Home Artists Posts Import Register
Patreon importer is back online! Tell your friends ✅

Content

We are working on something that is way more work than usual. It might be absolutely not worth it. This is a strange feeling because everything we work on is too much work. Kurzgesagt never wast hat goal oriented in the first place. When I started the channel nobody thought that investing hundreds of hours into a single video and then uploading it on youtube for free, was a smart move, including me.

But the current project makes me doubt myself. And to not get mad I have to talk about this at least semi publicly.


So we are doing a video on CRISPR, a DNA editing technique. It is pretty revolutionary and might change humanity forever. So I wanted to make an ambitious video, something that really explains the topic to the general public, from start to finish. It has been a while since I did as much research, there is SO MUCH stuff you need to talk about if you want to do the topic justice and also have fun future talk. 

But the video is getting longer and longer and longer. Right now the (still unfinished) script is in the 15 to 20 minute area. It is kind of a mixture between the fermi paradox video and the immune system. Future talk and speculation mixed with complicated science.

The thing is, is it worth it? Is it worth investing so much time in a single youtube video? After all, the video could be bad or mediocre, which would mean lots and lots of hours wasted on something big that should have been a forgettable quick video.


Also the length might actually hinder a lot or people to watch it all the way and get worth out of it. On top of that doing such projects always puts a huge amount of stress on anyone in the team (the human history video had a great reception and I’m super happy that we did it but after it was over we basically needed a few days to recover from it). More stress means less output, at least for a while.

So it might be a better idea do just make it a 7 minute video and cut all the future talk, make it really scientific. Or to make it a 7 minute video and make it lots of speculation and future thoughts. Maybe there script has to be vigorously cut so that it is one thing instead of a few things at the same time. I don’t know. But we might have reached a point where putting in more work is a bad idea.


There is no solution in sight. This video is a gamble and right now there is nothing but grinding on until it feels like it makes sense. Maybe it will be a very long video, maybe two. Hopefully it will be worth the time.


So much for a small peak behind the curtains, from a moment of frustration. Let me know if you find that kind of stuff interesting, it is a great way to procrastinate while pretending to do work. – Philipp


*(the text on the graphic says: „Return of investment on youtube“ and „Extra Effort is wasted (?)“. Sorry for my abysmal handwriting)

Files

Comments

Anonymous

Have been a fan of your teams videos for a while now as they are simply beautiful, informative and so interesting, no matter the topic. I would be delighted to watch a nice long form version of your videos as it would just be so much more of what I already love. Wish you guys the best, keep the awesome videos coming at whatever pace works for all of you. Your videos are totally worth the wait :D

Anonymous

I agree with Cole, your videos are brilliant! I would just go with it, I'd like to see a long video because every time the one I'm watching ends I can't wait for the next one and wish it was longer. I'm sure you'll make the right decision and it'll be awesome as always.

Mihai Cotabitiu

To be honest 30+ minutes video from this team would not be bad; you're doing a great job but a shorter video is much better because more people can watch your video during a short break instead of a 30+ minute video.

Anonymous

I would definitely be interested and even more so at longer videos; even the videos which aren't as interesting to me are always a joy to watch simply because of your unique style and explanations. Maybe make it a two part episode like the Fermi Paradox if you are concerned about putting people off?

Hugo van Niekerk

Guys - don't sweat it too much. This video i.e. CRISPR, is of utmost importance. Your supporters are commited to learning and knowledge. Hold forth guys (and girls?). The creative process in a doozy.

Anonymous

I have been very very interested in CRISPR since I first heard about it. I think it is the most important discovery humans have ever made. I also think that explaining what it is and what its current status is (how it is being used and by whom) would be more interesting than speculating on the future. I think we all know that it could be incredibly rewarding, while also very easily leaping over moral boundaries. I also agree that the longer it is, the number of people who watch it till the end may drop a bit....BUT, you guys make learning so fun that people want to binge watch all your videos at once (which I've done a few times already). So, with that in mind, I think even a longer (20+ mins) video would be nice to see as we could go deeper into the issue and its current state, and even if you touched on the future, I don't think people are going to be bothered by it. Personally, I'd like to see this format: - Good background history - In depth about current state and developments - a few minutes about potential future developments and moral issues that could arise.

Merlijn

I personally would love a long video with all the future talk, speculation and complicated science in it. Also I haven't seen a "bad" video of you yet, so it seems very unlikely to me that this one will be.

Anonymous

I'd really be interested in longer videos, and I'd certainly be willing to pay a little more to reflect the additional effort.

Anonymous

Whatever your decision will end up being, we'll support you in it. Just don't let yourself get too frustrated by having to make those decisions. The videos you produce are amazing, and they add value to people's lives. I'm sure this one will be no different, regardless of which way you decide.

Anonymous

As someone in the same department as doudna I would personally prefer a long video!

Anonymous

I would also prefer a long 20 or 30 min video as well :) And judging from your work, I highly doubt the extra effort won't be worth it.

Anonymous

great topic, yes, a longer video please!

Anonymous

I am for the long video. Even if people won't appreciate more than the others, or even if less people will watch it until the end, there will be people that will go through it and enjoy it. Keep making people think about the world, you are making the world a better place.

Anonymous

You guys put out excellent videos. If you feel that you'd do justice to the topic by making a longer video, but still think that shorter will keep people interested, why not break it up into 2 to 4 videos, like chapters, and that way, everyone will be happy. Maybe do a poll. If the majority of patrons will vote for longer videos, it might be worth the effort.

Anonymous

You split Fermi Paradox into 2 videos, is it possible to make 2-3 smaller videos that could be work in isolation as well as a whole?

Anonymous

How about two videos? One explaining the science and one explaining the future possibilities??? :)

Anonymous

longer videos mean more details and thats something I do personally really enjoy. I have no problem taking the time to watch one of your videos, even if it should not turn out to be the best you ever made. it will certainly be very interesting nonetheless and worth the wait. Still I would recommend, that you make sure you feel satisfied with the result and the time you invested. But I would prefer a more detailed longer version. Keep up the good work!

Anonymous

I would totally watch a long video from you guys. But when you have doubt that it would repel the average Youtube watcher, why not make it two videos: the 7 minute summary and the 13 minutes in-depth follow-up for those still interested. That would also mean double the ad space. ;)

Anonymous

Honestly I think all your videos are amazing and I can just watch it over and over.

Anonymous

I say go for it! I would love to see this video so I hope you make it, whether it's one video or more. I have complete faith in you guys to do what you feel is best though!

Anonymous

Forget about the digits. I even let my grandma watch your videos! And she loved 'em all!

Anonymous

I don't mind long videos, if anything I was sometimes a little bit frustrated when I thought your videos were a little bit short, and I wanted to know more about the subject. Of course, it's up to me to look for it, but the way you present the subjects is so much better! Anyway, I have never been disapointed by any of your videos, and I trust completely this one will be great as well. However, I do get your point about the time needed. It's always a balance to find, trying to reach the sweet spot at the top of your graph where the RoI is maximum...

Anonymous

Make a 7 min purely scientific video and everything else into the second, longer video.

Anonymous

I like that your videos have been short and to the point. Maybe you can split the videos in two parts? That would work for me. You probably have seen the TED talk by Jennifer Kahn on the topic. I thought that explained it really well without being too long. Of course, it was very short on the science side.

Anonymous

You're probably right that the way YouTube monetizes makes long videos less worth it, so for that sake, I think you could easily break it into multiple pieces. You could try to hook people with an exciting video about the things CRISPR could make possible (generating lots of views and some new subscriptions), and follow up with a no-holds-barred educational video about genetics in general, and and a third video about how CRISPR actually works. Once all three are up, you could upload a final video that combines them seamlessly, "for educational purposes". This would maximize views and YouTube/Facebook income while still keeping your subs happy.

Anonymous

Maybe this video will inspire additional research on this topic, and at the end you'll save millions of lives! Human History certainly was. Great work!

Anonymous

If something is complicated, it needs more time to explain. Maybe splitting it up is a good idea, like older movies had an intermission. Maybe split it in three, just to get more out of your work, the way youtube works... they pay per view, not per quality of content....

Anonymous

Make the Video! :D Cutting it into shorter bits is always possible after. I say let the people watch it and learn about the concept. The community can help digest it further, or give you the break-out points for a multi episode video. The most difficult part is to get the content 'right' and 'complete' the first time. That's why I say, make it and let us help digest it.

Anonymous

As a scientist, I would left the speculations. These are something you can chat about, not make a consistent topic or a video. But anyway, why don't you make two videos?

Anonymous

Brilliant Idea, CRISPR deserves its own video, once they will be awarded the Nobel prize, the YouTube stats will skyrocket! One time 20$ from me for that project!

SovietWomble

Oh god, I know THAT feeling. I'm in the exact same boat. I started making a single video of roughly 10 minutes in duration. But it ballooned into a 1 hour and 30 minute monster simply because there was so much to say on the topic. I would advise still going for it though. As I've learnt from feedback, people are more than happy to watch even very long videos if the quality is there. I'm guessing it's because the way people use Youtube has changed. People now have it playing on their secondary monitors as they do work. Or on their phones during the commute. It's taken the place of radio as a form of entertainment. Something you can put on, perhaps if you're busy doing something else, as background narration. I will advise one thing though...work on it in chunks. I find that going back to previously completed sections with a fresh mind, really helps to root out areas of the script that need improvement.

Anonymous

I'd personally love a longer video; I'd hate for you guys to feel like you have to omit interesting information. Splitting it into two smaller parts (if it's feasible) as someone else suggested would also be an agreeable format perhaps less intimidating to the normal viewer. I wouldn't sweat your worries about quality, your longer videos are among my favourite on youtube.

Anonymous

I agree, CRISPR really is a topic people should know about - and you videos really are a great way to get people into difficult topics. I would split the video into two: One video to explain how CRISPR works and a second two explain what this might mean for mankind. After all, this really could be a game-changer by giving humanity full controll over our DNA.

Anonymous

Thanks for involving us in the discussion. I would love to see a video on CRISPR. Have you guys thought about releasing it as a 2 or 3 part series if volume of information is too much for the average YouTube attention span? Edit: after reading the other comments. . . Of course I'm not the only one that has thought of that.

Anonymous

I don't know the technique, but I am interested in it. Also, I am curious to understand what is "return of interest", here... Views? Money? Well, it's good to be concerned about those, but personally my small contribution on patreon is there because I believe in the diffusion of knowledge. And I'm not only talking about nerds, scientists and people that enjoy learning something new in their spare time: I am also talking about future scientists, young students that can be intrigued, or learn something important in the "easy way", and radically change their life after seeing a good, clear and fun video. Do your work for them: a single person "converted" to science IS worth hundreds of hours of work. Go for it, make multiple videos (2 or 3 or 4) if you like, take your time. Do your best as always. I trust you guys :) EDIT: I also do like the idea that you make an initial video and expand it with other detailed videos... So that one doesn't have to see all of them if he/she doesn't like the subject.

SovietWomble (edited)

Comment edits

2022-02-13 07:36:09 着衣のままというのが、効いてますねぇこれは……鎖帷子の奥に仄見える素肌とか、実にいい塩梅なんじゃないでしょうか……。 さり気ないけど、脱がせないからこそのエロスがいい子ですねぇ……これは、じっくりと視姦するだけでも堪能できそうw
2016-07-12 10:03:02 Also, ignore the voices here requesting that you break it up into several smaller videos. One does not take a scalpel to a work of Leonardo da Vinci because they want the last supper sooner.

Also, ignore the voices here requesting that you break it up into several smaller videos. One does not take a scalpel to a work of Leonardo da Vinci because they want the last supper sooner.

Dean Herbert

To be honest (and I'm sure I speak for a lot of people) I couldn't care about the subject or length of your videos. Every one of your videos has been enjoyable and educational from start to finish. Believe in yourselves.

Anonymous

Echoing what others here have said about making it a 2- or 3-parter. You did it with a bunch of other videos and it worked great for those. Why not do it for this?

Anonymous

Do not overwork. You better split your videos in parts instead and not be stressed at all. Do not push all the people behind your team too much, this might kill everything you started. Stay simple, so far you are doing great work and I'm proud to be a part of this.

Anonymous

There is always the option of splitting the video up like the Fermi Paradox episodes, which with any luck would pull in viewers for repeat episodes and furthermore allow you time (if pre-made) to relax and make videos to whichever schedule you would prefer? Just don't push yourself if you aren't happy with the content

Anonymous

I don't know a lot about its availability but did you consider putting the video up for rent on youtube? I've seen quite a few channels do this lately.

Anonymous

Divide them into a mini series with two or three parts!

DrWex

I am also in the "divide the story up" camp. You may find that there's a part of the story you really want to tell, and people can find out the rest elsewhere. Or maybe doing shorter videos spaced out over more time will give you less stress and the chance to say something meaningful. I agree with you that CRISPR is potentially revolutionary and worthy of in-depth discussion.

Anonymous

yeah, two parts wouldn't be bad, maybe the first one is the scientific part and the swecond one is having all the speculation and imaginational stuff in it.

Anonymous

I'm with the others - although some people would enjoy watching a 20 minute video, the majority of people don't like to watch videos that long. I reckon you guys should upload it in a series, and make the first in the series scientific to place the groundwork for future speculation in a separate video.

Anonymous

First, thank you for share a little of the insides of your work. It has to be difficult to choose the right balance between quality and effort and, as you have said, there’s not a perfect solution. For now you’re doing a great work with your videos and I’m quite satisfied of giving you my modest contribution. The topic you’re working on seem really intriguing to me. I’ve been always fascinated with ADN issues and I consider having a better insight of its works and the future technologies related to it is really interesting. On the other side, I cannot even pretend the forecast the impact of such video and the work behind it. I guess you have done the numbers and already have a good understanding of what things should work and what should not. I hope that you finally manage to complete this work and it becomes a huge success. Meanwhile, patience and good luck!

Anonymous

Your videos are one of the best that exist on YouTube. They are not only full with intelligent content on which is difficult to find information sometimes, but also they are extremely entertaining and funny in the way they are presented and animated. The sounds, the graphics and the content of your videos come together perfectly, I have watched and re-watched most of them. You explain very well and clearly VERY VERYYYYYY complicated concepts - think about the quantum computing video. I come from a computing background and although familiar with the idea, I had never had such a clear idea about what it is before I watched you video (it was the first video I watched). You have explained a very complex concept to people who probably have no, or very little idea about computing. Just explaining such an unfamiliar concept is almost as difficult as inventing it. I can see that you and the team enjoy what you do and so you MUST NOT stop it or cut back. The stress is always there no matter what we do, weather it is physical or mental activity. When we are pushed to the limit and we want to make something that we love work perfectly, we will always have difficulties, no matter what we do. Stress is a part of the creative process. It is extremely difficult to do what you do. And you do it with PASSION - don't even think about stopping or cutting back on the video, think about what changes you must make in order be more productive and be less stressed during production: take more people, find more funding, team up with other creative folks like you. You have created a team which is liked and loved by a small community like us. We will support and will be there for you, don't stop what you do - especially since you love it. If the video is too long - what about starting a new channel - where you explain and go into more detail with less animation ? If you don't have enough funding why don't you think about merchandise- t-shirts, and iPhone cases and so on. Perhaps your team needs a different structure, additional people or a more clear plan as to who is responsible for what. You have a problem which a lot of companies have, you want to expand on a product (more content, longer videos, bigger audience) This cannot be done without restructuring. Most important is that you LOVE what you do, you must know that this something which I lot of people do not have and you should to be thankful for that. All the rest will sort itself out. My apologies, I wrote a bit too much and went all over the place, but your videos are the best and although you might have one long video (so want), next one will be less stress. We never know what the outcome of our action will be. I run a family business and sometimes we take an order that will generates lots of scrap - we lose money on it, but the customer is happy, then I am happy, no matter of the money. Sometimes I get an order in which we make 20% profit. Customer is happy - I am happy. This is how life work unfortunately. Just keep moving forwards and don't doubt yourself - do what you love.

Anonymous

Your videos are not "forgettable" or "quick", and nor should you aim to make them so. Much of what makes your work so good is that it provides a detailed summary of a topic in a very approachable way. I don't think long videos are a problem, as long as you have enough material to keep it interesting throughout (which it sounds like you do...). Certainly doing what you normally do just for longer would be highly excellent, and certainly not something you should shy away from just for reasons of length. I for one would welcome the occasional longer video (and correspondingly longer delay before it gets published)

Anonymous

While many people are addressing the specific of what to do with this particular topic, I'd like like to begin by saying I have no particular expertise or experience with this type of problem. Someone who does, and has talked / written publicly about it is CGP Grey, who you just finished an amazing collaboration with. Maybe he has some insight, if you guys haven't talked about it already. Unlike most commenters, I think long form videos are amazing. Grey's Humans Need Not Apply video is one of the most informative and best things that I point people to very regularly. I'd gladly contribute extra to have a long form video such as this. So if money is the issue, that is a solvable problem.

Anonymous

A serial piece is ok, just give each part a clear aspect or theme and it should be all good

Anonymous

In my opinion, your channel is the best channel in Youtube. There are many good ones like Veritasium or Minute Physics but none of them are so carefully crafted. I'm familiar with the problem of long videos in Youtube, however, I really like them when the content is worth it, and in yours, I"m confident it's going to be. So chances are it doesn't go viral and reaches millions in a few hours, but your subscribers and patreons will be delighted about it. Besides my 2$ pledge a month I'm going to make an extra pledge of 10$ in the hopes you guys can keep on working in this top-quality videos and, maybe, you can get some breathing space too. However, I'd also like to add that if you have to sacrifice some of the animation, it's fine as long as the content remains impeccable, as it's always been, in my opinion.

Anonymous

Longform video is great, but totally understand it's a pain to labour over something that seems so monumental. Maybe try this one big massive video once and you'll know if it does/doesn't pay off. Don't have to make more of them in future. At least you'll know* *selfish request to see it

Kok-Liang Lim

Your channel is the first ever channel I have supported since your early videos because it is just simply too good and information in a very creative yet simple way. I had fun and happy on your every release, and very proud as a patron. Please keep it up and don't get demotivated. Don't worry, I am sure all your effort won't go unnoticed.

Anonymous

Splitting the video à la Fermi Paradox would be a great way to tackle this issue. Personally I am always looking forward to a Kurzgesagt serial and I am probably not the only one

Anonymous

I don't mind a 30min video at all! If the subject is interesting (and this one CERTAINLY is) I will find the time to watch, even if it takes me two or three days to do it. But if you feel your audience (and specially, your patrons) will be bored by it (which I, personally, seriously doubt) make a two part video. Perhaps, not in a sequence. Make part 1 now, do one or two videos on another topic, take your time, and then release part 2. That works too. But please, do not opt on NOT covering this subject. Youtube needs your voice! :)

Anonymous

I seriously would be delighted to see a long kurzgesagt video. They always seem so short, but then I realise that the video covered the entire topic in a couple of minutes which is awesome. If the video is interesting and will leave me wanting to talk about it with someone else, I wouldn't mind the wait.

Matthew

Do it. I think long-form videos are awesome. Sure - if it would be beneficial to split it into a few videos, that's cool too. I get that you're worried that all this time and effort will be wasted, but I don't think it will be - you guys make great videos, and I look forward to watching and sharing them.

Anonymous

I'm open to a long video as well as a multi-part episode, do whatever feels right! I've loved all the videos so far, I'm always looking forward to the next one.

Nathan O'Connor

When i noticed a message from Patreon about a post from Kurzgesagt i was immediately interested, when you said that you would be doing a video on CRISPR my interest spiked. I will watch this video regardless of length! Happy to pay for the privilege, and it is a privilege, your videos are fascinating! If your worried about the YouTube viewers then split it into multiple parts, concentrating on the different elements of the subject, such as the science behind CRISPR, it's possible applications and side effects. Regardless of how you decide to format it, i will watch the video/videos.

Anonymous

My point of view is that your audience is mostly constituted by curious smart people like you and your team. If you think a subject is fascinating we will most likely feel this passion. If you feel like it needs a 1H video, it most likely does need it. And if you think this could be revolutionary, and this video with help (even a little) then you will be part of what make tomorrow better. So, please stop doubting you, we all trust you and your team, do what you do best and do it with a fiery passion.

Anonymous

I was starting to write a much longer, more philosophical comment and realized it wasn't necessary to convey my thoughts. (Yes, I see what I did there.) So, condensed version, two things to say. After reading the above post I looked a bit into CRISPR, and one of the first things that came to mind was this: I am very interested in this, but everything I have found to read about it is very dry. I bet Kurzgesagt could make this way more digestible. The second thing is simply that I have full confidence that the people who follow (and love) Kurzgesagt do so because of the very thoughtfulness and passion that has led to this situation for you. That being said, if you think the topic deserves 30 minutes, or 45 minutes or hell, 2 hours.......then so do we. The people who might think it's "too long" or boring most likely wouldn't make it through a 5 minute video so trying to please them is a pointless and fruitless endeavor. That's all. Maybe I'm giving us too much credit.

Anonymous

CRISPR is such a huge topic, I'm not surprised that it feels a little daunting. That being said, the subject isn't getting much traction in the media, especially the YouTube educational video sector. :p I think that a big, in depth, video is warranted (maybe even needed?) for such a revolutionary topic.

Anonymous

If you can do it, it is totally worth it. Series of videos is also ok. Go, go, go! :)

Anonymous

CRISPR is revolutionizing gene manipulation. It cut the cost of gene manipulation by orders of magnitude. I wouldn't be surprised if high schools one day soon adopt labs where they use CRISPR. It's definitely one of those topics that needs better understanding. I'd say totally do it. With the quality of Kurzgesagt, you'll single handedly raise the collective understanding of a huge audience.

Anonymous

You guys should consider getting a polling firm and get some market research. It'll help you guide your decisions. Additionally, I personally prefer learning cool new stuff than speculations. Just my two cents.

Anonymous

Why not posting a video explaining about it and link to a second video which explains the future talk? Anyway I would watch it in any form!

Anonymous

A video that's twice as long but means twice as much time to create (/twice as much time to wait for) is okay by me. I'm definitely a science nerd who will appreciate the extra depth a longer video offers.

Anonymous

Split the topic in 2-4 chapters and make a small series, you still do the topic justice but keep it easy on the viewers.

Anonymous

Liebes Team, I think that sounds like a great topic, and I'm always happy to see the video-makers I support try out new things. As many others have suggested here, if you are concerned about length, I'm sure you are just the right people to find a logical way to break the topic down into shorter chunks. I'd gladly watch a longer video, but I understand your concern that some viewers would find it off-putting. Explaining complex things is what you do best, and I don't think you've ever been less than stellar at it. I have full faith that you'll make something worth watching, and appreciate the efforts you guys go to in order to create perfectly digestible explanations and an appealing, consistent aesthetic. I understand what it's like to be overwhelmed by a large project. Take a team break for a day or two if you need and it might seem less intimidating! Viele Grüße!

Anonymous

This is indeed quite an undertaking, but I believe it is definitely worth doing. I agree with other commenters that a long video or a series would be fine and allow you to do CRISPR justice. This way you could include both science and speculation (perhaps in a 3 to 1 ratio?). Whatever you decide to do, take it easy and thanks again for your wonderful work.

Anonymous

It think this is best broken into 2 videos. Keep the current technology in one video and then the future in another. Release them at the same time. This will give everyone a good overview and those who want a more in-depth understanding can watch the second, more lengthy video. Just my $.02

Anonymous

Please don't give up. Short segments or one much longer piece than usual; your work is loved and valued. Hang in there - we're waiting patiently! :-)

Anonymous

split it into two videos!

Anonymous

I can't wait! Go for it.

Anonymous

I'm a researcher myself, and I perfectly understand what you are going through. I think you should break the video in half and release them separately. Perhaps leave the cell biology and genetics for a background video, and a separate video for introducing crispr and its implication on research. I'm using crispr in the lab as we speak.

Anonymous

High schools will probably never introduce crispr. Crispr requires virus manipulation, aseptic techniques, tissue culture, and primer design, which are all techniques requiring months to years of training. BUT it is true that the cost of gene manipulations are reduced significantly, however to acquire the technology, e.g. the appropriate expression vector and the cas cdna, the entry fee for the "crispr club" is very expensive.

Anonymous

Make 1 video that explains half of it first. Then if it is well received, make the second part. Personally, I would love to see a video on CRISPR.

Anonymous

The problem is that animation takes a hell of a long time, and the longer the video, the more it will cost. They aren't sure if the longer video will pay out more than a normal video either.

Anonymous

Look at Vsauce. His videos used to come out more frequently and be shorter. Now, some of his videos are really long, and they get seen by a lot of people. They only come out once every one or two months. I think that you should do the project, even if you will create fewer videos. There's an ocean of semi-professional good-enough videos on YouTube, but if you want to be different, do use an insane amount of hours on creating these. I think people value Quality over quantity. Especially on YouTube, where they can get a shitton of videos if they want and subscribe to many other science channels. Also, try talking with C.G.P. Grey about it - from what I've heard from the Hello Internet podcast, he thinks a lot about this kind of stuff.

Anonymous

As a humble patreon, let me give you my point of view. (which might not be of any help at all, I cannot give any meaningful advice as you are actually experts on the subject) The reason I contribute to your channel is, actually, not really for you, but for your audience! I contribute because you make excellent animations on difficult but important scientific topics. By doing so, you allow people that are scientifically curious (but sometime not motived enough) to dig into important matters and actually like it. In short, you do a fantastic job at "vulgarisation" (such an ugly word). As such, I feel that it is important to keep all or most of the scientific content that you can explain clearly thanks to your animation skills and add the little bits of speculation/fiction/humour here and there so that the whole video is exciting. But I feel it would be a waste to make science fiction the main meal. The main reason I give direct money is that, I hope, by diminishing the importance of advertisement, you keep a clear scientific focus and do not succumb too much to science fiction, which is pretty attractive but quite shallow. Also, I do not mind you being "late" publishing videos. I find you stress yourself too much about video frequency, I am perfectly fine without a specific schedule, when you are happy with a video, publish it and I/we will be delighted! On the subject of CRISPR, we see the science fiction popping everywhere, without really much details about how it works and what kind of challenges remains to be tackled and what practical use there is for it right now (and in the future). I am impatient to see what you make of the subject, no matter if it is a 7 minute video or a 20 minute one (also, most channels I follow have 9 to 15 minute video and I sometimes find 15 min video too short and 9 min video too long, if you have something to say for 20 minutes maybe that is because the subject is highly interesting). In short: take your time, and make the video you want to see. (You have great taste in quality and great judgement in what to explain and how, your audience [at least, me] has the same taste as you!)

Anonymous

The topic seems to call for a longer video, and a 20 minute video doesn't seem long for such a topic. I watch videos even longer, I'm also patreon of a channel with 50 minutes videos.

Anonymous

I would not care about the length of the video, I am sure your audience loves the quality of your material (in fact, many times I feel like I need more after watching one of your videos). If you feel comfortable with splitting it into two videos (one for the technical stuff and other for the future implications) go for it! (We did sort of this for the Fermi paradox, right?

Anonymous

Split it in two parts. If the first part is well received and people are clamouring for more, finish the second one.

Anonymous

I agree that splitting it is a good idea. The tough part is cleanly partitioning the material well, but the payoff is a cleaner presentation of the material when it's broken up logically.

Simone Spinozzi

Personally i like the idea behind the video so i would not mind it being long, but if patreon isn't your main source of income i can understand why you want it split.

Anonymous

More YouTubers could benefit from this statement: "... most channels I follow have 9 to 15 minute video and I sometimes find 15 min video too short and 9 min video too long, if you have something to say for 20 minutes maybe that is because the subject is highly interesting" I've watched short and long videos alike and they key to a quality product is quality content, and your videos always fit the bill.

Motionographer

Another vote for splitting! (Also: Thank you for sharing the struggle you're having. I relate very much to that struggle!)

Anonymous

Please make a two part video! Crispr is an awesome topic. I'd watch a half hour version too though.

Anonymous

I would really love to see a CRISPR video well executed and useful to explain to others. Also, Grey made a project that took him too much of all resources, but it worked out, mainly because of patreon. So keep the good work, creativity and gambles. We support you guys so you can get down on it freely!

Anonymous

I for one love your longer in depth videos. However splitting the topic Into 2-3 videos is still cool as long as I get schooled.

Anonymous

The thing I truly enjoy most about your videos is that they break some of the most complex topics down to the simplest level possible while still being able to present the concept of the topic itself. I am a programmer. I know technology and have a cursory understanding of many other topics. What got me hooked on your channel was the collection of videos about the immune system. I never understood how it worked, but after watching your videos, I certainly have a better understanding and I am able to communicate with my doctors better. I personally understand that certain topics are difficult to break down into smaller pieces and wouldn't mind one bit if you did a longer video. In fact, I enjoy the videos so much and learn so much from them, I'd honestly like to see more longer videos from you guys. Maybe even a 2-3 month cycle or something where you put out a much longer video on difficult topics like this one.

Anonymous

Oh , right. The vote. Splitting is fine.

Anonymous

Oooh i want the epic monster sized one!

Anonymous

It's definitely worth it! I would prefer a longer episode, but hey two episodes is great too! Keep up the awesome work!

Anonymous

Man, all my friends watch you now. You should make a long one, they are all asking for longer videos! I think half an hour or 20 minutes is fine. A lot of people will watch it! If you are trying to target the quick watchers i would go with two videos: First release the sciency one, than let it sink in for a week. Release the future talk a week later, people will love the continuation of the subject and will probably watch the second one as well! (maybe two 10 minute ones?). I think you should let exposure get in the way of creativity. You guys make great videos, keep up the great work and don't let the stress take over! Take your time guys!

Anonymous

I think the whole topic is wonderful! DNA editing has so much potential for good and bad. And with explaining it in layman's terms, there's no wonder that you have so much material. Personally I would want as much information as possible but I understand that there are limitations on your team. Whatever happens I'm not going to stop funding y'all. Hell I'll probably increase it a bit after reading how much work you put in.

Anonymous

split it into 3 parts if you have to, but this sounds fantastic. i'd be the first to not mind a 30 minute video though!

Anonymous

First, if we are all patrons, we all love your material. You are the first one I support directly on patreon because you are making big stuffs here. The science is something hard for the masses, but you are making people interested, open minds. Now, is it worth it? well, for sure in a none economic matter, and for that matter, we are not the right people to ask about, we are all supporters, we want more and better. You need to ask the people that spend hours on YT on more "light" material, if they want or are interested, we certainly do. I do recommend 2 parts, it is better for the less focused, but still great for us. If needed, why not creating special "campaigns" when such important projects are ongoing? I mean, if this is a project we all want to see live, and you are concerned about the bills, we can give a special pledge for one time only so you are able to complete the job. I usually donated to the UNISEF, and when they need special support, they ask us to double the regular amount for one time only. I will do it for sure. keep doing your stuff, it is important for more than the bills, it is important for the humanity!

Anonymous

I certainly can't tell you whether it will be successful overall but speaking for myself I'd love to see a longer or multipart video from you guys. Work on what you're passionate about and take a break when you need to recover!

Shelvacu

I think I'd like such a video. The only actual concerns you've presented afaict in your rant are that A. you are risking not getting a return on investment and B. You all are getting burnt out. (technically you didn't say that but it's heavily implied). First off, I'd reccomend not taking advice from random people who have never done anything like this before. For A, there's not much I can say. You seem awfully pessimisstic about it, but I also don't know how much of that is accurate. I personally *love* 20+ min videos, especially if they're educational, so the whole idea seems rediculous at first. As for B, you have to make of hard choice of simply doing less work each day. Less work, less stress, less burnout. Take a week-long break if you can. Other than than, I'm not sure. If I was king of the world, I would have all of your team properly paid regardless of output and tell you not to worry about it :)

Anonymous

My friends and I would totally watch an hour long video, or a series of shorter videos. You guys have always made great stuff so I've got complete confidence in the quality of your next video, however you choose to break it up ;)

Anonymous

Just read a book about genes & epigenes and future of editing them and would really love to watch this video, and would also not mind it being a two part video.

Shelvacu

I don't really like the idea of splitting personally, although it may be your best option. To me it feels like the two separate pieces you mention, when combined together the video would be greater than the sum of it's parts. You *could* do just one, but I don't think it would be nearly as good. Just my 2 cents

Anonymous

Good luck. And kudos for pushing yourself to the brink, and taking a risk, when it would be so easy to stick to the same successful formula. Next stop, full length movie? Ongoing television series?

Anonymous

While I personally love the longer videos, I do agree that a larger portion of your audience might prefer shorter videos around the 5-10 minute mark (you guys have all the viewership data :P). Other commenters have stated that going for mini-series set of videos might generate better return and that's what my gut says but it's all anecdotal from me at least.

Bryony Sanson

I love your work and I think it's absolutely astounding that you make such detailed, spectacularly well animated videos for free! I have been a keen supporter for well over a year now and I'm proud to say I've never looked back. Your videos are beautiful to look at and the script is so well thought out and I'm generally surprised that you don't have more subscribers! Back to the problem at hand; if you don't think the video is worth it then please don't give up! All of your videos are worth something to us and many of my fellow students who use them for learning and revision. I love the the longer videos as you guys really get into the nitty gritty stuff. Perhaps doing two videos would be easier for you? I would definetly support you whatever you guys do! ❤️

Anonymous

I think It boils down to what side of your audience you want to cater to. Your patrons are committed fans and would most likely enjoy longer, more in depth content and would appreciate a larger video but the average youtube viewer would most likely enjoy a shorter, simpler video. In order to make a choice that best serves your interests you may want to compare how much of your revenue comes from views on youtube vs. patrons. I know I would be willing to increase the amount that I pledge to you each month in exchange for longer, more in-depth videos and there may be others that would do the same. You might want to consider surveying your audience for others that hold this sentiment and then making your decision based on that. Regardless of the choice you make I have noted a definite increase in the quality of your videos since I became a patron and I personally think the transition to larger more "expensive" videos has been a deeply enjoyable one. Keep up the good work.

Anonymous

Entirely understandable and I admire your transparency and honesty. While I would love to see more frequent videos, I know that the rate of production is a function of the quality and effort you're willing to put it and I'm amazed you can manage the rate and quality you already work at. Personally, I don't think you should compromise on quality, especially regarding the information. Take as long as you need and since this is a subject that is both extremely interesting, important and complicated, I don't think anyone (read: reasonable people) will complain that it takes more than 20 minutes to communicate the subject. Don't let the stress of unrealistic expectations drain your energy, just keep on keeping on.

Anonymous

Great post. Thank you for sharing. Hard questions, hard work. All appreciated.

Anonymous

Your work is wonderful and your commitment to the highest quality is what makes me love your videos so much. Sometimes the satisfaction of creating something you're proud of is worth it. While I wish to see more frequent uploads, I completely understand if you guys need the extra time to post something you're happy with. Looking forward to it!

Arnim Sommer

So, basically, you are wondering if you should make two videos out of your material or trying to compress it all into one large one?

Anonymous

Maybe break it up into a multi-part video, which could be easier for the audience to digest and you and your team to research/create. I'm sure it's hard finding the correct areas to break up, but I'd just suggest maybe following history. These large ideas and projects you're trying to share didn't start at the bottom. Sure, those who started each step probably thought about the future, but they had to tackle smaller scope issues. Those who came later built on those solutions/hypothesis/theories. You could follow those merging fields/ideas and find milestones representing the current tech/knowledge which could mirror how the videos could be broken up also. Each video would be the Kurzgesagt-way of following in those men and women's footsteps of discovery, understanding, and application. By the way, great work. Kurzgesagt hasn't released a video I don't enjoy watching multiple times and haven't shared with all my family and friends :) Your formula is working great, so don't be afraid to experiment with it (longer, harder, whatever); maybe it'll be an amazing change or not. Failure helps too. At least in this case, if/when success doesn't come to one of your videos, we'll still be here to support anyway :)

Anonymous

I would like all the info you have gathered on the topic. You can make a miniseries ♡

Anonymous

I like the idea of shorter videos, so that the information can be digested in pieces. Part of communication is figuring out how to best convey ideas, and part of that is figuring out how to break it up into manageable chunks. Both of which you have thus far done admirably. :)

Anonymous

I'm really interested in this topic!! Every piece has it's own unique struggle, and it's own challenge. I know you guys will figure this out. I'm a patron because I'm always really inspired by the work you guys do, and I want you to continue to challenge yourselves and bring the complicated stories and ideas forward in such an enjoyable format. I just wanted to say thanks, and let you know that I have faith in your team.

Adam Berkan

This is definitely a topic I've been interested in, but haven't found a good in depth introduction. Everyone always glosses over the details. I would LOVE to have someone like you explain how this stuff really works for 10 minutes.

Anonymous

I say go for it - take the gamble - it sounds interesting and it will test what the tolerances are for your current followers (who won't leave) plus you may gain some new followers

Anonymous

I agree with Adam: 'This is definitely a topic I've been interested in, but haven't found a good in depth introduction. Everyone always glosses over the details. I would LOVE to have someone like you explain how this stuff really works' My partner and I equally love the explanation and speculation in your videos. To solve the current quagmire, and make it the optimal length to satisfy the general viewing public, break it up into 2 videos! 'Part 1: how CRISPR works' and 'Part 2: How CRISPR will change the world.' Thanks for pushing through the challenges, we LOVE LOVE LOVE Kurzgesagt!!!

Anonymous

If you are measuring ROI in terms of dollars or views, probably not worth it. If you are measuring ROI in terms of the love and respect of your audience, I can tell you almost certainly it is worth it! Obviously you can't put this amount of work into videos very often. But once or twice a year when a meaty or important topic comes along, I think the longer format brings some variety and depth to the channel that is much appreciated.

Anonymous

I think everyone else here is giving great advice on what they thing you should do, so I won't try to tell you to do anything else, haha. I'll watch anything/everything you guys put out! I love the thought and care you put into the details of the videos you do.

Anonymous

I think it would be good to split it into 2 parts: one part would be all of the science and the other part should be the speculation. Keep up the good work!

Anonymous

I get it how this is a real struggle for your team. I myself would be happy to watch a 20 Minute Video if it covers most of the things that are needed to get the topic. But maybe I am just one of a little group.

Anonymous

Philipp, what you and your team are doing is adding value to this world. No man can ask or expect from you guys to commit yourself to such a level that you start hating yourself and doubting the purpose; but if support would be enough to keep you going, I would personally like to emphasise how much I admire you videos, and the efforts you are putting into it. Trust me, it's worth it. For the sake of us all. Anyhow, at the end of the road all honours go to you, unequivocally.

Anonymous

As an responsible internet user, I would note that there is some level after which source of information becomes so trusted that usual rules of mindless browsing do not apply. I would not watch any 20 minutes video from unknown source, but I would certainly watch one from your channel and I advice it to my friends. I don't think that video will turn a lot of bypassers into subscribers, but there are many other videos to fill this purpose. Lengthy explanation of complex topic, however, may become self-fulfilling prophecy and paradoxically bring this future closer.

Anonymous

Love the look behind the scenes, and I can totally relate. We call it the "ugly in-between stage" most large projects seem to have that lull in the middle where you have to ask yourself if it's really worth the effort your putting in. In most cases, I've found it's worth the push especially on something a bit different, even if only for the learning experience ("well I WON'T do that again!" :-) One thing is for sure however... I wouldn't hesitate to watch one of your videos for 20 minutes. And I believe that the majority of people who are familiar with the quality of your work would feel the same!

Anonymous

I like long videos, and large channels about science, new advancements and last news on science, as they rely on their big audience and remain to keep them, they do never upload long videos. As a viewer of science videos from multiple channels (which by the way my favourite one is Kurzgesagt, that's why I donate) I would love and always crave for, sometimes even expressing it in the video comments, longer videos once in a while. As you stated above, it's true that it takes hours and hours to make a good content which can be stood by the audience during a prolongated lapse of time, and that's why only one video each ... well, many videos should be longer than usual in my opinion. Despite some viewers may or may not agree with me on this, I see as important as resuming and giving all the information plausible to the public as it's to cover a specific topic from head to feet, describing and explaining it very well. TL;DR Keep the long video, your effort will be worth it, not wasted.

Anonymous

I'm with the long video folks. Though your videos are peppy and exciting and make difficult information easy to parse, this is not their utility so much as the artful way with which you present information. I would watch an hour long video, or a two hour long video, and I would wait as long as it takes between each and continue to contribute. Do what you do as you want to do it, and we'll support it, because you've earned the inherent good faith and trust already. That's why we're here, after all. Sympathy with the stress, though, and good luck.

Anonymous

I support the channel because of the videos that you have already made and in order for you to be able to make more. I wholeheartedly support the long video on the super interesting CRISPR topic! If you are worried about the length, perhaps create a second cut of the finished product that can act as a trailer to the main one?

Adam Rak

I recommend splitting it to two 10 minute videos. In the first one you tell mostly science and a little bit of future talk, and in the next mostly future stuff, with a smaller portion of science. And you can use the first part to get some feedback for the second part.

Anonymous

Terrific topic choice. I'd love to head more about CRISPR. Most of all I'm curious about the science behind it. All I know now is the extremely high level overview that it is a DNA editing technique that I gather makes it easier than expected to edit DNA. But the implications for the future are pretty important too. If you are going to invest that much effort, why not get two separate videos for all that work? One that explains the science, and a followup that talks about the implications. I'd watch it either way, but two videos just seems logical.

Robin Beckett

I agree with Adam Rak, split it into two videos, cover different aspects in each one.

Anonymous

I, for one, would frame the use of CRISPR by humans as a pivotal moment tantamount to the evolution of sexual reproduction. I think that's worth the effort :D

Anonymous

CRISPR is a fascinating topic and I'd watch the hell outa a 20min video, but I get that not everyone can do that. To parrot a few other voices here, maybe breaking it up into a "Part 1 / Part 2" style is worthwhile? It makes it easier to consume, gives our brains a slight rest in between so they don't explode from all the knowledge, and hey - when we then watch both videos, you get twice as many views out of it :-P

Anonymous

Maybe you're aware of CGP Grey and his quite different "Humans need not apply" video? I am certain the same thoughts went through his head. I'd say: Go for it. Maybe it works, maybe it won't. I certainly won't abandon my pledges just because of one failed experiment. (And quite frankly, I don't expect it to fail.)

The Science Asylum

I say try it. If you don't at least try this once, then you'll never really know if it was going to work. If it makes you feel any better, I know that I wont stop pledging if you have to skip a month or something. I'd be willing to bet that others feel the same way I do.

Anonymous

Do what you like to do; that's how the rest of us came to like it, too.

Oskar Leirvåg

And some people like me love the hour long vids and would probably benefit a lot of the video. Reflect after, and possibly do some more research myself. Then probably​ use the next month or so preaching about the subject until all my friends hate me and I decide to finally shut up, AND HEY "In a nutshell uploaded a new video". I can't imagine how someone would not focus on the return from a video. But if you think this topic is important people should know, and you are privileged to do something about that. Don't let that go to waste :D

Anonymous

Great subject! Looking forward to the results.

Russell Uresti

In software development, we have the concept of a Minimum Viable Product (MVP). Basically, the concept is "what is the least we can do to get something in front of users and see if anyone cares?" This allows you to (1) not sink a lot of time into something that people may not actually be interested in and (2) start collecting feedback and gauging interest quickly. It may be too late now, but I would consider this for future undertakings. If you're not sure if it's worth it - do something quick, get it out there, and gauge interest. If people want more, they'll let you know. You'd also be able to tell by the discussion which part of the topic people were most interested in and which they were most confused by - which would help you focus any follow-up videos.

Anonymous

I would second Russel's suggestion to try "MVP videos" with the backers, and take from the comments to decide on whether (and on what) to spend time for the finalized (or v1?) of the video. It works wonders with software development, addressing the very issues you are struggling with. It could make wonders, and would make good use of the unique funding model.

Anonymous

so here are my thought's and I hope they help: did you ever try to pause in a Scishow or Crash Course video in the recent months?(different channels - I know but also centered towards science and probably a similar audience) it's basically impossible to pause without losing something. they cut the videos in a way the sentences overlap. there are absolutely NO pauses. both channels have a larger output rate than kurzgesagt so I think they have a better base for statistics and I guess they figured that longer videos do less well and they even shave off seconds with those annoying cuts just to keep the video short. so here's my suggestion: maybe split the video in different part with the main video teasing the more detailed parts at the end and linking to them. I think one long video will just end in tears and disappointment but please don't do those horrible cuts - thanks

Kurzgesagt

Wow, ok. I did not expect that much feedback and suggestions back. Thank you so much guys, it is extremely motivating to get your responses back. Reading through it the frustration fades away. : ) When the video is finished I will make a new post and talk about how the video turned out and why we made certain decisions (that haven’t been made yet at this point). Maybe we can give you guys a better idea of how our process works, something we haven’t been super open about in the past. Again thank you all for your support, not only monetarily but moraly. It actually means a lot. -Philipp

Anonymous

I think it sounds like an extremely interesting video, which could potentially become a quite big thing. As you say, CRISPR is an emerging and important technology, which I believe many people have a very limited knowledge about. To get a solid and well articulated video on the topic would give a tool learn and understand CRISPR, and a tool for helping passing on the knowledge. For me, it sounds like it potentially could be a bit like the "Humans may not apply video" by CGP Gray, which for me have been a wonderful tool to pave the way for discussions about emerging automatization and AI. So, even if the "Return on investment"-graph isn't maximized, it might very well get a good score on "Return on human benefit".

Anonymous

You could divide it in two (a science and a future) and let them cross-reference at the start and the beginning of the video with a 5/10 second blurb. I myself is more interested in the science part.

Anonymous

Every single video you guys have made so far has been incredible. If anything, sometimes I was annoyed that they had finished when I just wanted to know more and more! So personally, I would have NO problem with a slightly extended video. Or, as some others have mentioned, it might be worth dividing the video into two videos, one on the tech, and one on the future implications.

Anonymous

I have not heard of CRISPR yet and would like to know more on the science side, but I do also love future talk, thinking about stuff that could happen is always very creative and interesting.

Anonymous

Everything you make is mind-blowingly insightful, inspirational, funny and highly educational. I get the doubt you express regarding the extra effort vs extra returns. Just a word of encouragement; I guess from your work you guys aren’t in it for the returns, and even though it’s plausible you ask yourself the questions you pose, your returns/value provided is hard to measure let alone ascertain objectively. In short: We can feel the extra ‘love’ you put in, not just the animations you put out. I think judging from the general sentiment in these and all the Youtube comments, your fans and viewers (and of course Patreons) love everything that you do and how you do it. So don’t doubt yourself too much, and do what you enjoy the most doing for yourselves.

Anonymous

If you guys make a 20 minute video, I will simply put it in my TV while having dinner. I love the idea of extensive videos, they become mini-documentaries, and it reaffirms that I am doing the right thing by contributing to your project.

Anonymous

While I can't say whether or not making a longer video is a good choice for your YouTube channel or team, I can say that a longer video is definitely something I know most of us would enjoy. As a really big fan of your videos(especially the Fermi paradox one, really enjoy thinking about life in the future) though, seeing you guys burnt out is the least thing we want to happen, so if you think that it's starting to get to you a it's fine to make shorter videos, possibly split it into different parts like others suggested. Regardless of what you choose your still one of the best chanells out there! Keep up the good work.

Anonymous

I would definitely enjoy a longer video from you and your team.

Anonymous

Seems to me like what you've got there is a local maximum. If it were me, I would point to the very fact that you are so torn up about reaching for something bigger as evidence that you absolutely should. Greatness never comes from standing in a place of safety. FWIW, the best YouTube video I've ever seen is probably Vi Hart's "Twelve Tones," which is 20 minutes long. Your work to output ratio is undoubtedly higher, but longer videos can be great, and popular, and important. It's possible that a 20 minute CRISPR video won't make more views or more money than 7 minutes. But it doesn't sound to me like money is what you're doing this for, so throw out that useless metric and see what's left.

Anonymous

I also agree with the 2 video idea idea. One for what we know now, and one for what it might be in the future.

Anonymous

Normally a longer winded video would be excessive for certain subject matters. However I believe with a topic as complex and revolutionary as CRISPR, a longer video is not only understandably necessary, but most likely required for people to fully grasp the benefits and implications of such an advanced and likely historical moment in the scientific community.

Anonymous

JUST DO IT ! +1 for the multi-part, make it 2, 3 , 6 parts. With big questions at the end of each if you want to keep the audience from one part to another (even if I dont think you realy need that). You should't even take the time to read my useless comment, just make this masterpiece ! With love, from a motion design and science lover.

Anonymous

2 videos only. more than that and you loose eyeballs. <a href="http://ti.me/28StR8S" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">http://ti.me/28StR8S</a>

Anonymous

time mag posted a a 2 min video. it was good to understand the general concept. so more in depth but split into what is possible today and what could be possible in future. time mag video is way too short and lacking in the relativity to layman.

Anonymous

CGPGrey's Humans Need Not Apply video was a departure in many ways, not least watch time. That is still one of his most watched videos. I've watched it several times and pointed people to it many more. While it's true that people like to have bite-sized nibbles of interest I believe there is still the attention of interesting people that can be held for longer. People will invest the time and once invested encourage others to do likewise. Partly cos it's validation of their investment, but also because people want to talk to other people about this interesting thing they saw.

Anonymous

It's a bet. But a bet totally worth it. Hard to tell without seeing the work, but considering the great pieces you have come with so far, the odds are on your side. I believe chopping it into two episodes will help people breathe a little. Looking forward to it!

Anonymous

I would say include everything but split it into 2 videos. Knowing you guys, it will be very well-written and produced. Even if you need to take a break, I and everyone else, we are totally behind you and your work. And even if there's a small difference in ROI, the extra effort will make the difference between a "B" quality video and an "A" one that viewers will thoroughly enjoy.

Anonymous

I'd love a CRISPR video, especially from you guys because I know it will be incredible quality!! It sounds like you could do two videos: 1. Method, 2. Implications. I agree, shorter videos are more likely to be watched. Further, as a biology teacher, shorter videos are easier to use in class and/or assign for homework. I frequently use your videos in class and use your immunology videos as a scaffold for my immunology and infections disease course. It is truly excellent! Keep up the great work!!!

Vlad Tchompalov

Thanks for being honest about this. Why not test the waters: break the video down and do a series. You test the waters with less time investment. Either way, you guys always put out such high-quality stuff, I can't wait to see what do you do on this topic; I'll support you either way.

Kira Stegner

I know it sometimes flies in the face of industry wisdom, but I really love long videos from those I'm interested in. If a beloved creator puts out something longer, like CGPGrey's Humans Need Not Apply, I will assuredly watch it with glee. The length might necessitate that I pick a different window of time to watch it in, but I will be so happy it's there. I am with you guys, either way.

Zageron

If you're worried, I would split it into two parts, this would put a guarantee on your income and return. But you shouldn't worry about the response. I'd watch any length of video at your pacing and enjoy the entire thing, especially the soundtrack for it. Each successive video this studio releases is better than the last, so far.

Anonymous

DO IT. Either in two parts or as a whole

Anonymous

I agree with the other comments that you should do a series, or split the video! I love all of your content and almost always recommend the video to a science/thought-oriented friend, and a video on CRISPR would be a dream come true for me as well as my companions. I'll support whatever you decide, but i'll always prefer more content out of you rather than less, as long as it won't cause you too much stress

Anonymous

Hey, there's future stuff that's like science fiction and far off and then there's future stuff where they're just waiting for trials to come through right? Might make an easy split for either different videos or editing.

Anonymous

I think you should do like a two (or even 4 if necessary) part series. CRISPR is absolutely huge and it NEEDS to be presented to the masses in a fun and educational way, which you guys are killer at. Also.. talking about "worth". I think in the long run, as the term becomes more and more popular it will pay off. But I think this is one of those subjects that humanity needs to shine more light on - regardless of the financial benefit. If there is anyone that can do it right, it's your team. I know you are facing this huge ass mountain, but if you can piece together an introduction to CRISPR from what you have already (to buy you more time), you can make videos on other topics while the massive amounts of research you've done percolate. Sometimes massive pressure just kills the creativity of the project, so maybe if you let some air out of the balloon, you'll gain the mental clarity and space you'll need to click together the rest, to release at a later time.

Anonymous

In general I prefer short (so I can watch anytime) and more frequent (so I don't have to wait so much for the new one) videos. But I also like long ones! I think it's worth trying, keep the good job!

Anonymous

In regards to the long-video problem; why don't you chop it up into say 2 or 3 parts? You could even release the videos at an interval, say release one part per week? It would keep the masses interested because they will have to wait to get their next video, and it gives them time to ponder about what has been said. I know it's heading more towards the business-consumer point of view, which I don't think you guys are a fan of, but it would give everyone more time to unwind for a bit, and then work on the next part - like you have done before, right? Also, are you based in Germany now? I do some graphical work and such, and would love to get in contact about a possible internship or something alike? Unpaid that is, of course. I'd pay to get an intership at Kurzgesagt, haha! But yes, that is my view on this. Regardless, keep up the amazing work and I hope we can get in touch! :)

Anonymous

I'd appreciate it, as it is an interesting topic. As far as not liking it - I never saw a video of yours I didn't like. It might be good if it's a 20ish minute script to just split it in half for the sake of monetization and watchability. Try and find some natural breaking point or edit slightly so it's easier for people to digest.

Anonymous

Please do not give up on the video! CRISPR is such a fascinating technology and as you've already mentioned yourself, will probably change the future immensely. I also would rather suggest to cut the video in two halves than to cut something off of either very interesting and important part. I think it's especially vital to talk about the ethics behind it ( you may have already seen this but it's a very interesting article [in german] <a href="http://www.zeit.de/2016/27/gentechnik-crispr-anwendungsgebiete-kritik" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">http://www.zeit.de/2016/27/gentechnik-crispr-anwendungsgebiete-kritik</a> )

Zeragamba

I've been watching your videos for a while now, and after watching the CRISPR video i finally decided i wanted to support more of your videos. I don't think you should be that worried about what will work and what won't work on YouTube and just keep making videos you like.

Zeragamba

I've been watching your videos for a while now, and after watching the CRISPR video i finally decided i wanted to support more of your videos. I don't think you should be that worried about what will work and what won't work on YouTube and just keep making videos you like.

Anonymous

I hope you don't have any further doubts on your videos. I only recently came across your channel and have been a massive fan ever since. However, from watching your CRISPR video, it really hit me how much time and effort was put in to it. I really wanted to show my support for you guys beyond just liking and sharing, therefore, became a patreon. I hope every little helps you create more videos! Keep up the awesome work and keep doing what you think will work and enjoy!

Anonymous

The CRISPR video was so awesome it guilt tripped me sufficently from my adblock use to support you on patreon.

Alyn

As others have said, I decided to become a patron after watching this video. I've been watching your channel for a while but this finally pushed me over the edge. I think the fact that you can make a 16 minute video that still has that "in a nutshell" feel is something that will appeal to a lot of people and, after drawing them in out of sheer curiosity, keep them engaged long enough that they might learn a thing or two without even trying! (In the interest of full disclosure, I'm also a tad drunk, but there are worse drunk purchases to make than this!) Keep up the great work, guys! I wish there were more people gearing these concepts towards the masses the way you are! The world would be a better place.

Anonymous

It was a fantastic idea to make the CRISPR video longer! I just rewatched the video on the Standard Model and thought, "gee, it would have been nice to see them take the time to explain this like they just did with CRISPR." Truly great work!

Anonymous

I don´t know your financial situations, i don´t know how you feel about all of this but on my end, the viewer end, this is very much worth it. Your videos brighten up the internet :)

Anonymous

After watching the video like 5 times and showing it to my family, as well as becoming a patron because of its awesomeness, I can say with total certainty that the extra time and effort put in was worth it. Even if they will only be released every two months or so, videos in the 15-20 minute format are something I'd be happy to wait for.

Anonymous

You have my highest contribution on Patreon, and for good reason. What your producing is both important and of singular quality. Trust yourself to judge what's possible. Human attention is essentially unlimited for things that engage them sufficiently... and that's what you do.

Anonymous

The CRISPR video has been my favourite video from you guys EVER. Looking back, I hope you also think it was worth it!!

Connor Watson

Honestly, I and many people I know would watch your videos even if they were an hour long! Keep up the great work and don't get discouraged!

Nicolas da Luz Duque

I just read this. The CRISPR video is basically the one that pushed me over the edge and made me become a patron. I had been thinking about it before, but never actually gave you money before this video. Keep up the good work! Try to keep a sustainable pace. ;-)