The Night is Taking Over (Patreon)

"Really now, filly, it's almost like you don't want to reach the Elements of Harmony any more! Or spending time with your newfound friends~"

Imagine if things didn't go quite as Twilight had expected, all the way back at the beginning. Each of the supposed elements has been devoured in turn, and now there's only the upstart pretender of Magic left to witness. She won't be witnessing much any longer, and the moon is going to be getting a lot bigger...