Home Artists Posts Import Register

Content

With Supernatural coming to a close next week... omg 15 seasons over next week.

OK back on track.

What do you want to see take it's place? I would LOVE if Supernatural viewers had a bit more of a say in the discussion as it's their time slot but feel free to voice your opinion regardless :)

Please recommend stuff that I'd like :P

Comments

Anonymous

I know you really hate zombies but I feel like it’ll be a fail not to recommend The walking dead it’s one of my all time favourite shows and has 10 seasons of content!

Tony

Yeah nooooo... The Walking Dead will never happen :D

Anonymous

I mean I kinda guessed haha

ThatGuy11200

I'd like to see Grimm because it's one of my favourite series and, at the current pace, it will take you several years to get through it all. But I'm not sure it's that popular. Perhaps something short like The Boys could take that spot instead. That is if you liked the first episode enough to continue it. I'm not here for Supernatural.

Anonymous

It’s a fantastic show and even though I knew the answer I still never to try 😂

MyDanishThoughts

I'd like to see Vikings. That show too is about to end. Found your channel through Supernatural and have since followed your reactions to the Arrowverse as well.

Mariah Libby

I really think you should do Shadowhunters.

Anonymous

I'm thinking Spartacus since its only 4 seasons if Shan wants to watch a bunch of attractive shirtless guys fight to the death (recommend watching the series on blu-ray to watch the extended versions of most of the episodes). Maybe The 100, becuase the show does get really good past the first few episodes even though I know a lot of people weren't fans of the final season. Other than that, I wanna say American Horror Story since that has a similar tone to Supernatural but since I know Shan was a fan of Glee, i'm guessing she's already seen AHS

AfterShowReactions

If it's possible, please state whether you're here for Supernatural when recommending. As I'd just like to know what and who's interested etc :)

Anonymous

Haven or Lost Girl would be my vote.

Elisa Ingo

I'm here for Supernatural. I recommend Fringe. It's an amazing show by JJ Abrahams. I also recommend BBC's Merlin.

BJ Stephens

Out of the shows you've already seen some of I'd enjoy reactions to Chuck, Grimm, or The Librarians. But overall It should be something you enjoy watching. In the long run you need to have fun watching, or it will show and be less enjoyable for those watching you react as well, just mho.

Josh Lomax

Sticking with a supernatural theme, I'd vote for Haven, Teen Wolf or Grimm

David Brown

The Star Trek franchise. Start with Star Trek: The Next Generation. Early episodes were aired out of chronological order. This incorrect aired order is still how it's presented on Netflix and other services. If you pick this show I'll provide you with the correct order and/or discuss it with Chris in the discord spoilers section. Thank you for your consideration.

Heidi Elizabeth Marcum

I am a Supernatural fan. The early seasons are great for the most part. However, the later seasons are very hit or miss, with a lot of up and down episodes. As for which shows I would love to see you react to... I would love to see you watch and react to more Pushing Daisies, as well as to more of my favorite shows... Person of Interest, Leverage, Haven, and White Collar. Heidi

Jesus Alejo

Maybe before starting a long show you can use that free slot to finish a couple of show you've watched that have just a few episodes left, like Krypton and Cloak & Dagger... Talking about a new show, there are a few procedural shows that I really love but idk if you like that type of "police/crime" drama, the show "Castle" is one of the best ever, lots of humor, amazing relationship build up for the mains and almost no one out there reacting to it... If not, "Teen Wolf" would be really good, it gets better and better by the end of season 1 and has a huge fan base... And you can never go wrong with "Avatar"

Anonymous

Here for SPN too. I would suggest The Librarians ? I mean, you already reacted to the first season, it's a small enough show (3 more seasons of 10 episodes) and it stays in the supernatural type of theme. There's BBC Merlin and The Magicians, they're great shows too.

Josh Lomax

I second Leverage. One of my top favorite procedural shows of all time.

Jesus Alejo

I'm a Supernatural viewer, not my number 1 tho... I like the TVDU reactions, Once Upon a Time, the Arrowverse and superhero vids... But I think people reacting to some of the great procedural drama shows is something that's been missing out there

Anonymous

I'm here for supernatural, I would suggest The boys( if you want to see more of Jensen Ackles), or BBC show Merlin.

LuciferTheFallenOne666

*Supernatural Shows* Sleepy Hollow From Dusk Till Dawn American Horror Story, Teen Wolf The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina The Order Buffy The Vampire Slayer Angel ................................ Comedy Modern Family Brooklyn Nine-Nine Friends ............................. Others Scream (It is based on the slasher film series of the same name created by Kevin Williamson and Wes Craven.) The Witcher

Savannah De Tandt

I'm here for supernatural. I would suggest White collar, Grimm, La Casa De Papel (money heist) and Merlin.

Jeffrey Mlinek

Im primarily here for Supernatural and not sure if I will stay after it is over unless it gets a show I really like to replace it. Shows that I enjoy that you may enjoy? 1. Person of Interest 2. The Magicians 3. Weekly or 2 times a month movie slot

Tony

She's not big on scifi unfortunately. So Star Trek would be a long shot. She'll be watching the Stargate movie and the pilot of Stargate SG-1 soon. As scifi goes that's still grounded to modern day earth so it might be ok. But Star Trek is pushing it probably :D

Jeffrey Mlinek

Seasons 7-8 of TWD made me stop watching. I hear season 9 got better though

Tony

She's almost seen all of Supernatural, She's also seen all of Buffy and Angel and The Witcher Season 1. And all of Friends too. Thanks for the other suggestions though :)

Anonymous

Eric Kripke, Supernatural creator, is now Show Runner on The Boys. Go with that.

Anonymous

im here for supernatural i think shadowhunters

Jeffrey Mlinek

There is only 16 episodes but there will be more coming with Jensen Ackles in Season 3

Paul Gibson

I'm not a supernatural watcher but my suggestion would be to promote one of the longer running shows you enjoy from the pilot tier

Brendan O'Connor

I’m a fan of Supernatural, and if I didn’t know you’ve already watched/are watching Lucifer I would’ve recommended that. I started watching it a few months ago and I’m hooked. Besides that I would recommend The Boys, Merlin, and Brooklyn 99 (the pilot’s okay but the show really picks up after that)

Anonymous

To keep it somewhat related to SPN, either by actors, creator, supernatural theme...I suggest: The Boys(not a lot of episodes so prolly a long shot), Grimm(closest thing to SPN outhere), Walking Dead(I know, not happening), True Blood( a thousand times better than teen drama CW/MTV vampire shows), Dead Like Me(short but amazingly unique)......

David Brown

Eureka (AKA A Town Called Eureka) and Warehouse 13. These shows are connected. If you pick this, I'll provide you with a Watch Order and/or discuss it with Chris in the discord spoilers section. Thank you for your consideration.

Anonymous

Maybe you could go completely unrelated and pick from all time great shows, don't think you've done any of the greats. you've already seen GOT so not that one. But maybe: Breaking Bad, Battlestar Galactica, Deadwood....or maybe some great comedies without the fake laughs: Arrested Development, Community, Scrubs, Freaks and Geeks, IT'S ALWAYS SUNNY IN PHILADELPHIA( hint hint hint), Atlanta, Modern Family.

Collector of Stuff

Always a fan of Fringe or Leverage. Not many reactors do these show and they are great. It would be nice to see someone not doing the same shows as everyone else.

Jon

Person of Interest, the blacklist, Titans, Manifest, Young Justice, Leverage, Burn Notice

Anonymous

Make Grimm a regular. You already did a full season 1. And it's closest thing to SPN there is. And the creator David Greenwalt was producer and writer on Buffy and co-creator on Angel. Aren't those like your favourite shows?! So it just makes sense)

Anonymous

Fringe or The Blacklist would be my recommendations

Anonymous

I think she’s mentioned she doesn’t like subtitles so if she watches Money Heist she’d have to watch the dub which would be hilarious.

Steve Quast

Supernatural fan here. I second ForeverLannister's request to make Grimm a regular. Even if you only did 1 episode a week that would be amazing.

MagnusVD

I'm not a supernatural watcher(here for arrowverse, marvelverse and pilots currently) but I'm agreeing for supernatural genre: Grimm or Teen Wolf and some not as similar in vein as SPN, I would like to see you continue Gotham one day, or pick My Hero Academia as a regular show and for something not mentioned yet Dead Like Me. Maybe you can also take a look at that post some months ago about 5 shows people don't react to and choose something popular from there :)

Anonymous

I'd love to see the Magicians in the time slot

Anonymous

Vikings Teen Wolf The Fosters

Anonymous

Not a Supernatural watcher but I think Grimm would be good. A short series I’d to see as well is Selfie. Other than that Warehouse 13 and Eureka was mentioned and I second that. Along with Zoo.

Anonymous

I will say I really would be interested in your reactions to the Chilling Adventures of Sabrina and Roswell, New Mexico but if that means you have to see the original version first I think you should and that would be fun to see

Jeffrey Mlinek

Are you really not a supernatural watcher and is your name really Kevin Tran?

Wyatt

I haven’t seen supernatural and I have a list of shows you might like; however, i agree with staying in the genre and for that, you should probably pick Grimm. I mean whoever has been pick it got through an entire 22 long season. I feel like they earned it. Idk if you like Grimm as I haven’t seen it but if u do, that is what should replace it

Tom Tattershall

I am not a Supernatural watcher but I like many supernatural shows. I would like more variety instead of mostly supernatural/superhero shows. Whatever you chose, I think it should be from the pilot tier. Maybe one of the comedies: 3rd Rock from the Sun, Young & Hungry, New Girl, Sabrina the Teenage Witch, Kim Possible, or Ally McBeal. For supernatural/superhero shows: Gotham, Grimm, iZombie or The Magicians.

Zach Hershman

The 100, Fringe, Shadowhunters, Haven, and Person of Interest would all be good options. The first four are shows I'm positive you would like. PoI isn't a genre you normally do but it's a good show and has one character I know for a fact you would like.

TrekinJenn

I'm a supernatural fan. Therefore, for me it will be Fringe.

Anonymous

Would be nice to see Avatar: the last airbender, The 100 or Chilling Adventures of Sabrina (not a Supernatural fan tho)

Christopher simeon

I was a supernatural fan in the past but haven’t really enjoyed the show lately. Maybe doing a rotation with miniseries or shows with shorter seasons every week instead of just one show on that day. I recommend Russian doll

Christoffer Nilsson

I'm a Supernatural fan. and i think i would like to see Chilling Adventures of Sabrina :)

Anonymous

i would like to see person of interest

Tom Tattershall

I would be in favor of a rotation type slot as suggested. Would be good to continue a pilot pick you like for 1 season, then a different show. Definitely mix in shows with shorter seasons and/or shows with only 1, 2 or 3 seasons.

Devin Decoteau

The 100 Gotham The Magicians Brooklyn nine nine Under the Dome

Jonathan Giles

Prison break. More frequent Chuck or Grimm episodes

Anonymous

Leverage!! Such an awesome show.

Anonymous

YOU! i love that show to death (haha) and i would love if you would ever react to it!

Joseph LeRoy

Im here for Supernatural and jist about all the other shows too. Leverage, Person of Interest, White Collar, Teen Wolf, Shadowhunters, or Vikings. I love tv shows lol.

Joseph LeRoy

The Boys and BK99 are great too.

Anonymous

Prison break pleaseeee!

Anonymous

My favourite show is The Expanse but I think The Magicians would be more your kind of show.

Bryan Merino

I think you would really love the 100 or The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina. I became a Patreon because of your supernatural reaction. The end of n era.

Zoot!

I didn't read the zillion replies, I'm sure there's lots of good stuff in there. I'd like to see something fresh that nobody else is reacting to. Maybe something short? I wanted to pilot pick Dead Like Me someday, but the first episode is over an hour long so it was a pain to plan as a pick. It's only 2 seasons + movie. I'm pretty interested in seeing more of Revenge too since the pilot release ages ago. There's an older Sarah Michelle Gellar tv show called Ringer that's only 1 season - I'm not sure if its good or not. Wouldn't mind seeing a cartoon in the main schedule again, been awhile since Gravity Falls finished. That's my 2 cents.

Zoot!

I'd like to see that. Maybe Grimm or something like that. Another person meantioned Freaks and Geeks, that'd be a short one to finish off at least.

Zoot!

Ok I read a zillion replies now. I like the suggestion of promoting a pilot pick to main show slot. I like the idea of having one slot on the main schedule for short shorts/miniseries that are only 1 or 2 seasons long. I like the idea of having a comedy show on the schedule, but I'm not sure I've seen a show suggested that you'd really like there. I don't think you necessarily need something SPN-like as a replacement, but I get the idea behind that (pick something to keep the SPN fans around). One other suggestion is don't replace it. Move 2 of the arrowverse episodes to the SPN slot, then you'd have 2 per day, but spread out a bit. Maybe re-arrange so they're back to back days. Hopefully you're not too overloaded with suggestions, because I can't really decide now that I've read them all lol

Zoot!

I feel like Gotham would be a better replacement for an arrowverse show some day than to replace SPN. Also, never heard of Under the Dome, but at first I thought you meant Beneath the Dome, which is an R2D2 mockumentary lol

Taylor Richburg

I think you would really love the 100

El

seconded! I'm actually pilot picking that this month.

Anonymous

I was rewatching Charmed the original series and season 2 eps 7 Misha Collins was in it. I would love to see you reaction to maybe Haven or Roswell the original if you havent seen it. The Orville.

Tom Tattershall

You could finish The Librarians. Only 32 episodes total left in the 3 remaining seasons. You could knock it out in 4 months at 2 episodes per week.

Michele

Dark Angel Wynonna Lost Girl Grimm The Boys

Jeffrey Mlinek

Also Shameless (US) is a great show and something different that would be a great Supernatural replacement for me

Tony

She's seen all of Shameless (US) in her private time and some of the UK version :)

Jason Veevaert

Person of Interest Grimm Mystery Science Theater? (Possibly)

Taylor Richburg

You should continue shadowhunters, you always said you wanted to start it😊

Anonymous

Tru Calling i know you would like because of Eliza Dushku. Aka Faith

David Brown

SPARTACUS. You'll see a few familiar faces, and it's a really great show.

Anonymous

Gotham Van Helsing The boys Walker (new Jared Padalecki show) Jan 21 Avatar The Last Airbender Spartacus True Blood Sons of Anarchy

Anonymous

I wouldn't say no to Stargate. It starts with a movie, then Stargate SG-1, the spin-off Stargate Atlantis, 2 tv movies to end the story arcs of SG1 and another spin-off Stargate Universe.

Adira Griffin

I’m a bit late but I see a lot of people commenting about “The Magicians” I believe you’d really enjoy watching that show.

Anonymous

Based on the above, you won't lack for suggestions. I have two more not mentioned: 1) "Offspring" - One of your own homegrown dramedies involving a totally neurotic family living in Melbourne (with real Australian accents, naturally). Perhaps you've seen this live already, though when you have the time I'll never know. Seven seasons, 86 shows. Lots of room here for your reactions. 2) "White Collar" - according to IMDB, "A white-collar criminal agrees to help the FBI catch other white-collar criminals using his expertise as an art and securities thief, counterfeiter, and conman.", Six seasons, 81 episodes. I really enjoyed this series, with several major arcs throughout the six years and a small cast of "regulars" you'd come to love. The good guys survive.

David Brown

Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman (the 1990s show). I think you've said that you've only seen some of it and you don't remember much. So how about going into it with fresh eyes and watch/react to the whole show.

Anonymous

I would say Tru Calling i feel its something you would really enjoy but there's only 2 season.

David Brown

Shan, Star Wars: The Clone Wars (in chronological order, talk to Chris) and then Star Wars: Rebels. Start the binge watch. And FAST! ASAP! I'm sure Zoot! would agree with me.

Anonymous

Just thought of a better idea than my last one let "Once Upon a Time" take over the SPN slot. I'm sure that there are at least some other Patrons that would agree?