Multiversal Cheaters, Hotwives and Cuckolds - Chapter 06 (Patreon)

As thanks for supporting me, enjoy this Christmas-y bonus chapter this week. It’s honestly one of my favourites for a while - I hope you enjoy.

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays.

Thanks again for your support.

Chapter 6: Getting his Girl a Bull for Christmas

Fandom: Harry Potter

Tags: Stripping, Sharing, Threesome, Penis Size Comparison, Teasing, Bull, DP, Cuckolding, Denial, Loving relationship, Slight SPH

*Hogwarts starts at aged 18 after the students get a full, normal education*

**I was watching clips of Critical Role and was kind of inspired to write this chapter after hearing Marisha Ray speaking in a British accent. If you care about such things, I have her in mind when writing this Lily**

James poured three glasses of firewhiskey, making sure to dilute Lily’s with pixie syrup to both reduce its kick and make it sweeter - just the way she liked it.

It was Christmas Eve and Hogwarts was freezing, the castle mostly empty. A large majority of the students were off spending the holidays with their families, while the rest partied in Hogsmeade. Moony was a part of the former group, while Wormtail, to their collective shock, had scored a date and was no doubt living it up in the nearby town.

Lily’s sister was getting married and her parents were busy organising her January wedding while his parents were on a skiing holiday in the Alps. He and Padfoot usually just spent the holidays at his parents’ place, but knowing Lily would be here all alone, they’d opted to stay with her.

Turning, he smiled at seeing his girlfriend looking at her hand with frustration while Padfoot grinned cheekily at her. After they’d lit the fire and made themselves comfortable, they’d decided to play poker using a packet of Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans that Lily had received as a gag gift from a friend.

Lily was dressed in a simple, knit Christmas sweater over gloriously tight leggings and thick, woollen socks. It had been love at first sight for James when he’d first laid eyes on the fiery redhead, and he'd turned his charm up to twelve until she’d finally agreed to go on a date with him in their first year.

They'd been together ever since.

‘Cheers mate,’ Sirius thanked him, taking his glass of Firewhiskey with a nod as they both watched Lily squirm with mirth. Sirius was dressed in skinny jeans and an unbuttoned maroon shirt over a black tank top - he'd tossed his waistcoat into the large bundle of clothes by his bed and made himself comfortable when he realised they'd instead be having a quiet night in instead of joining everyone in Hogsmeade.

‘The rules are utter nonsense!’ Lily whined piteously, eyeing the pile of beans with distaste and trepidation. ‘The rules are incentivising me to fold!’

They were all sprawled out on James’ bed while they played, the rules relatively simple. The sweets were used as currency and forfeit both, with folding early incurring the punishment of needing to eat a bean at random while losing in a head-to-head requiring the losers eat two.

Sirius smirked. ‘Only if you’re too chicken Evans.’

Her beautiful, green eyes snapped up to Padfoots and narrowed in annoyance.

Merlin, she’s so beautiful when she’s angry.

‘Do you take me for a child?’

Sirius’ smirk only deepened. ‘Bok bok.’

‘Ugh, whatever. Straight, nine-high.’

If Padfoot smirked any wider, James was worried his face would split in two. ‘Jack high,’ he announced in a sing-song tone, laying his ten and jack out for Lily to see and rage at.

James might have coached Lily a little - both he and Padfoot being notorious card sharks and experienced at poker - but honestly, he was enjoying watching Lily eat one bean after another.

His girlfriend’s face flushed in anger before she took a calming breath and turned to him, brushing her fine, coppery locks out of her face. ‘Do you have the bucket?’

James grinned cheekily and, securing Lily’s drink in the nook between his crossed legs, he reached down and pulled out a pristine, steel bucket from under his bed.

It hadn’t always been pristine, to be fair. They’d been playing for a while, after all.

Thank Merlin for Magic…

With a face scrunched up in disgust and trepidation, she picked a sweet at random from the pot and popped it in her mouth, preemptively wincing as she expected the worst. When Lily sighed in relief, Sirius booed and James chuckled.

Opening her beautiful emerald eyes, she smiled at him, the expression making him want to cover her face in kisses. ‘Cinamon.’

‘Booooring,’ Padfoot exclaimed, dodging the pillow Lily chucked in his direction with a loud guffaw. Perhaps on a high from experiencing one of her favourite flavours of tea, Lily popped the next one in her mouth without the slightest bit of hesitation.

A decision she quickly came to regret.

Padfoot started rolling around with laughter as Lily’s face turned noticeably green and she snatched the bucket he helpfully held out for her.

‘Oh why?!’ she wailed around retches and dry heaves. ‘Why does it taste like a broken loo smells?!’

He and Padfoot looked at each other and answered in unison. ‘Sewage.’

The confirmation only intensified the power of her retching.

After calming down, her face scrunched up in disgust and looking pained, James finally handed her her drink and she greedily snatched it up, tilted her head back and emptied half the glass in one big gulp. Smacking her lips afterwards, she sent him a loving smile and kissed him on the cheek.

‘Thanks dear, I really needed that.’

‘Ugh, I think I’m gonna hurl now.’

‘Oh shove off, Sirius,’ Lily snapped back in annoyance as she took another sip, hoping to expel the foul taste from her mouth with the powerfully sweet and spicy cocktail.

‘He's just sore that his last date was a disaster,’ James joked, sending his girlfriend a conspiratorial wink as she giggled. Lily wasn’t usually one for giggling, but that often changed after she’d had a few. He’d need to make sure any more drinks were alcohol-free until she sobered up.

Padfoot scoffed. ‘Leave it out mate, I got my dates mixed up. It can happen to anyone!’

James resisted the urge to laugh and instead exchanged secretive grins with his girlfriend. He'd argue scheduling dates with different women on the same night accidentally didn't just happen to anyone.

Sirius was a bit of a ladies man though.

Who am I kidding? He's a bleeding manwhore.

‘Ugh,’ Lily scoffed, sending Sirius a look of disgust. ‘Every time one of your little tarts agrees to go on a date with you, I become that little bit more of a misogynist.’

‘Miso-whatnow?’

‘Means she hates women,’ James helpfully informed his clueless mate.

‘Rude! Girls love me.’

Lily rolled her eyes and shot him a tolerant smile. ‘At this point, that's unfortunately apparent. The issue is I just fail to see why.’

Sirius only pouted, taking the harsh words in the teasing spirit they were intended. ‘Double rude!’

James raised an amused eyebrow at his girlfriend and grinned. ‘I don't believe for a second you don't know why he's so popular. You call us disguising, but I've heard how you girls gossip amongst each other - bunch of randy, filthy whores the lot of you.’

The fact that Lily didn't arch up and hit him for his derogatory remark let him know he was right on the money. She blushed adorably, looked away and suddenly found her cards incredibly interesting.

‘Yes, well, that's obviously ridiculous.’

James and Sirius shared an amused glance before James folded his ace-high straight and swallowed a bean from the pot, wincing in disgust when the flavour hit his tongue.

Anchovies. Yuck.

Washing the disgusting flavour down with a swig of firewhiskey - genuinely believing it to be worse than the sewage his girlfriend was subjected to - he let the others know the flavour before grinning. ‘Alright then my love, win this hand and Sirius has to prove once and for all if the rumours are true, lose, and you have to show us your tits.’

The smile on Sirius' face nearly split his face and he wiggled his eyebrows suggestively, curling the tip of his moustache with his free hand and doing a remarkable job of looking like a villain.

Every exposed millimetre of Lily's pale skin lit up a brilliant crimson. ‘That's ridiculous! I'm not doing that!’

The boys shared an amused glance and grinned. James shrugged, patting and squeezing his girlfriend’s thigh in a consoling manner. ‘It's alright babe, you don't have to do anything you don't want to.’

‘Yeah,’ Sirius agreed, his roguish grin that had worked so well for him in wooing the fairer sex on full display. ‘There’s nothing wrong with being a chicken, Evans.’

Lily stiffened and her beautiful, emerald eyes narrowed dangerously at Sirius. ‘You must think I'm one of your brainless trollops if you think I'll fall for that.’

‘No, nooo, of course not,’ Sirius assuaged, managing to pull off an impressive amount of insincerity and condescension with just a few words. ‘You're much too smart for that.’


Before she could unleash her legendary temper on Padfoot and ruin his plans, James covered his face and made it look like he was about to sneeze, but instead he poked the lion.

‘Bok bok.’

His girlfriend’s head snapped in his direction, her eyes wide and her nostrils flaring. ‘Did you just -’

Sirius, apparently with no sense of self-preservation or fear of death, copied his best mate.

‘Bok bok bok.’

As much as Lily tried to look like she wanted to curse their bollocks off, she couldn’t help the corners of her lips twitching in amusement, her beautiful eyes dancing with mirth. ‘You two are children.’

‘Sorry,’ James teased, his charming grin levelled at his girlfriend at full force. ‘I know you’re trying to communicate, but I don’t speak chicken.’

Lily, laying on her side and propped up on one elbow, had her feet nearest to him and used them to great effect by kicking him in the side.

‘Ooft!’

‘Fine, whatever. It’s not like I’ll lose. Sirius’ hand is rubbish anyway.’

Sirius sat up in excitement, his eyes shining with poorly hidden glee and excitement. Though James had claimed ‘dibs’ on Lily when he first laid eyes on her, Sirius’ crush on his girl was no secret. He didn’t begrudge his best mate, his brother, his crush - he could obviously understand it, even.

Heck, a large part of his devious, perverted plans for that evening centred around that crush, after all.

‘Hell-o, get ready to show daddy those sweater puppies Evans!’

Lily snorted, grimacing in disgust at his reference to her breasts but motioning for him to reveal his cards regardless.

His grin like a shark’s, his eyes firmly on the swell of her breasts still clearly visible beneath her heavy, knit sweater, Sirius laid his two cards out, pulling from the community cards to show his impressive hand.

‘Read ‘em and weep Evans. Straight, ace-high!’

The second Lily plastered an impressed look on her beautiful features, James knew she had his best mate beat.

Excellent.

His plans would have been unaffected either way, but he knew Lily winning this hand was the quickest path to reaching his desired end-goal.

Sirius' grin slipped too when he noticed Lily’s faux impressed expression.

‘That’s a pretty good hand,’ Lily mused, looking at her own cards as if in deep thought. ‘You boys know this poker game better than me, but is it good when all my cards are the same suit?’

The innocent question was delivered with the most devious, shit-eating grin imaginable, belying Lily’s ignorance. Sirius cursed and tossed his worthless cards to the side before standing.

‘Oh?’ Lily pouted, her eyes dancing with mirth as Sirius walked over towards the corner of the room. ‘Throwing a hissy fit and welching on the bet Padfoot?’ Lily teased, her smug grin making her look even more gorgeous in his eyes. She sat up and shuffled on her knees towards James and plopped herself down on his lap, making sure not to spill her drink before leaning back against his chest. ‘Didn’t know you were a bottler.’

‘I’m not bottling nothing,’ Sirius snapped back before turning his back to them, unzipping his trousers and shoving his hand in his pants as he talked to them over his shoulder.

‘You’re not bottling anything,’ James corrected before his girlfriend could, years of being on the receiving end of said corrections himself having ingrained proper grammar in his mind. Lily, her smile wide with pride, pecked him on the lips before turning back to Sirius. His back was still to them and his arm was shaking in a jerking motion, clearly wanking.

‘Whatever,’ he grunted, paying them no mind. ‘I’m not letting Evans see my cock and balls for the first time unless they’re at their best!’

‘I thought you were supposedly hung like a Centaur,’ Lily teased, no doubt using words her slutty friends had used to describe his best mate. ‘Is this really necessary?’

Sirius didn’t rise to the bait and instead snorted. ‘I can’t wait to see the look on your face. It’ll be just like all the other girls.’

Lily stilled in his arms, the confidence in Sirius’ tone throwing her. James wouldn’t be lying if he didn’t share his mates’ desire, the look on Lily’s face when she saw his trouser snake would be…incredible.

Still, even after five minutes, his best mate hadn’t turned. His girlfriend was clearly feeling frisky, probably fuelled by James having slipped his hands under her sweater and running his fingers along her bare skin, coming close to but never touching her heavy tits. She was squirming in his grasp, but was clearly enjoying the attention. ‘What’s taking so long?’ Lily asked impatiently, her normally pale face tinged red. ‘Performance anxiety?’

Sirius didn’t turn. ‘It takes a while to reroute so much blood,’ he joked and James cackled.

James leaned down and pressed his lips against his beautiful girlfriend’s ear, her body freezing and her breath hitching in anticipation for what was to come. She loved it when he lowered his voice and spoke directly into her ear, saying it caused pleasant tingles and shivers to wrack her body. ‘If you want to speed the process along, my love, you could always let him see your tits.’

Sirius’ head snapped around to them, his eyes wide in excitement. James almost laughed when his girlfriend missed it because she did the exact same. Her beautiful eyes then narrowed. ‘What are you playing at?’

James only shrugged. Lily wasn’t stupid, she’d figure out what he was playing at eventually, but he’d rather she come to the conclusion when she was much more receptive…and hornier.

Instead of getting angry, she bit her lip sexily and frowned. ‘What was the point of winning the hand if I just flash him anyway?’

James grinned, having expected that question. ‘Had you lost, your tits would have stayed out for a lot longer,’ Lily flushed scarlet, clearly having not expected that. ‘Here, it’s just a flash to speed things along. Or we can wait, no big deal.’

Lily looked down and bit her lip again as she thought. He was glad she was only tipsy - his plans for the evening would have felt gross if she was shitfaced.

However, Lily got horny when she was tipsy. He also hadn’t shagged her for a week in preparation for this night, having promised her a special night tonight to compensate.

His girl was turbocharged and so horny it was only a matter of moments before she sighed and handed him her glass, her cheeks reddening. ‘Only a peek! Consider this your Christmas present!’

Her blush deepened when she turned back and saw Sirius staring at her over his shoulder with clear excitement in his eyes, the hand wanking his cock working overtime.

Getting up on her knees, she brushed her thick, coppery locks out of her face and mustered her Gryffindor courage, her hands gripping the hem of her knit sweater and dragging it up until it was just under her heavy breasts.

Lily wasn’t stick thin like some of the girls Sirius hooked up with, or athletic like some of his Quidditch teammates, but she’d never be considered chubby. She was curvy, soft and deliciously pliable. One of his favourite things to do with his girlfriend was squeeze her bum while he shagged her and watch the skin seep out from between his fingers while her body jiggled enticingly with each thrust.

Sirius was greeted to a glimpse of this when she lifted her top up and exposed her bare midriff. He was almost panting like the dog he was as Lily paused right beneath her tits, no doubt gripping the underside of her bra too.

‘Just a quick peek,’ Lily warned Sirius, preparing him.

Sirius only nodded silently, his wanking having become even more intense as Lily teased him. James would be shocked if he wasn’t hard by now, but his best mate wasn’t stupid enough to stop Lily when she was about to flash him.

After a deep, calming breath, Lily flipped her top up and exposed her heavy tits, allowing them to flop out and sway on her chest. Sirius actually groaned with lust at the sight of them, the way they bounced and swayed as gravity exerted its force over them and had them sagging on her chest enticingly.

Lily usually dressed in baggy tops and coats that often hid her womanly charms - not that James really minded. His girlfriend liked to act all prim and proper outside, focusing heavily on her studies and not feeling the need to show off to anyone - thankfully, she was a hellcat behind closed doors. Some of his fondest memories were study sessions they’d had together where she’d remove an article of clothing every time he got a question right.

While her face and eyes were always number one to him - the part of her that made him instantly fall in love and made him want to be a better man - it was always a close call whether her bum or her tits were second. Depending on his mood, he could lean either way, but seeing the effect her pale, heavy D-cups and perfect, galleon-sized pink nipples had on the salivating and thunderstruck Sirius had him leaning in the boob direction that evening.

When Lily quickly covered her tits again, a smug smirk permanently affixed to her face as she beheld their reaction, she briefly adjusted her bra until her breasts were secure once again and fell against his chest. ‘Come on then, chop chop.’

She emphasised her words with clicks of her fingers and Sirius looked down at his cock before turning back to his girlfriend with a wicked grin. Before Lily could heckle him some more, Sirius started backing towards his bed, causing Lily’s cheeky words to die in her throat. When he finally stood less than a metre away, his back still to them, he looked over his shoulder and winked.

‘You ready Evans?’

‘Oh get it over wi -’

She stopped mid sentence as Sirius spun around and revealed himself to his girlfriend in all his glory.

‘Stupefy!’

James guffawed as Sirius cast the faux spell, metaphorically stunning Lily by using his cock as a wand.

Lily clearly had the impression that her friends were exaggerating the size of his best mate’s cock…if anything, they undersold him. Something Lily was now experiencing first hand. At almost a foot long and about as thick around as her wrist, it was understandable how the joke was born that Sirius often played Quidditch with two beater’s bats.

Lily, her teasing tone long gone, just gaped at him in shock, her eyes glued to Sirius’ freakishly huge cock. As much as Lily was rendered speechless however, James couldn’t help feeling unbelievably turned on by seeing her stare at his best mate’s member in awe.

‘That’s the look I was waiting for,’ Sirius crowed, not bothering to cover up as Lily kept staring - in fact, he held his member in a tight grip at the base and bounced it for her in a teasing manner, his eyes crinkling when he noticed Lily’s beautiful emerald eyes following its movements. Sirius’ cock was so big that, even though it was as hard as it would get, it sagged and drooped under its own weight, his knob mere inches from Lily’s face. ‘You alright there Evans? No snappy comebacks?’

Lily finally snapped out of her trance, shook her head and looked up at Sirius in shock before turning to him, the look on her face not changing. ‘Is this a prank?’ she asked incredulously, knowing their propensity for such things. ‘Was he casting a growing charm all this time? A potion?’

Both James and Sirius barked out a laugh and Lily’s cheeks flushed in humiliation. ‘Love,’ James cooed, wrapping his arms around her midsection and pulling her close. ‘Sorry, we’re not really laughing at you, but every bloke is taught on day one of Hogwarts that casting spells on your own twig and giggleberries is…a bad idea.’

Both he and Sirius shuddered as the memories of the horror stories resurfaced in their minds.

James continued. ‘And you should know better than anyone that if such a potion existed…well, there’d be a lot of rich potions masters running around.’

Lily couldn’t help but giggle at the truism of his words before, almost against her will, she turned back and stared at Sirius’ sock. She didn’t even look up at him as she addressed him, instead opting to talk directly to the towering pillar of manflesh - something Sirius was clearly loving.

‘Alright I’ve seen it…you can put it away now.’

Sirius laughed. ‘My eyes are up here Evans.’ He laughed again when Lily ignored him and kept staring at his cock in shock. Sirius had explained this phenomena to him before, he called it cock-shock, where a girl would see his member and just keep staring in awe.

Sirius very much relished those moments.

When she realised what she was doing, Lily blushed all the way to her roots before almost forcibly ripping her gaze away. ‘Alright you cad, you’re clearly well-endowed. I was wrong, you were right, now put it away.’

‘It’s not that easy,’ James teased, his hands once again rubbing at her bare flesh. When she turned to look at him in confusion, he motioned towards Sirius. ‘Look how big he is, and look how small his trousers are, he’s not stuffing that thing back in there until he calms down.’

As if confirming his words, Sirius released his cock and just let it hang there before climbing back on the bed and retaking his position by his pile of beans. James grinned as Lily tracked his cock the entire way, especially as the tip dragged along the sheets as he crawled. The spell wasn’t broken until Lily threw a pillow into his lap, forcing him to cover up.

Both boys cracked up at that.

The atmosphere in the room had shifted ever since Sirius had revealed himself to Lily, there was a thick, not quite unpleasant, but definitely noticeable tension that James fully intended to take advantage of.

They went back to playing, with Sirius making sure to ‘accidentally’ expose himself as often as possible. The best part, for James, was that Lily didn’t object, she only stole cheeky glances every time Sirius would reach for the pot or readjust himself.

Lily had just lost a hand, but instead of eating the beans like she was supposed to, she was hesitating. She’d copped a really bad one in the last game - old gym socks - and was clearly still scarred.

‘Go on Evans, don’t be a girl.’

Such was her trepidation that she didn’t even explode at the joke. ‘I…think I might actually get sick if I eat another bad bean… like, really sick.’

‘You can choose not to eat the bean,’ James offered, and when Sirius made to arc up, James held out a hand and gave him a look that clearly told him to shut up. Seeing Lily’s look of hope, he was almost sad to dash her hopes.

That’s a bold-faced lie.

‘But, if you don’t eat the bean, you have to pay another forfeit.’

Her face scrunched up in confusion. ‘What do you mean?’

James pointed to Sirius’ groin. ‘That was a forfeit - you’d have to do something similar.’ She was about to object but he talked over her. ‘Otherwise, what’s the point if there’s no sense of jeopardy?’

She bit her lower lip as she thought, clearly understanding his point but not liking it.

Ultimately, the decision wasn’t too hard for his girlfriend. She’d already kind of paid a forfeit earlier, she’d only be doing so again. After a few moments to psyche herself up, she grabbed the hem of her top and, after only the slightest of hesitations, she flashed them her heavy tits again. Sirius groaned and Lily’s head snapped in his direction when his hand disappeared behind the pillow, clearly stroking himself at the sight of her. She flushed scarlet at the blatant wanking, even more so than the flashing itself had caused, and just bit her lip and held the pose for an entire minute before covering herself up again when James gave her a nod.

‘Phwoar,’ Sirius exclaimed, breaking the intense silence. ‘Evans, I’m not gonna lie, you have to have the best set of tits at Hogwarts.’

‘Don’t be disgusting.’ Her words didn’t match her reaction though and they chuckled as she looked inordinately pleased by the compliment. It was actually pretty funny looking at her face and seeing the complex series of emotions as she mentally berated herself for being so pleased by his words.

Though the door had been opened to pay with forfeits now, James and Sirius - by mutual, silent consent - chose to keep scarfing down the beans to stomach churning effect. A different kind of bluffing game was going on now, where both of the men would even exaggerate how horrible their flavours were just to make sure Lily didn’t decide to chance a bean the next time she lost.

And lose, she eventually did.

When she made to lift her top again, James stopped her with a raised hand. He silenced Sirius’ vociferous protests with another look before turning back to his girlfriend. ‘Sorry babe, but you can’t do the same forfeit twice - if you do that, the top is coming off for good.’

She slowly lowered her top and narrowed her eyes at him. ‘What then?’

Sirius booed her, clearly wanting to be rid of the baggy, knit sweater. He completely ignored her glare and gave her his most charming smile before she turned back to him. James’ grin widened and he motioned to Sirius’ pillow-covered groin. ‘Seeing as you can’t stop trying to see through the pillow, and that’s, ultimately, your fault…why don’t you give Padfoot a hand?’

Sirius instantly perked up, his eyes wide in shock at the surprise offer. He looked between both him and Lily several times before his gaze finally settled on the redhead as he slowly removed the pillow and revealed his still very hard cock again. It was laying against his abdomen like a felled tree and Lily’s eyes were instantly drawn to it.

She finally managed to tear her gaze away from the obscene endowment and stared into his eyes, her brow furrowed and all traces of inebriation long gone. ‘What are you playing at?’

James only grinned and shrugged. ‘You could always eat a bean?’ Seeing her shudder and dry-heave, he continued. ‘If you’re worried about me getting angry, don’t. We have a safe-word for a reason.’

Lily’s eyes widened and her cheeks flushed scarlet as she looked back at Sirius. He was back to looking between them with raised eyebrows, but he was smart enough to know when to keep his mouth shut.

He was also smart enough to know that by stroking his cock the way he was, he was drawing attention to it, and Lily’s eyes fell on his huge shaft once more, biting her lips as her mind raced.

Finally, she turned back to him, her eyebrows raised. ‘You’re sure?’

James was sure he failed to suppress his amused smirk. ‘You’ve been sneaking peeks at his dick ever since he showed it, you trollop, don’t act like you’re not eager.’

Flushing at being so blatantly called out, she grinned cheekily at him and Sirius cheered when she started to shuffle her way towards him, her face still as red as her hair but her excitement evident.

Sirius was now up on his knees, his cock an imposing, towering pillar of flesh in his lap. Lily positioned herself so she was kneeling beside him, their shoulders touching as both of them faced James. His girlfriend had kept her eyes locked on him during the entire trek, as if waiting for him to call the madness off at any minute, but James just stayed silent, smiling at Lily encouragingly as he stroked the bulge in his trousers.

Finally accepting that this wasn’t some kind of prank or bait-and-switch, Lily turned and gazed down at Sirius’ cock beside her with wide eyes, her breath hitching. Instead of palming him like they’d both expected though, she stared at his huge cock in thought, her mind clearly racing.

Turning her gaze up and looking at them both with an impish grin, Lily reached behind her back and apparently unhooked her bra through her top. They both watched with raised eyebrows as she wiggled and, a few moments later, she pulled her bra out from the bottom of her jumper.

‘Did you just do wandless magic?’ Sirius asked, eyes wide.

James grinned and shook his head. ‘That’s her favourite party trick.’

Her cheeks a rosy red, Lily otherwise looked pleased with herself and Sirius’ breath hitched as she reached down towards his cock. Instead of grabbing his member directly, she wrapped her bra around his shaft, using it as a kind of buffer between her hand and his foreskin.

Still, the second Sirius felt her grip tighten around his shaft, his head tilted back and he groaned with delight.

Lily slowly stroked the huge member, her mouth hanging open in shock as she stared in disbelief at both what she was doing, and the size of the thing. When Lily remembered he was there and finally looked up at him, her cheeks still adorably red and her eyes wide, James almost came in his pants when she whispered her next words. ‘I can’t even get my fingers all the way around it…’

She started in surprise when the words had his entire body visibly shuddering with desire. ‘You’re so beautiful,’ James panted, his voice hoarse and cracking with his arousal. ‘I love you so much…’

She smiled prettily in return, apparently aware of the absurdity of doing so while her hand was on another man’s cock. ‘I love you too.’

Padfoot, often the victim of the ol’ foot-in-mouth curse, was at least smart enough not to comment and kept enjoying getting a handy from his best-mate’s girl.

That didn’t mean he stayed silent, however. Lily Evans wasn’t the first good girl he’d messed around with, his vast experience letting him know exactly what to say to stoke the fires of her clearly raging libido.

‘Always knew you were a dirty girl, Evans,’ he panted, his hand coming up to grip her wrist so she wouldn’t pull away - not that she was showing any inclination of doing so. ‘You’d rather play with my cock than get your tits out or do literally any other forfeit…so naughty.’

Lily bit her lip and looked away in embarrassment, but she didn’t stop stroking or even bother to refute him.

‘You wanted to get your hands on my cock the second you saw it, didn’t you?’

Her cheeks were growing progressively redder, and she only looked away from his cock long enough to stare up at her boyfriend before she shyly nodded, earning chuckles from the both of them.

‘You’re no better than the trollops you were slagging off earlier,’ Sirius hissed, groaning in bliss.

Aside from her blush growing even redder, Lily said or did little else to defend herself.

What could she say?

Other than the sound of the crackling fire, the room descended into silence as Lily continued wanking Sirius. When she finally picked up speed however, a wet, squelching sound accompanied her motions. When a second hand joined her first, they finally broke the silence by laughing. Lily grinned too at the absurdity of it all.

‘This is a lot more work than I was expecting,’ she joked, her cheeks still flaming red. ‘My arm’s getting tired…’

It was obvious when Sirius was close to cumming. His breathing increased and he started to thrust his hips in time with Lily’s strokes as he leaned back and propped himself up on his elbows to watch.

Just as he was about to cum all over the place like an overpowered aguamenti charm, Lily did something she’d done to him many times in the past when she was edging and teasing him…she completely let go of his cock and stopped all stimulation entirely.

Sirius gasped as if he’d been betrayed, his eyes wide as he stared at Lily in shock. Lily only grinned at him coquettishly and shrugged, ‘The deal was for a wank, not for you to finish.’

‘It’s not a proper wank unless I finish!’

They both turned to him as if he were some kind of arbiter for this insane situation. Sirius lay there with his cock twitching and throbbing against his abs and Lily grinned impishly at him, the shape of her tits much more noticeable through her top now that they weren’t supported by her bra.


Even though she was finished, it took him a moment to get the image of Lily’s hand wrapped around his best mate’s cock out of his mind so he could answer clearly. His cheeks flushed and his desire for Lily at an all-time high, James could only shrug and grin. ‘You didn’t specify that you needed to cum - wanking you for a fair bit is an adequate enough forfeit on its own.’

‘Betrayal!’ he screamed as Lily and James broke out into overly hysterical laughter, the heavy sexual tension in the room finally finding some kind of release.


Still grumbling, Sirius stood and let his jeans fall to the floor, not even bothering or seeing a point with covering up anymore. James grinned as Lily kept shooting glances at his huge, throbbing cock as it bobbled around with his movements, as if she were being discreet.

‘I’m gonna have a slash and try to recover from this brutal wench’s teasing,’ Sirius grumbled, shooting Lily a dirty glare before turning and heading to the bathroom. As soon as the door closed behind him, his girlfriend turned to him with wide eyes.

‘What was that!’

James barked out a laugh.

‘My dear, that was you wanking Sirius for several minutes straight.’

She flushed and threw a pillow at his head, her fiery, emerald eyes telling him that wasn’t the answer she wanted to hear.

Instead of answering, James gripped her wrist and tugged her into his lap. Lily yelped but moaned in his grasp as he wrapped his arms around her and pulled her into a deep, passionate kiss.

When he pulled back, Lily looked dazed with lust while her gorgeous eyes smouldered with desire. ‘Are you enjoying yourself?’

Lily blushed and looked away, but James put his fingers on her chin and turned her face back to his.

‘No need to spare my feelings, you can barely keep your eyes off his cock,’ he teased as Lily whimpered and buried her face in his chest.

‘I can’t help it,’ she whined and buried her face in his chest. ‘It’s so big, I…It’s unbelievable.’

They heard the loo flushing and James tilted her head up so she was looking directly into his eyes. ‘Don’t worry about me, okay? Just keep having fun like the naughty little slag you are. Think of it as a Christmas present.’

Her cheeks flared a brilliant red but she nodded, a sexy grin gracing your features. ‘Who’s the present for, I wonder… Sirius, me…or you?’

James grinned wide but didn’t bother answering. After another heated kiss, she climbed off his lap and retook her position, her eyes flicking to the bathroom as Sirius rememerged, his heavy cock still very much hard, uncovered and dangling between his legs almost down to his knee. Sirius caught her staring and turned to him, his eyebrows raised. James, his grin still firmly in place, just shrugged and sent his mate a cheeky wink.

The look of excitement he got in return was exactly what James was hoping for.

Lily won the next few hands, but the boys just sent each other knowing grins as her lusty gaze barely strayed from Sirius’ heavy cock, still hard and resting against his abdomen. His mate was having way too much fun with it, making it twitch and dance for Lily while pretending not to notice her stares.

She went from taking the mickey out of her friends for being duped by Sirius all the time to not being able to take her eyes off his cock…that’s so hot.

When Lily next lost, she didn’t even bother with any pretences and immediately decided on what she would do as a forfeit. James’ eyes widened when instead of joining Sirius for some kinky time like he’d expected, his girlfriend crawled towards him and ran her hand over his bulge before unzipping his trousers.

As James and Sirius grinned at each other over Lily’s head, he figured he kind of understood what his girlfriend was intending here.

She wanted to see how turned on he really was.

James didn’t resist when she pushed his trousers and pants down to his knees and exposed his cock to the warm room. ‘I thought this was supposed to be your forfeit, not mine?’ James teased, hissing when she started to wank his far less impressive member without hesitation.

Her eyes twinkled with mirth as she shrugged. ‘I’m not allowed to do the same forfeit twice, so I’ll give you a handy this time.’

James sighed pleasantly, very much enjoying his girlfriend’s hand on his aching cock as he leaned back against the mountain of pillows behind him. While she was giving him a wank right in front of their friend and staring deeply into his eyes, she couldn’t help looking over at Sirius when he started to languidly stroke his own cock while watching.

Lily stared for several moments before turning back to James, a naughty smile on her face. She didn’t tell him what she was thinking, but her expression held enough devious promise that James instantly felt himself growing even harder.

‘Padfoot, come here,’ Lily purred, holding out a hand and curling her fingers as she beckoned him over. His best mate did not need to be told twice, moving so quickly that James wondered if he’d just impossibly apparated by their side. Lily giggled at his obvious eagerness and Sirius groaned, his hands interlocked atop his head when she gripped his bare cock for the first time with her other hand and started stroking him too.

James wasn’t self-conscious about his size at only a decently girthy six-inches. He’d been with plenty of women before Lily and had been able to bring each of them to screaming orgasms with his own modest endowment, but as his girlfriend held his and his mate’s cocks side by side - her hands cupping their bollocks and their shafts travelling different distances down the inside of her forearm - he couldn’t help feeling a little emasculated.

A little emasculated but very turned on. Especially when Lily looked up at him with wide eyes, her mouth slightly agape. ‘He’s so much bigger than you…’

She hadn’t meant it as a naughty tease, just a pure statement of fact, and that’s what made her statement so much hotter. James’ entire body shuddered as a pulse of ecstasy ran through each of his senses, his vision almost whiting out. Lily had noticed the reaction and her wide-eyed innocence had shifted to a devious smirk.

The silence was absolute, no one daring to say anything as Lily wanked both of their cocks while looking up into each of their eyes. When she released them, again without making either of them cum, she did so with a devious grin as she shuffled back to her spot.

James removed his trousers and pants entirely and tossed them to the floor while Sirius growled like a beast. ‘Fucking tease.’

Lily’s smile widened and she bore the tag as if it were a badge of honour. She was as aroused as they were, but Lily was having way too much fun being the most clothed out of all of them while having as much hard, naked cock to perv at as she wanted.

While they still kept the pretence of this being about forfeits up, continuing to play poker and enjoying themselves, everything had become incredibly sexually charged from then on. Lily tried to find any excuse she could to brush up against their hard cocks while both he and Sirius got noticeably excited every time it looked like Lily would lose a hand.

When she did next lose, both boys looked at her with eager anticipation as Lily decided on her next forfeit, their hands steadily stroking their aching cocks. With a chuckle, Lily shrugged and sent them teasing smiles. ‘I suppose it’s fair enough…’

Before either Sirius or James could ask what she was referring to, they both sucked in excited breaths when Lily removed her heavy, knit sweater and tossed it to the floor. Having removed her bra earlier, her heavy tits flopped free and hung low on her chest as she smirked and watched the both of them devouring her half-naked form as eagerly as Lily had been eyeing Sirius’ cock all night.

Lily laughed, her pale cheeks set in a permanent blush. ‘I don’t get it, they’re just sacks of fat.’

‘The best sacks of fat in all of Hogwarts,’ Sirius agreed reverently, his hand still stroking his cock and his eyes glued to her chest. James agreed with his best mate, holding out his fist to bump knuckles as they stared at the supremely pleased Lily’s tits. ‘I can’t believe you get to suck on those beauties whenever you want Prongs.’

James sent his girlfriend a warm smile and a wink. ‘And they’re still just her second best feature.’

Lily flushed a deeper scarlet as she stared lovingly at him and Sirius just looked at him in confusion. ‘You mean her ass?’

James barked out a laugh as Lily rolled her eyes and chucked a pillow at Sirius’ head. ‘I meant her mind, you bellend.’

‘Oh,’ Padfoot uttered, dodging the pillow and shaking his head in confusion. ‘Mate, why didn’t you tell me falling in love makes you gay? I think I’ll stay single forever - wouldn’t want to deprive the ladies.’

James barked out another laugh as Lily chucked another pillow at his best mate’s head. ‘You’re such a child.’

Sirius grinned wide and shook his hips from side-to-side, his huge cock flopping all over the place and slapping his thighs with heavy, meaty thwacks. ‘Nothing childish about this, love.’

Lily’s eyes followed the movement of his cock like a snake followed its charmer, earning more chuckles from the boys.

By some silent, unspoken agreement, both James and Sirius decided to stop being distracted by Lily’s charms and instead focus on making sure she’d lose quickly, and as often as possible. James started to blatantly cheat, dealing from the bottom of the deck and Sirius distracted Lily by playing with his dick for her.

His girlfriend was no dummy, she knew some of what they were doing, but it was a sign of how turned on she was that she didn’t even care.

Predictably, Lily lost the next hand and, without being prompted, she shuffled over to Sirius, her hand reaching for his cock.

‘Can’t do the same forfeit twice, my love,’ James reminded her but Lily didn’t seem perturbed. Sending him a wicked grin over her shoulder, Lily slid down onto her belly so her face was mere millimetres away from Sirius’ hard, aching cock. When she placed a tender kiss on his leaking knob, Sirius’ head flew back and he groaned so loud James was worried he’d cum on the spot.

Lily giggled and kissed his knob again, smirking as the gargantuan shaft pulsed in her hand. She languidly stroked his shaft, pulling back his foreskin and, each time his head was exposed, she’d lick up a fresh bead of precum. Sirius, leaning back and supporting his weight on his arms, looked like he was in heaven. ‘I’ve teased this big boy enough tonight, don’t you think, babe?’

James played along eagerly. ‘You’ve been so cruel to poor Padfoot, dear. It’s very unlike you.’

Lily sent him a smouldering look before turning back to Sirius’ cock. She held it with two hands towards the tip, and there was still a distressing amount uncovered as she stroked him with both hands, holding his knob towards her mouth. When she next kissed his head, Lily instead pressed her lips forward, her mouth opening wide and sucking in as much as she could manage.

‘Fuuuuuuuck,’ Sirius groaned, one hand threading itself in Lily’s coppery locks as she held his large knob in her mouth. Her lips were spread too wide to make it obvious, but James thought Lily was smirking around his friend’s shaft as she deployed her favourite technique, rapidly twirling her tongue around a bloke’s knob.

Unable to help himself, James brought his hand down on Lily’s soft, meaty ass with a resounding smack. She yelped but didn’t remove her lips from Sirius’ manhood, though she did turn to him, her eyebrows raised.

‘Suck that huge cock you dirty slag,’ he encouraged, massaging her meaty ass as Lily chuckled, the sound muffled by his mate’s cock.

James kept massaging her soft ass with one hand, while the other rapidly stroked his own modest endowment - the sight of his girlfriend giving his best mate a blowie too hard to resist.

Sirius was in heaven, his legs spread wide and his hands gently urging Lily to take more and more of his cock in her mouth. She wouldn’t be deterred though, and kept her lips sealed around his knob while her hands pumped his shaft. Finally, his mate looked up at him, his grey eyes wide with disbelief.

‘She’s incredible,’ he praised reverently around his moans. ‘You sure know how to pick ‘em Prongs.’

James spanked her soft ass again and Lily’s muffled squeal was followed by a guttural moan.

He noticed his mate was close to cumming and James suddenly had a wicked thought. Crawling over to his girl, he put his lips right next to her ear and whispered what he wanted. Instead of answering or showing she’d heard him, Lily just pulled off Sirius’ cock, ignoring his mate’s despairing groans.

Those groans were immediately silenced when Lily sat on her knees and cupped her tits for him. ‘You want to finish here, Sirius?’

Sirius looked at her in awe, but instead of answering, he stood up on the bed on shaky legs, his fist gliding up and down his cock so quickly that it was a blur, his knob aimed directly at Lily’s heavy, cupped tits. His girlfriend helped him along by cupping his bollocks and gently fondling him as he furiously wanked the end of his mammoth shaft, a gentle, serene smile on her face as she awaited her prize.

‘Are you excited to cover your mate’s girlfriend in cum, Sirius?’ Lily purred and Sirius’ knees nearly buckled at how sexy and sinful she sounded. James wasn’t faring much better, but he’d stopped wanking and instead chose to lean back in comfort and enjoy the show. ‘Cum for me, Sirius, mark me.’

The implications of her words sent a powerful shockwave through Sirius’ body, and with an almost startled moan, he gasped loudly, groaned and unleashed his first jet of cum on Lily’s tits with an accompanying full-body shudder. Then he shook again as another jet of cum splattered all over Lily’s chest, then another, and another. Lily could only watch with wide-eyed shock as her breasts were plastered with more cum than she’d ever seen in her entire life, and Sirius just kept stroking the end of his cock, his body convulsing as the discharge started to slowly ebb.

His cheeky best mate made sure the final few splurts hit Lily on the forehead, but instead of cursing his bollocks off, his girl just closed her eyes and allowed the warm discharge to cover her face, the almost relaxed, exultant smile so out of place given the situation, it went straight to his cock.

When he was done, Sirius’ knees finally buckled and he fell down to the bed, splayed out on his back with his chest rising and falling rapidly with his heavy breathing.

James didn't immediately clean Lily of his mate’s cum, instead sliding in behind her and wrapping his arms underneath her chest.

‘You're so beautiful,’ James purred directly in her ear, squeezing her tight. ‘I wish you could see what I see…such a horny little slut.’

His words were having a visible effect on Lily as she melted into his arms and inhaled a shuddering breath, her pink nipples pebbled and her pale skin breaking out in goosebumps.

Sirius had regained his senses at this point, and James could see him eyeing his handiwork in his periphery, his hand slowly stroking his quickly recovering cock as his steely eyes devoured Lily's soiled chest.

Shooting his mate a cheeky wink and ignoring the returned baffled, bemused look, James reached for his wand and made sure to clean just Lily’s face of cum. Lily peeked a beautiful eye open when she was no longer at risk and sent him a deadpan stare. ‘Really?’

James grinned, pulling Lily tighter against his chest. ‘You can take care of the rest.’

‘That necklace looks brilliant on you,’ Sirius interrupted cheekily. Lily was about to turn and snap at him but seeing him eyeing her soiled tits hungrily, his hand stroking the tip of his towering erection, her perpetual blush deepened and she looked away.

‘Cast another scourgify,’ Lily whined into his chest, and James almost laughed at her as her body acted contrary to her words, sticking her chest out and making her breasts look even bigger by bracketing them with her arms. ‘Don't make me hex your bollocks off.’

Instead of being cowed or feeling threatened, James turned her head and captured her lips in a heated, passionate kiss - making sure to ignore the salty tang on his girl’s tongue. When he pulled back, he rested his forehead against Lily’s and smiled. ‘I love you.’

Her blush intensified, smiled prettily and looked away, snuggling deeper in his embrace. ‘You’re daft,’ she said, but her gentle smile had his heart wanting to burst out of his chest. ‘Love you too.’

‘We still playing?’ Sirius asked with a crooked grin. He’d completely disrobed now, his thin, wiry physique completely at odds with his freakish, centaur-cock.

Instead of answering, Lily stood and got off the bed and before either of them could ask what she was doing, she turned her back to them and started to roll her skin-tight leggings down her legs, bending over at the waist and showing off her gorgeous, meaty ass and perfect, naked pussy to them.

James copied them and removed his clothes too. Lily, her leggings in hand, used them as a cloth and wiped her chest clean. Both boys watched her with rapt attention, their hands on their aching cocks as she unknowingly put on a show for them.

When she realised how intensely they were watching her, she started then, after a moment, grinned. Her movements became a lot more sensual, the same spot on her tits wiped several times as she pulled at and squished the soft flesh together.

Her musical laughter dispelled the heavy sexual tension and she winked at them, her hips swaying from side to side as she made for the bathroom. ‘Be right back,’ she teased in a sing-song.

Pausing in the doorframe of the bathroom, she turned back to look at them again, her bottom lip between her teeth. Lily didn't say anything, her smouldering gaze speaking volumes, before she almost reluctantly disappeared inside.

Sirius let out an audible sigh when they were finally alone, his incredulous stare pinning James on the spot. ‘Are you mental?’

James barked out a laugh. ‘Nah mate, just a horny pervert. Merry Christmas.’

Sirius returned his fist bump, but still looked confused. ‘What are you playing at, mate?’

James rolled his eyes at being asked that again. ‘Don't overthink it. She’ll always be my girl and the woman I'll spend the rest of my life with, and you're my brother.’ He grinned, a funny thought occurring to him. ‘And brothers share their toys.’

Sirius’ laughter was almost hysterical and he held out his knuckles for another fist bump. ‘Don't let Evans hear you say that, she'll cut your bollocks off.’

‘Hear him say what?’ Lily's suspicious voice asked from the entrance to the bathroom. Both of the boys’ heads turned towards the sound and they collectively swallowed their tongues at the sight of her.

She was standing in the doorway, her hands resting on the inside of the frame above as the light from the bathroom bathed her in an ethereal glow. While still holding the frame, she leaned forward, arched her back and stretched, her heavy chest hanging low on her chest enticingly as she very obviously showed off for them - evidenced by her cheeky grin at their stupefied expressions.

Audibly swallowing, James smiled weakly and sent his girl a smile. ‘It's, uh, your turn to make drinks.’

Shooting him a deadpan stare that let him know she didn't believe him for a second, Lily nevertheless strolled towards the liquor cabinet, a sexy sway in her step.

Unlike Sirius, he knew his girlfriend well enough to recognise she wasn't exactly comfortable with acting like a little tart, but the fact that she was even making an effort was a huge step that he really appreciated. It also made her actions that much hotter, because they were so out of character.

The fact that she was clearly enjoying herself made everything that much better.

They watched on in silence as they heard the clinking of ice, glass and the pouring of liquor. Of the three of them, Lily made the best drinks by far, her skills in potions allowing her to make additives to create unique cocktails with the simplest ingredients. They giggled like horny children when Lily started to shake the mixture, her entire body jiggling at her efforts.

She turned, eyeing them with a grin as she continued to shake.

‘Bloody hell,’ Sirius groaned, actively wanking at this point as Lily’s big tits shook all over the place.

‘You’re amazing,’ James praised, earning a widening of her beautiful smile and a darkening of her cheeks.

Snatching her wand which she’d left at the liquor cabinet earlier, she silently levitated the drinks to their recipients.

Taking a sip, James groaned in approval while Sirius only hummed thoughtfully.

‘You don’t like it?’ Lily asked in genuine surprise.

‘It’s missing something…I can’t quite put my finger on it…’

James hid his smile, instantly recognising his best mate’s scheming tone. Lily apparently did too, as she narrowed her beautiful eyes at him. A part of James still couldn’t believe she was just comfortable standing there completely starkers, her confidence making her even more breathtaking in his eyes.

‘Come here for a sec,’ Sirius beckoned Lily over and, though her eyes were still narrowed, she did as he asked. Sirius was sitting on the edge of the bed, his legs spread and his heavy cock hanging low. When Lily drew close, her gaze constantly flicking down to Sirius’ cock, his best mate wrapped an arm around her waist and drew her in, her breasts against the side of his face.

Lily yelped then moaned as Sirius tipped a bit of his drink out onto Lilly’s heavy, pale tit, the liquid running down the soft flesh until Sirius caught it again with his mouth when it hit her nipple.

Lily’s eyes fluttered closed and she would have swayed had Sirius not kept a tight grip on her. Instead, she moaned softly as Sirius tipped more of his drink out, sucking up the liquid and playing with her nipple both.

Grinning, James joined them, doing the same on her other tit while paying extra special attention to her hardened nub. ‘He’s right, you know,’ James joked, his eyes twinkling with mischief. ‘This tastes much better.’

Lily half laughed, half moaned as she wrapped an arm around each of their necks and held them close. Incredibly urging them both to keep suckling on her breasts.

Lily loved having her tits played with.

James kept his eyes locked on his girlfriend’s, his lips sealed around her nipple and his tongue twirling around her nub. He relished the look on her face as she swapped between gazing down at him and Sirius, a mixture between disbelief and delight.

Disbelief that this was even happening, he assumed, and delight at having two handsome blokes in the palm of her hand.

She moaned quietly, her mouth slightly hanging open as they pleasured her. ‘You boys are so naughty.’

Sirius’ chuckle was muffled by Lily’s ample titflesh, but James released her nipple long enough to smile up at her. ‘You’re the bad girl,’ James corrected, his grin infectious. ‘Just imagine the look on your sister’s face if she saw you now.’

The words had an immediate effect on his girlfriend. Her eyes widened in surprise and her knees almost buckled in shock as the mental image he’d put in her mind played out.

‘She’s so prim and proper, so traditional, while you’re messing around with your boyfriend and his best mate at Christmas,’ he teased, pouring out more of his drink on her tit and licking it up. ‘Such a good little slut…’

He punctuated his teasing slur by deciding to snake his arm around her waist, his fingers searching for her glistening womanhood. He was only a little surprised to find his way obstructed by his best mate’s hand, which was apparently already playing with her.

The moment Lily realised he found out what was going on behind her back, she bit her lip and grinned impishly. James chuckled and bit down on her nipples, ripping another moan from his naughty girlfriend.

Bringing his free hand back around to her front, Lily’s strength fled her and she collapsed against them when James instead started rubbing gentle circles over her clit.

‘Oh,’ she moaned, her eyes screwed shut. ‘I can’t believe I’m letting you both do this to me…’

‘Do you want us to stop?’ James teased, already knowing the answer when Lily’s eyes flew open, the lust shining in them clear as day.

‘Don’t you dare,’ she warned, her tone a breathy, lusty whisper.

James poured the rest of his drink on her tit and swallowed up as much of it as he could. ‘Mmm,’ James hummed in approval, having swallowed the majority of the liquid and now licking her wet tit clean. ‘Padfoot, I’m getting rid of the glasses tomorrow, I don’t want to drink anymore unless it’s from Lily’s tits.’

Sirius still didn’t remove his mouth from Lily’s nipple, but he chuckled nonetheless and increased his ministrations.

‘Oh God,’ she groaned, bowing her head as her body shook with pleasure. ‘I want to see what it tastes like too.’

Before James realised what exactly she was talking about, Lily stepped out of their grasp before pushing him in the chest. With a yelp, he fell back on the bed, his legs still hanging off the edge but his hard cock pointing straight in the air. Grabbing her drink, Lily smirked and crawled on the bed with him, brushing the cards and sweets aside with a careless wave of her hand - any pretence that this was about forfeits anymore long since discarded.

Lily laid down between his legs, one hand holding his cock and the other holding her glass. James hissed and moaned when, with a grin and a chuckle, she tipped some of her surprisingly cold drink on his throbbing shaft.

‘Quiet your whining Potter, you didn’t hear me complaining when you were pouring your drinks all over my tits!’

James chuckled weakly and ran his hand through her coppery locks fondly. ‘I think my cock and balls are a little more sensitive to temperature than your incredible tits are, my love.’

Lily smiled wide but didn’t bother refuting him, instead dipping her head low and swallowing his cock whole. James groaned, propping himself up on his elbows as he watched his girl lick up the excess drink and give him a world-class blowie in one. The fact that she could so easily deepthroat him while she struggled to get more than Sirius’ knob in her mouth was also an insane turn on.

Speaking of, he looked past Lily’s bobbing head to see his mate staring down at Lily’s exposed pussy hungrily, his eyes dark with lust. His mate held up his still half-full glass and swirled it at him with a cheeky grin and a wink.

James laughed and nodded eagerly, earning a narrowed eye stare from his girl, her pretty lips sealed tight around his shaft. When she felt Sirius’ hand running up and down her glistening lips, she froze, when he crouched down behind her and she felt his warm breath on her nethers, her eyes widened.

When Sirius upended the rest of his glass and emptied its contents in the crease of her beautiful bum, his tongue catching the cool liquid as it washed over her nethers, Lily spat out his cock and squealed.

James barked out a laugh, running his hand through her ginger hair soothingly as she gasped and shook from the sensation. ‘S-so cold!’ she whined, pouting up at him adorably as Sirius feasted on her womanhood. She stuck out her lip in a naughty pout and fondled his balls as if in apology, ‘I’m s-sorry honey, y-you were right.’

Instead of answering, James only smiled wide and guided her lips back to his cock. Lily had her eyes screwed shut, her bum gyrating on Sirius’ face as he ate her out, but when she felt him tugging her towards his cock, she stared up at him and eagerly swallowed him whole.

‘Bloody hell!’ His exclamation earned him an adorable, muffled chuckle from Lily as she stared up into his eyes.

He’d fallen in love with her at first sight. The time they’d spent together as a couple made up a huge majority of his fondest memories, but seeing her right there, naughtily looking up at him with his cock in her mouth and his mate eating her out, she’d never looked more beautiful.

And he’d never loved her more.

He tried to convey those feelings through his eyes alone, and, as if it were a sign that they were meant to be together, he felt Lily instantly understood. Her eyes glistening and twinkled with joy, her lips going all the way down to the base of his shaft and kissing his hairless groin.

That, unfortunately, spelt his end. James arched his back, his orgasm rapidly approaching. ‘Lils!’ he cried, and his girlfriend thankfully understood as she pulled back until her lips were only sealed around his knob.

When he came, it felt like stars burst behind his eyes, his entire body assaulted by waves of euphoria starting from his cock and spreading out to every inch of his being. He’d never had an orgasm as powerful in his entire life, and he put it all down to the insanity of that evening. Watching Sirius have his wicked way with his girl and seeing her reaction to his centaur-cock honestly just drove him wild.

When his senses returned to him, he was greeted to the beautiful sounds of his girl’s musical moans. Lily had her head buried in his groin, his cock now spent and shrivelled, while Sirius continued eating her out with gusto.

As if sensing he’d returned, Lily looked up at him, her mouth open and features set in a mask of perpetual pleasure as a steady stream of rapturous gasps escaped from between her glistening lips.

‘You, mmh, you need to get some pointers from Sirius,’ Lily only half joked as she held onto him for dear life. ‘I, hah, I don’t know what he’s doing with his tongue, but it feels amazing.’

James smiled wide, figuring it was the perfect time to drop the bomb he’d been planning for weeks now. ‘Why would I do that?’ he teased, only half meaning it, his hands grasping hers and interlocking their fingers together. ‘What’s the point of setting up Sirius to be your bull if he can’t do this for you whenever you both like?’

Lily’s eyes widened in shock and, before she could even get a word out, her entire body started to shake and convulse as her orgasm unexpectedly crashed into her.

‘Wait, what?’ Sirius popped up from behind Lily, his eyes equally wide in surprise. James held onto his girlfriend’s hands as she thrashed in bliss, but looked over at his best mate.

‘You heard me. I told you I’m a pervert, this is my Christmas present to both of you,’ he explained with a shrug, reaching over Lily’s back and holding his fist out. ‘It couldn’t be anyone else.’

Almost in shock, his eyes wide and his mouth agape, Sirius absentmindedly reached out and they bumped fists. ‘This…wow, this is a lot.’

James shrugged. ‘Don’t overthink it - I know you’ve always fancied Lily, and while you can’t have her, I don’t mind sharing a little.’

Almost in a trance, Sirius got up off the floor and sat on the bed beside them, his hand running up and down the curve of Lily’s spine appreciatively as he stared at her writhing form in awe. ‘Mate…you’re mental.’

James shrugged as they waited for Lily to recover. She was holding onto his waist in a deathgrip and James was running his hand through her hair soothingly. ‘It’s not entirely selfless. The thought of Lily cutting loose and being my little slut is…really hot.’

Sirius held his hands up. ‘Mate, if she’s down for it I’m not gonna bloody complain. Honestly, I’m still just shocked she hasn’t cut your bollocks off yet.’

‘I’m still thinking about it,’ Lily hissed with a groan, her voice muffled by his groin. She gingerly rose herself up, half sitting in his lap as she stared into his eyes. ‘What…did you mean? Exactly?’

James shrugged, taking her hands in his again. ‘Whenever you want, whenever you feel the itch, you can shag Sirius and only Sirius. The only rule I have is no secrets, other than that, have at it.’

Lily was gaping at him in shock, her entire body flushed with both embarrassment and arousal, and from her recent exertions. Sirius…Sirius looked like he wanted to drop to his knees and worship the ground he walked on. His hand was already pumping at his gargantuan shaft, spreading his pre-cum over the entire length and preparing himself for what was to come.

‘And you didn’t think we should maybe talk about this first?’ she hissed, her rising anger now contributing to her flushed features as she looked between the two of them.

‘Not really,’ James shrugged. ‘It was supposed to be a surprise, and this is us talking about it. I’m not forcing you to do anything and if you say no, I’ll never bring it up again and Sirius will just have to get over it.’

Lily’s gaze turned to his best mate and a hand flew to her mouth to stifle a laugh at the genuine puppy-dog look in his eyes. Honestly, it was even more effective than if he’d switched to his animagus form to try it.

Lily turned back to him, the anger having seeped out of her as she bit her lower lip sexily. ‘And…what about us?’

‘What about us?’ James asked in confusion. ‘After we graduate, I’m going to marry you and we’re gonna spend the rest of our lives together. We’ll live in a charming little cottage somewhere and we’ll have five children that’ll each have your beautiful eyes.’

Whatever she’d expected him to say, it certainly wasn’t that. Her hand flew to her mouth and her eyes glistened with unshed tears. They’d of course talked about their future before, it was kind of inevitable after dating for several years, but never had he been so forthright about it.

When she removed her hand, James’ breath hitched at the sight of her breathtaking smile, her entire face radiant and lit up by her happiness. ‘I…really like the sound of that.’

James nodded and thanked Merlin that his best mate had the good sense to remain silent, lest he spoil the mood.

To be fair, he’d been on his best behaviour that night.

‘And of course, Uncle Sirius will come visit all the time to spoil his Godchildren, and, when they go to bed…’ he sent a wink to his gobsmacked best mate before turning back to his future wife, ‘And when they go to bed, he’ll spoil you too.’

Lily’s eyes fluttered closed, her mouth dropped open and she shook as the words washed over her. ‘Only you could come up with something so beautiful and deranged at the same time…’

‘Oh?’ James teased, pulling his girlfriend into his lap and hugging her close. ‘Are you saying you’re not interested? Have I just imagined you being unable to keep your eyes and hands off Sirius’ hog all night?’

Lily whined and buried her face in his chest in embarrassment. He laughed however when she cracked open an eye and stared at the towering pillar of manflesh once more, her eyes clearly smouldering with desire.

‘I thought so.’

‘This is crazy!’ she exclaimed in a shaky voice, not even bothering to deny or hide it anymore and openly staring at Sirius’ cock. ‘You know this isn’t normal, right?’

James leaned down and pressed his lips against her ear. ‘Your sister is normal,’ he purred, shuffling back so Lily was laying on her back with her head in his lap, her legs spread wide and her pussy bare and exposed to his ravenous best mate. ‘She’s about to get married to some boring man and live a boring life in the ‘burbs. Why would you want to be normal?’

Lily’s breathing had become heavy as she watched Sirius crawl towards her on his knees, his hand massaging his knob as he stared at her, salivating as if she was a perfectly cooked dragon-rib steak.

Grabbing a pillow and stuffing it in his lap to make sure she was comfortable, his hands glided down her body and cupped her heavy tits as Sirius settled between her splayed thighs.

She didn’t protest for a second, she didn’t even move until Sirius had his huge knob pressed against her delicate flower. Before his best mate sealed the deal and impaled the one pussy he’d always desired, but had always been out of reach, Lily looked up into his eyes. They were no longer hesitant - ever since he’d brought up Petunia, he’d lit a fire under her, stoking the embers of her libido into a roaring inferno. ‘Is…is this really what you want?’

In answer, James leaned down and placed a tender kiss on her soft lips. When he pulled back, he was staring into her eyes, her face up-side down in his vision. ‘What I want is for you to want it. Do you want it?’

Almost hesitantly, shd nodded, the motion so minute it could have easily been confused for a shiver. James smiled lovingly at Lily and brushed a strand of hair out of her eye. ‘Don’t tell me, tell him.’

Sirius, the good lad that he was, had paused and kept his knob kissing Lily’s lips. Knowing how much his mate wanted to shag his girl, James could appreciate the herculean willpower on display in holding himself steady.

When Sirius saw her staring at him, he raised an eyebrow in expectation.

Lily inhaled deeply for several seconds, clearly psyching herself up for what she was about to say. ‘Sirius…add another notch to your bedpost...’

Sirius’ face had been set in stone as he beheld their tender moment silently, but the second he heard Lily’s request, a vulpine grin graced his features, his groan as he pressed forward and sank into his girlfriend, her lips parting almost obscenely wide, almost animalistic.

Lily’s eyes widened in shock and her back arched in pleasure as Sirius carefully sank inch after inch of his huge cock inside Lily’s warm, snug womanhood. Throughout her impalement, Lily didn’t tear her gaze away from his own. She said no words, her mouth open in a silent scream the entire time, but her beautiful, expressive eyes told a story more clearly than any book could manage.

Shock. Surprise, Disbelief. Guilt. Pleasure. More Guilt. Euphoria.

‘Talk to me,’ James whispered urgently as Sirius bumped up against Lily’s cervix and started to gently apply pressure. His mate had had a lot of experience with that beater’s bat he carried around, he knew to be careful to not hurt his lovers. ‘How do you feel?’

Lily’s cheeks were perpetually darkened with an intense blush, her back arching with every spike of pleasure shooting through her. James was cupping her heavy tits and bouncing them in the palm of his hand, adding to her pleasure by running his fingers around and brushing her nipples.

His girlfriend seemed to come to a decision, and her eyes fluttered closed before they snapped open and she stared directly into his soul.

‘He’s so big,’ she whined, letting out a long, keening wail as Sirius kept himself sheathed and increased the pressure against her cervix. Biting her lip, she grinned cheekily at him and moaned again, loud and proud. ‘So much bigger than you. He’s, mmm, touching places that have never been touched!’

James grinned and Lily squealed when he pinched her nipples. ‘You’re such a naughty little slut…’

‘I am!’ she agreed, sighing in disappointment when Sirius started to slowly pull out, her lips looking unwilling to let go of the girthy invader. ‘Oh God, I’m the worst! Sirius, you feel so good!’

‘We haven’t even started yet luv,’ he said with a deep chuckle, clearly struggling to hold himself back.

James slowly ran his hands down her flat tummy, letting her tits sag under their own weight. He had a new target, and when his fingers found her sensitive nub and started to gently brush against it, his girl squealed.

With his other hand, he pressed down firmly on her mons. Her look of confusion was just perfect, unsure what he was trying to achieve. When Sirius thrust back in however, she understood.

‘Oh God!’ she bucked and groaned as Sirius’ thick cock scraped against her g-spot in passing, the pressure James applied from the outside adding to the pleasure as he felt Lily’s insides bulge to accommodate his girth. ‘Oh Gooooood!’

‘Good girl,’ James praised, rubbing her clit and continuing to press down on her mons as his friend slid back in. ‘How does that feel?’

‘Oh my, oh Jesus,’ she gasped, her head rocking from side to side as she tried to thrash off the bed. Thankfully, he was holding her down and she was forced to endure the intense pleasure they were both subjecting her to. ‘Sirius,’ she gasped breathlessly, both of them reacting in shock at hearing her call his name out like that for the first time - with pure lust - ‘Go faster, please, mmm, I can take it, please.’

Sirius smiled wide and, with a jerk of his hips, he thrust all the way until his knob was pressing against her cervix again.

‘Oh fuck!’ Lily uncharacteristically cursed, her legs wrapped around Sirius’ waist and holding him close, unwilling to let him go. ‘So big, so deep, oh Jesus!’

‘Name’s Sirius, not Jesus,’ Padfoot joked and Lily let out a breathy laugh, her back arching in pleasure.

‘Keep, mmm, keep shagging me like this and I’ll start taking your name in vain too!’

‘As the lady wishes,’ Sirius joked and Lily moaned so loud James was worried the other students that had stayed behind would hear her.

Then again, someone walking in on us right now would be so crazy hot… imagine Snivellus seeing his precious crush like this…

With James playing with her clit and putting pressure on her g-spot and Sirius hitting her deep and rearranging her insides, it didn’t take long for Lily to have her first orgasm. When he felt it coming, Sirius quickly pulled out, much to Lily’s consternation and whining protests, but when he stuck his fingers inside her and started rubbing against her g-spot directly - adding to the pleasure James was providing by doing it from the outside - her hips almost launched off the bed and she cried with bliss.

‘Oh no, I’m, I’m -!’

‘Shh,’ James shushed, kissing her on the forehead. ‘Let go, that’s a good girl, let it out.’

With a wail that he’d never forget for the rest of his life, Lily came undone. All the strength left her body and she started to shake as her face scrunched up with pleasure, her womanhood gushing out as she soaked the bed with her squirting ejaculation.

Lily looked down the length of her body in shock, her eyes wide as Sirius’ hand pistoned in and out of her, her squirt seemingly lasting forever.

James had made her squirt in the past, but she’d never cum this hard before.

When the waves of euphoria let up and Lily was able to form coherent sentences again, she looked at the both of them in awe before chuckling, her tone deep and sultry.

‘How was that?’ Sirius asked smugly. He was still as hard as a beater’s bat and slapping Lily’s hypersensitive womanhood with meaty thwacks that ripped more tired moans from his exhausted girlfriend. ‘Did I pass my audition? Happy to have me as your bull, luv?’

‘Oh God,’ Lily groaned as she covered her face with her hands, though she was unable to hide her giddy smile. ‘Hearing you say it out loud is so embarrassing!’

Sirius ignored her and instead started tapping her clit with his heavy member, a cheeky grin on his face. ‘So…that’s a no then? One and done?’

Knowing what he wanted to hear, Lily looked up at him with an impish grin before turning back to Sirius. ‘Alright, that was the best sex I’ve ever had, are you happy?’

‘Not quite,’ Sirius teased, rubbing the length of his shaft against her glistening lips. ‘Am I your bull? Can I shag you whenever I want?’

Lily groaned and covered her face with her hands again before answering. ‘Yes, oh my God I can’t believe I’m agreeing to this nonsense, but yes.’

Unable to help himself, James pulled her hands away and bent down to capture her lips in a kiss so passionate, he almost forgot he needed to breathe. ‘I love you so much, my kinky little slut.’

Sirius chuckled. ‘The women of Hogwarts are going to riot. Why would I settle for any of them when I can now shag you whenever I want?’ He suddenly frowned, as if an unpleasant thought occurred to him. ‘Oh bloody hell my present is gonna look absolutely pants compared to giving me your girl!’

‘Lending,’ James corrected with a cheeky grin. ‘You should still probably find a girl of your own one of these days. Someone has to house train you.’

‘Oi!’

Lily chuckled at his aggrieved expression, though the heat of her teasing and ridicule had certainly come down to a simmer ever since he’d rearranged her insides. She was now looking at him with far more fondness, the disgust she often regarded him with long gone.

James leaned down and placed another kiss on his girl’s lips before getting up with a groan, his legs having fallen asleep. ‘I’m gonna take a piss, don’t do anything I wouldn’t do.’

Both Sirius and Lily smiled at his joke, but didn’t otherwise react. Their gazes were fixed on one another, their eyes smouldering with their lust.

James quickly emptied his bladder and splashed some water on his face. Looking at himself in the mirror, he grinned wide and shook his head in disbelief.

I can’t believe everything worked out okay…

Ever since it had become painfully obvious that his best made harboured a crush on his girl almost as strong as his own, James hadn’t been able to get the mental image of Sirius shagging her with his huge cock out of his mind.

When they first started dating, it had taken a while for things to finally escalate in the bedroom. Lily had been a virgin and James didn’t want to pressure her into anything she wasn’t comfortable with. When she’d finally given herself to him, it had been magical, and his love for her had solidified, but a part of him always desired her to be more kinky, more outgoing.

There was just something about corrupting his pure, innocent girlfriend that drove him crazy.

His thoughts were interrupted by a rapturous moan from the bedroom and the grin on James’ face looked borderline deranged.

Lily had been the epitome of an innocent girl-next-door when he first met her. Wide-eyed, pure, impressionable and innocent.

Now? Now she was in his bed with his best mate and, by the sounds of it, shagging his brains out.

My perfect little slut. I can’t wait to put a ring on your finger.

His biggest and only regret was that they’d both agreed to wait until after they graduated before getting married.

Chuckling, James grabbed his rock-hard cock and tugged it several times. Perfectly adequate, but in comparison to Sirius, it may as well belong to a child. Instead of just imagining and trying to remember what Lily’s perfect little pussy looked like when stretched wide by his best mate, James decided to go back to the bedroom and see for himself.

Opening the door, he crossed his arms, leaned against the doorframe and just watched the action going on on his bed. Sirius was laying on his back and Lily was riding him, her long coppery hair falling down her back in wavy, glossy tresses. James’ eyes trailed down her back and went lower to see Sirius’ big balls beneath Lily’s glorious, soft, bouncing bum.

‘Bloody shit,’ Lily groaned, her head swaying from side to side as she rode Sirius like he was a stallion. James greedily drank in the sight of her pussy gliding up and down his mate’s obscenely thick, veiny shaft, his hand gripping his own cock and wanking unashamedly.

As if sensing his presence, Lily turned her head and smiled when she saw what he was doing, the expression so beautiful it almost made his knees weak. ‘James,’ she gasped, biting her lip sexily as she watched him wank. Her gaze trailed down his beefy body before reaching his much smaller cock. Her condescending smirk as she watched him wank almost made him cum on the spot, and when her gaze flicked back up to meet his own, her cheeky expression almost made him fall in love all over again. ‘Go to the tree and get my present to you, you’ll need it.’

His eyebrows raised in curiosity, he grabbed his invisibility cloak and briefly considered leaving the door wide open before, wisely, thinking better of it.

Baby steps, Potter.

He was like a wraith as he snuck down to the common room, finding Lily’s present for him and snatching it up. There were a handful of people milling about, but the large area was mostly empty.

When he slipped back into their dorm room, he just watched as Lily kept riding Sirius. Realising he was standing in an open doorway, his girl’s rapturous moans audible to anybody that happened upon them, he quickly shut the door behind him and stepped inside. Turning at the sound of the door, Lily eyed him with a breathless smile and motioned to the small, gift wrapped package with a flick of her head.

‘Open it,’ she urged, her voice sounding strained and her breath coming in ragged, sensual pants.

Shrugging, James unwrapped the small package blindly, his eyes refusing to look anywhere but at his girlfriend’s impaled pussy. When he felt the cool glass of whatever was inside, his confusion rose when he realised he was holding a small, unlabelled vial of a mystery liquid he didn’t recognise.

Lily was still looking over her shoulder at him and smiling, her teeth nibbling at her lower lip. Noticing his confusion, her smile widened. ‘Remember when you, mmm, asked to bugger me?’

James’ eyes widened in shock and he almost dropped the vial in surprise. ‘Is this…?’

Sirius reached up and pinched her nippled before she could answer, her squeal then moan as he played with her body briefly scrambling her brain. When she returned to her senses, she bit her lip again and smiled, nodding at the vial. ‘Pour some out on your finger, then put it in my bum.’

James was sure he looked utterly ridiculous as he practically bounced over to the bed. His girlfriend’s almost mocking laughter as she watched his far less impressive manhood smacking against his thighs was not even close to enough to dampen his excitement.

Lily was a genius at potions and alchemy, he was sure whatever she’d concocted would work exactly as she described.

‘Pour a few drops onto your fingers,’ she instructed in between moans, ‘then lather it up until you, mmm, have a grease-like substance.’ Her eyes closed and her head tilted back as she continued to carefully bounce up and down Sirius’ cock.

James did as instructed, the oil acting exactly as Lily said it would. Figuring he knew what to do from here, he put a hand on his girl’s shoulder, causing her to stop her bouncing, rocking motions.

Lily looked over her shoulder at him again, her bottom lip firmly between her teeth as she watched. James spread Lily’s ass wide and, upon seeing her rosebud, he carefully slid a grease-clad finger inside.

She was tight, really tight. ‘Relax,’ he soothed, hoping to get her sphincter to loosen.

‘Easy for you to say,’ Lily said with a shaky, breathless laugh. ‘Maybe I should try sticking my finger in your bum.’

‘Okay,’ James instantly agreed, catching her off-guard. He winked at her look of shock and, when he felt her muscles relax, he slipped his finger through the tight ring of muscle.

Lily’s mouth dropped open in a silent scream, her eyes wide and the corners of her eyes crinkled. James used his free hand to thread itself in her hair, gently cradling the back of her head while the other slowly pistoned in and out of her, spreading the grease along her back door liberally.

‘How’d you know this stuff works if you didn’t try it on yourself?’ Sirius asked in confusion, watching the proceedings with interest.

‘Friend volunteered,’ she grunted, breathing heavily. ‘She said she loves it.’

James almost laughed at the conflicted look on Sirius’ face. To his credit, he tried to bite his tongue, he really did.

‘And what’s this friend’s name?’

Lily’s head snapped back to him, her eyes narrowed. ‘I thought you didn’t need the other slags now that you can shag me whenever you want?’

It was a glorious thing to see Sirius’ cheeks pinken like a child with his hand caught in the cookie jar. ‘I - I mean - I’m not -’

Realising his best strategy was to distract her, Sirius lurched up, grabbed Lily’s heavy, pendulous breasts in his hands, squished them together and feasted on her nipples.

James felt Lily’s rear end relax even more as she instead focused on Sirius’ suckling. He noticed something else incredible too, not only was Lily loosening up, but he felt his fingers grow pleasantly, unnaturally warm.

Figuring it would be best if he went for it now while she was distracted, James slipped his fingers out and got into position behind her, his knob pressed against her winking rosebud.

Lily’s head was swaying left to right as Sirius feasted on her tits, her hips swivelling in delight as his mere presence stirred up her insides. When she felt his knob slip into her backdoor however, she sucked in a shocked breath and froze.

‘You good?’ he whispered softly, gently brushing her hair back behind her ear as he carefully fully sheathed himself inside her, his broad chest pressed against her sweat-slicked back. He didn’t know the exact purpose of Lily’s mysterious concoction, but he’d slipped inside far more easily than his finger had been able to - he guessed some kind of relaxant and lubricant.

‘Mhmm,’ she hummed in approval, after getting over her shock. Her head had lolled back and rested against his shoulder as James started to carefully thrust in and out of her bum. Sirius remained perfectly still, waiting for Lily to grow used to the second invader.

‘You’re such a perfect little slut,’ James purred, his fingers dancing up her ribcage and palming her heavy tits. He kissed and suckled her neck and Lily moaned in bliss at the added stimulation.

‘Both of my boys are filling me up so well,’ she whined and James throbbed inside her at her words. Sirius seemed inspired by them too as he started to time his upward thrusts with his own. ‘Oh God, I’m so full, mmm, I can’t believe I’m doing this, hah…’

While James wanted nothing more than to go crazy, he and Sirius both kept up their slow and steady pace. Their lovemaking was less frenetic and more passionate, Lily didn’t so much bounce on their cocks as she undulated and danced, while James and Sirius matched her energy.

Her moans were deep and sensual, the most beautiful sound James had ever heard, and when she came, she did so with a shuddering gasp, one of her hands reaching back to encircle his neck while the other palmed the side of Sirius’ face.

They kept up this slow and steady shagging and Lily came several more times between them, the intensity of each orgasm seemingly more powerful than the last. James also noticed his cock starting to tingle, just like his fingers had earlier. It wasn’t unpleasant, if anything, it only added to his pleasure and made it harder for him to hold on.

‘I don’t know what you put in that potion of yours, but I won’t last much longer…’

Lily didn’t laugh so much as she smiled wide and leaned back against him. ‘I knew you’d like it,’ she whispered. ‘Cum in my bum baby, fill me up.’

‘I’m gonna cum soon too,’ Sirius announced with a grunt. ‘Where -’

‘In me.’ Lily’s answer brook no argument. ‘I want both of my boys to fill me up.’

James bit down on Lily’s slender neck to muffle his animalistic groan of desire. His girlfriend whimpered, but didn’t object, urging him again to cum in her.

When he did, his vision whited out again and he saw stars. He was quickly followed by Sirius, who roared his release and emptied a sizable load right into his girlfriend’s - thankfully - magically infertile womb. As if triggered by their releases, Lily came again as she was filled with their seed, her moans a beautiful, erotic symphony.

They eventually collapsed on his bed in a tangle of limbs, Lily snuggling up between them with a supremely satisfied smile on her serene face. The three of them watched as his girlfriend spread her lips wide and cum oozed out of her in thick, globby rivulets. James wrapped his arms around her waist when the show was over and pulled her close until they were face to face.

‘Merry Christmas,’ he whispered, pecking her on the lips. ‘You were perfect.’

Her beautiful emerald orbs were glistening and staring into his soul. ‘Was it everything you imagined?’

James grinned, not denying he’d been fantasising about this for a while. ‘It was way better.’

Lily stretched and purred like a kitten as she made herself comfortable in his arms, her head resting on his shoulder. In a move that would have had Sirius with a set of cursed bollocks only a couple of hours ago, he snuggled right in behind her, his face pressed against her back and his hands cupping her heavy tits.

‘Less talking more sleeping,’ he grunted, earning a giggle from Lily when he pinched her nipples.

Lily’s playfully twinkling eyes stared into his own as she ground her bum against Sirius’ deflated cock. ‘He’s so much bigger than you,’ she whispered so quietly it was barely above a gust of air, her lips right up against his ear. ‘Did you like watching him spread my little pussy wide open? I hope so, you’re going to see a lot more of it.’

Impossibly, James felt himself grow hard again and Lily smiled wide as she reached down and felt his reaction to her words. Smiling just as wide as his girlfriend, they passionately kissed and whispered sweet nothings until they fell asleep.

He was awoken again several hours later by a gentle rocking motion. The fire had died out but the room was still comfortably warm enough for it not to have been an issue. Rubbing the sleep from his eyes, he looked to the side to see Lily on her hands and knees with Sirius kneeling behind her. His hands were on her hips and he was shagging her from behind, his eyes screwed shut and his head tilted back in bliss.

Lily was more aware of her surroundings, and instantly realised he was no longer sleeping. Biting her lip, she smiled down at him as her body rocked with the motions, her heavy tits swaying back and forth as Sirius had his way with her.


He heard Lily’s soft laugh as his eyes noticeably zeroed in on her baps, their hypnotic movements an incredible sight.

James’ hand instantly went to his raging erection, the thought that they’d started shagging right by his sleeping form turning him on like crazy.

‘Sorry,’ she whispered, sounding genuinely apologetic. ‘I couldn’t help it. I dreamt about Sirius. How big he was, how he made me feel, how much more he stretches me than you… I had to have it again.’

James sucked in an excited breath, his hand like a blur as he wanked his aching cock while watching them. Lily delivered her words with an intensity that took his breath away, completely honest and eager to see his reaction, her beautiful emerald eyes smouldering with desire. He didn’t resist when Lily bent down and captured his lips in a searing kiss, a very notable salty tang on her lips.

When she pulled away, she was grinning wickedly at him. ‘You better get used to that taste, my love.’

‘Fuck, I love you so much…’

Her smile became less wicked and more loving as she bent down to kiss him again. She batted his hand away from his shaft and took to wanking him herself. She pulled back, pressing her forehead to his, ‘I can’t have my boys wanking, that’s my job.’

James screwed his eyes shut and pulled Lily back into a heated, passionate kiss. He’d awoken something deviant inside his once-innocent girlfriend, and he couldn’t be happier.

Best Christmas Ever.

Bonus Scene:

After the holiday break, classes had started up again where they’d left off. With the castle filled to the brim with students once more, James and Lily found little time to play like they had during the holidays.

James had left Moony and Wormtail after their shared Magical Creatures class; he had the rest of the day off while they had other classes to attend. He was heading back to the dorm to meet up with Sirius, as his girlfriend would be busy with classes for the rest of the day and his best mate only had Defence Against the Dark Arts that morning, having organised his schedule to have as much time off as possible - even if that meant they couldn’t share as many classes.

When he slipped into the room he shared with his mates, however, he looked around in surprise when he found it utterly silent.

Sirius always waited for him to finish his classes so they could either go play some Quidditch or hit the gym together. His absence was…notable.

As he dropped his bag, his face scrunched up in confusion, James pondered on the mystery before his eyes widened in shock. Hurrying over to his chest, he opened the hidden compartment and fished out the Marauder’s Map. His cock throbbed and he sucked in an excited breath at what he saw.

Oh you filthy little slag!

James quickly changed into something more comfortable and dug out his invisibility cloak, throwing the magical artefact over his shoulders and slipping out of his room unnoticed.

As he made his way into the busy common room, he reflected. When they’d first started their magical education at Hogwarts, they’d been put in rooms with other first years to help them acclimatise better and foster lasting friendships. The Marauders were all put to one room and they hadn’t seen a need to upgrade since. They enjoyed rooming together and were incredibly close.

Lily was different. Though she had gotten on with her roommates fine, she preferred her privacy and liked to study in silence. As soon as she was able, she’d opted for her own room, her rich, muggle parents happily footing the bill for the upgrade when they saw how excellent her grades were.

Lily had been ecstatic with the upgrade, if for no other reason that she no longer had to field the constant, annoying complaints about her perpetually bubbling cauldron from her roommates.

James snuck his way through the stairwells until he found himself outside his girlfriend’s room, plastering himself against the wall and waiting until the coast was clear.

When he no longer heard any footsteps on the stone floors, he slipped inside Lily’s room, pausing in shock at the sight that greeted him.


Lily’s room was half the size of theirs, a pretty sweet deal given it only housed a quarter of the students. To the left was a dresser and the door to her bathroom and to the right was her potion’s lab. Directly across from the door was Lily’s bed, the foot facing him, and a large window providing a gorgeous view of the castle’s grounds.

His girlfriend’s rapturous moans and the sound of hurried footsteps on the stairwell behind him broke him out of his stupor and he quickly shut the door behind him. Neither of the lovers on the bed even noticed their visitor, but he didn’t doubt some of his fellow Gryffindors had heard his girlfriend’s moaning, and would be able to trace it to her door.

I wonder if they’ll be able to put two and two together…

The thought had his cock throbbing almost as much as the delectable sight before him.

Lily was on her back with Sirius hovering over her missionary, her legs bent back and hooked over his hairy thighs. James’ position gave him a perfect view of his girlfriend’s pale ass, her rosebud fully exposed and her pussy lips spread obscenely wide as Sirius’ huge cock drilled down into her over and over.

His best mate was giving her the full experience, pulling all the way out until only his knob was nestled in her inflamed womanhood - honestly, it must have been quite the workout - before plunging back down as far as Lily’s pussy would allow, his hips grinding against her when he bottomed out.

It wasn’t hard or fast fucking, it was slow, measured and purposeful, and each time Sirius bottomed out in his girlfriend, stretching her and filling her to the brim, Lily would moan in exultation.

James quickly removed his clothes and palmed his rock-hard cock. Though he was still hidden by his invisibility cloak, he doubted it was necessary. Sirius and Lily were in their own little world and wouldn’t have noticed him even if he started doing cartwheels behind them.

‘Ooooooh fuuuuuuuck,’ Lily groaned and Sirius plunged his way back into his girl once again. ‘Oooooh, I needed this so much!’

Sirius chuckled, his voice hoarse with exertion. ‘Yeah?’ he teased, lifting himself up and plunging down again, ripping pleased moans from both of their throats. ‘You - hnn - you missed this, didn’t you?’

‘Yesssssss,’ she hissed, wrapping her arms around his shoulders and pulling him close. James noted that she still didn’t kiss him, turning her head when Sirius leaned down to capture her lips. It was an odd little quirk he’d noticed during their marathon shagging session over Christmas - not that he minded either way, though he found the gesture sweet.

‘Oh God I missed your big cock!’ She groaned, the words coming out in a guttural snarl that sent a spike of pleasure through James’ shaft. As Sirius chuckled, James moved around the bed and blindly reached for the chair by Lily’s potions lab and spun it around so he could take a seat.

When Lily saw the chair moving in her peripheral vision, she started and squealed in surprise, her eyes wide in shock. The look quickly faded however when she put two and two together and she smirked.

‘Finished with classes - nnh - my love?’

Sirius started in surprise at her question and followed her gaze. James whipped off the cloak and grinned at them impishly, his hand slowly pumping his far less impressive endowment.

‘You’re skipping classes now?’ James teased, after answering her question in the positive. ‘Such a bad girl.’

Lily’s laugh was breathless and the flush on her cheeks deepened. Her skin was glistening with sweat, the tips of her coppery tresses wet and stuck to her skin. Sirius looked likewise exerted, going back to his deep, penetrative thrusts with a grin.

They’ve been at this for a while…did they skip all their classes to fuck?! That’s so hot!

‘I - hah - I needed to feel this cock again,’ she whined, smiling up at Sirius as he kept up his relentless, measured thrusts. ‘I missed it - mmm - this is your fault James… you made me a dirty girl.’

James laughed and got off his chair, kneeling down on the floor beside the bed and taking her hand. She squeezed him, turning her head and smiling at him lovingly as Sirius kept fucking her. As much as he just wanted to sit back, watch and wank, he couldn’t help himself, she looked so beautiful, so naughty…

Leaning in, he captured her lips in a searing kiss, swallowing his girlfriend’s moans as Sirius kept up his deep thrusts. Lily deepened the kiss, threaded her hand into his messy, brown hair and groaned into his mouth when Sirius bottomed out again.

She pulled back when his best mate bottomed out once more and gave him a naughty grin. ‘Sit in the chair,’ she ordered and, with a dopey grin, he did as his horny girlfriend ordered. Lily slapped Sirius on the chest and whispered something in his ear, the intimate nature of the act sending another lance of pleasure through his already hyper-sensitive shaft.

I’m so messed up. Why is this so bloody hot?!

Sirius apparently did as Lily asked, pulling out of her inflamed and gaping pussy and flopping down onto her bed on his back, his cock a towering pillar of prime masculinity. Lily shuffled over and crouched over her bull, her back to Sirius and facing him while holding the huge cock against her once-tight pussy.

‘You want to watch me fucking this huge cock baby?’ Lily teased, her lips into a teasing grin and her voice oozing mind-numbing sensuality. Lily sat on Sirius’s abdomen, grinding her pussy against his cock as she smiled naughtily at him. ‘You want to wank your little dickie while I bounce on my bull’s huge cock?’

She laughed with delight when James and Sirius both groaned with unrepressed arousal.

Biting her lip, her expression reminding him of a sultry forest nymph, she slid further up Sirius’s abdomen until she could hold his knob against her gaping lips before, without a shred of hesitation, she slid it back inside her and wiggled down until over half of his best mate’s shaft was nestled inside her.

They both groaned and James started wanking again in earnest. James couldn’t decide where to look, the sight before him a feast for the eyes. His gaze darted between her smouldering eyes, her teasing smile, her heavy, swaying tits, her thick thighs and, obviously, her beautifully impaled pussy.

Her eyes were locked on his modest erection, eyeing him with delight as she gyrated on Sirius’ cock.

‘How does it - mmm - feel to know I was fucking my bull while you were stuck in - aah - class?’

James groaned with lust, the question driving him wild. Lily chuckled at his reaction, evidently pleased by the effect her words had on him.

‘You’re so beautiful,’ James whispered reverently, and Lily’s smile briefly shifted from teasing to loving before changing back so quickly James wondered if it had been a trick of the light.

‘Wank that little dicklet for me baby,’ Lily urged, her words coming out in excited, breathy pants as her chest rose and fell rapidly.

James did as she ordered, his orgasm rapidly approaching as Lily kept talking dirty to him. When he came all over himself with a groan, his cock spewing his copious ejaculate all over his chest, Lily’s delighted, mocking laughter only spurred him on.

After he’d calmed down he looked into his deviously grinning girlfriend’s eyes, her expression turning positively wicked. ‘That was cute,’ she panted, moaning as she kept gyrating. ‘You want to see what it looks like when a real man cums though?’

James sucked in an excited breath but otherwise remained silent. Grinning wickedly, Lily redoubled her efforts, rubbing her own clit and gyrating her hips even harder.

They’d had several deep and meaningful discussions ever since Christmas Eve, where Lily interrogated him further, wanting to understand his mindset. Lily had quickly uncovered how much he got off on watching her, and, with a mysterious smile, she’d told him she thought she understood without elaborating further.

She very much channelled that energy today, teasing and mocking him while he sat there and watched her get fucked by her bull.

James couldn’t remember a time he had ever been more turned on.

He was startled out of his reverie when Sirius let them know he was cumming - it was easy to forget his best mate was even there, such was the intensity of the moment between boyfriend and girlfriend. Lily chuckled breathlessly and started to bounce, the motion doing wonderful things for her heavy tits.

When it happened, Lily froze and screwed her eyes shut, groaning as she felt Sirius filling her up with more ejaculate than he could produce in a week.

After his best mate stopped jerking and unloading in his girl, Lily relaxed and sent him a pleased, luxuriant smile. Sliding off his spent cock, Lily let out a pleased sigh when Sirius’ plum-sized knob slipped free with a wet, sucking sound and, after only a few moments of waiting, a torrent of cum quickly oozed out right after.

She stood on her knees, massaging her pussy and coaxing more and more of Sirius’ seed out of her, grinning impishly at his obvious shock and arousal.

When the deluge had abated, Lily lay against the relaxing Sirius’ side and started to stroke rapidly hardening cock to life once more.

‘Have you finished your Transfiguration assignment?’

The question was so out of the blue James shook his head in disbelief, sense slowly returning to him.

‘...huh?’

Lily’s smile widened, but she didn’t repeat the question.

Frowning, he shook his head in the negative and Lily’s smile widened further.

‘That’s enough slacking off then,’ she teased and motioned to the door with a wicked grin. ‘Only good boys that finish their homework get to play, don’t come back until all your assignments are done.’

James flushed and gaped in shock at the brutal dismissal, the implication that they’d go straight back to fucking the second he stepped out of the door causing his cock to throb with desire.

Seeing she wasn’t kidding when she raised her eyebrows at him expectantly, James bit his fist to muffle his groan and hurried over to plant a chaste kiss on her smug lips.

‘I’ll be back as soon as I can,’ he promised and Lily laughed as he hurriedly redressed.

‘Take your time,’ she teased, mounting Sirius and looking over her shoulder at him with a wicked smile before he slipped back out of her room. ‘My bull will take good care of me.’

A/N: There will definitely be a sequel(s) to this. Holy smokes, I thought this would be a quick one but words just kept coming and the word count grew more and more.

James and Sirius are best mates. There will be none of that ‘replacing’ nonsense going on. Sirius knows Lily is his best mate’s - his brother’s - girl and he’s incredibly thankful that he’s sharing her with him.

There was also no playing in between Christmas Eve and the bonus snippet at the end, I realise how I write these it makes it sound like they’re constantly shagging and James is going without.

Sirius will eventually get married too and they’ll have a swingery kind of relationship between the four of them where they often trade partners. If you have any preference for who the woman should be, let me know in the comments or on Discord. Bonus points if it’s someone interesting.