Home Artists Posts Import Register

Downloads

Content

Training scars: the idea that your practice routine will dictate what you do under stress. Is it real? Yes. Does it need to be? No.

The first objective of basic practice and training is to become proficient at specific tasks, like drawing a pistol or reloading a rifle. Unfortunately, that seems to be where a lot of people stop. In my opinion, the real goal of practice and training is to develop the mental capacity to perform those tasks under stress while still be aware of both the task and the "big picture" situation of what is goin on around you. With no practice, you are unable to do complex things under pressure. With some practice, you are locked into how to perform those tasks so that you don't have to think about them. But the ultimate goal and purpose of practice is to be able to remain fully conscious of what you are doing under stress, so that you can do the right thing in any given situation.

In my experience, this sort of mental awareness comes from the amount of trigger time one has under stress - whether real stress or artificial competition stress. Competition is a lot more accessible and a heck of a lot safer than real combat, and thus competition is an essential element of any robust training program unless you're one of those tier 1 special operators who has access to shoot houses full of roleplayers on a daily basis.

The real training scars do not come from shooting too much competition; they come from not shooting enough competition.

Comments

Anonymous

Good post, agree with the primary message. "Flat range" work can get one good at a specific motor task - reloads, draws, target engagement - but competition has you doing those while moving a bit, and having to *think* the whole time, especially if there're targets you shouldn't shoot as well.

Anonymous

Training scars have to with repeatedly doing things that don't really work, simply because they are convenient for training purposes. One widely cited example is reaching for the empty magazine in a firefight, to put it back down on a table that isn't there. The things you do well in competition are probably not the things where training scars develop! It's going to be the other things, the things done repeatedly but "administratively". For example, the way that competition shooters approach a barrier to shoot around it probably doesn't get very much attention -- it's probably not scored and bad form probably doesn't result in disqualification.

Anonymous

Bravo. Well expressed. Agree completely.

Anonymous

Dang it, you really got me thinking earlier. Concerning mag retention, a big key is where are you going to put them. I really like running "Armored TST style", because I have a kangaroo pouch hanging off the bottom of my plate carrier - that's my dump pouch. When my weak hand takes a rifle/pistol magazine out, it goes straight down to the dump pouch, and, oh look, now it's not far away from my extra mags. So the process of retaining becomes a simple part of the reloading process. Combined with my background of generally not dumping mags, the rule at FB23 didn't really bother me, largely due to having what I feel is a very efficient retention/reloading process. But, what if I'm not wearing my plate carrier, 'cause I'm out and about around town? Almost year round, I have a jacket of some kind. I did a pistol course once, we had to retain empty mags, so my weak hand put it in a left side pocket of the jacket, and any extra pistol mags are on my belt on my left side. Not quite as efficient as the kangaroo pouch, but similar. Not an exact quote from General Eisenhower, but he did say something along the lines of this: "In combat, plans are worthless, but planning is everything." Practice different things, because you have no idea what thing you're actually going to need to do when "real life" happens.

Anonymous

This is a really good thought / self-evaluation exercise for people to take. I've taken a number of defensive firearms courses and a couple competition coaching sessions in action pistol, and I think the focus areas are complimentary. I'm reminded of a lot of the training I went through in skydiving to deal with parachute malfunctions. There is a lot of emphasis to students on building muscle memory to perform certain actions as mechanically and repeatedly as possible to release a main canopy and deploy a reserve. There is some, but much less, time spent on really understanding main canopy malfunctions, their progression, how quickly altitude may be lost, and what might happen if you grab what you could have sworn was a main release handle, but was actually part of your jumpsuit. I think competition in both shooting and skydiving are good sources of training stress to improve focus and overall performance when things go wrong. I think, in a similar vein and don't laugh, public speaking and/or sales experience can be a real asset in keeping an encounter from escalating to violence if it is at all possible.