Home
Artists
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register
Partychan Telegram Live Sex ThePornDude
Home Artists Posts Import Register

Did a Court Perjure Itself by DMCA'ing Hearing Recording? (Patreon)

Published:
2021-07-28 18:59:33
Imported:
2023-11
Tags:

Content

Mike Masnick from TechDirt reports that an LA Court sent a DMCA takedown notice to YouTube after a recording of a Britney Spears hearing was uploaded. The Court expressly forbids third-party recording or streaming of court hearings. But the DMCA is for Copyright violations - and that's not copyright. Let's review.

https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20210701/17462547105/la-court-abusing-copyright-law-to-take-down-unauthorized-recording-britney-spears-hearing.shtml

Files

Did a Court Perjure Itself by DMCA'ing Hearing Recording?

Mike Masnick from TechDirt reports that an LA Court sent a DMCA takedown notice to YouTube after a recording of a Britney Spears hearing was uploaded. The Court expressly forbids third-party recording or streaming of court hearings. But the DMCA is for Copyright violations - and that's not copyright. Let's review. TechDirt article: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20210701/17462547105/la-court-abusing-copyright-law-to-take-down-unauthorized-recording-britney-spears-hearing.shtml #Court #DMCA #Perjury Continue the discussion with the Lawful Masses Discord Community: https://discord.gg/SpC2utzr56 Support Lawful Masses! patreon.com/ljfrench sponsus.com/law THANK YOU SUPPORTERS! July 2021 $50+ Supporters: John Steel, Gavin Barnard, Eevi, Spirit Bear, Benjamin Hitov, Ugly Grill, Rudolph Bescherer Jr, torpedan, Brandyn Abel, ShadowTycho, RDHDragon, Earthbound Star, PureMagma July 2021 $5+ Supporters: Christoph Bolliger, Arron Washington, Felix and Gene, Keith Marrocco, Dustin Rodriguez, Josué Vicioso, Cindy Campbell, Brian Flowers, Mark Curtis, Lazy Wolf, Rob Frawley 2nd, Nick Bush, Gergely Varju, John Swanson, matthew beller, Aethero Toland, Priscilla Astling, Paul Sxton, Human Resource, David Zaslavsky, Roger Chen, Christian Ullrich, Brian Roush, NotMike, Firstname Mclastname, Lydia Collinson, Strawberry Puptart, HotGrillsInYourArea, JH, Stephen Bank, Michael Morris, Tron Bårdgård, Mark Randall, Richard Shotwell, Sarah Gerweck, Matthew East, Pat Delaney, Michael Howard, Mario Bonales, Michael Kenton, Euchale, Renee Starling, Ian McDonald, Marcus Agehall, Sokar117, Jonathan Robillard, Amanda Gillies, Justin Waddell, Andrew Sellers, Nathaniel, Tony Cruickshank, Cash Steel, Zoe, Druid, Richard Jeffery, Jason Lingle, Zzyzx Wolfe, Kasaryth, Oisin Creaner, Dimitrios Georgakopoulos, Stephen Christopher, TEEKAY, Stefan Persson, Frederick Cooper, HenTropy, CombatZAK, Catherine Tetzlaff, Jaimeson LaLone, Alexander Sihn, Kate Rijacki Ledum, Naomi Pool, Andrew Reid, David McGuire Jr., EnvyingWrath, Brody Eastwood, sehro, Brian Rossman, Steven Hess, FunnyHats, Dzyan, Chris Lindsay, allquixotic, Albert Demello, Rico Robbins, Kean Maizels, Durga Devi, Darkwolf, Anthony Webb, Joseph Alexander Brown, John Peter, Daniel Kertesz, Evan Foster, Nathaniel Reindl, Kai Raphahn, Håkan Andersson, Andrew "FastLizard4" Adams, Jesse Stam, Gumblejak, Si Wellings, Mitchell Thatcher, Hans Jacob Stephensen, Jessica Pearson, RedR0ze, LbxAni, Daniel Ducharme, Ph.D., majikthise, foonix, TheEuphoGuy, Anonymous Lizard, ShadowMage, Ormond S, rfc805, Schuyler Rowe, Brian, Matthew Bertrand, Jack Draak, piparalegal2019, DyneOnline, Eye_Make_Stuff, Nick Rowland, Timothy James Dodd, Scott F. Comstock, James Melanson, Lewis, Kat Willhite, Komrade Kettenkrad, Matt Arnold, Alan Nise, anton.molyboha, Kyle Siefring, Marianne Fletcher, te-online, The Disturbed Angel, Elliott Ingram, Eric Woodley, sera_denoir, Liryca, FlanBeast, Callie D, Logan Stromberg, scj643, Isaiah Matthews, Travus, Greg, Chris Connett, Haplo, Michael Ciesielski, Chris Hilliard, KoblerMan, Eric Barker, Jonathan Barchi, Jason Glaesemann, Q Squared, Jeffrey Cash, Marc Arendt, Gef the Mongoose, toadbear, Kory Sagawa, Barrister manque', DrJKL, Luke Nguyen, Lawrence Groupe, Leon Rosengarten, Michael, Wise Guru, Karen Mikulka, Andrew Venier, Peter Huston, QuasiAutonomous Bosch, CacklingDonut, Bill Tonnies, Katrina Middleton, Rabid Ronin, Thomas Dinsdale-Young, Zendane, EchoFoxAlpha, varia, s s, vknorris4, David Kushner, jag1110, STEVE YOCUM, kildes, Alisdair Meredith, Ulfr, Bill Somerville, Benn M, Mike Dunford, Kasper Brandt, Evan Davis, Haemocyte, Travis Mastin, Michael Smith, James Oxford, AlCD, Michael Stokes-Byrne, JovialJuggernaut, c, Jorge Vittes, Nate Gray, Tony Webster, Ross, Dustin Bosveld, Divan, Landon Noll, Jeff Gordon, Lucas Wireman, Bryan Lubeck, Lawful Leah, PinkFluffyTeddyBear, Paul, Morteth, Globochemist, Chip Phelps, Irene Torkel, Laura Hertzman, Thedougler303, Scott Rushing, Fran, CoAndCoLaptopAccount, Ivan Chepurnyi

Comments

Anonymous

If one takes a video without permission do they generally own that copyright? It sounds like for this case, yes. But three hypotheticals if I go to Hamilton on Broadway and take a video successfully do I own the copyright to my copy? If I go to a movie theater? If I am in a public space and someone is performing something they don't want recorded?

Anonymous
>>64657999

Patreon comments don't work well on mobile. This video just got me wondering. I'd guess you don't own in the case of recording a film, that's just making a copy in the same medium.

Anonymous
>>64657999

Not sure if you meant this as a question inspired by but not directly related to this video, or as a potential defense the court could bring up, but if the latter, I think the point here was that to make a DMCA claim, the claimant needs to be the one with the copyright. It's not enough that the person who posted the video does not have the copyright, and in using the DMCA to take down the video, the court represented that the court itself held the copyright.

Anonymous
>>64657999

Not directly related to the video, more inspired by it. As I understood things, the video referenced here specifically the copyright was not owned by the court, which means the court would have to use other methods to stop the publishing of the video (contempt). So this made me wonder who owns the copyright to the footage in other scenarios where the video creation isn't authorized or allowed.