Figured it out. And boy, is Patreon Stupid (Patreon)

Going to write the support team. So what apparently happened, is I had to create a separate account to see what wasn't showing up. Turns out somehow posts changed to Patrons Only during the Tier Deletion/change. 

So, yea, that makes sense, all patrons should see patrons only posts. But, that's not the case. It only shows posts tagged to what your tier is, which is really not good. 

So, hundreds of posts to change manually, going backwards and hour or two a day for now til maybe I can get some sort of help from Patreon Support.

Sela at the Lake Yesterday. At least this was a good point