Home Artists Posts Import Register

Content

See the attached gif, if circulates from 1, 2, 3


Help choose between size 1, size 2 and size 3 

We are trying to understand, how big is too big?



Files

Comments

Wilshire1701

I voted for 2, but personally, I wouldn’t mind seeing bigger if the size was distributed more evenly throughout the body instead of focusing mainly on the arms

windjammer

I voted for 1 but I would agree with Wilshire1701 in that I’d like to see muscle size more evenly distributed throughout the entire body. I think it’s ok for there to be a slight emphasis on the biceps.

Wilshire1701

Agreed. Big biceps/triceps are still good, but so is everything else 😁

RicketyRick

I enjoy bigger sizes but ultimately, it's the process which really does it for me. Size 1 might not be my first choice, but if the growth shown is nice and detailed, I will prefer it to a less involved process where the character goes from tiny to enormous in two panels.

windjammer

When I wrote my comment I was focused on proportions but I should have also I should have mentioned that I’m also fine with bigger overall muscle size as well. As long things proportions are roughly maintained I rarely find myself thinking that something is “too big”.

Redsaber

Personally I'm rather torn between 2 and 3 so I'm going to go with fourth option to play it safe. Mind if I ask what this is for? A new comic that's in the works.

Gwahar

Going with 2

Mr.BoneJangles

3 is about where my preferences usually max out, but the occasional bigger can work too ^_^

Jason White

If I have to pick one of these, it’s 1. However, they all look out of proportion to me. I like big, even impossible big, but I prefer proportional to some degree.

Kimenguman

I find that size 2 is perfect !