True Detective vs Black Mirror (Patreon)

These two shows ended up tied in the Tier 1 show replacement poll I did last month. I have reservations about both so let's chat about it and come to a consensus. 

I have reservations about True Detective because THE INTERNET tells me that anything after season 1 sucked tons of ass. I'm not spoiled on the show other than it has a different cast every season, but the sentiment bled through.

I have reservations about Black Mirror because Twilight Zone/Outer Limits shows are by their nature hit or miss. You have great episodes, you have shitty episodes.

So what do you think? Which should I do for Tier 1 to replace Mr. Robot?