The Boyfriend Thief: Part 1 (Patreon)

She brought it upon herself really. She could have just been a good girl and kept to her own boyfriend, but one was never enough for her.

Maggie had gained a reputation at her high school. The 18 year old was decently smart and was very involved in a lot of clubs. Unfortunately, she had a reputation that was much more infamous than everything else she was known for. Maggie was a boyfriend stealer.

The girl just couldn’t seem to be able to help herself. She never liked to stick to one guy. She was thrilled by the rush of danger when she would try to seduce some other girls’ boyfriend. Some rare occasions they would reject her, but more often than not they would cheat on their girlfriends with her.

Once Maggie had slept with a guy though she didn’t care about him anymore. She wasn’t in it to find a boyfriend, she was in it for the chase. A unique hunting game where her prey was stupid boys who were dumb enough to only think with their dicks.

Most of the time, it would end up getting out that Maggie had slept with a guy which would normally ruin whatever relationship that guy was a part of. Maggie had single-handedly been the cause of at least ten different relationships breaking up at her high school. Part of her knew that it was wrong, but part of her loved it.

Sure she got yelled at a few times by some of those catty girls, but big deal. It’s not like they were actually going to do anything about it. They were all just talk.

Sure her reputation had a lot of negative connotation to it, but part of it sent excitement up her spine knowing that she was sexy enough to have basically any guy in the school that she wanted.

At least... almost any guy. Things changed when Maggie tried to seduce Derek Marzullo. Derek was still a fairly new student. He’d transferred to the school only a couple weeks ago. As soon as Maggie saw him, she knew she needed to score the new kid. Only problem, or what would be a problem for someone that wasn’t Maggie, is that Derek had a girlfriend already. His girlfriend didn’t go to Maggie’s school, she went to the school that Derek had transferred from.

From Day 1 Maggie was working on what would be the best method for seducing Derek and getting him to cheat on his girlfriend. The obvious choice was that his girlfriend was long distance. She could convince him that he’d be able to see Maggie on a daily basis at school and his girlfriend would have no idea.

The day she decided to do it, she purposely dressed up even more slutty than usual to be sure she’d get his attention. The amount of cleavage she was showing was absolutely not within the schools’ dress code.

Though, to Maggie’s shock, Derek completely rejected her advances. He barely gave her a second glance and even laughed a little when she started practically throwing herself at him.

“I have a girlfriend. Get lost girl.” Was all he would say to her, leaving the beautiful girl stunned, watching him as he walked away from her down the hallway. She had to admit, she was pretty pissed off that he didn’t even consider her. Most guys needed to do little more than take one look at her ass before they were all over her. Derek was clearly gonna take a little more work to win over.

Little did Maggie know, she’d never get the chance...

 What she didn’t know, was that Derek’s girlfriend, was a witch! She came from a whole line of generations of witches whose powers could do all sorts of wondrous things! That night Derek talked to his girlfriend on the phone like they did every night and he told her about the slutty girl at school with the bad reputation who’d hit on him. His girlfriend thought it was hilarious. Some slutty little skank at her hubby’s new school thought that she could convince him to cheat on her? As if!

She told Derek to tell her as much about Maggie that he possibly could. Derek told her everything. The slutty clothing, having sex with almost every guy in school, her tendencies to be a boyfriend stealer. The young witch thought the entire story of it all sounded quite pathetic.

“Clearly, she wasn’t raised very well.” The witch said. ‘Raised very well.’ the phrase sparked an idea into the witch’s head. She flipped through her spell book and smirked as she stopped at a few spells. She’d make a customized curse that would work just perfectly for that spoiled little Maggie...

*****

The next day Maggie headed off to school normally as ever. She was dressed in one of her typical sexy outfits and feeling confident as ever. Once classes for the day were over she didn’t even wait a moment before trying something again. She went right up to Derek at his locker.

“Hey Derek, how’s it going?” Derek gave her a small knowing smirk.

“Hey Maggie, just getting ready to leave. What’s up with you?”

Maggie tries to look as seductive as possible for him, she will claim him if it’s the last thing she does. “Oh nothing really...” She batted her eyes at him a little and not so subtly pushed upwards on her breasts. “I was just thinking about what you said to me yesterday and I definitely think you should reconsider.”

Derek chuckled a little. “Oh yeah? And why’s that?”

Maggie let out a fake giggle before lightly biting her lip. “Just look at me suga... what does your silly girlfriend have that I don’t? Oh come on... let’s go fuck. I know you want to...”

Maggie’s eyes went wide as the moment she stopped talking she felt something strange happening. It was happening right under her skirt. Her panties felt like they were getting poofier; almost like they were expanding against her skin. They were lace panties, but now they suddenly felt more like plastic-y as well as making a strange noise every time she moved a little.

“What the hell...” Maggie said softly, her brain trying to comprehend the bit of magic that had just happened under her skirt.

“Something wrong?” Derek asked, hiding his smirk. “I thought you were telling me why we should go fuck.”

“Oh, uh y-yeah... I was saying that...”

“Well, let’s go then. I’ll bring you to my place.” He said, taking her by the arm and leading her out of the school. Maggie was shocked and confused at her sudden victory. She would have been thrilled if the strange thing under her skirt wasn’t suddenly making her waddle.  

______  

This story was written by Zander Chesney
You can find more of his content here :
https://zanderchesneyoriginals.tumblr.com/