucking anyone, so all those times were daisy-chains and not ‘proper’ threesomes.” Belle held her hands up out of the water to do the air quotes.

“Makes sense to me,” Naimh grinned. “I get to say I was part of Matty’s first threesome!”

“Well I wanna be part of Matty’s NEXT ‘proper’ threesome,” Sam announced, elevating herself up from the hot tub and spreading her arms out to the sides on the deck, a position which put her huge tits on full display. “I've spent the last three days in a full-blown panic that I’d never get to be with him again, and lemme tell you, once you’ve had that bad boy inside you, you won’t be able to LIVE with yourself never having it again.”

“Agreed!” Naimh announced while raising her right hand.

“Agreed!” Belle called a second later, also raising her hand.

I frowned and said, “Hey, roll it back a notch. We’ve talked before about not putting pressure on the other girls.” I looked to the left at Mari and to the right at Alice, both of whom wearing nervous expressions. Zofi, on the other hand, looked perfectly comfortable, although I couldn’t tell whether that was because she already planned on having sex with me as well or simply didn’t feel pressured to do so.

Mari spoke up, saying, “It’s alright, Matty. The girls expressing how they had such a good time is just that – expressing themselves. I don’t feel pressured to put out just to keep up with them. It just reassures me I made the right decision when I decided to save myself for you. Uh, not that I’m gonna come crawling into your bed right away or anything. I… uh… I’m not…”

“You don’t have to say more,” I told her reassuringly. “I won’t ever expect you to do anything you’re not ready to do.”

Mari looked worried for a second. “But you WILL do it with me when I AM ready, right?”

I blinked twice and looked around at the other girls, suddenly worried I was going to get jealous looks from the ones I’d already slept with. But Sam, Naimh, and Belle were just smirking at my discomfort. On sudden impulse, I reached out and drew Mari into my lap, brushed her hair back from her face and leaned in to give her a tender kiss. Our lips rubbed together for only a few seconds, and as I pulled back she felt my erection trapped between us and grinded herself down against it.

I grinned and nuzzled her nose. “Whenever you’re ready, I will be too.”

Mari gave me a relieved smile. “Thank you. I’m glad.” She then blushed while sliding back into her own seat, and around us Sam, Belle, and Naimh started hooting and cheering.

I leaned back to allow myself a moment of contentment as my three lovers enthusiastically encouraged their virginal friend to join them, when out of the corner of my eye I saw my best friend’s hand come down to slap the surface of the water, splashing a surprised Zofi. We all turned to Alice, her face a mutinous mask of hurt and angry emotions.

“Well I’m glad everyone’s singing Matty’s praises and you’re now quite literally queueing up to be his next conquest,” Alice bit out through frustrated tears as she elevated herself out of the tub and sat down on the deck. Water streamed down off her naked body, cascading like waterfalls over her exposed naked breasts. Shaking her head and frowning at Mari, she continued, “I thought at least ONE other girl here had enough sense to realize we’re opening a can of worms and this whole thing is gonna turn out to be a trainwreck that destroys everything we’ve built together. But I guess it’s just me. Have fun being Matty’s Harem, everyone. I think it’s time I went home.”

“Alice!” Naimh called out in alarm as the Korean girl spun around, got up, and marched back into the house.

Heaven help me, I couldn’t stop myself from ogling Alice’s puffy pink pussy from behind when she’d bent over, but I quickly brushed that idea away and called after my grade school buddy, “Alice! Come on! We didn’t--”

Naimh was already getting out of the tub as well, and I momentarily caught myself ogling HER gorgeous figure with water running in rivers down all of her curves. Only after she was out did I finally haul myself out, grab a towel, and follow after.

This was NOT good.

****

Alice was crying in the armchair when I walked in, wrapped in a towel but still pretty wet. Naimh was kneeling on the floor in front of her, clutching another towel around her midsection but the back had come loose and the terrycloth draped to either side of her, leaving her completely exposed from behind. But this wasn’t a moment to get sidetracked.

The girls took one look at me as I came in, and Alice immediately held up a hand, saying, “Go away, Matty.”

“Please,” I said gently, holding up both hands. “I’m not here to make you feel worse, but I DO want to do whatever I can to make things better.”

Alice clenched her jaw and looked up at the ceiling for a moment. “I should be really mad at both of you for crossing the line and screwing right here on the couch. YOU, I get it.” She pointed an accusatory finger straight at me. “You’ve spent years gleefully accepting whatever we girls would let you have. It’s never been a question of whether or not you’d say yes if one of us wanted to fuck you. We’ve always known the answer.”

I didn’t really know what to say to that, so I stayed silent. But I did at least approach and sit down on the couch cushion closest to her.

Alice turned her ire to Naimh. “YOU, on the other hand. You KNEW I didn’t want the group crossing this line.”

“I know, but that line has already BEEN crossed,” Naimh argued.

“That doesn’t make it right! You were supposed to be on my side. But what did YOU do when you found out Sam and Belle seduced him behind our backs? You immediately forgave them so you could finally fuck him on the spot! What the fuck, Neevie? Let Sam and Belle be the skanks that betrayed the BTC. Not you too!”

“I forgave them because they’re our friends.”

“They’re bitches is what they are. And I can’t believe you’re defending them! How the fuck does Sam ALWAYS get her fucking way even when she’s quite literally the fucking bitch that stabbed us all in the back?!? And Belle too!”

Naimh frowned. “Do you really think they’re skanks and bitches just for giving into their feelings for him? Belle’s loved Matty for YEARS. And Sam… well… I think Sam’s just possessive. That thing with Holly really threw her for a loop, and she wanted to mark her territory or something. As for me… you KNOW how long I’ve wanted him.”

Alice’s shoulders slumped in resignation as the fight went out of her. “I know. I get it. I can’t ask any of you to stop now that you’ve already started. That’s why I should be the one to leave the BTC.”

“Don’t say that.”

“Isn’t it obvious? I’m the only one who DOESN’T want him! I knew Zofi would follow Sam’s lead, but I at least thought I could trust Mari would keep her panties on. Now she’s said flat out she’s gonna put out for him as soon as she’s ready and I can’t be the only one in the club who’s not on board with this brave new Matty-boning paradigm. It would just be WAY too weird, knowing the five of you are all… I just…” Alice sighed and looked straight at me. “I thought we were fine being buddies. We’ve been so good as buddies since seventh grade. Even after all the teasing and messing around and… shit… letting you eat my pussy… I thought we could at least stay buddies until the end of high school, you know? But now that you’ve started fucking the others, it’s only a matter of time until everybody starts expecting the same of me, and I wouldn’t be able to deal with that kind of obligation.”

I shook my head. “I would never obligate you to--”

“Oh, shut the fuck up, dude,” she cut me off. “Everybody knows you’d never force anyone to blah-blah-blah or obligate them to blah-blah-blah. That’s not the fucking point. It’s never been about YOU - this is entirely about THEM - and I don’t fit in anymore. I’m not sure I ever did. I just watched my two best friends fucking each other – and that doesn’t even mention Belle sucking a creampie out of you right after – and it’s freaking me out because I am NOT ready for this. This isn’t what I signed up for. I mean seriously, has EVERYONE been building and building and building to this point for the last few years? Was I was the only one stupid enough to believe the lie that we were keeping you around as the safe guy we could experiment on?”

“It wasn’t a lie,” Naimh stated. “I knew what I was getting into when I joined, and I knew full well Matty was off-limits. That didn’t stop me from wanting him, because nobody can really control their feelings, but I had accepted that it would never really happen. Matty was a rare and precious resource, for all of us. Sam wanted to protect that, and her heart was in the right place when she made The Rule. I genuinely believe she never intended to sleep with him that night. I’m telling you sincerely that -I-didn’t come here this morning planning to have sex with him, either. These things just sort of happened.”

“Yeah, these things just sort of happened, and now Matty’s Harem has been born. I suppose that’s no worse a title than The Big Tits Club.” With a scowl, Alice started hunting around for her clothes.

“Please don’t leave,” Naimh implored. “We can work this out.”

“There’s nothing to work out. It’s okay, Neevie. I’m happy for you, even if it doesn’t seem that way right now. Because I know how you REALLY feel about him. I know how long you’ve wanted him, and now you finally get to have him. Enjoy yourself. Enjoy HIM. I want you to. It’s just that can’t stand around watching you and everyone else fucking him when that’s not something I want for myself, that’s all.”

“Alice…” Neevie turned to me with a helpless expression on her face, plainly asking for help.

“Alice, please,” I began. “I don’t want to lose you.”

“It’s okay, Matty.” My friend since fourth grade gave me a sad look. I wasn’t even tempted to ogle her as she shrugged into her bra and started pulling on her shirt. “I’ll always be grateful you were the one guy who could let me be me. Thank you for that.”

“Then stay and let me let you be you. NOBODY in the BTC is going to stop you from being you. You’re my buddy, and you’re their friend. Yes, some of them have started having sex with me, and it looks like they intend to continue. But that’s between me and them. It doesn’t have to change your relationship with any of us.”

“Everything already HAS changed. Sex changes everything, don’t you get it? Half an hour ago, Neevie asked everyone if they wanted to go skinny-dipping. Everyone ELSE eagerly said yes, and nobody paid any attention to me frowning and shaking my head no. Did I want to strip down naked and go out to the hot tub? No, I didn’t, but I felt like I had to go along. Right before that, everyone ELSE eagerly agreed that sex was now on the menu! And nobody paid any attention to me still being angry at Sam for betraying the BTC in the first place! I’m already the odd girl out, so I’m simply removing myself from the equation.”

By now, Alice was fully dressed, and right as she said the word “removing” she started walking towards the front door. Naimh and I both followed after, still clad in nothing but our towels.

Naimh suddenly changed tactics, barking angrily, “Don’t you DARE walk out on us, Alice! Come on! I thought we were friends!”

Alice stopped for a moment and turned around to face us. “We were. You two were my BEST friends, but maybe we’re not meant to be anymore. Romantic couples break up and go their separate ways when they realize they’re not compatible anymore, and friends stay together because of common interests. For us, Matty, it was video games, comics, CCGs, and talking Sci-Fi. Neevie, it was art and comics and just finding a great girlfriend since the others were already paired off. And even though you and I were always at opposite ends of the spectrum when it came to sex stuff, I never once doubted that you cared about how this shit would affect me.”

“I did. I do,” Naimh said emphatically.

Alice shook her head. “But now you’re fucking him, and I’m not. We’re not compatible, and our interests aren’t in common anymore. Goodbye, Neevie. Goodbye, Matty.”

“Alice--” we both called at the same time.

But Alice didn’t turn around. She opened the door, walked away, and didn’t come back.