She tricked us all (Patreon)

Carol needed willingness and desire to switch bodies with another person. Unfortunately, this was never an easy thing to do. When she started learning magic five years ago, she wasn't expecting her studies to move along so slowly, but she knew what she wanted to do with her newfound abilities. Eventually, she wanted to become a more attractive woman. As a girl with low self-esteem, Carol frequently felt left out at parties and other social events. Her friends always told her that she was pretty, but she never truly felt pretty.

So when a fellow student, Miranda, offered to temporarily switch bodies with her so that she could experience what it would be like in a hot girl's shoes, Carol accepted. Miranda had studied with Carol for years, and the two girls knew each other extremely well. What the unconfident girl didn't know was that Miranda had a dark secret hiding beneath her flesh.

In reality, she wasn't a fellow student who was roughly the same age as Carol. She was a 72-year-old witch who loved to brew potions that could physically transform her into the most gorgeous woman. Sadly, old age left her joints sore, and there wasn't a spell that could alleviate it for a long enough period of time. She would have to repeatedly cast the spell, and that often required a lot of energy.

That's when she ran into Carol. Sure, she wasn't as beautiful as the women she could become with transformation potions, but the girl had a lot of untapped magical potential. Her low self-esteem and desire to switch bodies with any attractive person left her as the perfect victim for the old woman's body theft plot.

Unfortunately, Carol would realize this far too late. The two girls ended up standing at the center of their teacher's basement with their hands locked together. Uttering the spell, they both agreed to swap bodies, and the blood circle beneath their bare feet pulled their souls out of their bodies. By the time Carol had opened her eyes, she was looking back at her old body with the most evil of grins. She did her best to ignore the pain in her joints, but when she returned home, she was shocked to find her body shifting and transforming. It didn't take long before she was looking into an old woman's eyes. She let out a horrified shriek.

Meanwhile, Miranda would go on to use her new body to really enjoy life. And with the right transformation potions, she could really augment her new body well. Carol was still an attractive woman, so making a few alterations here and there were all Miranda needed to really bring her beauty out. Carol would inevitably run to her teacher for help, but even Miss Sharp was taken by surprise. 

She had no idea that Miranda had secretly been a powerful witch. She deceived everyone, and the body thief was a thousand steps ahead of them. It took some time for Miss Sharp to piece things together, but she finally realized that Miranda had been looking for the perfect victim the entire time. She always seemed like a person who was capable of more than she displayed during magic lessons, and now things made sense. Sadly, nobody would ever find out where Miranda had gone with Carol’s young body, and thanks to her transformation potions, she would forever be hidden from plain sight.

As for Carol, she would never see her body again. She had foolishly trusted someone who she thought was her friend, but that trust ended up destroying her life. All she had now was regret and the knowledge that her body was out there somewhere, being used by a twisted witch who enjoyed her stolen life to the fullest.