COMMISSION: Mystery at MacMaster ch.2 (Patreon)
Content
Author's Note: More this!
[story] [all characters are 18+]
_______________________________
Four Years Ago
“Alright, kids, remember: a little noise is fine, but if you get too loud I’m gonna have to come back up here and start some trouble,” the tall, swanlike blonde beauty that was Mrs. Vinke pursed her lips at the small gaggle of young teens, one thin brow arched to show that while she was serious, she was also in relatively good humor. “And I want you all in bed by ten, too, alright?”
“Yes Mrs. Vanessa’s Mom,” one of the five girls, Octavia, intoned drily, while the others basically nodded along.
“Please, it’s Kri-- alright, whatever,” the older woman chuckled. “I’ll be up in a few hours to see if any of you need anything.”
Clicking the door shut behind her, Mrs. Vinke left the five girls alone in Vanessa’s spacious, aggressively pink room. An only child with well-off parents, Vanessa’s room showed the relative opulence she lived in, with stuffed animals being gradually phased out in favor of teen heartthrob posters, makeup kits, and other various ‘influencer’ merch, leaving childish things behind now that she was officially a high schooler.
Among those present was, naturally, Vanessa herself, a bit more gangly than she would come to be known and sporting braces she couldn’t wait to be rid of. Octavia Phan and Mica Bell were Vanessa’s two best friends, the former sporting jet-black pigtails and the latter a head of thick, untameable red hair. Lastly was Piper, a beanpole by any measure at this age and even more conspicuously lanky in comparison to her classmates, sporting braces of her own... and, of course, Piper’s plus-one, with her refusing to go to the slumber party if she couldn’t bring Kora along. Kora sat with her back pressed up against one of the bunk-beds, headphones over her ears and her eyes glued to the screen of her DS -- while she would go on to change little aesthetically over the next four years, it would prove a critical time for her development socially.
“Alright, so,” Vanessa began, taking in a deep breath and putting on an immediate air of authority with her mom out of the room. This was her house, and her slumber party; she was the one in control here. “We have some sandwiches that I helped make if anyone wants, and there’s a cooler with soda just outside the door. It’s all diet so no complaining. I have some video games, or we could do each other’s makeup, or....”
“I, uh-- oh-- um-- I also brought a couple board games if you guys want, and a miniature-based tactics game Kora and I are really into,” Piper offered hesitantly. “S-sorry, I didn’t mean to interrupt. Have any of you guys played Wars of the Red Field? The main campaign is short, like three-to-four hours, but I think you’ll really appreciate how subtly it introduces lore through its mechanics and builds on it over subsequent playthr--”
“Ooh, what about truth or dare?” Mica suggested, seamlessly talking over Piper, a devilish grin spreading over her face, green eyes lingering on her for a moment before moving past. Piper was a decidedly unorthodox addition to these kinds of get-togethers, ill-fitting with and largely unliked by Vanessa’s other friends -- theorized to be a replacement for a friend who’d recently moved to Ohio with her parents. Still, she and Vanessa seemed to get along, if strangely, and it was what Vanessa wanted that mattered.
“I think that’s a great idea,” Octavia giggled evilly, shooting quick glares at the two girls who didn’t belong, then to Mica -- the two held one another’s gazes a long moment, as if reading each other’s minds, already in on some sinister plan.
“I was thinking we could do that later, but if you really want to, alright, let’s get in a circle,” Vanessa huffed, breathing a quiet complaint about nobody taking any sandwiches as she perched down onto the carpet.
Piper fidgeted, faking a half-smile. “Alright, cool, and maybe after we can give Wars of the Re--”
“Vanessa, do you wanna go first?” Mica interrupted immediately, sitting up from her perch at the edge of the bed to sit on the floor, her and the others beginning to form a loose circle that only Kora wasn’t in on. Glancing her direction, Piper tugged gently at the edge of her friend’s shirt.
“Uh?” Kora grunted, shifting one of her headphones to the side and half-glancing at Piper from her game.
“We’re playing a...” Piper paused. This was far from a game, and definitely not something she wanted Kora to get her hopes up about. “We’re going to engage in an activity, your presence is required.”
“Oh, ‘kay,” Kora nodded, switching off her hand-held and begrudgingly removing her headphones, scooting forward to take a position in the newly-formed ring, with Piper to her right and Octavia to her left.
“Alright,” Vanessa breathed in once everything settled down, “we’re going clockwise, so--” looking to the girl to her left, Mica, she stifled a giggle. “Mica, truth or dare?”
“Truth,” the redhead chirped contently, her face showing the cold confidence of someone with nothing to hide, a bold position for someone so young.
“Okay,” Vanessa grinned, biting her bottom lip as she tried to think of a sufficiently wicked question, eventually choosing to expose, rather than a secret, an opinion. “If there were a zombie apocalypse, who here do you think would be the first to get eaten a l i v e?”
“Well, having seen how clumsy Piper is, I’m sure she’d trip and fall in the first few minutes; she’s like a baby foal,” Mica snorted, a laugh Octavia joined in on all too quickly. “Yup, easy take!”
“Hey, I have, um... longer legs, so I can run,” Piper frowned, only for the laughter to rise in volume, now joined by Vanessa.
“She has a point, Piper, you do fall down constantly,” Vanessa chuckled, though it lacked the reflexive earnest of the other two girls -- more like someone who joined in laughing in order to be in on the joke. “Alright, Mica, it’s your turn.”
Biting her lip, Mica turned leftward, facing Piper, “Alright zombie-bait,” she said, causing another little roll of giggles through the group, with Piper’s freckled cheeks turning deeper and deeper pink. “Truth or dare?”
“Um... truth?” Piper said hesitantly.
“Have you ever kissed someone before?”
Piper’s blush only grew more intense. Despite barely being in high school, there was always gossip about who was kissing who, who held hands, who was ‘going steady.’ Innocent stuff, but still, it was sort of a sign of how important and popular you were. Despite not having been friends with Vanessa for long, the blonde had already mentioned going on ‘real dates’ or having girlfriends... but that wasn’t the case with Piper. Even if all that gossip was just made-up bravado, she had to tell the truth, here. “N-... n-no, I haven’t.”
“Big surprise there,” Octavia giggled.
“Pff, like you’ve kissed anyone, gator-breath,” Kora chimed in, jumping to her friend’s defense.
“Hey, I kiss all kinds of people,” the other girl frowned, but Vanessa took the reins again, quickly pointing to Piper. “Alright, your turn, Pipe.”
Swallowing hard, Piper glanced over to Kora, taking a bit of solace in the fact that she could play with her own friend for a moment, rather than the two vultures Vanessa had brought over. “Okay, um, Kora, truth or dare?”
“Mm, dare.”
“Ooh, okay, uh-- Vanessa, you said you brought sandwiches, do they have pickles?”
“Oh no,” Kora groaned.
Vanessa’s nose crinkled, “Yeah, why?”
“Okay, Kora, you have to eat all the pickles on one of those sandwiches,” Piper showed off a big, toothy smile, as if she had embodied the very soul of wickedness. “But you can’t just eat the sandwich! Only the pickles!”
“Ugh, gross,” Kora sighed, wincing as she went for the plate of sandwiches, opening one to reveal the lightly mustard-caked trio of pickle chips inside. “Fine, fine... phhh, this is gonna be nasty.” Hesitating, then sighing, she crammed the pickles into her mouth, making a face as she forced herself to chew them, doing so as quickly as possible before finally swallowing. Extending her tongue to show they were gone, she held out her hands as if issuing further challenge. “Done!”
“First dare of the game,” Vanessa chuckled, “cute. Good to see Piper didn’t take it too hard on you, let’s see how you extend that courtesy now that it’s your turn, Kimmy.”
“It’s Kora.”
“Right, Kora Kate.”
“Kora Kane,” the girl exhaled through her nostrils in annoyance, then shifted her attention to the girl to her left, Octavia. “Alright, truth or dare, I guess.”
“Let’s do... truth.”
Kora furrowed her brow in thought, for a moment. The issue was, she didn’t actually care about anyone here besides Piper, so no information she might get would have any value to her. She also lacked any genuine desire to humiliate -- but, with the way these two had been treating Piper, maybe a little payback would be fun. Her mind working quickly, she came up with a question that would leave Octavia in hot water, regardless of her answer. “Do you think Vanessa’s mom is hot?”
“I-- uh--” Octavia swallowed hard, looking to Vanessa, then back to Kora. “Um... no...? She’s like, so old, so like--”
“She is not, she looks great,” Vanessa grimaced, and Octavia backpedaled.
“Like, she looks great and everything, but like, just way outside my... range. Of people. Like I would like.”
“Tch, whatever,” Vanessa pouted. “Alright, your turn I guess.”
“Okay, Van, truth or dare?” Octavia said hesitantly.
“Hmm. Dare.”
“I dare you...” Octavia glanced to Mica, who flashed a brief grin, “...to kiss Piper, on the lips. Finally give her that first she’s been needing.”
Piper’s heart leapt into her throat, her mouth suddenly dry. The friendship she shared with Vanessa was not entirely innocent -- the two weren’t in any kind of relationship, of course, but Piper’d been nursing a crush on the blonde since gradeschool, getting closer and closer to her and even finally infiltrating her group of bitchy friends in an attempt to better get to know her. This could be the moment she’d been waiting for, the moment when sparks flew, when Vanessa realized she felt the same way.
That moment of terrified elation came tumbling down when she saw the look of shock on Vanessa’s face. Not horror, but... not far off. Closer to disgust. Mica and Octavia were both giggling quietly as Vanessa began to stammer. “Wait, hold on? Piper? No way -- I’d rather make out with my own mom! You’ve gotta be, like, totally kidding--!”
“Those are the rules, Vanessa, you chose dare, you have to do it!” Mica jeered. “Though, I mean, I can’t imagine you’d actually want to....”
“It’s okay, Vanessa, it’ll be quick, w-we can just--” Piper tried, only to be quickly cut off.
“No way, it’s my slumber party, it’s my house, I decide what flies in truth or dare, and I’m tired of this game anyway!” Vanessa scoffed, either ignoring or not noticing the sudden rush of wetness to Piper’s eyes, her blush of shame and humiliation rapidly returning. She may not have noticed, but Kora did.
As the sound of raucous laughter from Mica and Octavia grew seemingly deafening, Kora had wrapped her arms around Piper’s shoulders, lifted the two of them to their feet, and hurried downstairs to call their parents and get taken home. The two of them didn’t get invited to any parties after that, and Piper’s friendship with Vanessa had ended as abruptly and unexpectedly as it had began.
o-o-o-o-o-o-o
Present Day
“Yo, I just got a--” Kora looked driverside, pausing when she saw Piper’s distant, thoughtful expression. “Hey, you good?”
“Mm?” Piper said absently, then shook herself from her reflective daze. “Oh, yeah. Was just thinking about something from a while ago. What’s going on?”
“I got a text from Heather Edwards, of all people.”
“Heather Edwards? I didn’t even know she had your number.”
“Neither did I, honestly-- ooh, taco place is right up here!” Kora paused and pointed, directing Piper to turn into the parking lot of a hole-in-the-wall fast food place called Quesadillicious.
“What’d she say?” Piper pulled into a spot, then unbuckled her seatbelt and gave Kora her full attention once again. “I can only imagine it’s something important, it isn’t like Heather Edwards is known for making social calls. Not to us, anyway.”
“Hey, I think we get along better with Heather Edwards than most of the girls at MacMaster,” Kora shrugged. “But yeah, you’re right. She said she thinks Millie Nowak’s still alive, and to meet her tomorrow at Shivers around one.”
“PM?”
“Uhh, I hope so.”
“You never know with Heather Edwards.”
“Point, I’ll make sure.” Kora paused, sending a quick text back, then waiting. The phone vibrated an instant later. “Yeah, PM.”
“Good. I don’t wanna get arrested for loitering outside Shivers after-hours.”
“Saaaaame.”
The pact sealed, the two went inside. Tacos were had, and they returned to Piper’s house, playing video games together until the eyes of both were bleary and bloodshot. They had a big day ahead of them tomorrow. Nobody was summoned by Heather Edwards unless they had a big day ahead of them.
o-o-o-o-o-o-o
Shivers was an ice cream parlor on the south side of town. Originally, it was meant to be called ‘Shakes,’ on account of the fact that they had milkshakes, and that the milkshakes in question were... well, cold, sufficiently so to make one shake. It was eventually decided that this was a rare combination of both being too on-the-nose, and too difficult to explain, and the name was changed to Shivers. It consisted of a single large kiosk with a pink roof and peeling white paint, surrounded by uncomfortable plastic benches, those in turn shielded from the elements with pink-and-yellow striped awnings. Parking was dreadfully limited, forcing most people to walk from a block or more away.
It was there to which Piper and Kora walked now, Piper’s car parked on the side of the street about a block away. How Heather Edwards had arrived, if she had, remained unknown, but as the two made their way up to the little shop, they saw her, sitting placidly at one of the benches, twiddling a plastic spoon back and forth into the middle of a plain white shake. Heather Fucking Edwards.
She was lean like a sword, taller than average if not quite Piper’s height. Light skin was contrasted by black hair, cut short and styled into a lazy upward spike in the front. Her eye color was unknown -- she was never seen without a pair of round, Lennon-esque sunglasses, only streaks of dark eye-makeup visible beneath them. Converse, black jeans, and a long-sleeved, logo-less, navy-blue shirt rounded out an almost effortless aesthetic. Heather Edwards didn’t need to look good. She only needed to look cool.
She was part of no clubs, played no sports, was barely social with anyone. Her grades were so bad she’d been held back a year. Ate by herself. But when Heather Edwards ate by herself, she made it clear that it was only because no one else was badass enough to sit with her.
“Hey!” Kora called out as the two friends approached, holding one hand up in an awkward wave. “Heather Edwards!”
“Mrh,” came the grunted response, saving her breath until the pair approached fully, taking seats at the other side of the table she’d been previously dominating.
“You called us, right?” Piper tilted her head slightly sideways, then fell silent, not wanting to press. A long moment passed as Heather Edwards stared at the two through the hollow black abysses of her sunglasses, lips pursed in mild disapproval as her spoon slowly stirred around and around the center of her milkshake.
“So, two little birds come to perch on my windowsill. Two peanuts in a husk, yet to hit the hot oil.” Heather Edwards’ lips twitched, something that could almost be considered a smile. It was gone before it appeared, something for an alternate reality to enjoy. A ghost. “I did summon you, didn’t I? Seems so long ago, now.” Her voice was low, husky, intense yet somehow effortlessly so.
“...It was yesterday evening...” Kora frowned.
“Perhaps it was,” Heather Edwards drew in a slow, deep breath, finally slipping the long, red plastic spoon from the frozen vortex of her milkshake, and gently licking it clean. Suggestive, though, the gesture was not whatsoever -- unless one considered it suggestive when the flat of a panther’s barbed tongue scraped the last vestiges of flesh from an otherwise cleaned bone. “Something’s happening at MacMaster. Happening in this town. Something silent yet reeking, like the corpse of a deer on the side of the road. It looks pristine until you poke it with a stick, and then the hiss of gas and stench of death from within lets you know in no uncertain terms what’s happened. The disappearance of Millie Nowak is the corpse, unfortunate but innocuous, clean-cut, irreversible, obvious. Try to investigate, and all you find it more and more rot -- more maggots, more stink. Something horrible’s happened.”
“That’s, um... o-okay,” Piper stammered, caught somewhat off-guard by the sudden diatribe.
Kora chimed in. “But wait, didn’t you say she wasn’t dead, in the text?”
“She isn’t. At least, I don’t think she is,” Heather Edwards took another bite from her milkshake, gathering her thoughts for a moment. “Murders tend to either be abrupt -- sudden twists of fate leading to death, or earned -- a series of events where someone places themselves in direct danger. Some illicit affair (maybe an actual affair) that draws the wrong kind of attention from the wrong person.”
“How do you know all this...?” Kora frowned, but was talked over.
“Nowak fits neither. The more I look into what happened, the more I find something strange happening. Reports of odd behavior. She visited the MacMaster library more times in the month before her disappearance than her entire time in high school. One-hundred and twenty-three times. Nowak was a swim jock, a C student, used to have nerds do her homework for her in exchange for quick handjobs, otherwise undeserved,” Heather Edwards chewed at the edge of her lips a moment, another thoughtful pause in between strands of rapid-fire theorization. “But going to the library isn’t something someone gets killed for. It isn’t normal, but it isn’t wicked either.”
“If you don’t mind my asking,” Kora took the ensuing instant of silence to interject, her own mind attempting to click the pieces of this puzzle together, but it was like trying to fit a seven-pointed star block into a square hole half the size. “Why... are you telling us this? Like, why us, of all people? We didn’t even know her.”
“Someone has to know. A story without a listener becomes no more than an errant thought, insignificant. I tell the jocks, they’ll blow it off. An adult, they’ll think I’m crazy. Cops could be in on it. Nerds lack the balls to take action. So the merry-go-’round brings me to the two of you -- no stakes, big imaginations, maybe just enough spunk. Take it as a compliment.” Heather Edwards paused again, looking up at the hazy halo of light coming through the awning, marking where sun would be, just above. “I didn’t know Nowak well. She seemed like an okay kid. She didn’t deserve to die... and if she is still alive, she probably won’t be for long.”
“This is... crazy,” Piper shook her head, “we’re not detectives, or police, or PIs or anything like that. We’re just nerds, we’re not cut out for something this big, even if it isn’t as big as you seem to think it is.”
“You gonna let that stop you?” The dark, round pools of Heather Edwards’ sunglasses bored into Piper as if the other teen was staring into her soul, piercing her with a look. “I told my handler about this, what was happening, what I’d found out. It was like she was watching me on mute, like I was speaking another language. She just went quiet, stared at me, looked confused, then asked me if I’d seen any good movies lately. She wouldn’t even talk about it. I don’t know what’s happening, not yet. If it’s a conspiracy, or just a bunch of soulless wageslaves with bigger problems than worrying about a dead teenager nobody particularly liked. I don’t know. But I’m willing to keep looking.”
Piper remained silent for a long moment, and Kora looked between her and Heather Edwards, drawing in a deep breath and keeping it held for some time. Finally, in a long stream of air, she released it, then shrugged. “Alright, I’m in. Where do we start, Heather?”
“Excuse me?”
Kora cleared her throat, quickly going red in the face. “Heather Edwards.”
“That’s Heather Goddamn Edwards to you. You’re on thin ice,” Heather Edwards let out a short sigh, then allowed herself to move past the egregious faux pas. “Right now, I just need you to listen. Keep your ears to the ground. You’re part of the swim team now, right?”
“Yeah -- wait, that was last night and you weren’t even there, how do you know that?”
Heather Edwards just stared silently at Kora, giving the deafening quiet a solid ten seconds to simmer until Kora relented.
“Right. Yeah, I am.”
Clearing her throat, the girl with the sunglasses continued, “You’ll have access to people who knew Nowak, might be able to learn more about her comings and goings. Whatever she was into, it’s been happening over the past month, or just before it.”
“Alright, yeah, I’ll keep my ear to the ground and let you know if I come up with anything.” Nodding slightly, Kora glanced back at Piper with a worried expression, though one that relaxed after a moment. “You with me, Pipe?”
Piper sighed, recoiling at first, before her shoulders finally slumped into the posture of resignation. “I’ve been with you through everything so far, Kora, just like you’ve been through everything with me. You know you don’t even have to ask. I’ll see what I can dig up.”
Standing up, Heather Edwards tossed the rest of her milkshake into a nearby green-wire trashcan, straightening her shades. “Radical. My next target’s the library; I’ll text if I’ve got anything. Oh, and... don’t tell the wrong people about this. Definitely not teachers, parents, cops. Something wrong with them. Not sure what yet. And don’t tell anybody I’m involved... the more secrecy I can move in, the more I can get done.”
Without so much as a ‘later, nerds,’ Heather Edwards walked away, leaving the two other teens sitting on the bench together, a bombshell dropped into their laps that they still didn’t understand. Was Heather Edwards just crazy, was any of this real? Was she trying to fabricate a mystery out of a garden-variety disappearance, and were Kora and Piper now accomplices in some kind of high school conspiracy?
“So, uh...” Kora chewed the inside of her cheek a moment, then her expression forcibly brightened. “You want a milkshake? I’ll buy.”