Which thumbnail? (Patreon)

I filmed another ILTS for YouTube & can't decide which thumbnail is best? I feel like #1 but idk!!! So vote #1 or #2 below :') For context, the title for #1 would be "I'M CANDLE CRAZY | I LOVE THIS STUFF" & the title for #2 would be "I'M BONKERS FOR BEDDING" or some shit idk (still workshopping this obviously! LOL)