Home Artists Posts Import Register

Content

Picture: Paddington 2 (55/5)
Director: Abbas Kiarostami, 24 Frames (54/5)
Actress: Lady Gaga, A Star Is Born (57/8)
Actor: Jason Bateman, Game Night (57/7)
S. Actor: Steve Buscemi, Lean On Pete (54/6)
S. Actress: Molly Parker, Madeline's Madeline (42/6)
Screenplay: Valeska Grisebach, Western (46/5)
Scene: "Rock Around the Clock," Cold War (40/3)

[Couldn't remember what was distinctive about this scene, and I still don't really get it after watching it again (admittedly out of context this time—might be the sudden incursion of rock and roll energy). But then I also never understood people's passion for the "This Time Tomorrow" dance in Regular Lovers.]

HISTORY:

Happy to see Kiarostami get one last posthumous nod, especially for such an unorthodox work—one that challenges our very notion of what "directing" entails. He previously placed 15th for Taste of Cherry (1998), 8th for The Wind Will Carry Us (2000), 4th for Certified Copy (2011), and 13th for Like Someone in Love (2013).

Bateman landed at #14 three years ago for The Gift. (He should have won.) I'm gonna hold off on Buscemi since—spoiler alert—we'll be seeing him again. Gaga is new, and so, to my surprise (given her prominence ca. 1996–2000), is Parker. 

Grisebach's only previous Skandie-eligible film was Longing, ignored in all categories save for a lonely, token 5-point vote in Director. Be My Star had many fans among the AVB, but was never released in the U.S. (probably because it's barely an hour long).

For those who are wondering, not only did Paddington fail to place in Best Picture three years ago, it failed to receive even a single vote. The two films seemed pretty similar to me, quality-wise. Lotta befuddlement for me this year.

Files

Comments

Anonymous

I think the first PADDINGTON got boned on release date (thanks to the TWC implosion) and had fewer viewers and also was not a welcome respite from a Trumpian hellscape.

Anonymous

And having just seen COLD WAR I can say that I considered "Rock" briefly for scene as it is a defibrillator to the staidness of the film. Also, other people like long tracking shots nore than you.

Anonymous

And the return key closes comments on my phone so I apologise for all of these being broken up but LONGING is fucking amazing and more people should watch it. But I think it's quite hard to track down.

gemko

It's not the release date—both <i>Paddington</i>s were released in the U.S. the second week of January. Second one has six more Crix Pix votes than the original, which can't have hurt but isn't an overwhelming difference. I'm betting on Trumpian hellscape.

Anonymous

The Rock Around the Clock scene in Cold War does indeed benefit a lot from context—I liked the movie, but I remember the scene being a real jolt of energy.

Anonymous

Ah, I'm mixing up with a NZ release date issue of some kind that kept me for voting on it in a local poll, although I do recall there being some limbo around TWC which may or may not have effected how many people saw it theatrically or caught up with it later. Interestingly, PADDINGTON is 3.8 on LBxd, P2 is 4.2, and David Ehrlich's review of the latter (the first that comes up for me) references both Trump and Brexit. (I think I heard Christoph Waltz just say something about a bingo.) I agree they're about the same for me.

Anonymous

The first Paddington made almost two times more money in the U.S. than the sequel. The latter was effected by the Weinstein accusations - it fell into the hands of WB mere weeks before release.

gemko

That makes more sense to me as a Scene choice. (What I most remember from <i>Cold War</i> isn't a scene but the mirror shot.)

Anonymous

Accidentally deleted my comment that Mike was responding to. I was just pointing out that I was likely the sole voter for a very similar scene from <i>Cold War</i>, "Two Hearts": <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IxFsK7xKRPM" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IxFsK7xKRPM</a>

Anonymous

I am responsible for you seeing Be My Star.