Home Artists Posts Import Register

Content

Most of you are likely familiar with the Skandies, but for those just tuning in: This is an annual year-end survey I've been conducting since 1995. Roughly 30 cinephiles take part—some of them professional critics, most of them not. The August Voting Body (AVB), as we call it, mostly formed on a Usenet movie chatgroup in the mid-to-late '90s. It's heavily male, and in fact this year is 100% male, as all three of the women currently on the roster abstained for various reasons. Rather than announce the results all at once, I draw the thing out for three freakin' weeks, revealing the top 20 in each category one day at a time, starting with everything that placed 20th. (That's what you'll find below.) Eventually the complete results and all ballots will be available at the not-terribly-official Skandies website, where you can currently find results from all previous years. Any questions, ask away in the comments. Away we go...

(The parenthetical numbers are points/votes. I stole the Pazz & Jop rules: 100 points for each category, maximum of 30 and minimum of 5.)

Picture: Bisbee '17 (53/5)
Director: Tamara Jenkins, Private Life (49/5)
Actress: Jeanne Balibar, Barbara (40/2)
Actor: Viggo Mortensen, Green Book (47/5)
S. Actor: Mark Rylance, Ready Player One (38/3)
S. Actress (tie for #19): Isabelle Huppert, Claire's Camera (36/4)
S. Actress (tie for #19): Alia Shawkat, Blaze (36/4)
Screenplay: Barry Jenkins, If Beale Street Could Talk (39/6)
Scene: The big corporate presentation, Dim the Fluorescents (35/3)

[Click the link to watch the scene, assuming YouTube hasn't killed it. Note: It's the end of the movie, and probably incomprehensible out of context.]

HISTORY:

Jenkins did not place for Slums of Beverly Hills or The Savages.

It took four years after his death, but Huppert has now tied Philip Seymour Hoffman's record for most career appearances in the top 20, with 15. (Hoffman remains in first place for the moment, however, because I break ties by average placement—he's tended to finish just a little bit higher, overall. Both have won outright: Hoffman for The Master, Huppert for Elle.) Here's her complete rundown (the lowercase s = supporting):

1. Elle

2. The Piano Teacher

2s. 8 Women

4. Gabrielle

8. Abuse of Weakness

8. The School of Flesh

8. Things to Come

12. White Material

13s. I ❤️ Huckabees

13s. Amour

15. La Cérémonie

17. Time of the Wolf

17. In Another Country

19. Home

20s. Claire's Camera

Mortensen, who I really did not expect to see here but okay, has placed four times previously (mostly in Cronenberg films), for A History of Violence (#2, 2005), Eastern Promises (#5, 2007), A Dangerous Method (#7s, 2011), and Jauja (#19, 2015). Balibar makes her first appearance in a decade (and her first in a film not directed by Rivette); she previously placed 18th for Va Savoir (2001) and 8th for The Duchess of Langeais (2008). Rylance, who I think may hold the record for longest gap between appearances—he placed 11th for Angels and Insects in 1996, then didn't show up again until landing at #3 in Supporting for Bridge of Spies in 2015—likewise gets his third nod. Shawkat is new. (And there's actually a third actor tied for #19—I'm arbitrarily saving the first name alphabetically for tomorrow's post.) 

Jenkins' screenplay for Moonlight placed 12th.

Files

Comments

Anonymous

This is the bittersweet part of the Skandies rollout, where I’m glad other voters helped someone get into the top 20, but then I’m like “only #20?!” Come on guys Tamara Jenkins... she directed the ever loving shit out of PRIVATE LIFE and just because it wasn’t the Most Directing doesn’t mean it wasn’t the best. Only 5 of us found room for her in the top 10? Sigh.

Anonymous

My first thought was "Barry Jenkins wrote Slums of Beverly Hills?!"

gemko

Ha! I didn’t even notice that two different Jenkinses placed 20th in Director and Screenplay. Think I’ll leave it confusing.

Anonymous

I look upon today's initial results with an indescribable sense of accomplishment.

gemko

Balibar in particular is the only top 20 finish this year that made it on just two votes. (Mostly because Actress was a bloodbath this year and all the points are up top.)

Anonymous

And now for my annual prediction of the Skandies Top 19: 1. Burning 2. First Reformed 3. Support the Girls 4. Roma 5. The Favourite 6. Leave No Trace 7. The Ballad of Buster Scruggs 8. Western 9. Let the Corpses Tan 10. You Were Never Really Here 11. If Beale Street Could Talk 12. 24 Frames 13. Private Life 14. Cold War 15. Zama 16. BlackKklansman 17. The Death of Stalin 18. The House That Jack Built 19. Paddington 2 And if any of these end up not making the cut here is what I think are the most likely candidates to take their place: Shoplifters, Jeannette: The Childhood of Joan of Arc, The Day After, Madeline's Madeline, Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse, Sorry to Bother You, Annihilation, Mission: Impossible - Fallout.

Anonymous

Glad to see Rylance here, I couldn't stand the movie but I thought his, Cooke and Mendelsohn's performances were its one saving grace.

gemko

You have truly covered all your bases this year. Eight alternates! Someone *really* doesn’t want to have missed anything (for some reason).

Anonymous

The love just seemed to be really spread out this year!

Anonymous

Hooray, Skandies season kicks off with a rocket for Shawkat, declares that Huppert is su-per, gives rankin's to two Jenkins.

Anonymous

Going to retire MuseSwami, as I have little sense where the AVB is (or even who's still in it) these days. And it's particularly difficult to forecast this year's results since there's little consensus even among the larger pool of critics (<i>First Reformed</i> won the MD'A-organized VV poll, <i>Roma</i> took most of the critics' awards, <i>Zama</i> topped the Film Comment poll). I guess my sense is that <i>Roma</i> will finish in the top 3 here and that <i>Zama</i> will place higher than 15.

Anonymous

I appreciate the ❤️ in Huckabees, above. Looking forward to the rest of the countdown!