Home Artists Posts Import Register
Patreon importer is back online! Tell your friends ✅

Files

(No title)

Comments

Heidi Elizabeth Marcum

The Doctor- Thank you very much for another fabulous reaction, Jay! I really love this episode!!! :) First... I have to admit, I was surprised to learn that Doctor Whale is Victor Frankenstein, of all people. And even a little taken aback by it too, because the story of Frankenstein doesn't exactly fit into the fairy tale world. Or at least, so I thought. However, the more I thought about it after watching this episode for the first time and ever since having now finished this show in its entirety, the more I really came to like this twist of Whale being Victor Frankenstein. Because it does fit into the storybook world since Frankenstein is a classic novel, and it has been mentioned before numerous times, including by Jefferson himself here in this episode and in season one's episode... Hat Trick, that there are other far off lands beyond the Enchanted Forest. And Red Riding Hood herself, is also a werewolf of sorts. Plus... The Wizard of Oz is also referenced to in this episode, and The Wizard of Oz is also just a classic novel, not a fairy tale. So, of course it makes perfect sense!! :) Besides... I absolutely love the rivalry or debate established through Whale/Victor Frankenstein and Gold/Rumplestiltskin... Magic versus science. Absolutely fantastic! Regarding the name, Dr. Whale, being significant to Victor Frankenstein... Dr. Whale's name is a reference to famous movie director, James Whale, who directed the classic horror movies... Frankenstein from 1931, and Bride of Frankenstein from 1935. And now, in regards to Jefferson and others calling Doctor Frankenstein a wizard... The Wizard of Oz reference to the Ruby Slippers was just that. A minor reference or nod. And it's quite possibly meant to be a misdirect. But more importantly... Science is not a power the people who live within the Enchanted Forest and other lands with or without magic, have ever heard of before. Science... Like magic is for those like Emma from our world or for Victor in his own world, is unknown in other realms. And so to see someone harnessing lightening and to meet someone who claims to be able to resurrect the dead through the lightning's power, it makes sense that those in the Enchanted Forest would believe him to be a wizard of sorts. And in regards to Rumple's mention of the magical slippers when they're inside his castle towards the beginning of this episode, when Regina and Jefferson meet for the first time... Rumplestiltskin had hired Jefferson to collect these magic slippers known to be able to transport someone to other worlds and lands. They're most definitely a reference or nod to The Wizard of Oz, which reveals that Oz is one of the mysterious worlds that the Mad Hatter can travel to through his hat. Rumple hoped to be able to use the magical slippers to travel to our world... A Land Without Magic, to find his son, as Dorothy uses them to return home to Kansas within The Wizard of Oz. But Jefferson states that they had been taken to a new world. Foreshadowing that they were stolen by someone from Oz. There are magical items, nods, and references to all kinds of fairy tales, classic novels, tall tales, etc... brought into Once Upon a Time, and I absolutely love how so many stories are brought into this show in some form or another. So, with this mention of the magical slippers from The Wizard of Oz and with Jefferson calling Frankenstein a wizard, it would make perfect sense for us fans to think that this wizard could be the Wizard from The Wizard of Oz. I thought so too, when I first watched this episode, only because it made more sense to me at the time that they would bring in characters from The Wizard of Oz, over the characters from the classic novel... Frankenstein. However, they are definitely not a combination of the same character. Now... We also get to see another new world again, known as the Land Without Color, as the world is black and white just like the old classic black and white monster movies, which I absolutely love the design of, as well as the organ music and many symbolisms to Frankenstein's story. And we have the lightning striking down as well. It's really brilliant! I always love seeing new worlds, realms, and kingdoms brought into this show. As for where his land is located... Rumplestiltskin tells Jefferson that he's been seeking a way to get to a land without any magic. To our world, so he can find his son. But there's no more magic beans or portals to our world because it's a land without magic. And Jefferson can only transport himself and others to magical worlds through his hat. This tells us that Frankenstein's world is separate from our own, just as it is separate from the Enchanted Forest as well. And while science is what Frankenstein studies and practices, magic does exist somewhat within his world as well. Just think through your classic black and white horror movie knowledge if you know anything about them, and you will realize there's such things like werewolves, witches, sorcery, etc... This is why Jefferson is able to travel to the Land Without Color through his hat, but cannot travel to our land, that is without magic. I hope this makes sense. Now... I really love this twist in Frankenstein's story, and I love the backstory between Victor, Rumplestiltskin, Regina, and Jefferson, who is finally shown as the true Mad Hatter he used to be before his life was turned upside down by Regina. And I absolutely love, love, love this side of Jefferson!! He's charming, funny, and Sebastian Stan plays the Mad Hatter in this episode brilliantly! He's amazing in this episode! I also love that we learn how Jefferson and Regina meet, and how the three men come to work together in order to manipulate Regina into making her become the Evil Queen. It's very sad, but brilliant. What a twist! Personally, I love this backstory all the more for seeing how Rumple manipulates Regina so she can become the Evil Queen. Her story is far better than Whale's, given that I have never really liked his character all that much before. But I do still like enjoying getting to know who Whale really is, and seeing how his story is connected to Regina's. Very interesting indeed. As for my thoughts on why Regina becomes the Evil Queen within her backstory throughout this episode... I feel it's definitely because Regina finally realizes and understands she no longer has reason to remain good for after she was manipulated into believing Frankenstein couldn't bring Daniel back to life. The love of her life was truly dead and because Jefferson has harped so much on the fact that if Dr. Frankenstein couldn't bring back the dead, then no one could... Regina has come to believe he is right. And truth be told... he is. For Regina... When the Doctor fails to revive Daniel as far as she knew, that was it. Daniel was truly dead, and she no longer carried that hope that magic or science could bring him back to her. So, instead of remaining good like a part of her did for Daniel's sake, she gave into the hate and anger she felt for Snow White and her mother, and returned to Rumplestiltskin to finish her lessons no matter what path he took her down. She shows Rumple she was prepared to do whatever he asked of her, even if it meant killing innocents. Just like Rumplestiltskin wanted all along. Lana Parrilla's acting in this episode is phenomenal and her scenes with Jefferson, Whale, and of course Rumplestiltskin are amazing. I feel so badly for Regina both in her past storyline with trying to bring Daniel back from the dead with Victor's help, as well as her present storyline with Whale, who actually succeeded this time, even though Daniel is revived to become more like Frankenstein's monster, and not just himself as he was, like most people would expect of him to be. Because he's in so much pain. It is so sad she had to watch Daniel die again as she kills him for a second time. And Daniel is dead, thanks to Regina using her magic to lift the preservation spell keeping his body preserved all these years, and therefore his body is restored to as it would be had Regina not cast the spell. Nothing but dust. Very sad. I absolutely feel so sad for her. I also love seeing Regina go to Archie twice throughout this episode so he could help her talk through her pain. Regina's really trying to change for Henry, and I love this development in her character. And Archie is so kind to her in spite of her former reign of terror, which I also really love. I love how he is able to put her past behind him enough to try to help her. Now... I really love the scenes between Henry and David too. It is very sweet for David to give his grandson a horse to take care of before he learns to ride it. Very smart of David to tell Henry that he must learn to care for it and to allow the horse to get to know him before Henry learns to ride it. And Henry is really cute with his horse too. I love how David teaches to care for his horse before he can learn to ride him. It's so important. And lastly... I absolutely love, love, love the first meetings between Hook, Emma, and Mary Margaret, along with Mulan and Aurora there too. These scenes with Hook are my favorite throughout the episode! I just love, love, love how sassy Hook is, and it's phenomenal when Emma sees right through Hook's lies, and his story is convincing even though we know exactly who he is. And I love how you can see there's quite a difference in the man we got to know in the previous episode... The Crocodile, compared to the man he's grown to become since his time spent in Neverland while seeking revenge against Rumplestiltskin. He's most certainly evolved. However, Hook finally confesses as he explains he was asked by Cora to join with Emma and Mary Margaret to find out everything he could about what they would be facing upon arriving in Storybrooke, then heroes and villain make a deal that allows for Hook to remain alive and at their side. I absolutely love the scene while Hook is tied to the tree. It's my favorite moment from this episode, especially Hook's line as he introduces himself as Captain Hook... absolutely fabulous. :) "Killian Jones. But you all may know me more by my more colorful moniker... Hook.", to which Emma retorts, "As in, Captain Hook?" Perfect! And yes... Hook is absolutely gorgeous!!! :) Also... I love Hook working with them now and how quickly he's prepared to change sides. That he's willing to turn his allegiance over to whoever can give him what he wants. Yep... He blabs everything because he doesn't care. He's very sly and clever. I also love his answer he gives to Emma to convince her why he wants to go with them to Storybrooke. Because it's the simple truth. He wants revenge against Rumplestiltskin for cutting off his hand, and more. Oh yeah... And in regards to why Jefferson has to come with anyone who jumps into the hat with him... It's because Jefferson serves as a guide for the hat. If you remember back to season one's episode... Hat Trick, the first time you see Jefferson inside the hat along with Regina, we see a multitude of doors surroundings them. These doors all lead to other lands with magic in which they could travel, including Wonderland like in Hat Trick, and now to Frankenstein's black and white world... A Land Without Color. Jefferson would have been needed so he could show Dr. Frankenstein which door to take. If he were to enter the world with the Doctor, then the rules of the hat would apply. The rules which state that if two people enter the world, then two must return. If one enters, then one must come back. But Jefferson only would have traveled as far as inside the hat upon returning Victor home in the end, simply to show Frankenstein which door to take to get home. At least... This is what I believe. Just my theory. I hope all this makes sense. All the scenes with Hook in them are my favorite scenes throughout this episode!!! However, I also really enjoy Whale's overall backstory with Rumple and Jefferson too. And I absolutely love, love, love the Mad Hatter!!! And there's so much more to come!!! I can't wait for more!! Thank you, Jay! Sincerely, Heidi