☆ Third Times A Charm ☆ (Patreon)

Reader founds out that Kendall knows about her and Bella's hook, and that Kendall has hooked up with Bella. A naughty idea is sparked in Reader. This is going to be a two-parter!  NGTHYB!Kendall x Reader x Bella, Word Count: 4k.

☆・*。

Y/n did not like to mingle with Kendall's friends.

It was nothing personal against her friends, Y/n never was buddy buddy with any of her girlfriend's friends. She's seen it get messy many times and she just wanted to avoid all of that. Not to mention she's fucked a few people who may be close to Kendall's circle that would probably be best for her to avoid. Too bad the closest one of them all was Kendall's best friend.

Y/n and Bella know what happened between them. Bella and Kendall know what happened between her and Y/n. However, Y/n is unaware that Kendall knows about what happened. It was a trifecta of mess.

It was a fleeting thought for Kendall, really. She didn't have that many qualms about it because it happened three years ago and Kendall was the one with Y/n as hers, not the other way around. It was really a test of her maturity when she was reminded of the situation. Kendall wasn't super insecure and jealous like she used to be when she first started dating Y/n officially. If Bella and Y/n actually had more than sexual chemistry and tried to date then she'd feel a way. But, since it was harmless fun during a lapse of judgement, it didn't upset Kendall that much.

There was no way Y/n was going to be able to avoid being around Bella. Her and Kendall chilled together, talked everyday, and even worked together. This relationship was getting serious and Kendall was bound to bring Y/n around her friends.

Unaware of what Kendall knew, Y/n was feeling guilty that Bella was coming over tonight and there was an elephant in the room. The elephant was even larger than Y/n expected with everyone knowing what happened that night a few years ago. Y/n was jittery but she was able to play it off, something she has grown accustomed to once she began working in her field.

"I got the rosé you like," Kendall says while holding up a bottle of the pink wine. Y/n smiled warmly, grateful that at least Kendall seemed to be the only acting normal. However, Kendall was also in the same boat as Y/n: nervous, but doing her best to not show it. "I don't know what time Bella is coming, maybe around 8 so that gives us plenty of time to be alone."

Kendall wrapped her arms around Y/n's waist from behind, pressing herself into Y/n. Y/n could feel Kendall's hard nipples underneath her slip dress. Y/n's mind was straying away from her thoughts and onto Kendall's behind her. She grinds her ass against Kendall's, signaling that she wants her just as much. Y/n looked over to the clock, it was 4 pm. She couldn't resist even if she wanted to when Kendall started to run her hands down Y/n's sides.

Two hours later and Y/n was out of breath. Kendall was looking for her dress that Y/n threw somewhere around the room. Y/n just watched her from bed. That post-orgasm haze had her in a weird spot. She was so use to pillow talking after sex, and more often than not, having a moment of vulnerability.

"Kenny I have to tell you something." Kendall doesn't respond, but Y/n knows she's listening.

"It's about Bella and I."

Kendall stops looking for her dress this time to look at Y/n. Her face was flushed from what Y/n believes to have been her orgasm, but it was a mixture of that and feeling anxious about what Y/n was going to say next. Well, she knows what Y/n is going to say next, but she's sort of freaking out that Y/n is coming out with this today, hours before Bella is supposed to come over and not after.

"A few years ago before we met, way before we met, I sort of kind of hooked up with Bella."

Y/n flinched as her own words left her mouth. She watched Kendall's face closely for a reaction, but there really wasn't one; it confused Y/n.

"I know. Bella already told me." Kendall turned away from Y/n as if unbothered by what Y/n had just confessed.

"Wait, what do you mean you know?"

"Before you and I got together, Bella told me about what happened between you two. It's really not a big deal Y/n, it's okay. I'm not jealous, it happened before we met. Besides, neither of us should be surprised that Bella had both of us. I don't mean to be shady because she's my best friend and I love her and I mean in the best way possible, but the girl can get around."

Kendall spoke her words so closely together, Y/n almost didn't catch that Freudian slip.

"So, we both had Bella?" Y/n had a smirk on her face now. A tinge of pink stained Kendall's cheeks. She knew Y/n wouldn't have been upset, but her hooking up with Bella (and Hailey for that matter) was something she sort of wanted to keep to herself. She wasn't ashamed, it was just that it felt unimportant and with all the context of the relationship between the three of them, it didn't seem appropriate to just bring it up.

"And you swore you didn't like girls before me. You're such a little sneak Kendall, I wonder what else I don't know about you." Y/n held a playful tone and the glint in her eye told Kendall that Y/n wanted to fish for more. "Was she good? She was a little needy with me, but I'm assuming between the time she's fucked you and I that she's had other experiences with women."

"It was fun, I can't lie. We haven't discussed it since and there is no awkwardness about it which is good because she's still my best friend no matter what. She's hot as hell, but I don't have any romantic feelings towards her, it just happened on a whim."

"On a whim, huh? Sort of like something tonight could happen on a whim?"

Y/n's voice was suggestive. The implications of her statement made her a little nervous. If anyone were to try anything, it'd be Y/n. But, Kendall wasn't too sure if she was keen on sharing.

"Don't get any big ideas Y/n."

"Too late honey," Y/n says with innocence. "You already put all of the ideas in my head."

With the knowledge of how both Kendall and Bella are in bed, Y/n wondered what the two of them would be like together with her presence also being in the room. If her memory serves her correctly, Bella was a bit of a pillow princess but if she was pushed, she could do glorious things with her hands and mouth. Kendall was becoming more dominant in bed with Y/n, but she knows that Kendall has more sexual prowess over Bella. However, Y/n is obviously the head bitch in this possible situation. She could make Bella and Kendall get each other off then Y/n could fuck both of them. Her thoughts were dirty but so exciting.

"Your silence scares me," Kendall jokes.

"My ideas aren't that wild." Kendall sighed and paused for a minute.

"You really want to do this?"

"It'll be fun! Just like my college years when I was having threesomes galore. I've fucked Bella, you've fucked Bella; why not just fuck each other!"

Kendall couldn't believe how laissez-faire Y/n was. She shook her head in disbelief, but she was on board. It would be fun, and it would be nice to have an exciting night instead of gossiping about whatever with Y/n barely chiming in because she doesn't really care. Not to mention that Bella would definitely be on board. She's single and she's been going through a period of "sexual liberation to free herself." Kendall's mind wanted to label all of this as awkward, but she shushed it away.

-

A few glasses of wine into the night, Kendall didn't have anything on her mind that was holding her back. Bella didn't find anything to be weird or find anything off about how open and friendly Y/n was and how suggestive the two of them were being. Kendall always found Bella to be super flirty and things were exaggerated when she was a little bit tipsy. Bella rambled on about nothing while Y/n looked over to Kendall to see if she was ready to make the next move. Kendall stared back at her; she wasn't backing out, just unsure how to go about this and how to initiate this. This was certainly Y/n's wheelhouse but not Kendall's. Y/n's lack of patience was obvious by the questions she kept asking Bella. She was prompting her to say even more outrageous things, as if she wanted Bella to confess to either one of the nights she had with Y/n and Kendall respectively; or she's trying to get her to initiate it first.

"I do need to get fucked. It's been a week now." Bella talked about it as if she hasn't had any sex in years. Y/n found it comical that she was such a sexual person yet she and Kendall found it hard to bring up that they should have a threesome. Y/n thought that she would just take a dry approach and flat out ask her, but for some reason she had some hesitance to be that bold.

"You have a million friends, you can find someone to fuck."

"A million friends in relationships. Not even my safe bets are free," Bella says with a defeated sigh.

"You have me and Y/n."

"I couldn't do that...even though I-" Bella cut herself off before she could finish. Even though Kendall and Y/n have been together for a good while, she was unsure if they knew how deep the three of them intertwined. Bella glanced over at Y/n to see if she caught onto her, but Y/n had a nonchalant look on her face.

"You know how open Y/n and I are when it comes to good friends." Kendall is obviously getting at the fact that all three of them have shared each other separately and now it was time to do it together.

"Kendall's right Bella. You're a good friend. You're safe with us."

Bella felt a bit confused, but she was more horny than she was confused. She hasn't even been touched, nor have Y/n and Kendall said anything explicitly dirty, but everything was getting to her and so was the excitement swirling inside of her.

"I feel like I'm being spoiled with having the two of you," Bella giggles. Kendall smirks, happy that it was easier to initiate.

Bella sometimes thought about how Kendall kissed her when they hooked up with Hailey. Her mouth was warm and her lips always had a thin layer of chapstick or gloss on them. She wanted to feel them on hers again and Kendall could see it in her eyes.

Bella pressed her lips against Kendall's mouth.  Kendall quickly caught on and moved her mouth against Bella's. The taste of that nice bottle of wine Kendall bought was heavy on Bella's lips. Kendall pushed past Bella's lips and moved her tongue into her mouth. By the way they kissed, Y/n definitely, knew that these two have fucked before. Y/n was more turned on than she was envious. Neither her or Kendall are fond of the idea of sharing one another, but with Bella it was an exception because they had a clear understanding that Bella is a very submissive girl and would listen to both of them eagerly.

Almost a minute passed before they broke their kiss. Kendall loved over to Y/n who was watching them intently. Without speaking verbally, Kendall beckoned for Y/n to join them but her girlfriend was unmoving. Y/n to watch how they played first; she had a glass of wine in her hand and she was enjoying the sight before her.

Bella had wandering hands that lingered on the exposed parts of Kendall's skin. Her touch was electrifying. Kendall let Bella take the lead for this moment, she watched Bella make careful decisions of where she placed her hand. Having their clothes on was pointless and Kendall wanted to discard them. She grabbed the top of Bella's strapless dress and pulled it down. She had no bra underneath and Kendall bets that she also has no underwear on too. Kendall cupped her perky tits before squeezing her nipples. Bella hummed and through her head back, a stupid smile on her face. Kendall leaned over so she could take one of Bella's nipples into her mouth. Bella sighed feeling Kendall's hot mouth on her.

"You know I like when you suck on my tits Kenny," Bella cooed. Kendall raised her other hand to tweak Bella's other nipple. Y/n raised a brow at Bella's words, but she'd be an idiot to interrupt them with stupid questioning.

Kendall pressed her weight into Bella until she was resting her head against the arm of the couch. Kendall looked up at Bella before her eyes wandered over to Y/n who was still just watching them.

"Get over here." Kendall quickly popped Bella's nipple back into her mouth, making Bella squirm against her. Bella nearly forgot that Y/n was in the room, but she was reminded when she felt another hand that wasn't Kendall's ghosting on her shoulder.

"She looks like she's already going to cum for you." Y/n's voice is above Bella's head now. She could feel her warmth emanating off of her.

"Do you want me to make her cum already?" Kendall teases Y/n, both of them temporarily forgetting about Bella's presence (despite talking about her) while they tease each other and stare into each other's eyes.

"Show me what you two did that night." Kendall smirked; she was up for the challenge.

"Want me to see how I licked her cunt until she came?" Y/n nodded her head. Although Bella wasn't involved in the conversation, she made her feelings known by wiggle against Kendall impatiently. Kendall pulled her eyes away from Y/n and looked down at Bella.

Kendall traveled down Bella's body until she was pushing the body of her dress up. No underwear, just like she's suspected. Y/n ran her arms down Bella's chest, brushing against her nipples before dragging her hands back up to play with her tits while Kendall nipped at her inner thighs.

"She's so wet Y/n."

"Not surprised, every time I've been around her she's dripping wet."

Bella blushes thinking about her past encounters with Y/n. Bella isn't hard to turn on, it's something she's not ashamed of but it's different to hear those words spoken out loud.

Kendall dragged her finger against Bella's slit. Bella held her breath at the slight pleasure. On Kendall's finger was Bella's wetness. She held it up for Y/n to see. Y/n leaned over and opened her mouth to suck her sweetness off. She hummed around Kendall's finger before she popped it out of her mouth.

"Tastes just as good as I remember."

Kendall stops playing her little game with Y/n and places her head between Bella's legs. Bella moaned as she felt Kendall's tongue flick against her sensitive bud. Kendall snaked her arms under Bella's thighs and hooked around them. She pulled Bella's cunt closer to her face and placed her entire mouth on her cunt. Y/n was still playing with her tits as she watched her girlfriend devour her best friend's cunt. Bella moaned loudly at all the attention she's receiving.

As much as Y/n loved watching Kendall play with Bella and she liked playing with Bella herself, Y/n was getting too turned on to stay still. She pulled herself away from Bella, receiving a groan from her, and got behind Kendall. Kendall was a little confused about what Y/n was doing, but soon her confusion was dissipated when she felt Y/n pushing up her knitted skirt, pulling her thong to the side, and shoving her face in her pussy. Y/n licked her with so much hunger. She moaned into Bella's cunt, sending vibrations throughout Bella's body. Y/n's eagerness only made Kendall work her mouth faster against Bella's pussy. Kendall jumped when she felt Y/n's finger pressing at her tight hole. Her and Y/n have never done many things with her ass, but she loved when Y/n teased her asshole. Kendall moved her fingers to Bella's slit and she pushed into her dripping cunt.

Kendall was pushing her finger in hard and fast into Bella's cunt. It was hard to keep her still, but Kendall did her best while also dealing with the onslaught of Y/n's tongue. Bella was moaning loudly over the sounds of both Kendall and Y/n's mouths against wet cunts.

Kendall didn't think she'd be able to keep up eating Bella out with Y/n sucking on her clit so harshly. Her thighs were shaking against her face and Y/n knew that she was ready to give into her. Y/n pulled away and slapped her ass twice, her skin turning red from the stinging contact. Kendall pulled away from Bella's cunt and gasped into the air.

"I didn't tell you to stop eating her."

Y/n shoves Kendall back down until she's taking Bella's cunt back into her mouth again.

"How does her hot little mouth feel?" Y/n asks Bella. Bella can barely speak, but seeing how dominating Y/n is, she finds the answer quickly.

"It feels so good...I love having her mouth on my cunt." Bella's voice was half of a whisper until she felt Kendall's tongue slide into her cunt. It was weird to explain, but Kendall felt a little jealous that Y/n reprimanded her and gave her attention to Bella instead. She wanted to impress Y/n by making Bella cum against her mouth as she screamed. She focused more on her best friend's hot cunt instead of Y/n's mouth against her pussy; her mouth was hard to ignore, but she did it. Kendall, however, did wiggle her ass against Y/n's face as she continued to suck at her folds, but she was putting all her effort and energy into Bella's pussy.

Y/n pulled away, breathless and with a messy face. Kendall didn't even flinch when Y/n took her tongue off of her, she was too focused on Bella's cunt. Y/n watched her from behind, watching her ass shake as her body moved as she tongue fucked Bella. Y/n was completely turned on; she couldn't turn her eyes away from the sight of her girlfriend eating Bella's cunt. But, Kendall's cunt was looking good to her too.

Kendall didn't notice Y/n disappear, she was too busy with her face buried in Bella's cunt. Bella's  fingers were lace through her hair. She was the only one in the room to notice that Y/n left, and the only one to see her walk into the room with a strap-on around her waist. Bella watched keenly as Y/n kneeled behind Kendall once again. Kendall noticed Y/n's presence when she felt the head of a cock poking at her slit. Kendall's eyes widened as she was filled with that thick cock. She pulled her mouth off of Bella's cunt and rested her head against her pelvis, but she kept her fingers inside of Bella. Y/n allowed it and watched Kendall's face contort in pleasure as she took the cock. She looked at both of the women in front of her being pleased; both of them had a similar look on their faces. Y/n drove the cock into Kendall a little bit quicker and harder when she heard her moan.

"Only two fingers? I know Bella's little pussy can handle more than that." Y/n gripped Kendall's hips and pulled her ass back to meet her pelvis. Kendall moaned, a little bit lost in her pleasure but not lost enough to where she couldn't slide another finger into Bella. Bella was moaning louder, a little bit of pain mixing with her cries of pleasures. "I know she can handle it. She's a good little slut; always have been, always will be."

Both Kendall and Bella were getting off on Y/n's words. She had a dirty mouth and the two of them loved to hear it. Kendall was pushing into Bella faster at Y/n's encouragement. Bella's warm walls were gripping her as she moved them in and out.

Kendall moved her face towards Bella's cunt again. She just licked at her clit while she finger fucked her cunt. Bella was begging to cum. Y/n and Kendall were unsure who she was begging to let her cum or maybe she was asking permission from the both of them.

"Make her cum Kenny. Let her drench your face in her juices."

Bella's mouth fell open as she gushed around Kendall's fingers. Her hips bucked upward and she couldn't be stopped. Her pussy had an incredible grip on Kendall's finger. She stopped pumping them inside of Bella, but she kept her filled. Kendall did pull her tongue away from Bella's pussy as she began to move around too much.

The sight of Bella cumming made Y/n fuck Kendall harder. Bella laid there tired and in a state of bliss, but Kendall still had her face near her cunt. Kendall was groaning as the cock reached deep into her.

“Good girl," Y/n coos at both Bella and Kendall. "Now it's your turn to cum Kenny."

Bella's ears perked up at that. She opened her eyes again to see her best friend getting pounded from behind by Y/n. It made her hot and nearly ready to go again, but she could still feel tingles in her clit from what Kendall did to her.

"Yea, cum for her Ken," Bella adds in a weak voice. Kendall looked up at her until her eyes closed again. She grabbed Bella's hips to brace herself for Y/n's harsh thrust.

"See even your best friend wants you to cum for me. Show her how good you look getting fucked."

Y/n grabbed a fistful of Kendall's hair and pulled her up so her face was right in Bella's face. Bella couldn't help but play with her pussy a little bit. She was still sensitive so she had to avoid certain areas on her cunt, but everything felt so good. Kendall's vice grip on her hips was sure to leave a mark that would remind her of this evening.

"I'm cumming!" Kendall announces loudly.

Little synapses in her body were going off. Her body warmed as her orgasm wrecked her. Her mind felt like it was at an all time high. Until she heard a phone ringing. She didn't let it ruin her orgasm, but it instantly annoyed her and nearly ruined the moment. The three of them tried to ignore the noise, none of them were done with each other, but the ringing was persistent. Even when it stopped and Y/n was slowing down her thrusts into Kendall, it was ringing again. Y/n pulled out of Kendall quickly instead of staying inside of her like she normally would. Kendall groaned at losing the feeling of the thick cock inside of her. Her and Bella looked at each other as Y/n stalked over to her phone. She sighed heavily as she stared at the screen and then answered it with hesitance.

"What......are you fucking kidding me?......Okay fine, fine, calm down. I'll be there in minutes." Y/n quickly hung up the phone and started gathering her clothes.

"What's wrong babe?" Kendall asks in confusion.

"Work emergency. I've got to go. We'll have to reschedule."

"Reschedule a threesome!?" It sounded ridiculous when Kendall said it out loud, but there was no changing Y/n's mind.

"I'm sorry, I’ve really got to go. You two can do whatever you want to each other. I don't know when I'm coming home so don't wait up for me."

Y/n is already halfway out the door, with her hair disheveled and her clothes not completely on her body.

"Oh," she stops in her tracks before leaving. "I'm not done with you two."

And with that, Y/n is gone.