Prompt: Helping a Friend Ch 5 (Fairy Tail) (Patreon)

Summary: Gajeel's found out about Lucy's many sexual partners, and he wants in. Includes: Smut and NTR

---

Lucy sighed when she felt the hot water of the shower splash against her body. The water hit her body, cascading down her large breasts, and shapely curves. She closed her eyes as she simply enjoyed the peace, relaxing as her stress was washed away.

The young woman was tired and sore, but who could blame her? After all she had been through in the last few days… so many sexual partners, all the sex and fun she’s had lately would leave anyone fatigued.

She brushed her hands over her body, letting out a quiet moan as her fingers brushed against her hard nipples. She groped her breasts, feeling the sizable mounds for a moment. They were nice. A good pair of tits that she knew so many people loved, including herself. Was it wrong to feel pride in them? So many people saw her as gorgeous, it wasn’t arrogant to agree with them... 

That’s when she heard someone knocking on her door. The blond let out a sigh, stopping the shower and stepping out. She grabbed a towel and wrapped it around her body, letting drops of water trickle down her figure. The water flowed down into her cleavage, pooling between her breasts as she tightened the towel around her body.

She walked to the front door and peeked through the small peephole, finding a familiar, if surprising face. Gajeel, the former member of the Phantom Lord Guild, and current member of Fairy Tail. Lucy was surprised to see the man, but she wasn’t just going to ignore him.

The blond opened the door a crack, and leaned her head out. She tried not to give the black-haired man a peek at her body, but it was almost impossible, and she could see his eyes glancing down her body as she spoke.

“Gajeel? What are you doing here?”

He placed a hand on the door and gave it a small push. Well, small for him. For Lucy, she almost fell back as the door was fully opened and her towel-clad body was revealed to the man. She blushed as she stood before him, pressing the towel against her body, only accenting her hourglass figure and how small the towel was. Much too small to cover her entire body, and Lucy’s blush only got worse as she tried to tug on the towel.

Her nipples were almost exposed as she looked away. The hard nipples were brushing against the fabric, but she did her best to ignore that Gajeel’s low voice growled. 

“I’ve been hearing a lot of things about you lately, Lucy. Got to tell you, I didn’t expect you to be so easy with so many people. Then again, if this is how you greet your visitors…” His eyes focused on her cleavage, and she shivered, wrapping her arms over her bust to try and hide it from his lecherous eyes.

“H-how-?”

“Ah, it wasn’t hard to figure out, Lucy. I walk by your place all the time to get home.” He tapped his ear, his sharp teeth forming a smile. “Easy to hear you with ears like these. You, and all your partners. Who knew Bisca was such a moaner?” he chuckled.

Lucy’s crimson face only burned brighter as she glared at the towering man. She opened her mouth to bark out a threat, putting on a brave face, but his hand stopped her. The young woman didn’t say a word as Gajeel smirked. 

“Calm down, your secret’s safe with me. Everyone’s secret is, but I want a piece of the action in return. We got a deal?”

Her jaw fell open and her eyes widened at the deal. She stuttered out a response, scarlet shame crawling down her neck. Lucy couldn’t utter a single, complete word as her blue eyes fell down his body. 

That was a mistake, because she was soon staring at Gajeel’s erection, clearly pressing against the fabric of his pants, trying to break free. He dick’s shape was clearly seen through the cloth, and Lucy couldn’t help but think about what the real thing would look like. 

“Like what you see, Heartfilia?” Lucy swallowed spit down her throat, finally closing her mouth.  

She blushed as his eyes stared her down. What options did she have? What could she say to argue with the muscular, powerful mage? He had her, and there was no way out of the deal that kept her dignity intact…

“Fine,” she finally answered. Gajeel’s toothy smirk grew wider, if that was possible, and Lucy ushered him in with one hand. He accepted the offer, stepping inside as Lucy looked down the street. 

As far as she could tell, no one had seen Gajeel enter her home. Good. She didn’t want a repeat of this incident…

---

The two entered her bedroom quietly. Neither said anything, something Lucy was thankful for. She couldn’t imagine having to deal with the arrogant man’s teasing. She gulped down her nerves as the brawny man sat on the edge of her bed, looking her room over. 

“Not a bad place, Lucy.” She didn’t respond, standing her ground with as brave of a glare she could muster. Gajeel seemed to find her expression cute, because he laughed when he saw it and patted his lap.

“Come on, sit down, facing me,” he ordered, and Lucy obeyed the order. She walked towards him, and with one last embarrassing gulp, sat down, her legs on either side of Gajeel as their faces closed in on each other.

His arms slithered around her back, stroking her smooth, moist skin, until suddenly she was pulled into the man. Their lips met, and Lucy’s eyes widened. Gajeel was not a gentle kisser, and before she knew it, his tongue had strong armed its way into her mouth, smacking around the inside of her mouth as she quivered.

The kiss was almost bruising as he held her against his firm body. His tongue smacked against hers, dominating and powerful, and she couldn’t help but smack her own against his. Their tongues wrestled as Gajeel’s lips pressed against Lucy’s, gently rubbing against them. Lucy’s tongue soom crumbled against the man’s, and she closed her eyes as his wet tendril dominated her mouth, wiping itself against her teeth and tongue.

He pulled on her towel, and it came off in an instant. She was naked, but their bodies were still pressed together, her hard nipples rubbing against his top. Lucy shuddered at the feeling, trying not embarrass herself by moaning. 

As the two kept kissing, that proved almost impossible. She really wanted to moan, just from the kisses alone… Suddenly, though, he pulled away, leaving her whimpering and whining for more. A trail of saliva linked their mouths as the dragon slayer grinned, licking his teeth.

“Take my clothes off,” Gajeel ordered, making her blush.

She was already one step ahead, tugging on Gajeel’s clothes to try and strip him bare. She didn’t say anything as she unbuttoned his top, revealing the thin shirt that he wore beneath. When the two pulled away, their eyes were locked on each other. Lucy blushed with shame as she struggled to catch her breath. Gajeel beamed with pride. 

It didn’t take long for the clothes to hit the bedroom floor, letting Lucy brush her fingers against the dark-haired man’s chest. He was muscular, firm, strong. Her kind of man, unfortunately. He was so damn powerful, so much stronger than her, and his body felt like sculptured marble. 

“Everything okay?” he teased. “You seem to be enjoying yourself,” he chuckled, savoring the embarrassed look on her face.

”A-am not. Just… just shut up,” Lucy muttered, before trying to kiss him again. She pressed her lips against his as their tongues met once more to wrestle for dominance.

She felt his erection against her body, so big and long that it brushed against her belly. It gave Elfman a run for his money. It rubbed against her, warm, hard, and already dripping precum. Her pussy tingled as she imagined it inside of her...

Gajeel had to pry the gorgeous blond off of him, letting out a low, almost sadistic laugh. Lucy still had his arms on him, and her first response to being pulled off was to whimper and quietly beg for more. Gajeel just smiled and leaned in close, whispering into her ear.

“I’m ready to fuck your brains out, slut.”

Lucy felt her pussy quiver. Her mind raced, and she couldn’t help but feel excitement coursing through her veins. She was going to do it with another Dragon Slayer, and that made her wet and horny. She wanted to do it with him. Right now, Lucy wanted nothing more than his cock…

She glanced down, and she saw the towering flesh rod with her own two eyes, falling for it, in a way. Before Gajeel could do anything, she moved first. He watched with a raised brow as she got off of him, sliding down so she was on her knees, face to shaft with his penis. 

The blond licked her lips, before she leaned forward and pecked the tip of the hard dick. It felt so good against her lips. She almost trembled from how good it felt.

“I-it’s so hard,” she marveled. Their eyes met and Lucy blushed as she kissed the tip of his dick again. “Probably the hardest I’ve ever seen. L-like an irod rod… S-such a big, hard cock…”

“I’m glad you like it. Now, show it the worship it deserves.” 

Lucy obeyed, opening her mouth and taking the cock down her throat. She moaned around it, feeling it push down her tongue. She licked the underside of his shaft, shivering at the salty, savory taste. Her hands moved to help pleasure the dick, one stroking and caressing the base while her other hand squeezed and massaged his balls.

Gajeel moaned at her soft fingers and warm, tight mouth. He knew Lucy had experience with sucking dick, but he couldn’t have predicted how good it felt to feel her blowing him. He placed his hands on her hair, digging his fingers into her bright, sunshine-colored locks as he began to fuck her face. Her head was impaled on his rod as he moved back and forth, stretching her throat out with his cock.

“You love it, don’t you, slut? Huh? Bigger than your boyfriend’s, I bet. Certainly harder than any guy you’ve been with.” Lucy couldn’t answer, so Gajeel just smirked and took her moans as confirmation. 

He kept fucking her face, feeling his dick go deeper and deeper down her throat. By now his balls were begging to slap her chin, and Lucy stopped stroking his nuts. Instead she started to massage and grope her own chest, kneading her tits and drool and precum dripped down her lower lip.

The sexual juices and spit fell onto her large chest, but Lucy didn’t stop. She just kept rubbing her breasts, wiping the juices along the hefty titflesh. She moaned as his balls continued to hit her face, pinching her own nipples. Her moans grew louder, and they vibrated against his shaft, further pleasuring the man.

What happened next was something Gajeel had been fantasizing about for a while. He let out a low groan as he came, unleashing a flood of cum down her throat. Lucy’s eyes widened, and she quivered between his legs as he unloaded his seed right down her throat. Despite the circumstances, Lucy took a deep breath and tried to simply swallow the seed. 

It was slightly bitter, but with a strong, savory taste. She moaned at the taste, closing her eyes to help enhance the delicious taste. She felt his shaft escape her mouth, slowly pulling out as she swirled her tongue around, feeling her appendage wriggle in a small pool of semen. Lucy finished swallowed the cum, and she opened her mouth, letting Gajeel see her hot and empty mouth.

“Good work, slut,” he chuckled, earning another blush from the woman. “Now then, get on the bed. We’re doing this doggy style, like the bitch you are.”

Gajeel picked Lucy up with ease, like she weighed nothing, and brought her onto the bed. He dropped her onto the soft mattress, and she didn’t fight him. In fact, she was the one to get into position, getting on all fours as he rubbed his still iron-hard dick against her pussy.

“You’re all wet for me. Good. I knew you were enjoying yourself,” he smirked. Before Lucy could argue with him, he thrust his hips forward, stretching her pussy open. She moaned loudly, bending her head back as she trembled. Her tongue stick out of her mouth as her vision blurred.

Gajeel slowly pulled his hips back, only to thrust forward again, making Lucy cry out once more, louder than before. He kept thrusting in and out of her, listening to sweet symphony of her moans. 

“How do I compare to that boyfriend of yours?” he asked, his smile widening as Lucy refused to answer. Her arms were shaking by now, and she looked ready to fall over as the black-haired man continued to stretch her pussy apart. “Here, let me help you.”

He bent forward, pressing his strong, hard chest against her back and placing his coarse fingers on Lucy’s chest. He began to play with her tits, enjoying their size and shape. 

Lucy was hardly the first fuck he’d ever had, but she was certainly different than his usual lay. Lately, Gajeel had been rocking Levy’s world, to the point where the two were basically living together. The petite, blue-haired woman was a great fuck, but damn. Lucy had one quality Levy certainly lacked.

A soft, heavy pair of udders. Gajeel made sure to give Lucy’s knockers special attention as he growled into her ear. “You’re a slut, Lucy. I bet you want me to fuck your ass too, huh?” 

Suddenly Lucy lifted her hands off of the bed, and she would have fallen onto the soft mattress had Gajeel not been holding her. The man raised his brow, about to ask the blonde what the hell she was doing, when he realized what she was doing. She had one hand on his, helping him grope her chest as her other hand pointed to a nearby drawer. It was by the bed, and just inches from Lucy’s quivering fingers. 

Curious, Gajeel adjusted their bodies, still fucking her tight pussy, though at a much slower rate than before. He allowed Lucy to reach into the drawer with his dick still plunging into her womanhood, and as his tip kissed the entrance to her womb, Lucy showed Gajeel what she had in her hand.

A small bottle of lube.

“Y-you’ll be the first,” Lucy confessed, turning her head to stare into his eyes with a bright, shimmering pool of sexual desire. 

Gajeel’s eyes widened, before he grinned. 

It didn’t take long for the man to lube up Lucy’s asshole. He applied the lube to his fingers, before he massaged the entrance, even slipping a finger in to make her writhe in pleasure. Once that was done, Gajeel pulled his dick out of the blond’s pussy and down her asshole, splitting her ass apart. Almost immediately, he went wild, really showing the woman how good his shaft was inside of her as he listened to her cries. 

Lucy’s scream was even louder this time, and Gajeel was left groaning from the pleasure. The young woman was shocked at just how good the man’s dick was in her asshole, even as he tore her cherry apart. The lube mixed well with the leftover saliva Lucy had left on his shaft, and his lube and saliva-coated cock pounded away at her ass.

Gajeel was hammering away at Lucy’s heart-shaped ass. He showed no restraint or mercy, after all, he hadn’t gotten the chance to fuck an ass this perfect in a long time. Levy didn’t give him the chance to fuck hers, so having the chance with Natsu’s girl was almost too good to be true. He made sure to paint her ass red, slapping each cheek as he stretched her asshole apart. 

Lucy seemed to like the slaps. She moaned louder when he hit her, and so Gajeel took a sadistic pleasure with each blow he delivered. Each of Lucy’s ass cheeks were soon a faint shade of red as they jiggled and bounced against his hips. 

It was a wonderful sight, but Gajeel soon decided on a slight change. He grabbed Lucy by her breasts before he fell back. In one swift move, Lucy was sitting on his lap, impaled on his penis. She was on top of him as he sat back, moaning from how tightly her ass was squeezing him.

Lucy screamed at the sudden change, her eyes rolling into her skull as she just… sat there. His massive cock was all the way inside of her, and his hands continued to smack her ass. She loved the stinging pain. He loved watched her ass jiggle. 

She didn’t move at first. She just sat on him, slowly gyrating her hips to let his cock rub the inside of her butt. 

“Fuck, you’re a better fuck than Levy.” Lucy’s eyes widened at that. Some part of her told her to feel guilt, to feel shame at the compliment, but that voice fell on deaf ears. 

“Oh…?” Lucy groped her own tits, squeezing her mammaries. “Why? Because of my tight ass? Or my warm mouth?” She licked her lips. “Or my huge tits?” Then she lifted herself up, and bounced herself on Gajeel’s iron dick .”Or. All. Of. The. Above?!” she moaned, emphasizing each word with a bounce.

“Oh, fuck! You’re better than her in every fucking way, slut! God, your ass is perfect!” Gajeel growled, giving it another harsh slap that left her red butt stinging. 

Something about the compliments Gajeel was giving her, about being better than Levy, made Lucy’s heart race. Before she knew it, she was giving Gajeel that same feeling…

“Your cock is bigger than Natsu’s…” Gajeel’s eyes widened at that. “And you fuck my pussy better than he did too!” She bounced on his dick, shaking her ass for him as she continued. “You’re stronger than him, faster than him, better than him! Gajeel, m-m...Master!” The word slipped out, but it pushed Gajeel over the edge as Lucy screamed. “You’re better than Natus!”

He wasn’t the only one to be turned on by those words. Lucy was too. Saying those things to her boyfriend’s rival, it… it drove her wild. Lucy closed her eyes as Gajeel grabbed her hips and held her against him. He unleashed his seed into her butt as she came hard on top of him. Their bodies trembled together as both were rocked to their very core, grinding their bodies against each other’s as their juices marked the other.

Both of them were left panting afterwards, basking in the afterglow of sex. Neither said anything as they slowly caught their breath, but the moment was suddenly interrupted by a high-pitched beeping sound. Lucy watched as Gajeel reached over the edge of the bed and picked up his pants.

Despite facing the other way, Lucy could still spy the name on the phone from the corner of her eye. She gulped as Gajeel commanded her. She could practically hear his grin.

“Don’t make a sound, slut…”

---

“Yeah, I just have some errands to run. Don’t worry, I’ll be home soon. Just as soon as I’m done… here!” 

Gajeel was pounding Lucy’s pussy. The two were facing each other, missionary style, as the brawny man made a mess of the blond’s cum-filled womanhood. The man had a phone to his ear as he fucked Lucy, one hand on her chest to squeeze and play with her breasts.

Lucy struggled to obey Gajeel’s command as she watched him make small talk with Levy. He had a grin on his face, as if he was enjoying her agony and shame. Lucy blushed, trying not to think about how Levy was just on the end of the phone, not knowing her boyfriend’s balls were deep in Lucy pussy. 

The voice from before tried to guilt Lucy, tried to tell her to stop. Lucy couldn’t hear it over the sound of Gajeel fucking her. All she heard were their moans, and the wet smacks of his cock pounding her cunt. 

The pleasure was mind blowing, ecstacy in its purest form, and Lucy was left a moaning, melted mess of flesh. She kept her hand over her mouth, trying to keep from moaning too loud as Gajeel went to town on her.

He fucked her harder than he ever did Levy, and that thought sent Lucy into another mind blowing, soul-shaking orgasm. She screamed into the palm of her hand as her mind entered a unique sort of peace…

This was the heaven, the nirvana she experienced when in the throes of pleasure. The same sensation Gray and the others gave her. When Natsu inevitably returned, could she really end things with them? She was sure she could once upon a time, but now she wasn’t so sure.