Your opinion on which panel to go with (Patreon)

I'm working on the progression on the RIGHT side panels... 1st- she is "inflated" to the point of popping- she can't get any bigger 2nd- she starts deflating as the darkness exits her body 3rd - the darkness has fully left her body and it is now basically a black pile of bones as she collapses to the floor.

So, do you think the spherical sketch looks better for this? Or does the one where she has more of a figure and you see her arms flailing work better?