Duff YCH Format Poll (Patreon)

OK so idea here...

I could do one big ych thing where we do the usual bid war and one person gets a really nice piece OR... I could do a YCH where multiple folks can buy in and have their character inserted into the YCH slot, effectively doing one piece with several alts with different characters. (i.e. a version with duff and character a, duff and character b, and so on) 

Which one sounds more fun? Lots of alts of one winner in higher quality, or several alts of totally different characters but probably only in flats? (keep in mind the quality would be for the whole pic... Wouldn't be able to do several character alts in full color/shading.)