Home Artists Posts Import Register

Content

54/100

Ignoramus alert! Neon Genesis Evangelion (which I watched prior to this film, one episode per week over the course of six months) is my first experience with long-form anime...and while I'd intended to address the TV series just briefly before focusing on the film, that turns out to be not just ill-advised but downright impossible. The End of Evangelion—at least as it appears on Netflix; some quick googling suggests that any differences elsewhere are cosmetic—expressly serves as an alternate version of the show's final two episodes, even going so far as to mark where episode 25.1 (let's call it) ends and episode 26.1 begins. As it happens, 25.0 and 26.0—which is to say, the original conclusion—are the only episodes that I actively love, and the last thing I wanted was to see them explained, counteracted, or even supplemented. In short, what we have here is a solution to a problem that I submit never existed in the first place. 

So: the TV series. For the most part, it's not my thing. While striking images abound, they seem rooted in manga (another subject about which I know virtually nothing, please note), amounting to a series of dynamic poses rather than a kinetic flow. Presumably that's a budgetary issue, but knowing that they didn't have much money doesn't make the visual stasis any less distracting. One significant supporting character spends almost literally the entire series in a contemplative pose that places both hands before his jaw, obviating the need to animate his mouth when he speaks. Part of the charm for some, perhaps, but I couldn't even hack Speed Racer as a little kid. As for the apocalyptic narrative, its Angel Of The Week approach quickly grew wearisome for me, offering little more than the superficial novelty of discovering what bizarrely random form the latest model would assume and what strangely random powers it would possess. That leaves the characters, and I'm just not someone who's gonna empathize much with Shinji's daddy issues, or be amused by Asuka's petulance (which turns out to involve mommy issues), or identify with Rei's detachment. Maybe you have to be younger—I doubt I'd have much regard for, say, The Breakfast Club had I not initially seen it at age 17. But it also doesn't help to situate that adolescent angst within the context of a battle to save humanity itself from extinction. I was drawn mostly to Misato and Ritsuko, if only because they're both fully engaged with practical necessities. (Though that entails a whole lot of tedious dialogue at NERV HQ, with people forever shouting things like "Solenoid graph inverted! Ego boundary weakening!")

Consequently, I was thrilled when the show made an abrupt avant-garde lurch in the home stretch, abandoning any pretense of life on Earth ever returning to normal and enfolding everyone's neuroses into a Borg-like Human Instrumentality Project. The final episode, in particular, anticipates what Lynch would do with Mulholland Drive, albeit in reverse: It's as if he'd made an entire season about Diane and Camilla, concluding with an episode devoted to Betty and Rita (with no more explanation than we get in the actual film). Neon Genesis admittedly chickens out a little, ultimately withdrawing from Shinji's re-imagined world and deeming it one possibility of many (or something like that); I'd have preferred more conceptual fortitude. To my mind, though, that's otherwise a nearly perfect ending. I had no further questions and some difficulty imagining what this film could even possibly be about. Evangelion had already decisively End-ed.

Rabid fans back in the '90s did not agree, apparently. Thus this revised extended denouement, which is admittedly pretty bugfuck in its own right but nonetheless struck me as almost entirely superfluous. (And of course it's not really a movie, though I saw the version with just one set of credits—in very cool proto-Noé helix form—sandwiched between the two double-length episodes.) Major characters die heroically, but that seems almost meaningless given that we'd previously seen everyone merged into a single entity. Are we meant to mourn their absence from the collective? Meanwhile, the Christian symbolism, which had been omnipresent but relatively low-key, really goes into overdrive, with crosses fucking everywhere and the Lance of Longinus making a climactic reappearance. I did appreciate that Shinji's emotional issues finally transcend "Daddy didn't love me," reaching new levels of self-loathing; it's quite startling that the film opens with him jerking off to Asuka's comatose form (I guess Japanese filmmakers, too, can be more explicit when they move from TV to the big screen), and while I still prefer the original "fantasy" ending overall, Asuka's final utterance here is so unexpectedly harsh, and the choice to end on that note so audience-unfriendly, that I was genuinely taken aback. Hard to square that with my general sense of this as a cop-out intended to placate those who'd found the show's final episodes too obscure. In any case, can't say I'm eager to jump into Dragon Ball Z or Cowboy Bebop (though I know Rian Johnson's a huge fan of the latter). I may occasionally revisit Neon Genesis' opening credit sequence, though. Annoyed me at first, but by the seventh or eighth week I was not only eagerly looking forward to it but also singing the tune around the house, with invented English lyrics: "There's no neon in this motherfucking show / I don't know why they threw in that adjective..."

Files

Comments

Anonymous

You should check out Those Clone Wars on Disney+--curious what you would think.

Anonymous

Requester here: quite happy with this! Honestly expected 40-49 rating for the movie—that you actively loved the ending (and liked the ending to the movie) is even better. Did you enjoy the “Ode to Joy” sequence in the show at all? That’s a pantheon sequence for me.

Anonymous

There’s nothing quite like Evangelion. You may want to steer clear of any other anime series if the final episodes were your sweet spot. I’ve yet to find another show that matches their audacity.

Anonymous

If you feel like trying something else, I really dug SERIAL EXPERIMENTS: LAIN 20 years ago, though I have no idea what I'd think today.

Anonymous

Everyone's going to be throwing anime suggestions at you, and I'm no different. My pick is PARANOIA AGENT, which is kinda-sorta like a David Lynch TV show turned into a cartoon. Also, it's only 13 episodes.

Anonymous

"Cowboy Bebop" would've been a better introduction to longform anime. Not much visual stasis there.

Anonymous

"a cop-out intended to placate those who'd found the show's final episodes too obscure" As someone who enjoyed both the original ending as well as the movie version i've always felt this version's greatest strength was the contempt it held for its original otaku detractors. A real subversive fuck you to those who wanted a conventional ending even if it's a bit cloaked under fan service. In terms of "audience-unfriendly" I still get a kick out of the original advertising behind this release. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HALL5-PZu4 Anyways as always appreciate the review!

Anonymous

If you found Evangelion tedious, you should never watch Dragon Ball Z.

Anonymous

This is about the review I expected when I heard EoE had been chosen. Evangelion is one of those anime that I think actively improves the more anime/manga you consume, the same way that say, Watchmen improves the more comic book history you know. In both cases, I think the work stands fine without further context, but Evangelion in particular expects you to know and care about mecha and anime tropes. That's Ed, if you do try anime again, I'd recommend both of the Fullmetal Alchemist adaptations. Unlike most manga adaptations, the author of the original series helped craft an entirely different story for the first adaptation, while the second one (Brotherhood) is a direct adaptation. If nothing else, I think you'd dig how you can take the same basic characters and premise and result in two very different stories.

Anonymous

Hey, a D'Angelo "on the fence, leaning forward" rating for one of my favorite movies...I'll take it! Also I gotta say I'm touched by your willingness to sit through a 26-episode show you mostly didn't care for just to honor a patron request. Though you may want to set some limits before folks start requesting, e.g., the Steven Universe movie...

Anonymous

Thirded, especially if you feel like being a Satoshi Kon completionist. I see you’ve been been mixed on his features, but if it’s any incentive, the series is very much its own beast.

Anonymous

Speaking of advertising, I'm not sure anything in the series itself is quite as surreal as the spectacle of Shinji's dad shilling for disposable razors: https://youtu.be/xli293P8fug

Anonymous

I showed this review to my 20-year-old, who is a huge fan. (He managed to rope his Mom into watching the series with him - I, thankfully, have been spared). His comment is that without having seen a lot of other manga you wouldn't pick up on how Evangelion is riffing on these tropes, which quite obviously you had no way of knowing. But otherwise everything you said made sense to him.

gemko

Apparently it didn't make a significant impression on me, as I remember having heard it at some point but can't recall the context.