Home
Artists
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register
Partychan SimpleX Chat ThePornDude
Home Artists Posts Import Register
Join the new SimpleX Chat Group!

BE ORIGINAL: (G)I-DLE "Oh My God" (Patreon)

Published:
2020-04-10 16:01:57
Imported:
2021-01

Content

Stay tuned for my "suit dance" reaction video for a more in depth discussion about their choreo!

Release Schedule: tinyurl.com/fotschedule

Master list of all reactions: tinyurl.com/fotmaster 

Files

2020-04-09 20-24-59

This is "2020-04-09 20-24-59" by PD on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them.

Comments

Carly Pearl

The suit dance is really good for seeing the choreography.

ice4fresh

Shuhua didn't get any center but she didn't stand in the back of the choreo either. That's a plus at least.

Tom Poston

After four days of listening to I Trust I am finding that "Oh my god" isn't clicking with me like "Uh Oh" or "Lion" did. I like the song, I *respect* the song and think Soyeon and Sancho did a great job as usual in creating it (except for the line distribution issues that PD points out). But I don't LOVE the song. And that's OK - not every song is going to be an instant earworm, for anyone. "Oh my god" is another great Idle comeback that just hasn't pushed my buttons the way I hoped.

Rowie de Riel

I also really love this song! Loved it from the first listen and I think it's a really good accompaniment to Lion. (from watching reacttothek's video I see the segment of the song that's really similar to Lion but overall I do think they're quite different) It's true about the line distribution... Even in the debut song Shuhua only got to sing "latata" and nothing else. Though I think that it was worse for Loona So what with Vivi basically getting no lines at all. Of course that's no excuse so I hope all the members will get to shine in performances and future songs, I liked g-idle since debut but I've been really getting into them after Lion and I was looking forward to going to their concert so much! After blackpink and dreamcatcher they're the first girlgroup to tour in Europe and as a girlgroup stan I desperately need more groups to come here, so I hope it'll still happen once the pandemic subsides and that it'll be successful and an example for others (please izone, we need you here! >.<)

RobotoMon

Line distribution might be unfair, but I think this is the only time Soyeon really gets her moment. If you think about it, who's the most popular member of the group. Yuqi first then probably Soyeon. Who do you think of when it comes to Variety Shows, Yuqi or Shuhua. Who gets the most views for fancams, Shuhua and Soojin. Soyeon is 3rd and sometimes 4th. She doesnt even show up in many of the I-talks or VLives. The rest of the members are the main source of content and I think the girls are okay with the distribution.

Vytautas štrofas

hey thats me <3 even tho im fairly certain im not the first one to post it, im just posting it cuz pd sayed he didnt get much recommendations for lion so i took it apon myself to fix that with this comeback by posting everything they do :)

Joonka

This is probably a controversial statement but I hope fairness never becomes the leading motivation behind line distribution. It should be about what sounds best. Yuqi’s high range with her deep voice is often used in their pre-choruses to give urgency and momentum before the chorus. I honestly don’t know if she can do falsetto. I think each member’s voice fits the story of the part they sing. Also Yuqi said in a recent interview that they all chose the line distribution together. Oh My God distribution to me seems average. Dun Dun and So What seems much less balance(No hate. I love Loona and Everglow). Lion was about as balanced as it gets. Shuhua has always had less lines per HER OWN REQUEST.

Joonka
>>35027645

Very good points. In the end it’s about even exposure, not who sang most and least

Joonka
>>35020261

Completely agree. Come wait for the world tour. As for Shuhua, as I commented below, she requested less lines because of her language. Tbh, I don’t know how much she is improving even after almost 2 years. I still see her struggle in interviews and sometimes even read her answers of a paper.

NanoPIX
>>35042639

Line distribution issue is so overblown... People just look at seconds and complain... There's more to lines than simply seconds. I can agree that Shuhua not being noticed until her bridge feels a bit bad, but she has an entire bridge for herself. As for Miyeon and Yuqi, they have what for me is the best part of the song and has great impact, the pre-chorus.