Let me keep her (Patreon)

"You're so bad," Chester laughed as his hands squeezed Arnold's bum. He pulled him closer as Arnold's breasts pressed up against the tall man's chest. He could feel Chester's thickening package and the swapping stone in his pocket. Chester's voice became a whisper. "What if I just fucked you over right now and told her?"

Arnold pouted. "Tell Shelly? You said yourself that she's never given you head as good as I have. Don't you have more fun with me? You know I'll let you do everything you want to MY new body."

"But even this is going a little far, don't you think? Destroying the swapping stone would make the swap irreversible. She's letting you do whatever you want in her body, but I doubt this is something she wants." Chester planted a kiss against Arnold's lips before he could respond. He was guiding them both to the nearby bed, the same one they'd shared for the past three nights. After voluntarily switching bodies, Shelly would attend a wedding that Arnold didn't want to go to, while Arnold felt what being a woman was like.

He was always curious about transitioning. But with Shelly's body at his disposal, he could skip the years of physical changes. He had everything he could have ever wanted. Soft skin, a gorgeous smile, and luscious blonde hair were all a waste in Shelly's hands. With Arnold in her body, he could turn heads and make everybody swoon. Just as Arnold fell onto the bed, he felt Chester placing something hard in his hand. "Do what you have to do," the man said in a low voice. "Become her forever."

Smiling, Arnold threw the stone across the room and watched it land in the nearby fireplace. Chester kissed the side of his neck as he watched the stone turn the fire green, only for the dark magic to disperse and crackle with the melting stone. The only way to reverse the body swap was gone, and Shelly would be stuck as him forever.