Straight Secrets - Part 5 (Patreon)

All characters are consenting adults (18+) 

The heat became more and more intense as the day went on. Most of the guys had resorted to stripping down to their underwear and dipping in and out of the lake, and I wasn’t one bit upset about it.

Colton emerged from the water. His boxer briefs stuck to his groin, outlining everything I enjoyed most about him. Beads of water dripped down his mostly naked body, and I watched from under my sunglasses as he ran his hand through his hair and walked toward me.

“Throw me a beer” he called, and I did. He cracked it open and gulped from it, but my eyes were fixed to his junk.

Having already jerked him off just weeks prior, I knew exactly what he was hiding. Naturally, we hadn’t spoken a word about our little secret, and I was unsure whether that was because he was ashamed of it, or because he simply didn’t care. Colton crunched the can in his hand and belched.

“You not getting in?” He asked.

“Later”.

He looked back over his shoulder as the rest of the guys remained in the lake. They were throwing a ball around, and seemed preoccupied enough for Colton to finally break the silence.

“About last time” he started, but I shook my head and smiled.

“Forget about it” I said, “we were just fucking around”.

“I liked it”.

I froze. It was one thing to flip a straight guy. I mean, it’s not like they’re not the most sexual beings on the planet. But it was entirely another, to hear one say that he liked it.

“Oh” I replied, shocked. “That’s uh… That’s good”.

He looked back again before turning to me and lowering his voice. “I could um… I could do with another one” he said, “what do you think?”

“Here?”

“Over there” he said, pointing toward the trees, “they won’t notice”.

My heart began to race. Was Colton seriously suggesting that I jerk him off whilst our entire friend group were right there?! I sat up.

“Come on” he pressed, and pulled his wet underwear away from his body, before gazing down into them. “He’s getting impatient” he laughed, and flashed his meaty rod at me.

I wasn’t particularly bothered that the other guys might notice our disappearance, but I was certainly surprised that Colton had suggested it. I got to my feet and followed him toward the trees, and a few moments later we stood facing each other.

“Sup” he grinned, and rolled his boxer briefs down his legs, revealing his cock which was now half hard.

“Sup”.

“I was wondering” he continued, checking behind him again, “if maybe you could um… Instead of giving me a handjob, if you could maybe… I mean… Suck it?”

I raised my brows. If Colton had any idea how I’d spent my morning, he’d realise that sucking straight cock was becoming something of a speciality of mine. Without a word, I got to my knees and wrapped my lips around his delicious cock.

“Holy shit” he gasped, holding onto the tree next to him as his legs began to buckle. “Dude, that’s… Oh fuck, that feels good”.

The feeling was mutual. His cock stiffened further inside me. I took more of him into my throat, gently gagging as his breathing became laboured. Only seconds later, he began to pump pre into me, and I swallowed it down eagerly.

I used my hand to help. I held the base of his hard cock and twisted my fingers around it, draining more of his juices into me as I licked and sucked on his thick cock head. He gasped as I did it, and watched me with interest.

“You’re good at this” he managed to say, and I mumbled back as I swallowed more of his meat.

After almost ten minutes, Colton pinned me against the tree and pumped six thick wads of hot cum into my mouth, and I gulped it down as best I could. We both remained in place, and I held his cock on my tongue as it softened.

“We should get back” he said, breathlessly, as his cock slipped from my mouth.

“Right” I nodded, as he helped me to my feet.

“Thanks for that”.

“No problem”.

The two of us stepped out of the trees, and stopped dead. The rest of the guys stood around, all of them dripping wet and wearing only their underwear. Of the five of them before us, I’d already blown three. They knew exactly what had just been happening, but it was Craig, the only person in the group more homophobic than Trey, who was struggling to piece together what he was seeing.

“What the fuck was that?” He asked, his eyes narrow. “Did… Did you just… Why were you on your knees?” He glared at me, but Craig and I had never seen eye to eye, so I had no time for his bullshit.

“I was sucking his dick” I said, and even Colton gasped.

“Dude?!” He growled, but I shrugged.

“You were doing what?” Craig snarled, and I could see the disgust in his eyes.

“Sucking his dick” I said slower, “if you want, I’ll suck yours, too”.

His jaw dropped. Unlike Trey, Craig wasn’t actually as dumb as he acted. His eyes shot toward the others, but aside from Robbie, they were all well aware of the secrets we all shared.

“You’re sick” he spat, but Robbie, who was the only other guy who I’d yet to flip, began to laugh, and being Robbie’s literal fanboy, Craig gawped.

“You think that’s normal?” He barked, and Craig shrugged.

“Why does it bother you so much?” He asked, and I was rather shocked. Robbie was one of the most popular guys in the group. He was extremely carefree, but I hadn’t expected such a nonchalant reaction. What I also didn’t expect, was what he said next.

“In fact” he continued, his eyes on me, now, “I think this could come in useful”.

The others, who had now all experienced my mouth around their cocks, seemed to relax slightly. Having Robbie’s blessing must have been important, because Dale spoke next.

“He sucked my dick, too” he admitted, and everybody looked at him. “What?” He snapped, “he’s good at it”.

I felt a strange sense of pride as they looked back at me.

“Mine, too” Charlie chuckled, and Craig’s face became more and more red. He glared at Trey, who shuffled on his feet.

“Not you, as well?” He hissed, and when Trey grimaced, Craig sighed.

“You’re all gay?” He groaned, sounding horrified.

“Who said anything about being gay?” Charlie asked, stepping closer to me. “What’s wrong with helping out your buddies?”

As the rest of the guys watched on, I felt Charlie’s hand slide down the back of my pants. My eyes widened.

“We’ve got a guy who’s willing to help us all out, and you’re acting like a little bitch because it’s too ‘gay’” he scoffed, and pushed his finger against my hole. “Feel free to go” he continued, tugging my shorts down as the rest of the guys watched in awe, “because I’m not passing this up”.

My cock flopped out as Charlie stripped me, and instinctively I covered it with my hands. The others continued to stare at me, and I wasn’t sure whether to be excited or mortified, until Dale walked over and winked at me.

“You up for taking two cocks?” He asked, and I nodded without thinking.

“I can’t lie, guys” Trey finally winced, “he’s really good”. He walked over to me as my t-shirt was pulled over my head. “How about three cocks?” He asked, and I gulped, and nodded.

“I’ve got another load in here” Colton chuckled, “can you manage four cocks?”

I was already leaking into my hands as they surrounded me like lions. Playing with them all individually had been amazing, but this was beyond my wildest dreams.

“I’m up for fucking a guy” Robbie shrugged, which left only Craig as the rest of them crowded around me.

“What’s it gonna be, Craig?” Robbie asked, and everybody turned toward him.

His cheeks continued to blaze as he gawped at us. “Come on, man” Robbie continued, “it’s just a bunch of guys messing around, who’s gonna’ know?”

The young man rubbed his eyes. Perhaps he was hoping he’d wake up from this nightmare, but when he dropped his hands, he sighed.

“Can you manage six cocks?” He asked, and the rest of the group cheered and laughed as he walked toward us.