Home Artists Posts Import Register

Content

It's not necessarily a common event, but when you need to make a square hole, it can be difficult to get a precise result.


One of the best methods to achieve a professional cut, is to use a custom made broach.

Free Plans:

http://www.clickspringprojects.com/uploads/3/8/2/2/38221101/small_square_broach_brass_only.pdf

Cheers,

Chris.

Files

Spare Parts #13 - Making A Square Broach

Making A Square Broach, by Clickspring. It's not necessarily a common event, but when you need to make a square hole, it can be difficult to get a precise result. One of the best methods to achieve a professional cut is to use a custom made broach, so in this video I go through the process of making one from scratch. Free Plans: http://www.clickspringprojects.com/uploads/3/8/2/2/38221101/small_square_broach_brass_only.pdf If you would like to help support the creation of these videos, then head on over to the Clickspring Patreon page: https://www.patreon.com/clickspring ________________________________________________________ A very special thank you to patron Dan Keen. ________________________________________________________ You can also help me make these videos by purchasing via the following Amazon Affiliate links: Cameras used in this video: Panasonic GH5 - https://amzn.to/2rEzhh2 Panasonic X920 - https://amzn.to/2wzxxdT Tools & Shop Products: "Solidworks 2013 Bible": http://amzn.to/2FObS1D "Hardening, Tempering and Heat Treatment (Workshop Practice Series)" - https://amzn.to/2KbZo6l Sherline Lathe: http://amzn.to/2pnXM19 Sherline WW collets: http://amzn.to/2FYZ7F8 Heavy Duty Arbor Press: http://amzn.to/2G4gog7 Generic Dial Indicator 0.001": http://amzn.to/2FOFTyF Norton 1-by-2-by-8-Inch Fine/Coarse India Combination Oilstone, Red: http://amzn.to/2tTEPb0 Kaowool 24" X 12" X 1" 2400 F Ceramic Fiber Insulation: http://amzn.to/2pfsM3d Abbreviated Transcript: 00:06 No matter what your style of metal working project might be, every now and then there's a need to form a precise square hole. 00:21 A pilot hole locates the exact position of the desired square, and then the broach is forced through the workpiece. 00:53 And that's because, all of the teeth prior to the last tooth collectively prepare the opening for the final tooth to set the dimension, so within reason, we can tolerate some small errors in those teeth, providing that the very last one is correct. 01:26 Its much too long and slender to be turned between centers, so I'll need to form the features by incrementally extending the work from a 4 jaw chuck. And the other key feature is the pilot diameter, which must be centered on the square, so I'm taking care to center the raw stock prior to forming that cylindrical shape. 01:48 I have the work reasonably well centered to begin with, so that when I position the dial indicator, the error that I see for each jaw is quite small I then use 2 chuck keys in opposition to each other, to move the work, so that the dial reads directly between the original 2 readings for both jaws. 02:13 Once its close, I move the zero reference to that point, so that becomes my target when I start to center the other two jaws. Once the work gets close to being centered, the errors start to sit nicely either side of that zero reference, and it gets easier to pull it into position. 02:53 But even doing this quickly, you can see that it will take a fair amount of time to do this for every cut, so there's a strong incentive to bypass this centering process if we can. For now though, the work is centered, so I can make a start on cutting that pilot diameter. 03:39 Next I'm using the first groove position to register the tool after extending the work, and then I'm using the hand wheels to advance the tool the required amount to form the next groove. Now inevitably I will have introduced a small eccentricity to each of these cuts, and the teeth won't be precisely spaced either. But as I mentioned before, they don't really need to be. 04:14 Providing I don't introduce any gross errors, It's close enough for the final result, and by accepting a small error, I can move through this part of the process very quickly. 05:14 The total amount of metal to be removed, is determined by the difference between the pilot diameter and the diameter of the circle that just encloses the final square. That metal removal must now be shared across all of the teeth, so it determines how much I feed out before cutting each tooth, and that in turn ends up determining the broach depth of cut. 05:32 The diameter difference also gives an indication of how many teeth are required to keep the chip load manageable. 06:15 At this point all of the features of the broach have been formed, so it can now be quench hardened, and on this occasion I'm using the tray that I recently made for the current clock project. 07:07 In an industrial setting a broach is far more likely to be pulled through the work rather than pushed like this, and there's a real risk of fracture using an arbor press in this way, so be sure to take it carefully. 07:19 Make sure the broach is perfectly vertical before you push it through, and as always have your eye protection on. But even with all of the compromises, its still a great way to use home shop tools to quickly shape a precise square hole. Making A Square Broach, by Clickspring.

Comments

Tom Colson

Not sure when I'll next need to make a square hole in brass, but I might have to make one of these just because...

John Creasey

That's really useful and well explained. Did you temper the broach after your hardened it?

Paul Grodt

Quality broaches can be crazy expensive. But they are often made from pretty high grade steel. If you are just doing stuff with brass and maybe mild-steel, even taking the cost of labor into account, this sort of thing might still end up saving you money!

David Rysdam

Are you using your bluing tray to temper? Would be a great way to get a nice even temper.

clickspring

Hey David, in this case I just did my usual thing of using a gentle heat while resting the part on some ceramic wool, a thin cross section part like this tempers very quickly. But it certainly wouldn't hurt to use the tray. Cheers, Chris.

Dan Cowsill

Very cool Chris. Thanks for posting!

clickspring

Hey Paul, yes absolutely. Especially when you consider that often the holes are non standard dimensions to suit a particular need. I wouldn't like my chances of finding a 3.4mm square broach at an affordable price! Cheers paul :)

Anonymous

Great tip, Chris! I'm curious if the hardening would be necessary if you were only going to use the tool to make one or two broaches in brass.

clickspring

Hey Ken, yes it will need to be hardened. Even though brass is quite soft to machine, when under compression like this it will quickly distort the annealed tool steel, and dull the cutting edge. Even when hardened and tempered, a carbon steel cutter still has a finite life before sharpening is required, even if its used exclusively in nice soft brass. Cheers mate, Chris.

Paul Busby

Awesome. A surprise new video. As always, great work and a real joy to watch. Looking back to the beginning would that heat treat tray have been a good idea for the screws and other things you have done compared to the wire method. The tray seems a lot easier and reliable. The only problem now is when this and the previous video pop up on the subscription feed making me think even more new video's are released. Really looking forward to the next clock video.

PJ

Great camera work Chris! Better all the time! Did you start with 5-6mm RB and mill it to dimension or 4-6mm sq stock and mill it to get the 3.4mm square first? Pretty odd size, can't wait to see what it is. Thanks Much! ~PJ

clickspring

Thank you PJ! I started with an offcut of 3/16" ground flat stock, milled it to shape as you suggest, and then lapped it to the final surface finish and dimension. Have a great day mate :)

clickspring

Hey Paul, I agree with you its a far more effective way to do this than the wire - its now on the to do list! The current one would probably be a bit wasteful of boric acid and gas for something small like a screw, but I think maybe a set of trays from 1/5th size, 1/2 and then the current one would be a good idea. Another video?

Anonymous

Nice video! I have no idea what I'd need to put a square hole in, but there must be something .... thanks

Jerry Vella

Hey chris, great video as always, was just curious if if would be better to remove the piece from the heating tray just before quenching it to cool it down faster and improve the hardness, would it still build up some black scale if it was exposed for just a second? or are you getting it sufficiently hard with it still in the tray?

clickspring

Hey Jerry, I wondered the same thing about whether it would quench fast enough, but it came out glass hard from the tray, so no need to take it out any sooner. The whole mass cools down fast enough that it doesn't seem to matter. It wouldn't form scale if you were to take it out just before the quench though, so you could do that if you wanted to without consequence, and that might be required if the part was much larger. This broach is so thin that it quenches very easily. It also occurred to me that it might introduce distortion because of the heat differential on the inside surface, but it seems to be fine. Same result with the recent hands, so I'll continue to use it. Cheers mate :)

Jerry Vella

thanx for the response Chris, i didn't even consider distortion from differential hardening but it would definitely show up in a part like this, good to know how well the heating tray works, looking forward to your next vid, cheers