Prompt: Gildarts' Harem Ch. 5 (Fairy Tail) (Patreon)

Summary: Erza followed Lucy to Gildarts' home and finds the two in a compromising position. Lucky for them she wants to join in. Includes: Threesome and strap-ons. 

--- 

It was a beautiful morning as Erza and Lucy enjoyed their breakfast together. The small cafe the two went to was a simple, rustic place, and the food had a wonderful, homemade spice to it that both girls found utterly delectable. 

They ate together and exchanged small talk, talking to one another about cute clothes they saw in stores and possible shopping ventures together. They laughed and chuckled together, when suddenly Lucy noticed something that caught her eye.

She stared at something over Erza’s shoulder, and when the redhead turned to follow her gaze, Lucy pulled her back.

“S-sorry. Just thought I saw something,” the blond muttered. “I just remember, I-I have to go see Natsu about something.” Lucy rose up from her seat, and grabbed her purse. 

“Huh? I thought you were going to go shopping after?” 

“I know, and I promise, next time, but I really need to go check on this.” There was a tone of breathless excitement in Lucy’s voice. “I’ll see you later, alright?” Lucy flashed a smile to Erza, before she made a quick dash away. Her heels clicked against the ground, leaving the redhead behind. 

Erza’s brow rose up as she watched her friend leave, and immediately, the red-haired warrior feared the worse. Did Lucy see someone suspicious? Why not include her to help? Erza was sure she could help Lucy deal with any kind of problem…

Unless she was in trouble? Perhaps this problem was blackmailing her, or had a hostage? Perhaps Lucy needed help, but lacked the strength to call out for it? 

Erza left some money to pay for their meal, before she stood up and marched after Lucy. The blond was just beginning to vanish around a corner, but Erza was confident she could follow her friend. She ran after her, dashing past strangers.

Erza was faster than Lucy, but the hard part was simply making sure Lucy did not spot her. Something else Erza was trying to do was predict just where the blond was going. It didn’t take her long to realize just where Lucy was headed though.

There was one house this way, one home for one individual they both knew, but could she be headed that way?

Erza got her answer, though, as Lucy arrived at Gildarts’ house and knocked on the door. She was answered in a matter of moments, but before the man greeted her, Erza could see how nervous and anxious Lucy was waiting for an answer. Her foot bounced on the ground as she looked around, before suddenly the door opened and her mood improved .

Erza was confused and curious, before she was blown away, staring with wide eyes as Lucy kissed the older man’s lips. The man was old enough to be her father, yet Lucy kissed him like he was her boyfriend! 

The redhead watched the two slip back into the house, before Erza rushed forward to get some answers. The young woman was never one for subtly, so she marched right up to the doors and forced it open. She used her superior to tear the door open, before bursting into the bedroom as a scream filled her ears.

She was ready to fight and die for Lucy, only for Erza’s eyes to widen and her cheeks to turn as red as her hair. Her jaw hit the ground as she found Lucy and Gildarts on top of one another, the older man’s cock inside Lucy’s pussy, fucking her in what Erza believe was missionary style. 

Both of them looked at her with shocked, wide eyes as their mouth hung open. Erza wasn’t much better as a tiny squeak slipped out of her mouth.

“E-Erza?! I-I can explain! Y-you see, Gildarts was just… We were just… I-” Erza held up a hand, stopping the blond as Gildarts tried to pull his dick out of the younger girl and get off of her. Both froze as Erza held up her hand, and the red-haired woman closed her eyes.

“Gildarts… Are you forcing yourself on Lucy?”

“No!” 

“Lucy, are you forcing yourself on-?”

“No! Erza, I’d never do that!”

“Is anyone getting hurt in a manner that… that will leave lasting injury, or in any way they do not consent to?” Erza inquired, her words coming out naturally for the most part.

The two looked at one another as they sat on the bed, before both looked at her and shook their heads.

“Good. That’s… that’s good. As long as no one is getting hurt, and you two are both consenting to the act.” Erza nodded her head in approval, before looking behind her. She closed the door before there was a flash of light.

By the time the light had ended, Erza stood before both Gildarts and Lucy, naked as the day she was born, her cheeks a subtle shade of red. Her large breasts bounced against her chest, freed from the confines of a bra as she stared at the two.

“Would either of you be against me joining in? I haven’t been able to find Jellal is weeks and I’m getting rather sick of taking care of business myself. What do you say?”

Lucy blinked. Gildarts blinked. Erza did not. The couple glanced at one another, and Lucy began to smile as Gildarts nodded his head in approval. 

Seamlessly, Erza joined in, walking forward with hips swaying and breasts bouncing. The happy couple got back into position, with Lucy under Gildarts and his cock pushing into her waiting, wanting pussy. 

Lucy moaned, gasping as the cock pushed into her pussy, sliding back and forth. She licked her lips as she watched Erza wrap her arms around the older man, holding him against her body as their lips met. Their lips nibbled on one another, before the two opened their mouths and their tongues slipped out to greet one another. Their tongues wrestled as Lucy watched them kiss, digging her fingers into the bed to try and bounce her body on Gildarts’ dick.

One gorgeous blond on his cock, one sexy redhead in his arms, making out with him. Gildarts patted himself on the back as he reached a hand down to grope Erza’s fat, firm rear, before his other hand groped her chest. 

He gave her breast a gentle squeeze, pressing it against her chest, before moving his hand down her body. As Lucy continued to moan on his cock, he slipped a finger into Erza’s pussy, fingering her as she moaned in his arms.

His middle finger pushed in and out, thrusting into the already wet snatch of the mighty woman. Erza seemed to like his touch, pressing her body against his, rubbing her hard nipples against his chest as their tongues wrestled, drool spilling onto her soft body.

Eventually the two had to come up for air, and they broke the two as Erza moaned loudly, humping his hand. She clearly wanted more than just a single digit, but Gildarts just chuckled and pulled her into position.

He moved back, keeping his tip in Lucy, as Erza got on top of the blond. Their nipples brushed against one another as Gildarts returned to fucking the wealthy wizard, pushing his cock in and out of her as Erza stared at each other face to face.

“Ah! God, you’re going to love his cock, Erza. It’s so f-fucking good!” Lucy mewled, gasping as his cock slid along her wet walls. 

“Mmm. I can’t wait. Until then…” Erza kissed Lucy’s lips, surprising the other girl, before Lucy shrugged her shock off and kissed right back. The two women wrapped their arms around one another as their breasts pushed against one another, nipples prodding each other’s soft boobflesh as their lips pressed together.

Gildarts grinned at the show, picking up his pace as his hand came down to spank Erza’s ass. She moaned at the hit, shaking a bit as he spanked her again and again, each time making her moan into Lucy’s wet mouth. Their tongues wrestled, drool spilling down onto Lucy’s body as Gildarts suddenly pulled his hips back.

Lucy whined at the sudden emptiness she felt, before the older man shoved his cock into Erza’s pussy, bucking back and forth and making the taller woman grind against Lucy. Erza gasped, eyes nearly vanishing into her skull as Gildarts held her by her hips.

Erza was shocked at just how wonderful this man’s cock was. It was mind-numbingly good. Better than Jellal’s, to be sure, but she wasn’t sure if that was a difference in skill or experience. She didn’t really care either as she tried to push herself back onto his cock, trying to match his thrusts.

Right before she almost matched his pace, Gildarts pulled his cock out. Erza whined, before the cock was pushed into Lucy’s waiting pussy to the blond’s endless joy. His hips were almost a blur as he pounded Lucy’s pussy, listening to the sound of his hard cock sliding back and forth and the slap of his body against hers and Erza’s. 

This kept going on for a few more minutes, with Gildarts switching back and forth again and again, before he pulled his cock out and released jet after jet of semen. Both girls moaned at the sensation of cum splattering against their bodies, before the two closed their eyes and kissed once more.

They both hit their climax as they felt his seed land on them. They rubbed their bodies together, smearing the semen into their skin as they moaned, riding the waves of pleasure together, lips locked. 

When they eventually finished, both girls looked at Gildarts with an eager grin. The three moved positions, until Erza was on Gildarts’ lap, riding and bouncing upon his cock as Lucy rode his face, grinding her pussy lips against his own lips and tongue. Both women moaned as they leaned forward, catching each other in a kiss as their hands stroked each other’s bodies. 

Their hands groped the other’s chest as their lips pressed against one another. Lucy sucked on Erza’s tongue as the redhead pinched her friend’s nipples, and below both of them, Gildarts did his best to live up to their expectations… and beyond.

His hands were on Erza’s hips, lifting her up and down. His cock stretched out her walls, and the tip pressed against the entrance to her womb as she moaned and writhed. 

“Ahh! It’s so good,” she mewled as Lucy giggled.

“I know, right? It’s just so wonderful… Once you’ve had it once, most guys are just disappointments.”

“Promises, promises,” Erza chuckled, before trembling. “Ah! I-I’m cumming! I-ahh!” True to her word, she came on Gildarts’ cock. Her womanhood squeezed tightly around his shaft, clinging to all sides of it as he let out a groan.

His voice sent vibrations up Lucy’s pussy as he came, spilling his seed right into Erza directly. The older man’s sperm coated the walls of her pussy, even spilling into her womb as the redhead fell forward, needing Lucy to hold her up as she gasped for air.

Soon the three changed positions again, but Erza had a special idea for this one. She summoned a strap-on to her hand, and she strapped it on as she licked her lips. Gildarts and Erza were of one mind as he stepped back and allowed Erza the chance to be on top.

Lucy gasped, before giggling as she was pushed down onto the bed. In a funny, little twist, Erza and her were in the missionary position now, with Gildarts sitting on a chair and watching the two, the base of his cock wrapped tightly in his hand. He was touching himself as Erza pushed the plastic sex toy into her friend’s waiting pussy. 

Erza fucked Lucy just like how Gildarts had been earlier before. The redhead had her hands on Lucy’s ass, fingers digging into the soft, yet firm flesh as her hips bucked back and forth. Lucy moaned at the pleasure, shivering as the toy slid along her insides, her tight pussy walls clinging to it as her tongue hung out of her mouth. 

“Oh, fuuuck!” 

She was drooling in pleasure, drowning in the sensation as she wrapped her arms around Erza. The other woman licked up a small line of drool, before kissing Lucy. Their tongues angoed once more as Gildarts grinned, moving his hand in time with Erza’s humping hips. 

Part of him wanted to join in, but he rather liked this. Watching the girls’ large, bouncy racks mashed together, their tongues twisting around one another, Lucy’s body shivering from the thrusts of an equally gorgeous woman…

He stood up and walked over to the two, looming over them as his hand moved faster on his cock, stroking the sides as he began to quietly moan. The two women broke their kiss and looked at him, smiles on their faces as Erza kept fucking Lucy. A hand grabbed the woman’s blond locks, pulling on them slightly as Erza moaned. 

“Cum for us, Master… Cum all over me…” 

Hearing the powerful and alluring redhead call him that and beg for his seed… It was too much, and Gildarts’ seed soon came raining down, splattering against Erza’s back as the two women mewled below him. 

The girls soon came right after their man. They trembled, holding one another as the same fucked silly smile formed on their face. Their tongues hung out of their mouths as they eyes almost rolled into their skull. They cried out in wonderful, heavenly pleasure as their bodies quivered from the force of their orgasms. 

Then the two went limp, and they gasped for air as they laid on top of one another with tired smiles still on their faces. They moaned as they held one another, nipples still dragging along the other’s flawless skin.

Erza smiled at the two, resting her head on Lucy’s boob like a pillow for a moment as she said, “Thank you… That was… wonderful.”

---

Eventually the fun had to come to an end, of course. After hours of fucking, the three agreed to part ways. Gildarts began to clean up his bedroom as Lucy and Erza got dressed. After bidding the lucky man goodbye, the two left, walking to Lucy’s house together. 

Erza insisted on accompanying Lucy, wishing to protect her in case anyone unsavory was skulking the town in the middle of the night. Thankfully nothing happened and the two reached Lucy’s home without a problem. They stood outside the blond’s door as she smiled.

“That was a lot of fun.”

“Indeed. Just what I needed.”

“Well, I guess I’ll see you tomorrow? Goodnight, Erza.”

“Lucy, wait…” Erza pulled the blond towards her, and kissed Lucy once more. Lucy’s eyes widened as her body was pinned against the wall. Their bodies pressed together as Erza wrapped her arms around Lucy’s neck, moaning as their tongues met once more. 

Yet this kiss felt different. There was just something about it, some kind of fire to her lips. Erza’s knee pressed against Lucy’s pussy, rubbing against it as the blond’s legs trembled under her. Erza sucked on Lucy’s tongue, almost sucking the strength out of the curvaceous woman, before suddenly breaking the kiss.

“I hope next time, it’ll be just us.” Erza winked at Lucy, before turning around and walking away, leaving the blond standing there with bright, red cheeks.