Home
Artists
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register
Partychan Telegram Live Sex ThePornDude
Home Artists Posts Import Register

Star Wars: The Acolyte 1X1 Reaction Edited (Patreon)

Published:
2024-07-22 19:00:02
Imported:
2024-07
Tags:

Downloads

Content

This was... messy, The story as a whole seems interesting with a twin assassin going after Jedi but the writing and structure of the episode were definitely odd, hoping it improves as it progresses though.

Files

Comments

Soosmann

I personally liked the show and I am here to make it as enjoyable as possible for you. Show a different side to the negativity. I will structure my Comments as follows: 1st what I got out of the episode, what I liked and what I criticize 2nd try to answer your questions and giving insight into things you might have overlooked 3rd talk about common criticisms (that were not already covered in (2)) and where I think the critics got a point and where they might have overlooked something 1: squid game Actor: Yes, that's him. The director really wanted him for the show, even though he didn't speak english before, so he learned english just to be part of this. I think he is the perfect cast for the Character, because he manages to perfectly convey his emotions. Master Soul is my favourite character of the show and there is more to him tham meets the eye. Because of his more emotional side in comparison to the other jedi, he feels very Qui-Gon-like, which made me immediately fall in love with the character. I loved seing choruscant and the Jedi in this. In the Prequels the Jedi were cool of course, but there was allways this depressing feeling, because you knew that they are pawns in Palpatines game. Here, the Jedi Temple feels very wholesome. Across everything star wars, we have seen, (for me) it has never looked this good. I love the idea of the ship docks under the tempel edge, which are only possible, because the other buildings haven't risen up as high yet. Also the sets and Alien costume designs stood out to me. It looked amazing. Also the introduction of the pip droid multitool is really creative. In a lot of the newer shows, they introduce new types of companion droids and this one is amazing, because it is not only useful, but also serves as comedic relief in future episodes. When it comes to the story, there isn't much I can say yet, because we got mostly introduction to different characters. I love the group of people we are following: They are all unique and have their strengths and weaknesses. Yord for example being headstrong and a little impulsive, but loyal to osha. Soul being an emotional Jedi with empathy, which seems to be a strength, but when I see him sitting and pondering, I feel like this strength could turn on him. Venestra being a typical Jedi, but her actions don't seem to add up. What's going on there? Jacky, the friendly open and enthusiastic Padawan. Let's see were her story goes. Also a mysterious dark side Person. For now not a lot to work with... When it comes to Mae and Osha, I am not that much of a fan yet, because they do indeed seem to be somewhat inconsistent, but we'll see where the story goes. Of course I also liked the fight scenes 2: What is the Jedi's role? Why are they in the Pub? Jedi don't just use lightsabers? This is towards the end of the high republic era. The era where the jedi were not fighters under the command of the senate but independent. They were what the jedi always should have been. In these times of relative peace, the jedi use (and that means as a weapon in fights) their weapon only as a last measure. For tool purposes (light in the cave) this doesn't apply or it's at least an edge case. In these times, the Jedi are spread across the galaxy and don't "hide" on Coruscant. They set up smaller Temples all around the Galaxy and even visit Pubs and stuff, to be closer to the people. Not as slodiers, but as kind of an inofficial police force. The Jedi are at the moment not yet involved in politics, but some Senators want to change this, which is one conflict that we will see evolve. Jei Outfits: The golden and white robes seem to be used in the temple and when they want to appear formal. The thicker brown robes are used on missions that might require protection against the weather for example Not having Astro mechs for Mechanics stuff?: They do have droids, but I would assume that living mechanics are cheaper if they are poorly payed and almost live in slavery Fire in space: In my interpretation the fire is meant to burn because of the escaping gas. It doesn't really look that way, but that's my interpretation and fire in star wars allways seemed to not need as much oxygen as in reality, since we see ships explode with giant fireballs in space all the time. Here the fire is a stylistic choice, because it is a common theme throughout the show and introduces us here to some past event that seems to have been relevant for Osha. The point of the Yord Shirtless scene: I think mostly pointless and fan sevice. In hindsight, I think that might be done to reflect his bold character. Yord seems to be the more aggressive and impulsive character of the bunch, which is also indicated by him pulling out his saber in the cave, when the others stay calm. Is this a flaw? About Venestra not wanting to send people to look for the ship: This might either be stupidity or she has other motives that are not clear to the viewer yet. One of the things that encourage speculation. Why Osha suddenly runns away from the ship? Before her vision, she wasn't sure what to make of the situation. There seems to be a reason that the people that know about the fire are convinced that mae is dead, so after osha learnts about mae being alive (hrough the vision), she starts running, because she thinks that the jedi wouldn't believe her. This isn't the most rational thing to do, but an emotional decision in reaction to her vision. Understandable to me. mae being misguided because being wrong about how Jedi use their lightsabers: I'm not sure if she's wrong about that (she maybe only meant in fighting contexts), but where she got her ideology and beliefs fron is a very interesting question, which is another interesting point to speculate about. About The guy at the end talking about killing a Jedi without a weapon: Yes, this didn't happen. So mae failed his master (if we want to call him that...) I think that this is one of those lessons where the Master might tell the student vaguely what he wants and the student tries to make it work somehow, fails, but the real lesson for the student might be to understand what the master wants them to do... The challenge is not to do it, but to figure out how to do it. Also the not killing with a weapon is not somehting generally forbidden to my understanding. I think this is just a challenge for this one lesson. Maybe to earn the right to be an Acolyte (just like you earned the right to use a calculator by first learning to do math on your own) About the End: Red Lightsaber might indicate Sith and is definitely some connection to the sith, but weve seen a lot of outcast sith and fallen jedi, that didn't fall under the rule of two, so we shouldn't jump to conclusions. It'll make more sense, as the show goes on. (I remember you having a similar reaction to meeting Ventress) Fun fact: The first two episodes were released at the same time to make it more catchy. About Lore: This Show will reintroduce a lot of Legends concepts and do great worldbuilding. I am personally allways concerned for Canon consistency, which is why I didn't like Tales of the Jedi (Ahsoka Farm Episode) and some other sutff that you haven't yet seen. I am not the kind of person to be easily pleased, but I can assure you that this does fit into canon. 3: Criticism: "Is there a point for writing it so weirdly?" I think that the reason is to give small clues and be vague and confusing on purpose, so that we as the viewer have more to speculate over. I think that I personally managed to get what the creators wanted to achieve, but one has to really concentrate and be able to creatively interpret what we see, in order to follow the plot. This is not a good thing, when you want to target a wide audience and this is the reason, why so many people think there are so many plot holes. I think the direction becomes much clearer as the show goes on. There is also a lot of Criticism about the whole strucure and story of the entire season, but I won't talk about that yet, because spoilers. The Jedi Master being killed "easily" and being stupid for not seeing the second knife coming: A lot of people criticized that Mae was able to beat a Jedi Master with the knife trick. In my interpretation of the scene, I think that the Jedi did see her death coming, and she would have been able to save herself. So she didn't get killed because she was distracted, but she knew that there was a second knife, but she chose to save the civilian instead of herself. Venestra not sending Jedi to investigate immediately: I already talked about this above, but this is also the kind of criticism that a lot of people have at different points and it shows why so many people dislike the show: Characters do things that seem stupid and therefore the plot must be bad and the story doesn't make sense. Personally I think that these curiosities in the character's behaviors are intentional because we deal with a mystery here and of course people act odd sometimes. This gives us as viewers clues for our speculation and some of our theories might turn out true, other things might be false leads, but this is one thing that made the show enjoyable for me. I do respect if this is not your cup of tea. Not everyone has to like this kind of writing. Plot convenience Prison ship escape: This is a point for the critics. I think that there can be a prison escape sometimes and in this case, against all odds the aliens inprisoned were just the right combination to manage this unlikely escape, so it makes sense what happened, but it is indeed bad writing, if the protagonist has to rely on luck to progress the plot. This one thime, I forgive the writers though, because they had so many things to set up, that there was probably not the time. Mae or Osha changing a lot and seeming inconsistent is tied to the same problem and for setting up characters and their traits, this shouldn't happen. I am especially mad, because this goes on in some other episodes, which stopped me from connecting to these characters like I dod with others. I think that for this to work out right, the show would need more time, which it unfortunately didn't have with only 8 episodes.

Hi Man

Oh boy, the Acolyte... Well let me just start off by saying I don't like this show. But there are still many things I like about so I will sprinkle some of those in there so that my comments won't be so overly negative all the time. I think that the set designers did a fantastic job. It's always amazing to see when a project actually has real and meticulously made sets. Instead of the actors standing behind a green screen. Each set feels so alive and lived in and I can see that so much real love and passion went into how the show looks and how it feels. The acting is great as well especially Lee Jung-jae who plays Sol. You will see it more in futute episodes that he is absolutely phenomenal. But the craziest thing is that he didn't speak english before this show if I'm not mistaken. But he specifically learned to speak english for this show which is INSANE. Imagine being so dedicated to your work that you learn an entire new language. It's incredible. His character is also the most interesting in the series in my opinion but he will shine more in future episodes. The basic set up of the story isn't bad either. I think even though the "one evil twin, one good twin" storyline has been beaten to death in Hollywood, it's still an interesting concept to bring into Star Wars and if executed well it could work. The fight scene at the beginning was dope as hell. The fight choreography in this show is absolutely phenomenal and easily the best we have gotten since the prequel trilogy. The fight between Indara and Mae. The fact that she didn't really use her lightsaber at all was awesome and it perfectly shows the main difference between the Jedi of the Clone Wars and the Jedi of the High Republic Era. And how far the Jedi have fallen from their original teachings during the prequels. Because originally the Jedi only had lightsabers not to have it as a primary weapon but to use it if all else fails. It's sort of a last resort type of deal. It's actually very rare in this era for the Jedi to use their lightsabers, mostly relying on the force. This definitely showed that the Jedi were once actual peacekeepers and rarely resolved to violence but instead used martial arts to disarm their opponents without killing them thus following the peaceful philosophy of the Jedi. But when you look at the Clone Wars for example, it's an incredibly stark difference. We have seen in the Clone Wars that the Jedi, even when slightly threatened immediately pull out their lightsabers at the slightest of opportunities. This is one thing I really like about this show. The fact that they were able to show so effectively the contrast between the Jedi Order in their Golden age and the Order in their final few years at the top of it's corruption and faulty teachings. Of course the Order still has flaws even during the High Republic era but it's still an overly positive and good organization which upholds their values and teachings. Although it's important to rememeber that this show basically takes place at the end of their "Golden era". Which means that the Jedi are already somewhat involved in politics on Coruscant and the Senate but of course still not to the extent of the RoTs Jedi Order. Also the explanation as to why Yord draws his lightsaber most of the time is very simple. They explained that he just passed the trials to become a Knight. So he is very inexperienced and young. He also seems much more agressive in his personality and easily jumps to conclusions. So I think this coupled with his general inexperience explains why he draws his lightsaber so much. He still has a lot to learn and be comfortable with not using his lightsaber but instead relying on the force like the rest of the more experienced Jedi. Also to explain the fire in... space. Well people have criticized this a lot when this episode came out but on the other hand. We have seen fire and explosions in space since the Original trilogy and in every animated show. So fire in space has always been a silly little part of Star Wars but I think people got so weirded out by this scene because we have never actually seen like a campfire sized small fire just gently burning in space before. I think that's why it's such a strange scene, we have seen massive explosions and such in space but never something so obviously unrealistic in that environment. Yes, the explosions don't make any sense either but I think when you put it in such a small context like a small fire gently burning it does look very ridicilous even for for Star Wars🤣 And to explain why they haven't sent droids to fix the fire, well because they are expensive and since the Trade Federation are assholes they would much rather sacrifice cheap human lives than expensive astromechs. It's messed up but it makes sense😅 Also the shirtless Yord scene made absolutely no sense. It's like they are trying to do the "funny haha, shirtless guy cought shirtless" scene from the Marvel movies but if feels so unlike Star Wars and overall just silly and pointless. To me this just goes to show how much Leslie wants to unnecessarily bring Disney stuff over to Star Wars because she thinks that's what we want. But of course here comes the part where I rant about a few things. It's no secret that the main reason people were skeptical about this show even before it came out is Leslye Headland. She is an infamously bad director and you can even go to her Imdb page and see that basically everything she has ever made is rated horribly and people just generally don't like her in the industry. But of course because she has a bunch of powerful connections in Hollywood, she keeps getting these high profile projects to work on even though she dosen't have the resume to back it up. That's Hollywood for you, corrupt and awful but of course we all know that. It's also worth noting that in the promotional material leading up to the release of this show she has shown time and time again in inderviews that she dosen't respect Star Wars and it's fans, and just wants to insert her own ideas and politics into a well established universe. Of course this inculdes her literally stating and I quote "It's my show" in response to criticism regarding her many canon breaking decisions throughout this show, which is just insane. Imagine being so full of yourself that you can't recognise that this is not a reboot or a different interpretation of the Star Wars universe. She was hired to do a show in the Star Wars universe so she has an obligation to follow the rules that were set by previous stories in this universe and keep it a connected through a shared and identical canon. But instead she thinks that she can do whatever she wants because it's "her show" and dosen't care about breaking canon and previously established and well liked storylines. What's even more upsetting is that she clearly dosen't understand Star Wars and has a very limited knowledge about it. There are so many interviews on Youtube where she just so blatantly gets stuff wrong about the lore and seems to think that her interpretation of events is superior to that of the LITERAL creator of this universe, George Lucas. There is also the topic of her very heavily inserting IRL politics into this show. But since this is a highly sensitive subject i think I will simply say this. It's not inherently a problem to give your piece of media some sort of political undertone and real life message. That's completely fine in my opinion. But there comes a point where if you put too much and so blatantly obvious political messaging into your show it can become very distracting and seem overly preachy and annoying. Which is what many people are complaining about with this show. And I don't think I have to explain how OBVIOUS the irl political messaging in this show is, especially in later episodes. With that said I think the way I look at it is that, if you want to get your message across, you first have to remember that your are telling a fictional story. And the story itself should have the priority. And the political messaging should be in the backround and not so blatantly obvious. Because when it's this obvious, it can easily take you out of the show and make your realise you are watching someones political hitpiece. The point of these stories is so we can escape the real world and to embrace fantasy and fiction. But when you do this, you get taken out of that wolrd and it's not fun. Once again I think I have to say this, I don't care what anybody believes politically. It's a free wolrd I will not judge anyone based on their beliefs but it's also important to remember that maybe sci-fi fiction isn't exactly the best way to express your political opinions and preach it to random nerds who just want to watch two people hit eachother with a lightsaber for a few hours. So yeah that is my overall opinion on the broader aspect of this show and I will definitely give my opinon on the main story itself in future episodes but until then, the most I can say is that the shows writing and pacing is what ruined it. Everything else from how it looks to the score, acting costumes, fight scenes etc. are all mostly excellent. But the writing jsut absolutely ruins it all. And not just the overall plot of the show is poorly written but most of the dialogue in this show sounds so bland and unimaginative. It's very basic with no nuance or purpose. It's just dry and sounds like something I would write when I was a teenager. A very good example of this is the scene when Sol talks about Mae to the padawans on their way to Osha's crash site. In that scene Sol instantly shuts down the other and says that there is no way Mae had survived the fire. Implying that it was Osha who killed Indara. But then moments later when they find Osha he immediately switches up and believes everything she says. And then there is of course Osha after the crash. Even though she said that she had full faith in the Jedi, she decided to leave the relatively safe ship which protects her from the storm and is most likely to be searched first by the Jedi she trusts so much and goes ouside into a raging Blizzard running away from her rescuers for some reason and standing on a ledge like she is cornered or something. It just such a sudden switchup from both Sol and Osha in their characters that it's just redicilous. And there are going to be far worse things when it comes to character motivations when it comes to this show believe me. This is just the tip of the iceburg. And to circle back to bad dialogue, the ending scene where the mysterious Sith makes his bad guy speech sounds so corny and awful. He says a lot of things but he makes almost zero sense. His monologue literally feels like they just straight up used ChatGPT to write evil villain dialogue and bombard it with the most stereotipical bad guy garbo and buzzwords to make it sound cool🤣 The way they killed Indara was also stupid and made no sense to me. You are telling me that a Jedi Master who was able to easily deal with her opponent without a lightsaber was beaten because Mae threw a second knife at her and for some reason wasn't able to sense it or block it. Even low level Jedi can sense the moment before someone even pulls the trigger of a blaster but for some reason she was "distracted" and didn't have time to sense the second knife coming ? Even if she didn't sense it, Jedi can literally project a sort of force shield infront of them to block anything coming their way, like we have seen many times in the Clone Wars or other media. So why didn't Indara, a powerful Jedi Master simply put up a force shield with her right hand and save the civilian with here left ? This makes no sense whatsoever and it's just once again a sympton of bad writing. I could think of a thousand better ways for the writers to realisitically have Mae kill a Jedi Master but they just went with the classic Hollywood "I will throw one thing to distract and after that throw a second thing to catch my opponent off guard." It's such a cliche way to do it and this technique is so boring and overused in Hollywood. Also fun fact, the show was supposed to have multiple seasons going forward but the reception was so bad along with record low viewership that the news came out yesterday that the executives at Lucasfilm have cancelled season 2. So I will let you decide what you want to think of that information🤣 I'm also pretty sad that this was your first live action SW show experience🤣 There are so many awesome live action Star Wars show content out there so it's sad that this was your introduction. Especially since you've been on such a Star Wars high with the two awesome trilogies followed by the Clone Wars and Bad Batch, both excellent shows. So it's a pity that your streak of amazing SW content was disrupted by this especially since the next shows you will watch after this after you return to chronological order are all excellent as well. But hey at least you will get this out of the way and don't have to worry about it afterwards.🤣 P.S Lastly I know that this comment was overly negative and believe me I hate having to write about this because I like to look on the bright side of things most of the time, but with this show I can't ignore how flawed and overall bad it is, not just to me but to the Star Wars franchise as a whole.

Ben Spiller
>>144454197

Thanks so much for this, having watched up to episode 3 now my opinions on this show are getting stronger 😂 but I do really want to find a way to enjoy it so when I record again, I’m gonna start looking for things to enjoy each episode as I think that might make it a bit more fun. Wait so the squid game actor actually learned a whole language to play this role!?! That’s absolutely insane! He is probably my favourite character out of this show so far and now matter my criticism I really hope the future is bright for this guy because to learn a whole language and give such a good performance is incredible and I’d hate for however this show is being viewed to negatively impact him or any of the actors. I do really love how much Sol feels like Qui-Gon, It’s so cool to think such a similar character existed 100 years before him and that I guess Jedi like Qui-Gon aren’t so rare, hopefully that might mean even more will be out in the Galaxy. Yes! Really enjoyed seeing the jedi like this without the fear of Palpatine’s influence and it felt so free without him! No fear of anything going on in the background to backstab anyone and the Jedi felt at peace and less war-like from the modern time. I do like Pip and I’m hoping they do more with it, right now it almost feels like a bit of plot armour with how it’s solves a lot of Osha’s problems here but hoping we get to see a point where she can’t use the droid, other than that the little guy is great, and I do love how they’re able to basically make a rectangle cute 😂 Didn’t get the impression of loyalty from Yord, he felt like he’s very by the book and he almost doesn’t want to be there or just wants to get it over quickly, almost like he’s uncomfortable with how much trust Sol is placing in her while he just wants to get her to Coruscant without getting emotionally attached. Sol, great, no complaints with him and I’m just hoping his attachments won’t become a weakness and we get to see that it can strengthen a Jedi, Jacky reminds me a lot of Ahsoka at this point with her snark but somehow, she seems even more snarky than when Ahsoka was first introduced. Mae and Osha, same thoughts, as the stars of the show I should be attached or invested in them immediately, but this didn’t do that which is disappointing. Fight scenes were awesome! Loved the flowing movements and how they used the Force in it. Thanks for answering my questions, I do like the Pub scene went to show off the Jedi’s more casual position in society now as opposed to a military. The fire thing bugged me because it should look more like a Bunsen burner with the flames shooting out escaping with whatever gas it’s igniting, like when air escapes and airlock. It’s only a minor thing but I do call back to it in Episode 3 but this is far more forgivable when it could be said that Osha’s seeing worse in her mind which is then what we as the audience see. Yord’s scene just took me out of the episode, to be placed between scenes that are building tension to just stop and have everyone stand still for a while to fit in something comical didn’t work for me, I feel like it could have been done differently to still capture the dynamic between Sol, Jacki and Yod but this didn’t do it. I’m hoping Venestra’s decision is down to another reason yet to be seen but still doesn’t help that all we got to go off was that she would send people to hunt a fugitive, that decision needed to have reason at least hinted at for the benefit of the audience when it’s something that important. Coming more around to her decision to flee the Jedi but still feels like an odd choice when the point of the scene is about trust, could have been done better if the ship landed on a ledge and she had to trust Sol to save her from it while she tells him about the vision, just find traveling through the snow an odd choice when simply changing the landing of the ship could of helped. I started to understand the Master’s lesson in episode 2, it’s written as if it’s a law that Jedi can only be killed a certain way when it should have been posed as an aim for her to aspire to, having that explained in episode 2 was a disservice to the premier True about the Red Lightsaber, just figure with it being this early in the timeline there isn’t much going on force wise since I think it’s only Plagueis and his master so having an enemy of the Jedi with the Red Lightsaber felt like very obvious messaging but would gladly accept this guy being something different. With Lore, I’m definitely gonna need you for Episode 3 😂 😂 that’s still got me scratching my brain. I’m really hoping the direction becomes clearer, 😂 having a show be vague and create speculation is fine but when that is surrounding what appears to be every important part of the story to the point that in episode one the Audience doesn’t have a kind of clear picture as to what is going on is definitely a step in the wrong direction. I don’t think the Jedi was stupid for being killed by a knife, honestly it was a pretty good trick with distracting her and making her chose to put her focus somewhere else, it did feel a little underwhelming but that’s not really that big of a deal, only criticism would be that the death is meaningless to me, I have no clue who this Jedi is or their personality so their death carries no weight. I’m quite surprised some would call this kill easy as the point was to show Mae had training and was capable of going against a Master Jedi, plus the fight scene did justice to that Jedi at least in combat. Overall the main thing about it was that it shouldn’t have been at the beginning but rather at the end to build tension and give some meaning to this life that was lost. I do think it’s interesting how they’ve chosen to write the characters then, at least if it is intentional to write them like they’re unsure of what their doing. Will have to think about this one but if there is a super obvious decision that needs to be made and a character doesn’t do it that probably won’t work for me. Now you’ve mentioned it, I think I can guess what this also refers to in episode 2 with Mae’s confrontation and yeah, I didn’t really like what they did there 😂 The prison escape I can get over honestly, it was convenient but was hardly the most important aspect of the episode, but it would have been nicer to get a more challenging situation for the protagonist to get out of as all this showed off is that she’s nice to save the violent guy and she isn’t strong with the Force as she could pull Pip to her. Mae and Osha I’m getting really worried for, as the stars of the show they should have my attention, focus and investment but that just isn’t there 3 episode’s in and it’s such a disservice to the show as a whole since it’s their story we’re following, hoping it improves though as that is probably my biggest problem with it so far and if I can start caring for those two characters specifically, I can see myself enjoying the show a whole lot more.

Ben Spiller
>>144458334

Yes! This is something I noticed in Episode 2, the sets look really nice and detailed, and it really does draw you into the world and after seeing a lot of animated Star Wars it was awesome to see the setting so seamlessly transfer over into Live Action again. Sol is definitely my favourite at this point and his acting has been great, I only just found out he learned English for this role with is so amazing! I hope nothing but good things happen for him after this show as of course there’s been loads of controversy, but this man deserves for his career to grow from this. I can’t even begin to imagine the dedication this man has to be able to do this 😂 If anything his performance is what’s pulling me to watch this show as I really don’t want all his hard work to go to waste. The storyline is very common, but Star Wars could do something new with it, we got to see Luke and Leia as force twins, but they never knew each other when they were younger so this is a nice new perspective on how the Force can affect something like that. Hollywood is certainly baffling; Lesly doesn’t seem like the best fit for a project as big as Star Wars when her resume is much to be desired. And I completely agree with your sentiment about a creator coming in and making a project about themselves rather than the story they are meant to be producing, smaller, artistic and Indie stuff is the main outlet for creative freedom for self-expression but when a big company hires you where they set the boundaries of the story, the job is no longer self-expression but to tell a story that they may have no connection with. I had the same opinions with Marvel for a while now, so much of the recent stuff pays no mind to the comics which is just disappointing at the end of the day, getting a new bit of hope though with Deadpool & Wolverine coming out 😂 but it is sad that this issue seems to be in many places where the creators can get caught up in the self rather than the story. The writing as a whole is proving to be a big problem for this show, I have no attachment to the main characters, the dynamics seem quite weak between the others in places and a lot of the decision making is questionable at best. It is a shame to go from Bad Batch where each line of dialogue had importance to here where some go to waste like at the start with the causality of Osha’s job, that felt very bland and empty. Oh wow, didn’t realise it did so terribly, at least this means that Disney does listen to fans in a way, so they cancel the stuff that doesn’t work, and at the vest least they took a chance to do something new, but it backfired massively. Don’t worry about the negativity, just wait till you see my reaction to Episode 3 😂 I tried to stay positive but that one took it out of me 😂 😂