An Unexpected Twist Ending to a Fantasy Threesome (Patreon)

“Taylor? Are you home?” Gavin called out as he wandered through the living room and kitchen in search of his live-in girlfriend. Her car was in the driveway, but there was no sign of her in the house.

“I’m upstairs!” Taylor called out.

Gavin followed his girlfriend’s voice up the stairs and towards the bedroom, but it wasn’t Taylor he saw in their bed. Instead, it was her friend Sienna. She was dressed in a full black lace lingerie set, including an exquisite pair of black stockings.

“Oh,” Gavin said as confusion reigned in his head. “Sorry, I…uh, what’s, what’s happening?”

“It’s okay,” Sienna said with a smile. “You can come in. It’s your bedroom, after all.”

Gavin stepped into the bedroom and saw Taylor standing at the foot of the bed in a black lingerie set that nearly matched Sienna’s.

“Welcome home, darling,” she said.

Sienna swung her long legs over the edge of the bed and both girls approached Gavin. His heart pounded with such speed that he felt like he might collapse.

“What’s going on?” he asked.

“A few weeks ago I asked you about your fantasies,” Taylor said. “Do you remember that, Gavin?”

Gavin nodded and Sienna moved behind him and ran her hands down his back. Taylor stepped in front of him and reached up to slowly unbutton Gavin’s shirt.

“What did you say your fantasy was?” Taylor asked.

“Uh…a…a threesome,” Gavin replied. He remembered the conversation, though in his memory Taylor had been somewhere between nonplused and annoyed by his response.

“That’s right,” Taylor said as she pulled Gavin’s shirt off and tossed it on the floor. “You said you fantasized about a threesome where you got to fuck two beautiful girls. You said you fantasized about two girls getting on their knees and sucking your dick together. Then they’d get on their hands and knees in bed and offer their pussies for your pleasure. Am I remembering your fantasy correctly?”

“Yes,” Gavin said.

Sienna pressed her body against Gavin’s back and kissed his neck. “That sounds like a very naughty fantasy. Do you think you could handle two beautiful girls sucking your dick, Gavin?”

Taylor took off Gavin’s pants and underwear, revealing his stiff cock. “Would you like to find out, Gavin? Are you man enough to be with two girls at once?”

Gavin nodded. It was his fantasy, after all.

Taylor smiled and sank to her knees in front of him. She wrapped her lips around his cock and sucked hard. Her tongue swirled around the head and Gavin couldn’t help but moan as his loins came alive with pleasure.

“Does that feel good, Gavin?” Sienna asked. “Does your girlfriend’s mouth feel good?”

“Yes, fuck, yes,” Gavin replied.

Sienna kissed his neck again and whispered, “Would you like me to get on my knees with Taylor? Would you like me to suck your balls while she sucks your cock, Gavin? Would you like us to make your fantasy come true?”

“Oh, fuck, yes, I’d like that very much,” Gavin said.

Sienna stepped in front of Gavin and fell to her knees next to Taylor. She looked up at him and smiled before sinking down and taking one of his balls into her mouth.

All Gavin could do was moan. His fantasy was coming to life and it was so much better than he’d ever imagined. Both girls looked flawlessly beautiful and they were putting in an incredible effort. Gavin wasn’t sure what he’d done to deserve such pleasure, but he wasn’t going to question it.

His cock slipped out of Taylor’s mouth and she wrapped her fingers around his shaft and stroked as her gaze turned upwards. “Does it feel good to have your fantasy come true?” Taylor asked.

Gavin nodded and moaned as his girlfriend concentrated the efforts of her fingers around the head of his cock.

“Did I pick the right friend?” Taylor asked. “Does Sienna turn you on?”

Gavin nodded again. He still couldn’t believe what was happening.

“Did you ever imagine Sienna would be such a little slut?” Taylor asked.

Sienna moaned as she took both of Gavin’s testicles in her mouth, but he wasn’t sure how to response to his girlfriend’s question.

“That’s what you wanted, right?” Taylor asked. “You wanted two little sluts to do as you pleased? You wanted two dirty little sluts to offer you their bodies for your pleasure?”

Gavin felt far more aroused than he should have as his girlfriend peppered him with questions. It felt wrong to want Taylor and Sienna to be his personal pornstars, and yet he couldn’t help but desire it, especially as both girls were currently offering the most intense pleasure he’d ever experienced. “Yes, that’s what I want,” Gavin said. It felt good to say it, to admit what he desired.

“Should we kiss, Gavin? Would you like to see your two little sluts kiss?” Taylor asked.

“Yes,” Gavin said. He felt more confident. “Kiss your friend. Kiss her for me.”

Taylor grabbed a handful of Sienna’s hair and pulled back. She leaned forward and their lips met. Gavin watched their tongues dance and listened as both girls moaned.

“Can I suck your cock, Gavin?” Sienna asked with a light sheen of saliva on her lips. “Please, can I swallow your cock like a good little slut?”

Gavin smiled. “Yes you can. Go ahead, swallow my cock. Be a good little slut.”

Sienna took Gavin’s cock in her mouth and Taylor put a hand on the back of her friend’s head. She pushed hard and Sienna gagged as Gavin’s dick moved into her throat.

“What a good little slut you are for my boyfriend,” Taylor said. “What a good little cock whore you are.”

Gavin closed his eyes as a kind of pleasure he’d never experienced emanated from between his legs. His cock moved in and out of Sienna’s throat as she pleasured him with ease. It was too much. It felt too good.

“Wait…fuck, I’m close, please, stop,” Gavin said. He didn’t want to cum. The threesome had barely just begun. It was too soon.

Sienna didn’t stop. Taylor wouldn’t let her. She pushed on the back of her friend’s head and Gavin’s cock moved in and out of Sienna’s mouth. She reached up to play with his balls and moaned like she was actually enjoying herself.

“Fuck!” Gavin said a moment before unleashing his load. Sienna took every inch of his cock as Gavin unloaded. Pleasure shook his body and his knees nearly buckled. “Oh, fuck, fuck, fuck. That was…holy fuck.”

“Pathetic,” Taylor said.

“What?” Gavin asked.

Taylor looked up at him with a mixture of anger and disappointment in her eyes. “That was pathetic,” she said. “That took four minutes, Gavin. You blew your fucking load after four minutes.”

Taylor released Sienna’s hair and the beautiful, lingerie-clad girl pulled off of Gavin’s cock, swallowed and looked up at him. “She’s right,” Sienna said. “That was pathetic. I thought you said you could handle your fantasy coming true, Gavin?”

“I…I’m sorry,” Gavin said.

“You didn’t even make it through foreplay,” Sienna said. “What the fuck? Taylor and I were both looking forward to getting fucked, Gavin. We were looking forward to being the dirty little sluts from your fantasy. We were hoping you’d bend us both over and pound our tight little cunts. Instead, you nutted down my throat like some kind of minute man loser. What the fuck, Gavin?”

Taylor stood and helped Sienna to her feet. “This simply won’t do,” Taylor said.

“I’m sure I can get hard again,” Gavin replied. “I can. It won’t take long. You could, I don’t know, you could make out or something. Or you could go down on me again. I’m sure I’d get hard again. I could give you what you need.”

“No, Gavin,” Taylor shot back. “You can’t. That much is clear. Come here.”

Taylor grabbed his wrist and dragged Gavin towards the bed. He followed and she yanked the nightstand drawer open, pulled out a pair of handcuffs he’d never seen before, and attached them to his wrist before Gavin knew what was going on. Taylor pulled his arm with remarkable strength and attached the other end of the handcuffs to one of the bedposts.

“Get in the bed,” she said. “Right now.”

Gavin got in the bed without argument. His cock was half hard but rapidly softening thanks to the confusion that had once again taken root in his head. “What’s going on?” he asked.

“Your girlfriend planned for this,” Sienna said. “She knew you wouldn’t be able to deliver. She knew you’d never make it past the blowjob. She actually thought you’d last a little longer, but she was wrong about that. You spurted like a pathetic little bitch just because you were getting throated.”

Gavin watched Taylor walk out of the room with a remarkable sense of purpose.

“Where’s she going?” he asked.

“Like I said, she planned for this,” Sienna replied. “She invited someone over. Someone that’s going to actually get to enjoy your fantasy.”

“What?” Gavin asked.

Sienna approached and gently ran her fingernails down Gavin’s chest and stomach. He winced at the pain and she smiled. “Taylor liked your little fantasy,” she said. “She’d never really thought about it before you mentioned it, but she liked the idea of doing something so slutty. The truth is, I liked it too, though I’ve always been that way.”

“Really?” Gavin asked.

“Taylor knew from the start that you wouldn’t last, though,” Sienna explained. “She knew you’d nut before you got in either of our pussies. She was absolutely certain of it, and she was right. You came too fast and she didn’t get what she wanted, Gavin. You deprived your girlfriend of enjoying her part of the fantasy. Thankfully, she planned ahead, like I said.”

“What does that mean?” Gavin asked.

Taylor stepped into the room with a tall, handsome, muscular, nearly naked man behind her. “It means I invited a real man to finish the job you started,” she said. “It means I found someone that wouldn’t nut just a few minutes into getting his cock sucked by two dirty little sluts.”

Gavin panicked and pulled hard against the handcuff. “What the fuck is going on here?” he screamed.

Sienna slapped him with surprising force. “Shut the fuck up, Gavin,” she said. “Taylor and I are going to complete your fantasy. Had you managed to hold your load it would have been you fucking us. You didn’t, though, so Oscar’s going to take your place.”

Taylor approached the bed as Sienna moved towards Oscar and pulled his underwear off, freeing a rather massive-looking flaccid cock.

“You’re going to want to fight this,” Taylor said as she reached out and caressed his face. “Any man would. You’re about to watch another man use your girlfriend, after all. You’re not going to fight it, though. You’re going to be good for me. You’re going to sit here and watch. If you want, you can masturbate. That’s why I left one of your hands free. If you can’t behave, I have another set of cuffs and a ball gag I’ll be happy to use to restrain you and shut you up. Either way, you’re going to watch me enjoy the rest of your fantasy.”

“Wait,” Gavin said as Taylor turned and joined Sienna. The girls fell to their knees and a smile crossed his face, just as it had Gavin’s face earlier. “Taylor, please, wait. Don’t do this!” Gavin pulled against the handcuffs once more, but all he succeeded in doing was hurting his wrist. “Fuck!” he screamed.

“You’re wet, aren’t you?” Sienna asked.

“Soaked,” Taylor said. “I can’t believe how soaked I am.”

Sienna looked up at Oscar and asked, “Are you going to last for us, or are you going to nut in less than five minutes like that pathetic loser in the bed?”

“I’ll last as long as you need,” Oscar said. “Don’t you worry about that.”

Sienna took his cock in her mouth and sucked ravenously as Taylor went after his balls. Gavin felt the urge to yank on the handcuffs again, but he’d learned his lesson. He was stuck. Taylor was going to have a threesome with another guy and there wasn’t a damn thing that Gavin could do about it.

“Damn, I can see why you couldn’t hold out,” Oscar said as he smiled at Gavin. “These girls are hot as hell and they can do wondrous things with their mouths.”

“Are we being good sluts?” Sienna asked.

“Yes you are,” Oscar replied. “Why don’t you both suck my cock. Kiss it. Lick it. Suck the head together. Kiss over the head.”

The girls did as Oscar suggested and Gavin couldn’t tear his eyes away from it. He watched his girlfriend and her beautiful friend kiss, lick, and suck on the other man’s big cock. He watched their tongues dance over the head and heard the girls moan as they gave pleasure to someone else.

“Now take me in your mouth, Taylor,” Oscar said. “Deepthroat me if you can.”

Taylor wrapped her lips around Oscar’s cock and swallowed nearly half of it in one go. Sienna turned and smiled at Gavin as she put her hand on the back of Taylor’s head.

“Look at your girlfriend be a good little slut for another man,” Sienna said. “Look at her making your fantasy come true for another man. Look at her be a cocksucking slut for him.”

Gavin tugged against the handcuffs, though absent any sense of urgency. He wanted to dissipate the energy building inside him, but there was nowhere for it to go. He had to sit there and witness the agony of his girlfriend having a threesome with another guy. He had to see Oscar live out the full version of Gavin’s fantasy.

Sienna turned towards Taylor and Oscar and leaned closer. She kissed Taylor’s neck and whispered, “Swallow that cock like a good little slut. Swallow every fucking inch of it. Let it make your throat bulge you nasty little slut.”

Much to Gavin’s surprise, Taylor moaned. It was like he was in different dimension. It seemed impossible that his girlfriend was actually into the debauchery playing out in their bedroom, and yet by all indicators she was turned on.

“My turn,” Sienna said.

Taylor pulled back and Sienna immediately wrapped her lips around Oscar’s cock. She swallowed him with ease and Taylor went after his balls. The girls worshiped him like they really were filming a porn video, and yet they both kept moaning.

“Is your girl like this all the time?” Oscar asked.

“No,” Gavin replied. “I don’t know what’s gotten into her.”

“I like it,” Oscar said. “I guess I have you to thank for this. Had you not shot your wad I’d still be in the other room waiting. If you were more of a man I’d have missed out on this whole thing. Lucky me, I guess.”

Oscar pulled back and Sienna unleashed a desperate-sounding moan like he’d just deprived her of her favorite thing in the world. “Open your mouths and put your tongues out,” he said.

Both girls did as instructed and Oscar wrapped his fingers around the base of his thick shaft. He stepped closer and slapped his dick against each girl’s tongue. Then he stuffed his cock into Taylor’s mouth and fucked her face for a few moments before pulling out and doing the same with Sienna. He was using them as his playthings. He was doing whatever the fuck he wanted and the girls seemed entirely on board for it.

“This could have been you, man,” Oscar said. “If you weren’t so fucking pathetic.”

Taylor laughed and turned to look at Gavin. “He’s right. You could have fucked both our faces before you fucked our cunts, Gavin. You could have done whatever the fuck you wanted. Instead you’re handcuffed to the bed while another man uses us.”

Oscar pulled back and stroked his cock as he looked down at Taylor and Sienna. They both opened their mouths as if on instinct and looked up at him. “Get in the bed, girls. On your hands and knees. Face him.”

Taylor and Sienna stood and dutifully crawled into the bed. They both faced Gavin and he wished desperately that he could escape the situation.

Oscar walked to the foot of the bed and looked at Gavin. “Who would you have fucked first?” he asked.

Gavin looked away. He wasn’t going to answer. He wasn’t going to play their game.

Taylor crawled forward and grabbed Gavin’s balls with such force that he screamed in pain. She squeezed hard and said, “Answer him. Remember, this is your fucking fault. If you hadn’t nutted down Sienna’s throat you’d be the one making the choice. Instead, you were a pathetic quick shooter, so now you’re going to watch. If you can’t handle that, this will be the last time I handle your balls. Do you understand?”

Gavin turned to his girlfriend and withered almost immediately when he saw the serious, borderline angry look on her face. “Yes, I understand,” he said softly.

“Now tell him who you’d fuck first,” she said.

“Sienna,” Gavin admitted.

“Typical man,” Taylor said as she moved back into position on her hands and knees next to Sienna. “You just can’t pass up the new pussy, can you?”

“Don’t be mad at him,” Sienna said. “You’re just jealous because I get to feel that fat cock in my cunt before you do.”

Taylor looked at her friend and smiled. “You’re right about that. I suppose I should be thankful. After all, if Gavin hadn’t cum too soon we’d both be taking his cock instead of that glorious slab of fuck meat that Oscar’s wielding.”

Sienna was about to reply when Oscar sank into her from behind. She closed her eyes and parted her lips. A long, loud, low moan escaped as he started fucking her with power and speed. She was clearly wet enough to take it and he was eager enough not to give her even a moment to get used to his size.

“Fuck, it feels so good,” Sienna said.

Taylor looked over her shoulder at Oscar and asked, “How does her cunt feel?”

Oscar looked at Gavin and said, “It’s perfect, man. It’s tight, wet, and hot. You have no idea what you’re missing out on.”

“Poor baby,” Taylor said. “You have to sit there cuffed while the two girls you were going to fuck enjoy another man’s cock. It’s a shame you couldn’t hold your load, isn’t it?”

Gavin tried his best to hide the fact that he was getting aroused, but Taylor spotted his growing erection.

“Well, well, well, look who’s enjoying himself,” she said. “Go ahead and masturbate, Gavin. Neither Sienna not I will be touching your dick again for the rest of the night, so you might as well enjoy yourself.”

“Stroke yourself, Gavin,” Sienna said. “Do it. Jerk off while Oscar uses me like a slut. Stroke yourself while he uses me like you thought you were going to.”

“Fuck it,” Gavin said as he wrapped his fingers around his dick and stroked.

Oscar pulled out of Sienna, quickly moved behind Taylor, and plunged into her pussy. She closed her eyes, opened her mouth, and let out a moan similar to the one her friend had emitted. It seemed that Oscar’s cock had a way of making women feel particularly good.

“Fuck me,” she said. “Fuck my cunt. Fuck my tight little cunt while my boyfriend watches. Use it. Use my cunt for your pleasure. Use me like a fucking slut. Use me like he dreamed of using me.”

Oscar leaned forward, grabbed a handful of Taylor’s hair, and pulled back hard as he used it for leverage. He fucked her with wild abandon, making her tits bounce. Sienna looked a little jealous, like she wished Oscar had seen fit to do the same for her.

Gavin stroked his cock faster. His girlfriend was basically a pornstar in that moment. She was the embodiment of what so many men enjoyed when they fired up their favorite PornHub video. He was completely lost in the pleasure of it.

Oscar leaned forward and put two fingers into Sienna’s mouth. She moaned in surprise and immediately started sucking like he’d fed her a cock. He pulled his fingers out and rubbed them between her ass cheeks. The look on her face made Gavin certain that Oscar was playing with her asshole.

“Oh, fuck,” Sienna said with just a hint of pain on her face. Oscar had slipped a finger into her ass. “Fuck, yes, fuck, finger my ass. Finger my fucking ass.” Sienna reached back and played with her pussy as Oscar fucked one girl and anally fingered the other, deepening the mixture of arousal and jealousy that Gavin felt.

“You can have my ass,” Taylor said. “Gavin’s never had it, but you can have it. Take it if you want.”

Oscar pulled his fingers from Sienna’s ass and leaned forward. She wrapped her lips around them and moaned. Gavin got close enough to cumming that he had to stop stroking.

“What a good slut you are,” Oscar said, eliciting yet another moan from Sienna. He pulled his fingers from her mouth and rubbed them over Taylor’s asshole. He spit on the head of his cock and then Gavin saw a look of pain come over his girlfriend’s face.

“Take my ass,” she said. “Take my fucking ass.” She cried out and a look of pleasure crossed Oscar’s face. He was taking her ass. There was no question about it.

Gavin couldn’t help but jerk off. He was so close, but it was too hot to resist. He’d never seen anything like what was unfolding in front of him. He had to pursue his pleasure.

“Come here,” Oscar said as he gestured to Sienna. She turned around and crawled towards him. He grabbed a handful of her long, soft hair, pulled out of Taylor’s ass, and fed his cock to Sienna’s eager mouth.

“Oh, fuck!” Gavin said as he climaxed. Cum rocketed from the tip of his cock and spilled onto his legs and the bed.

Taylor laughed. “Jesus, Gavin. Fucking pathetic. You couldn’t even control your orgasm with your hand? What the fuck is wrong with you?”

Sienna gagged on the cock in her mouth but she didn’t pull away. She kept on sucking. She followed through on her promise to be a slut for Oscar, which is precisely why Gavin hadn’t been able to hold onto his load.

“Well, this dirty little party is just getting started,” Taylor said. “Maybe you’ll cum again. You’re certainly not going anywhere.”

No, he wasn’t. Gavin only hoped his desire would return quickly, because it was a far less pleasurable experience to watch after he’d cum.