Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays! (Patreon)

In the poll results - 

Hannah and Caroline slid in as the number 1 couple most likely to dress up as Santa/Mrs. Claus... and in a wholesome family manner, I do not disagree. Little Miss Grinch aka Caroline Parker would absolutely - grudgingly, at first - dress up as Santa for Abbie's giant holiday party at school. How is she going to say no to the big blue eyes asking her? Especially when Hannah acquiesces to be her Mrs. Claus.

Riley and Gianna came in as a very close second, and I'll be honest - they were my first thought, as well. But most definitely not in a wholesome family manner, at all. In fact, I believe they would be wearing "costumes" in a very loose definition of the word... mostly consisting of red lingerie. 

Taylor and Brooke coming into third place? Absolutely. Taylor is always ready to dress up, and Brooke is willing to do whatever she needs to do in Faircombe to make an event go smoothly. So, if the Santa/Mrs. Claus can't make it to the holiday carnival - Taylor will volunteer them to do what needs to be done. 

Ellie and Mia would not be put in this scenario, as they will always have Riley and Gianna willing to do the dress-up gimmick. 

And, as some people pointed out, Sutton and Charlotte would 100% pay to have someone in costume. For a little soothing balm after last night's Midnight Rain, rest on Christmas knowing that in this universe, Sutton and Charlotte spend all of their Christmases happily together. And they most definitely have a santa claus come around to see their daughters every year. Sutton - with the larger feet of the two - will also pull off an elaborate ruse of "Santa's footsteps" from the fireplace to the tree, while Charlotte makes different nibble/bite marks on the carrots and cookies left out!