Home
Artists
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register
Partychan Telegram ThePornDude
Home Artists Posts Import Register

ONE PIECE REACTION POLL (Patreon)

Published:
2019-10-13 13:47:27
Edited:
2019-10-13 19:24:16
Imported:
2021-05

Content

Alright so here is the deal as we have seen there has been a good number of ppl who felt some type of way about the edited episodes, while there were some who actually liked them. I am going to take a poll ( something I shouldve done before hand..my apologies everyone) to see how the majority feel. I actually rewatched the last 5 episodes already and though I feel like I really didnt miss too many things I can understand some of your guys points of view.  Ssef has edited quite a bit already and has posted mega links in the last OP reaction comments for you all to see what he has done to the next episodes. I just want to go about this the right way now and ask should we continue as we have been going just watching the anime as is? or Use Ssef's edits? As always I really appreciate everyones feedback. Hope you all have a wonderful Sunday!!!

Comments

Anonymous

If you are not going to use the edits, do it after the next arc. That is my advice to you.

Wesley

The edits are fine, you especially are going to need them in the next arc.

Tevin Logan

Honestly I don't mind either ones

Anonymous

Like next arc if he wants to take out the flash backs thats cool but leave everything else we don't need a shot-by-shot manga for the anime

Anonymous

Love the edit so far but if the majority vote on using the original I hope yall have some suggestions cause the next arc and wano so far are absolutely horrible. I don’t want her watching feeling bored to death cause I do...

Anonymous

I say go for the original episodes, but only for the next arc use an edited episode, im pretty sure you can compress the entire arc in like 30 minutes...

Leon

I'd say use the edits for ep 878-889. Original way for the others (890 and onward) In short I think it should be a mix of both. Edits are nice (especially in the next mini-arc!), but not always necessary. If you already edited 872-877 as well you might as well use the edited versions for that one (as long as 875 and 877 are intact because of reasons). If it's not edited yet, go with the original length of the episodes.

HowardisBoss

I voted edits, I personally don't mind the final episodes of Whole Cake in its original form anime staff did a great job with this arc. It's the mini arc after this that I feel needs the edits, since that was butchered with flashback scenes to prolong a quick arc.

Yamato

Just don't take out to much stuff. No one needs a recap that was shown 10 times already. I would keep the stuff like added scenes and most anime only filler.

Florin

As the others said, I think a mix would be best. Sometimes edits are needed (such as long, pointless filler flashbacks), but sometimes they are not necessarily needed (like your last reaction imo)

Anonymous

I really liked the edits. Just don't cut the fillers away.

Anonymous

Hope you have a good Sunday too :)

Anonymous

I think either way we should thank ssef on his or hers hard work, editing is a pain so to take the time and effort to try and make a better viewing experience is admirable. Im definitely in favor of the next arc for sure being edited because it is HEAVY with the flashbacks.

Anonymous

With the edits the next arc shoud only be like 20 minutes lol.

Anonymous
>>27838568

Yes that's what I've been talkin about we don't need a shot by shot of the manga

Anonymous

I voted "original". But Edits would be much appreciated for the next arc.

Anonymous

The edits was good but it was kinda weird that seff took out some parts from the anime, cuz it wasn't in the manga? No disrespect to mr.seff tho... and why are people tripping about the next arc? 😂 Sure everyone have watched the next arc but why can't she just experience it herself?

HowardisBoss
>>27838741

Yeah some of the cut scenes were kinda weird, like episode 870 I think was good enough to not need editing personally. But people are tripping about the next arc because manga-wise it was one of the best arcs hype-wise (6 chapters of greatness), but the anime decided to put like 15 minutes of filler/flashbacks and leave only 5 minutes of canon material every episode of the arc. Nobody needs to see recaps for 12 episodes.

KillerB

okay so I don't really wanna go over topic or ask this question in here but where is demon slayer's final few episodes? like I joined Patreon for demon slayer and just watch op on youtube. so if you don't mind then can you tell me when will the next few episodes of demon slayer will be up?

Anonymous

I don't understand it completely. The edit version just for the current arc and maybe the next one or till the end of one piece?

Anonymous

So I actually didnt mind the edits for the most part. The only problem I had was he took out training montages with Rayleigh that are important IMO. Showing that gear 4th bounce man had weakness and Rayleigh easily dealt with Luffy in Gear 4th was Awesome.

Leon

I love how even the people who voted for "Original" are like "But not for the next arc!" Really displays the infamy of the padding in that arc.

Anonymous

I want to comment on another thing that ruined for me reaction of Ssef's edit. He used weird smoothing out of frames when rendered his version. It's like between the keyframes there were frames made from merged two frames with different opacity - it made the video blurry and strained my eyes so much. Normally I use motion-interpolation on my TV and Computer to watch anime on 60 or 120 frames per second, but with this I couldn't do that. So I was forced to watch it in original low fps and couldn't even focus on reaction because of this smoothing out and blurriness.

Anonymous

I voted for no edits because, I wouldn't want them for the majority of the show. The next arc however could benefit from them imo.

Anonymous
>>27838975

I think they should drop the whole idea like it's called a full reaction for a reason not trying to be mean or anything

Anonymous

I think that the problem was that he took out the scenes added in the anime that complemented the story, but if he had only erased the flash back scenes that we had already seen, perhaps there would have been no problem (which was not in the last chapters of Whole cake) . In the next arc it might be good to use edits, but only deleting the flashbacks and not the added scenes :) Allona could be seen first 3 chapters of the next arc and she see if continue seeing that arc as well or edited. PS: Sorry for my english hahahahaha

Anonymous

I would actually recommend reading the manga for the next arc. It's just that bad, I doubt even someone who doesn't like manga wouldn't enjoy it more.

Tyler

It's hard to vote for because I appreciated him taking out so many of the redundant scenes, but he also took out scenes that complimented the fight like the little flashback showing the thought process Luffy went through with Rayleigh to come up with Snake Man. The edits are really well done so if you choose to continue using them I wouldn't be mad. I think they are better suited for the next mini arc because half of every episode in that arc is just a straight up flashback.

Anonymous

I think wci doesn't need editing but the next arc definitely needs some editing

Anonymous

Editing is ok but not to much

Anonymous

I agree with the no edits for WCI, you’ve made it this far without them. I’ll also agree that the next arc should be edited, since the show is only about a year old for you, it’ll feel like you’ve just seen certain scenes because of the flashbacks.

Anonymous

The next arc could use editing as a lot of it is flashbacks. but currently I prefer without the edits - even though it was hard work and well done!

Anonymous

For the next arc, watch with edits or one pace(Its an edited version of One piece that has a good flow and doesn't feel like it randomly cuts off on scenes). But after that watch the regular episodes (Although some episodes have some ridiculously bad filler),

Anonymous

Just in case I wanted to showcase both of my edits for these two sets for you to watch and know what you think: 872-877: https://mega.nz/#!D40lRQCL!xjSzLZWTENd5POOtgDi7YwUWNt-bF4_QfFR4U5wSyS0 878-889: https://mega.nz/#!aw12iQIS!9sI7guNsZhP-s5xSz4bhnS2Vy7HSg2J_9AuJ8Z3TyfY 872-877 is the one that took most of my time (one week more or less) If you watch it you will see why. This just feels like an epic final movie of a saga, LOL. Plus in this particular set I barely took any filler since I found it to be interesting and meaningful, they really helped some characters in the process, but at the same time I keeped it close to manga. I think I found a good balance for it. Please take in account that If Allona used these edits It would make an easier job for her in general. Thank you for your consideration :)

Medusa

I don’t mind the edits personally however I will say the extra stuff that they added for Whole Cake is what made the arc even better for me personally (but a lot of manga readers have also said they liked the anime version of Whole Cake a bit more then the manga). I think what made people upset/threw them off is that. You just randomly started to doing them during the climax of a big arc. I definitely think you should go with the edit for the mini arc after this cause oof.

Anonymous
>>27838512

I compressed it to an equivelent of a set of 5 episodes by keeping all the canon scenes. I got to follow Oda's plot structure from the manga too. I think the result was pretty organic. Here you have it: https://mega.nz/#!aw12iQIS!9sI7guNsZhP-s5xSz4bhnS2Vy7HSg2J_9AuJ8Z3TyfY

Anonymous
>>27838515

That's exactly what i did for 872-877, the amount of work on that one was gigantic, trust me. Here you have the link for it; https://mega.nz/#!D40lRQCL!xjSzLZWTENd5POOtgDi7YwUWNt-bF4_QfFR4U5wSyS0

Anonymous
>>27841222

Como dije en un comentario y creo que todos pensamos lo mismo, que el único problema fue la extracción de las escenas agregadas que complementan la historia :) pero por lo demás, fueron unas muy buenas ediciones <3 de hecho solo me di cuenta porque extrañé algunas escenas ahahahahah Si bien me gustaría que viese el anime original, para el siguiente arco quizás sea bueno que vea las ediciones para que no se coma nuevamente escenas repetidas, por eso es dificil votar porque es solo para el siguiente arco y no para Wano (que personalmente pienso que no necesita edición)

Kiyale King

I think the edits are cool, it feel like we watching one big movie with you. Either way it doesn’t really matter

Anonymous

After you catch up to anime which could be in two weeks ,you should try reading few chapters of manga and record yourself. Doing live reactions if you will like it. Manga is more popular than anime. There is a reason why is One Piece most sold manga/comic in whole world

Anonymous

Like others, use original from 872-877, though the edit was great for those episodes and I would love to have seen the edited version reacted to, but the majority don’t want that, but for ep 878-889, use the edits! The edits is needed to bring out the arc to its full glory, the anime butchered the mini arc.

Sam JoyBoy
>>27842695

The most sold comic in the world is Superman, One piece is second atm.

Anonymous

I think the editing for the last two reactions was GREAT, but it was sorely needed in those episodes. Afterwards, there isn't much need for it, and the episodes are honestly great on their own.

J.D.Wall

After this arc the edits are going to be needed for the recap episiodes with little new content.

Anonymous

What’s the point of edits at this point your already this far into the anime and your almost caught up.

allonashareetv
>>27843333

The point is that he's already taken his time to do them so it would be extremely rude if I didn't even consider it correct?

Anonymous

either or is fine. As long as you catch up quickly.

iloveass

To all the voters who voted for original. Don't Cry When Flashbacks starts with 3 minutes of canon material for STRAIGHT 13 EPISODES. 😒

Leon
>>27844205

I think most agree with edits for ep 878-889 and originals from 890 and onward.

Anonymous

I voted for original but edits for next arc are needed. I just remembered that anime screwed whole arc with crazy flashbacks seen 100 times already.

Anonymous

I'll post it again because I think people didn't get to see it, these are the edits: 872-877: https://mega.nz/#!D40lRQCL!xjSzLZWTENd5POOtgDi7YwUWNt-bF4_QfFR4U5wSyS0 878-889: https://mega.nz/#!aw12iQIS!9sI7guNsZhP-s5xSz4bhnS2Vy7HSg2J_9AuJ8Z3TyfY

Anonymous

I’m with the original way But the next arc u have to watch One Pace version not Mr.Ssef

Anonymous

Use One Pace for the upcoming arc.

Anonymous

What they mean by original way is to stick to the manga version XD

Anonymous

I'd say watch the original for this arc and the edits for the next arc.

Anonymous

Allona, whatever you decide is fine. If you want to use the edited version out of respect of Ssef’s work, then go for it. I don’t think he’s removed anything terribly important or enhancing. What matters to me is that you’re able to react to the work. I am here to watch you react, and not to watch One Piece. I could do that on my own time. I think Ssef’s work is great since you’re binging these episodes and keep a lot of material fresh in your mind. People forget that this arc took a year or so (maybe more) to complete; Ssef taking out the flash backs is a great time saver. Any “fluff” removed is good too, because it doesn’t mess with continuity. Oda could always explain things in the tankobons or further down the line in a manner that contradicts the anime. All this to say that regardless of your choice I’ll be around to watch and laugh with you.

Anonymous

I come here at Patreon because I like she watching unedited episodes, to see her reaction. If it was to see edited videos, I would watch it on You Tube.

Levy
>>27845488

oof.. this is tough decision. I reaaaally wouldn't mind going with these edits. I think it wraps everything up nicely and quick of course.. But it looks like majority are against it :(

Anonymous

As it's my first time watching One Piece and I personally prefer without edit. I appreciate the edit version tho, it's really good.

Galen Vaughn

The rest of WCI should be kept in the original and the next mini arc I’m sure people wouldn’t mind you cutting all the recap/flashbacks from episodes we already seen, that much should be obvious

Anonymous

I think the only edits needed are for episodes 878 and after since half of every episode is flashbacks

Anonymous
>>27849622

I just want some feedback on it to be honest, this is 872-877: https://mega.nz/#!D40lRQCL!xjSzLZWTENd5POOtgDi7YwUWNt-bF4_QfFR4U5wSyS0

Anonymous
>>27850667

To be honest I didn't take out almost anything with 872-877, I took my time with this one and I would love it If you just checked it out first, please. This is the link to it: https://mega.nz/#!D40lRQCL!xjSzLZWTENd5POOtgDi7YwUWNt-bF4_QfFR4U5wSyS0

Tony

i finally watch the reaction..i think the edit made the snake man transformation less impact-full IMO.i really wish that rayleigh vs gear 4 scene was not cut.and also the pudding sanji ending was not cut...i appreciate the effort but importing things were cut...the snake man scene feels like. if you youtube goku going ssj for the first time with Bruce falconers music vs the kai sometimes the extra fillers for anime just makes it much better than manga

Anonymous
>>27843226

Please check out what I did with 872-877 I would appreciate the feedback before anything, this is the link: https://mega.nz/#!D40lRQCL!xjSzLZWTENd5POOtgDi7YwUWNt-bF4_QfFR4U5wSyS0

Anonymous
>>27841275

I would love If you checked ep. 872-877 edited by me just to know your opinion at least before voting, I would really appreciate that. This is the link: https://mega.nz/#!D40lRQCL!xjSzLZWTENd5POOtgDi7YwUWNt-bF4_QfFR4U5wSyS0

Anonymous
>>27848881

This has nothing to do with her Youtube reactions, those are chopped up for copyright reasons. The edits that I did are just to make all the episodes into one, just to connect them and make the whole thing seem continuous, to give a movie feel to it. The only thing that I've cut out in the previous set was a filler flashback that didn't contribute much and some other small filler parts that I thought they would ruin scenes that are coming later in the series. Trust me when I say that I edited all of this for Allona to have a better experience, everything It's calculated to be close to the manga and at the same still keeping some worthy fillers. Allona would have an easier time at recording and editing her videos too with this method.

Anonymous

I'm writing this just for all of those who are a little bit confused. The only sets that I edited are 872-877 and the next arc, that's it. I will not touch anything else because there's no need for it after 889. Let me say that I have enough confidence on my work to say the edits that I did are a good enough. Again here are the edits for both of them, please consider this: 872-877: https://mega.nz/#!D40lRQCL!xjSzLZWTENd5POOtgDi7YwUWNt-bF4_QfFR4U5wSyS0 878-889: https://mega.nz/#!aw12iQIS!9sI7guNsZhP-s5xSz4bhnS2Vy7HSg2J_9AuJ8Z3TyfY

Anonymous
>>27850116

Check the edits first If you can, please. This is the for 872-877: https://mega.nz/#!D40lRQCL!xjSzLZWTENd5POOtgDi7YwUWNt-bF4_QfFR4U5wSyS0

Anonymous
>>27851347

The Sanji and Pudding scene was cut just when Pudding took Sanji's cigarrete away. Later on there's a scene where everything is shown, the manga way is more impactful than in the anime since you don't know really what happened until you finally see it later on...

Bustersword88

I'm sure the majority who want the original episodes will be anime only watchers. Even though Ssef's cuts are good, I still recommend watching the original when it's your first time through One Piece. I think if you generally don't like the pacing and not enjoying the anime because of it then stick to the edits but honestly my opinion the implied fillers in whole cake island have been the best yet and as far as recap goes in the next arc, there are recaps of past episodes I haven't seen your reactions or opinions to yet and to be honest, since it's your first time through One Piece, they won't be as bad as you think. Most of us on here will say differently because we've seen the anime multiple times not to mention read the manga and there was only a couple of panels of flashback each chapter. Of course it sucks for us because we have seen them enough but I'd like your reflection on them :) On a second note, I'm probably the only one to do this but I play your reaction videos right along with other One Piece reactors and sync them together and watch them because I'm an adult and don't have enough time to watch them all separately. Watching the edited episodes, I can't make that happen at all lol Plus there's the first time factor. It's hard to watch you react to the edited episodes for the first time since it's technically the first time I'm watching the edited episodes too. Again Ssef, these were great and must have taken a ton of time to do, but I would recommend watching them if you were to watch One Piece all over again. I, myself, basically have the entire One Pace collection and watch them. (They made Punk Hazard and Dressrosa tremendously better). I just think for the first time though, watch the originals. If the pacing wasn't bothering you, then definitely do so.

Jonathan Tavira-Alcaraz

i don't mind either way as long as the important amazing moments don't get cut out I'm good.

Anonymous
>>27855433

At this point everything is up to Allona. I wrote everything that I needed to write. I understand your case tho... But These edits are not only to enhance her experience but also to make her job easier, It's not the same when you have to put together 6 episodes separately along with your reaction footage than having only one video with all of that. I'm sure it's even easier to record. I have to say again that for 872-877 I barely took out the fillers, beacuse I found them to be worthy for some characters. Thank you for your feedback :)

Anonymous
>>27855578

i would never cut out no canon scene, that would be disrespecful towards Oda's work. I even mantained most of the filler. The edits of 872-877 feels like movie that wraps up everything and is more faithful to the manga as well. Please check it out: https://mega.nz/#!D40lRQCL!xjSzLZWTENd5POOtgDi7YwUWNt-bF4_QfFR4U5wSyS0

Eric

use original but USE EDITS FOR REVERIE

godUsoland

The edits were fine, though I don't mind the original eps for these reactions. However, with the next arc, the edits are A MUST.

Resticon

I've checked out Ssef's version of the next mini-arc and it will work great with just enough flashbacks that it works well as a refresher while still improving the pace of the episodes. It does appear he kept many of the best moments from the remastered flashbacks and the rest is new content. For the remainder of the Whole Cake Island arc, however, I still think the best way is to watch the full episodes.

Leon

I’d say at this point use the edits for 872 to 889 (since those are already edited and as many stated here esp. 878-889 really need the edits, and the edits shown were pretty good for 872-877) And from there on out go for original for 890+

Anonymous
>>27861437

Thank you so much for taking your time on watching the edits. I really appreciate that :)

Anonymous

You need to finish this arc with the originals episodes. Edits are great for manga readers but as an anime watcher you should react to them normally imo. HOWEVER you can watch the edited version for the next arc. Seef did a great job with it trust me. And then go back to the normal anime. The pacing is trash imo but if it’s your first time it’s not that big of a deal. And edited videos mean less content, it’s not good financially for your channel (even though I know that you don’t care about that haha) 💕

Anonymous

I personally like the edits but I'm a manga reader. The pace of the anime is awfully slow at this point in the anime and it's grating for me to personally watch the episodes. It honestly depends on how you feel about it since your enjoyment of the episodes is the main reason we watch. I don't think the editor is cutting out anything crucial so it's not too significant IMO.

Marah Kitten

Personnaly I like it, the editing version. And it will be more pleasant for the next arc, really. I didn't watch it, I go to Wa country directly. I'm a manga reader so I know what it's about, but the anime just lost me there with all the flashback I know too well now. (Sorry if my englis is a bit confusing)

Anonymous
>>27866302

Your English is great 😸 and yes these edits are really good. It is a pity the poll says otherwise.

Martin Sætran

I voted for unedited episodes but won't cry nor whine if you choose edited.

Anonymous
>>27859867

She should use the Edits for reverie or One Pace, check One Pace out pretty sure they do a good job for following the manga as much as possible.

Murkrow

I really do not care XD So I will not vote! :P

Dominic

I am on a cold turkey of one piece already. :o :D Guys! Vote faster! :P :D

Anonymous

I think Allona will enjoy the edited versions better since she is watching them 3-5 or so at a time. The Anime is edited to be seen weekly and it has to be edited such. That is why when watching back to back it feels like there is a lot of flashbacks. Each episode might have to flash-back to even the previous episode if they need to evoke a memory or emotion. Just my $.02. I will keep watching regardless.

Anonymous
>>27884995

Those were my exact thoughts to why I wanted to do this for her. Thank you for understanding.

Anonymous

For me the watching her react to the edited version was like watching the last season of Game of Thrones . You watch it knowing it could have been much better like the previous seasons ( in our case unedited episodes ). Can't believe I am saying this but we voted for a reason :D

Anonymous
>>27890160

Because of the filler flashback? I didn't add that becuase I thought It would ruin the continuity of the fight and since it was a trivial filler I decided to take it out. I don't think it was that big of a deal to be honest, just because "Rayleigh" is in there doesn't mean it's a necessary filler scene, but to each their own. I really appreciate your feedback. Did you watch my edits for 872-877 and 878-889 just to formulate an opinion about it first?

ST Deville

I can't believe the edits lost by that amount

Nyb

Allona i think most of us agree that you should watch the rest of this Arc in its original format. but for the next mini Arc you should watch Mr.Ssef’s version because he is talented and he would make that mini arc so much better. I just hope he dosen’t cut out any cool in canon filler scenes that contributes in a good way to the episode.

Anonymous
>>27891172

My only goal on this whole thing was to make it more faithful to the manga, so in terms of that my version does a better job than the original, but at the same time I kept some fillers that I thought It would give more shine to some characters. So It would be a big insult towards Oda's work If i took out any canon scene out of these One piece episodes in my opinion. Every single canon scene it's kept and placed in the same order just like in the manga. I took my time in following panel by panel every chapter to make sure of it. Thank you for your nice comment by the way, I appreciate it :)

Anonymous
>>27890928

I can its not necessary for this Arc maybe next arc . plus I want unedited so she can take her time

Anonymous

Mr.Ssef one thing about your edit, the op 20 you put in the beginning of the edit would have been better left out. I feel like op 20 and op 21 should be viewed with the original visuals rather than a cut up montage of things we just saw in the past few episodes. :)

Anonymous
>>27895056

I tried to make a mix of all the versions of opening 20 and opening 21 into one. I would take it out If Allona wants to of course, but probably she's not gonna watch my edits of 872-877 anyways, LOL. I see what you're saying tho :)

Anonymous

man this is a hard question (im a manga only fan, only watch the anime with you), so im not sure how you should go about it...maybe the edited is better...

Anonymous

@Ssef I think another reason why others like to follow the unedited anime version is that there are people here who make money by grabbing content and posting side-by-side reactions on Youtube. Using edited version basically just made it harder for them to edit it. I am all for it, personally.

Anonymous
>>27911286

Well, personally I was thinking more about Allona's enjoyment than anything else to be honest. Maybe that was my mistake, I don't know... Thank you for voting for my edits anyways :)

Anonymous

I think i'd go with Ssef edits, following the manga is great in my opinion, Toei totally ruined the upcoming arc. Or if not you can also use One Pace not many poeple know about it I checked it out and its also great.

Anonymous

The edits would be fine if they were just removing the intro and outro. When it got to the point where scenes were getting cut out that's kinda where it got to be a bit much.

ST Deville

When's the next reaction? :)