Natural Soft vs Flash Soft (Patreon)

Just a quick nerdy comparison you might find interesting!

Same model, same wall, similar pose. (images are taken 5 minutes apart) 

What makes this images different is the position and type of light used - on the left we have indirect natural light coming from a bunch of windows and on the right a 40x60 cm rectangle softbox shining light through a 2x2 meters diffuser.

Windows are about 2-3 meters away from the model and are much bigger in comparison to the diffuser resulting in bigger, softer light and brighter shadows. In the image on the right light is smaller and closer to the model giving a more distinct soft and darker shadow.

Which one is more appealing to you? Also, questions on the topic are welcome! :)

All the best
Vihro