How do you like your covers? (Patreon)

I just did two covers over the last couple of days for the $13.99 tier people. One was more or less identical to the original, and the second was quite different to the original.

Anyway, I'm interested to know what your thoughts are on the whole cover thing. Do you generally prefer covers that are close to the original, or do you prefer to hear it completely changed up? Or maybe you don't like covers at all?