Thoughts on Lighting? (Patreon)

Hey Everyone, as some of you may know, I got very attached to a new idea of Lara Croft vs Jill Valentine! The Story is about Lara Infiltrating a heavily guarded yacht off the coast of Italy. She makes short work of the guards, but Jill poses a much more unique threat..."

I've been getting some assets together, but the only thing preventing me from starting is deciding what lighting looks better. I'm truly conflicted here.

The sunset background would like nice, and will clearly illuminate the action, but it conflicts with the story. The Darker background is more fitting for the narrative, and will hide some of the animation errors! However, I am afraid of Youtube's Compression! What do you think!

May I get your thoughts in the comments below!!