Home Artists Posts Import Register
Join the new SimpleX Chat Group!

Files

The Drydock - Episode 122

00:00:00 - Intro 00:00:31 - Shells of the same calibre in different guns 00:05:58 - The ballistics of shells in water 00:13:33 - Specialist Athlete 00:15:17 - Design teams you want to reach back through time and slap 00:20:00 - Why two dispacements for submarines? 00:21:37 - No guns larger than 5" after WW2? 00:25:07 - Alterations to shell charges for autoloaders 00:30:57 - Did navies ever run out of gun barrells? 00:36:32 - Examples of terrible leadership ruining an otherwise good ship? 00:39:43 - WW2 ship components underwater 00:42:48 - Of the retrofits and conversions that occurred after WW1 and before/during WW2 which would you have stopped and which would you have altered to create a better ship that the original conversion/retrofit? 00:47:06 - What would be the first class of warships (or approximate year) that were designed from the outset to incorporate future improvements? 00:52:24 - Was battleship machinery custom-designed for each ship class, or did designers select from what was readily available from commercial suppliers? And why? 00:55:45 - Which of the Navies involved in WW2 were the best at night fighting? 01:01:29 - Historically, which was more dangerous in the age of steel and steam, a hit to a gun turret or a direct hit to a magazine? 01:03:58 - Sperrbrecher anti-mine vessels 01:08:31 - Was PQ17 right to scatter? 01:10:55 - Large warships in enclosed bodies of water 01:15:29 - Manufacture of naval shells 01:22:42 - Official report into the loss of HMAS Sydney 01:27:45 - Could the North Carolinas or the SoDaks ever have been upgunned to the 16"/50? 01:31:25 - How is weather measured and forecasted for fleets? 01:38:00 - Which is worse for a navy. Lack of manpower, or lack of resources? 01:42:42 - What happens if a loaded gun tube is filled with water or fouled by ice? 01:45:51 - Lexington sailing through a smoke screen 01:46:49 - Did the adoption of naval boilers lead to ships having desalination systems to water their boilers and sailors? 01:51:55 - Aye vs Aye Aye and weighted plates 01:59:23 - Ericsson and the ships propellor 02:05:02 - Starter boilers? 02:07:53 - The Duke of Wellington twice described his army as "the scum of the earth". Could the same be said of the sailors of the Age of Sail? 02:11:03 - How much of an impact did the invention of smokeless powder have on naval artillery? 02:14:35 - What US presidential or congressional election had the largest impact (good or bad) on the US Navy? 02:19:21 - Portholes and ships armour 02:22:09 - Bismarck armour scheme, designed to fight the French? 02:26:01 - Dipping flags whilst in port? 02:28:28 - Did Polish naval forces ever attack Russian forces during WWII? 02:30:12 - Is being first in the line of battle suicide? 02:37:32 - Were Japanese operation names random or were they blatant references to their targets. MO being Port Moresby, MI being Midway? 02:40:44 - In your research, which admiral or officer have you found that possessed the best sense of humor? 02:45:15 - Why do USN ships have so many guns? 02:53:13 - Effectiveness of battleship/cruiser shore bombardment 02:59:39 - When (and why) did peacetime paint schemes stop being a thing in the major navies around the world? 03:03:15 - Why did some navies move away from the armoured conning tower sooner than others? 03:08:45 - RCN in WW2 03:12:50 - Iwo Jima vs Gibralter defences 03:19:31 - Channel Admin / Ship design competition winners An archive of Drydock Questions and free naval photos - www.drachinifel.co.uk Model ships of many periods - http://store.warlordgames.com?aff=21 Want to support the channel? - https://www.patreon.com/Drachinifel Shirt/mug/hoodie - https://shop.spreadshirt.com/drachinifels-dockyard/ Poster? - https://www.etsy.com/uk/shop/Drachinifel Want to talk about ships? https://discord.gg/TYu88mt Want to get some books? www.amazon.co.uk/shop/drachinifelDrydock

Comments

Anonymous

Hi, one of the Draftsmen here. There were two errors on nationality of the listed SpringSharp design competition winners. Almirante Brown and Guerrico were both Argentine, not Chilean and Brazilian respectively. Sorry for any issues this may have caused, there was a communications breakdown internally and it will not happen again. Thank you for your patience and we look forwards to the next contest which will be starting very soon.

Anonymous

Thank you for the great Answer! There were many operation names that I didn't know.

cousarmy0001

Hey, the larger part of my question this month was skipped over. Was it too silly?

videodude26

I don't know what the correct usage is, but personally I find myself using the full "aye aye, sir" most commonly when acknowledging an order whilst on Individual Augmentee assignment to an Army unit. Army officers HATE that.

cousarmy0001

Through a miracle of modern engineering and the questionable handling of state secrets, the Americans are able to outfit the Iowa class with turrets that utilize Dutch stabilization technology, and are also able to scale up the Des Moines' autoloaders to reliably fit the 16"/50s. Assuming all other systems are as they were at the time of Operation Ten-Go, how many Yamatos would be needed to put down such an Iowa? Bummer about the smoke screen footage, though. A photograph I hadn't seen before is a good substitution :-)

Drachinifel

I must've accidentally cut off that portion of the question when copy/pasting into the word document I use for the livestreams. I'll try to remember to add it to this weeks. :)

Thomas Riley

That was one big bottle of iron bru!

Thomas Riley

With respect to peacetime colourschemes, I remember reading one of the findings of in the Falklands was that *anything* that broke up the uniform grey (black line on the funnel etc.) could form an aiming point for jets doing straffing runs.

Anonymous

That is interesting, and I'm kinda surprised that it would have made that much difference. I had wondered (after typing the question) if paint technology moving on might have had something to do with it. Things not needing repainted every week, that kind of thing.

Anonymous

Oh, hey! You answered my question. Thanks a lot. I guess I forgot how huge naval artillery is. Yes, I've seen the guns (and shells) in front of the IWM but that's about it. Naval shells are huge. I usually imagine something much smaller.

Anonymous

Concerning the last question in Drydock 122 and an officer saying taking Gibraltar would be easier than Iwo Jima. As a kid of the 1960`s we all thought of "The Rock" as the most invincible fortress. So I believe it was meant as an expression rather than a direct comparison.